News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by walterbell on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:19PM (#8647224)
http://www.slate.com/articles/technology/technology/2014/10/...

"But the maps have problems, starting with the fact that the car can’t travel a single inch without one ... all 4 million miles of U.S. public roads will be need to be mapped, plus driveways, off-road trails, and everywhere else you'd ever want to take the car. So far, only a few thousand miles of road have gotten the treatment .., The company frequently says that its car has driven more than 700,000 miles safely, but those are the same few thousand mapped miles, driven over and over again.

... Safety is at stake here; Chris Urmson, director of the Google car team, told me that if the car came across a traffic signal not on its map, it could potentially run a red light, simply because it wouldn't know to look for the signal. Urmson added, however, that an unmapped traffic signal would be "very unlikely,"

... MIT roboticist John Leonard says it goes to the heart of why the Google car project is so daunting. "While the probability of a single driver encountering a newly installed traffic light is very low, the probability of at least one driver encountering one on a given day is very high," Leonard says. The list of these "rare" events is practically endless, said Leonard, who does not expect a full self-driving car in his lifetime (he’s 49).

... "None of this reasoning will be inside computers anytime soon," says Raj Rajkumar, director of autonomous driving research at Carnegie-Mellon University, former home of both the current and prior directors of Google's car project."

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by pikachu_is_cool on Saturday November 22, 2014 @08:04PM (#8647375)
This is kind of irrelevant. Sure, these are problems that will prevent the technology from existing for at least another 10-20 years probably. But there definitely is going to be a future with self-driving cars. These things just need to perform better than a human, which isn't that hard all things considered.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by icebraining on Saturday November 22, 2014 @08:02PM (#8647370)
Google's car is just one approach to the problem. Not every autonomous car project out there relies on pre-mapping.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by MarkPNeyer on Saturday November 22, 2014 @06:44PM (#8647114)
if you own a self driving car, you could either have it sit in your driveway doing nothing - or you could hook it up to an api provided by uber to put your car to work.

if everyone does that with their self-driving cars, the cost of transportation will go down. it'll change the economics of car ownership; the cost of using a car will go down because the cars that exist will be put to greater use - so why bother buying one?

that whole thing could precipitate a sea-change in how the auto industry works. we'll see far fewer cars, built to be maintanable with easily replaced parts, sold to people who use them as investments that generate returns.

it's even going to change the _retail_ model if you think about it. couple the ability to see anythign you want with an occulus-rift headset, and lower traffic (thanks to fuller cars driving smarter) means it'll take less time to get where you want to go, and the model of 'a target every 1 mile' will just stop making sense.

the FUTURE!

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by seanmcdirmid on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:02PM (#8647164)
> You could either have it sit in your driveway doing nothing

Driveways are such an American luxury! There are many places in the world that lack these. One reason I don't own a car in Beijing...where would I park the damn thing? A parking space is a comparable expense to my apartment rent.

The real value of self driving cars is (a) optimizing road bandwidth and (b) getting rid of the need for parking everywhere. I can't imagine people owning their own cars as densities increase (which invariably will happen, even in the states), especially if they don't need to.

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by toomuchtodo on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:16PM (#8647206)
I've always been fascinated with the thought of driveways disappearing from new homes in America once self-driving vehicles take off. Future generations will see garages as a decadent luxury, akin to an indoor swimming pool or a private, on-property tennis court.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by waterlesscloud on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:42PM (#8647304)
I wonder what percentage of garages are used as storage/workshops/playrooms now? In my personal experience it's very, very high.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by srs0001 on Saturday November 22, 2014 @06:52PM (#8647128)
This is interesting. I've assumed ride-sharing services would benefit self-driving cars, but the thought that individuals could own cars and rent them out in an AirBnB like manner is something I hadn't considered. That's very cool, considering that today cars are a pretty poor investment.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by codingdave on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:33PM (#8647276)
Maybe it is because I live in a small town on a small hobby farm, but it seems to me that the vision of self-driving cars is very much a city thing.

I can't see self-driving cars being used to drive around my fields, picking up rocks, towing farm equipment, hauling hay, or any of the other things that pickup trucks are used for.

Maybe they will be able to navigate 4WD roads to get up into the mountains or out into the desert, but I'm not sure that would offer as much benefit as it would in city traffic.

The visions people just look to me a lot like the future of public transportation, and not at all the future of motor vehicles in general.

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by seanmcdirmid on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:36PM (#8647286)
I think this is right: people living in rural areas will probably be driving on their own for a long time to come. But the world is increasingly urbanizing at high densities, and this is probably the future of personal transport for the majority.

It is not really "public transportation"; taxis are not public transit even though they are pretty ubiquitous in cities (less so in the US, but more so everywhere else).

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by waterlesscloud on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:40PM (#8647295)
Probably true, but you'll have very heavily "assisted driving", with the computer controlling a lot of things while you retain overall control. It's a continuum.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by icebraining on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:47PM (#8647319)
I'm sure the US rural demographic is different, but around here (Western European country), the rural population is on average much older than city population. Having (reasonably priced) self-driving cars would be a boon to the millions of elderly folk who can't drive anymore and have to rely on inflexible and often expensive transportation services.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by mikerichards on Saturday November 22, 2014 @10:01PM (#8647658)
Yeah, I see these things rolling out as fine-grained additions to buses. Public transport in the U.S. sucks unless you live in the cities..it sucks in the suburbs too.

I see self-driving taxis coming first, on "battle-tested" roads. You might have to walk a few blocks still, but it will be much more convenient than public transport is now.

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by markdown on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:54PM (#8647344)
> I can't see self-driving cars being used to...

Your kids will be saying things like "I can't see self-driving cars driving me all the way to Timbuktu across land and sea."

They'll be wrong too.

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by DanielBMarkham on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:12PM (#8647199)
During the War of 1812, word reached the East Coast of the U.S. that there was going to be a battle near New Orleans.

There was a guy who _ran_ all the way from the East Coast to New Orleans. When he got there, the battle was already over, so he ran back.

My point is this: technology is not just making us live happier and healthier lives. It's also beginning to raise a generation who won't be able to self-propel themselves over long distances, whether by foot, horse, car, plane, or whatnot. This is going to have implications for the way cities handle disasters.

I love this tech, but it stands to change the nature of what it means to be human almost as much as the electric light did.

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by npalli on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:19PM (#8647223)
Sorry but this is so odd to hear, but why was this guy running to new orleans. Didn't he have a horse. Also, why did he run back again once he knew the war was over. He could have waited perhaps?
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by DanielBMarkham on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:23PM (#8647240)
Growing up in the East U.S. and being a bit of a history buff, I've heard several stories of folks running incredibly long distances in times past.

Native Americans were known to put rocks in their mouths and run for hundreds of miles. How they managed this over rough terrain is a mystery to me.

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by npalli on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:37PM (#8647287)
I understand people running long distances. Not sure why you would run hundreds of miles to inform people about a battle. It would be too slow to be effective, plus the reverse run seems odd again. Consider that Paul Revere took a horse to inform people living a few miles around.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by markdown on Saturday November 22, 2014 @08:01PM (#8647366)
What did the rock do?
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by dingaling on Sunday November 23, 2014 @04:40AM (#8648283)
> What did the rock do?

Possibly the same trick that the Foreign Legion used in the Sahara; a small stone held in the cheek tricks the mouth into generating more salivia, reducing the perceived 'thirst'.

The underlying hydration isn't addressed but it does psychologically increase endurance between drinking.

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by nether on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:33PM (#8647278)
Sounds like bullshit. That's all I'm going to say.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by DanBC on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:42PM (#8647305)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tarahumara_people

> The Tarahumara word for themselves, Rarámuri, means "runners on foot" or "those who run fast" in their native tongue according to some early ethnographers like Norwegian Carl Lumholtz, though this interpretation has not been fully agreed upon. With widely dispersed settlements, these people developed a tradition of long-distance running up to 200 miles (320 km) in one session, over a period of two days through their homeland of rough canyon country, for inter-village communication and transportation and

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by toomuchtodo on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:14PM (#8647202)
Are we destined to turn into the version of humans depicted in Wall-E? Unable to self-propel and requiring the assistance of machines for the simplest of tasks? Doubtful, but anything is possible.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by DanielBMarkham on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:18PM (#8647217)
How do you think that guy would feel if he was told about healthy people who feel like walking a mile to work or the store is undoable? To him, we're already there.

Related:

http://farm4.staticflickr.com/3883/14742634290_ae3baeefc0_o....

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by Broken_Hippo on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:27PM (#8647254)
The picture you provided was originally a group of graphics depicting how far parents allowed children to roam as they grew up. AS time has went on, parents aren't allowing children to go out. This isn't the result of tech: this is a societal issue and doesn't follow through everywhere.

And honestly, most places in the states, walking is downright dangerous. I enjoy being able to walk to the store in Norway (well, weather depending). There are safe paths and pedestrian/cyclist paths that make it shorter. Laws are designed to protect pedestrians. In the states, much shorter distances were stressful and often without sidewalks or much of a shoulder on the road.

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by icebraining on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:58PM (#8647358)
I don't see why would self-driving cars change this, if regular cars haven't.

In fact, if it becomes popular to not own a car and rely on shared service, that actually introduces more friction on using them for short distances, since you'll have to wait for one to arrive, not to mention pay for the ride if you don't have a flat plan, instead of just having one parked just outside your home.

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by kjksf on Saturday November 22, 2014 @08:16PM (#8647412)
You'll adapt your habits to new circumstances.

You know your trips in advance so you can get in the habit of summoning a car 5 or 30 mins in advance of when you plan to leave.

You will probably even be able to schedule recurring trips e.g. if you go to work every day leaving at 8:00, you can schedule a car to be there every day at 8 at your door.

It's not a big deal, especially if you compare it to all the hassle involved in owning your own car: * you have to find parking spot * you have to maintain it (buy gas, change tires, replace oil) * if it breaks, it's a major hassle of calling AAA, towing it to repair shop etc.)

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by bentcorner on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:07PM (#8647182)
I'm really excited about this aspect of self-driving cars.

In the future, one day a father may need to schedule a doctor's appointment for his son. He will schedule it after his son's school, and a self-driving car will pick up his son in the pick-up loop (just like how he's dropped off in the morning). Dad will also schedule a self-driving car to meet his son at the doctor. He will receive notifications and photo/video of the pick-up of his son at the school. They will arrive at the doctor's office at the same time.

There's way more things that will change, but I think family planning and dynamics around travel will be one of them.

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by toomuchtodo on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:12PM (#8647198)
Wouldn't your intelligent agent (Google Now, for example) schedule the necessary legs of the trip with your preferred mobility provider, and keep both parties updated about location and arrival time?

"Google, make an appointment with Tony's doctor for $datetime, and arrange transportation for both of us there."

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by Havoc on Saturday November 22, 2014 @06:42PM (#8647105)
Makes sense from an efficiency point of view. Not exactly keen on the hygiene aspect of shared cars though.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by petercooper on Saturday November 22, 2014 @06:44PM (#8647111)
We (mostly) resolved the issue with things like hotels. A car or bus could essentially become like a tiny, travelling hotel room and return to base for "housekeeping".
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by schoen on Saturday November 22, 2014 @06:48PM (#8647121)
I guess if it were designed appropriately inside, you could actually use it as an accomodation and plan to sleep in it during an overnight trip, much as we've had night trains with beds onboard.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by bentcorner on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:00PM (#8647152)
In the far future we'll see the inside of cars the same way we see the waiting room at a restaurant or doctor's office. A common place that we all don't mind sitting in for awhile, but it's really not ours to do with as we please.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by toomuchtodo on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:14PM (#8647205)
Like a bus or a train?
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by kemiller on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:03PM (#8647169)
I suspect there will be classes. I.e. "first class" cars akin to Mercedes/Lexus/BMW which would have a different kind of clientele. And, probably, penalties or expulsion for damaging or soiling the interior.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by seanmcdirmid on Saturday November 22, 2014 @06:59PM (#8647150)
I lack a car and live on taxis in China. Hygiene is definitely something you notice, but I doubt would be a big problem for non-hypochondriacs.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by incompatible on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:12PM (#8647196)
I just walk everywhere. Hygiene is good if you live in an area with low pollution. I haven't owned a car for many years.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by seanmcdirmid on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:19PM (#8647222)
Well, Beijing isn't exactly a city with low pollution [1] :). I also live pretty far away from work (live on the east side, work on the west side). Thankfully, taxis are affordable, and there is also a subway if you want to brave it.

I didn't own a car when I lived in Switzerland either: I walked or biked around my little town, it was awesome. But now my license has expired and I can't even drive if I need to (e.g. to rent a car).

[1] http://aqicn.org/city/beijing/

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by selectodude on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:21PM (#8647230)
That really limits the places that you can live, though.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by mikerichards on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:00PM (#8647153)
More likely is that the government will (via regulations) make it very hard to own cars. There are downsides to self-driving car though. Eventually you will have to give up anonymity and the freedom to go where you want, when you want. The government will surely "own" the system that runs the self-driving cars network. Self-driving cars aren't autonomous.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by Broken_Hippo on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:20PM (#8647227)
I agree that many governments will make it expensive to own cars - and make the requirements for owning them stringent. I think this is a positive step.

As far as the freedom bits are concerned, I disagree. I think with the changing travel dynamics, walking and bicycle riding will increase and some roads will change to pathways. Why call for a car when you can just walk 15 minutes to the store? Still privacy.

Besides, I do think we'll get used to surveillance once we get balance (as in, we'll be able to see government about as easily as they see us). Once that happens, most people's whereabouts will just fall in the broad range of 'normal'. This stuff isn't really doomsday scenario fuel: Data gives people the chance to point to the facts and then point to the law and say, 'hey, look, this law really doesn't follow the will of the people, change it please'. The problems that prevent change from happening are problems we have now and are separate from surveillance.

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by seanmcdirmid on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:10PM (#8647188)
Many governments already make it hard to own cars: Beijing as a lottery for the privileged of owning a car, given the traffic problems we have here (too many cars, not enough road, horrible smog). But I think I'm OK with that, it is necessary.

Self driving cars could be autonomous, unless you believe that technology freezes in time from today and won't get better in the future. But the main value of self driving cars is optimizing road bandwidth, especially in dense cities like the one I live in, and it makes sense that they would be coordinated rather closely.

It is unclear that the government would own the cars themselves though...just like governments often don't own taxi companies.

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by mikerichards on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:35PM (#8647283)
It is unclear that the government would own the cars themselves though...just like governments often don't own taxi companies

The government doesn't need to own the cars, since government will own the kill switch so you can't go anywhere.

Oh, and nice downvotes for not going with the anti-car hive mind that infests HN.

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by seanmcdirmid on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:38PM (#8647289)
They already own the kill switch. Haven't you ever been subject to a road block before? Beijing was closing down a bunch a ring roads a couple of weeks ago because of visiting dignitaries; and there is always the occasional land slide/avalanche backing up traffic when travelling between cities through mountains.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by mikerichards on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:57PM (#8647354)
They already own the kill switch. Haven't you ever been subject to a road block before?

You seriously want to compare a government controlled kill switch to a landslide or a roadblock?

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by seanmcdirmid on Saturday November 22, 2014 @08:29PM (#8647450)
Whatever you want to compare against or not compare against, the point is that the kill switch is already there; cars are useless without roads, and roads are fairly easy to shutdown.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by mikerichards on Saturday November 22, 2014 @09:56PM (#8647651)
Except the kill switch isn't already there unless you think that there's a way for the government to shutdown every road.

If you're fine with governments having real kill switches, then please make that argument, but please don't make these silly comparisons that are obviously false.

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by seanmcdirmid on Saturday November 22, 2014 @10:53PM (#8647743)
> unless you think that there's a way for the government to shutdown every road.

Isn't that what they* did in NYC during 9/11? And whenever the president comes to town, they'll shut down whole corridors. Now, it is inconvenient (not to mention expensive), and so they don't do it often. Also, our road systems are pretty fragile outside of cities, there are very few corridors where your car becomes basically useless if they happen to be shut.

* I assume you are being US-centric here, correct me if I'm wrong.

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by mikerichards on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:29PM (#8647808)
I assume you're being very non-US-centric since you brought up Beijing.

But you're still not getting it. This isn't about martial law, which is what you're essentially describing. Even with martial law, the U.S. way too many road, way too many people, for that to be effective, but that's besides the point, so let's focus on the kill switch.

Assume that self-driving cars would be not be really autonomous in the sense that you would have a very detailed local map or GPS that the government doesn't have their hands in. I think that's pretty reasonable considering what we know about government (at least the U.S. government and many other western governments).

If that's a reasonable assumption say 45-50 years from now, then any individual, groups of individuals, any area (big or small), any groups of area can be kill-switched with the press of a button. That is not ANYTHING like what you are describing as possible now with "roadblocks".

Don't you find that in the least bit disturbing, in that a fundamental of travel is very easily disabled for just about everybody and anybody?

I love the idea of self-driving cars. Driving is a nuisance for me as well as most people out of their teens, but for people that value freedom, you have to take a realistic look at what the cost will likely be.

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by pkroll on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:50PM (#8647326)
You're not anonymous when you drive a car today: it's got a license plate and there are cameras everywhere, never mind that you're probably carrying a phone that acts as a universal locator for you to any government agency that cares.

I can't imagine a general restriction on going where you want when you want, but as others have pointed out there are roadblocks today when the need arises. Assuming some cost for the cars, and of course taxes on their use, no one's going to restrict a source of income for the heck of it.

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by mikerichards on Saturday November 22, 2014 @10:13PM (#8647680)
I pretty much am anonymous if I want to be. There's no system in place right now that can conveniently track me. Yeah, there's some cameras in some places, but for the most part I could drive to the store, pay with cash, and pretty much be anonymous.

But what's disturbing about these replies to my comment is how many people are almost gleeful to have the government tracking every movement they make by making almost hysterically silly arguments that it's being done today.

Just the fact that "well, it's done today, so I'm OK with it" is disturbing on what used to be site for Hackers.