News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by seanmcdirmid on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:10PM (#8647188)
Many governments already make it hard to own cars: Beijing as a lottery for the privileged of owning a car, given the traffic problems we have here (too many cars, not enough road, horrible smog). But I think I'm OK with that, it is necessary.

Self driving cars could be autonomous, unless you believe that technology freezes in time from today and won't get better in the future. But the main value of self driving cars is optimizing road bandwidth, especially in dense cities like the one I live in, and it makes sense that they would be coordinated rather closely.

It is unclear that the government would own the cars themselves though...just like governments often don't own taxi companies.

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by mikerichards on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:35PM (#8647283)
It is unclear that the government would own the cars themselves though...just like governments often don't own taxi companies

The government doesn't need to own the cars, since government will own the kill switch so you can't go anywhere.

Oh, and nice downvotes for not going with the anti-car hive mind that infests HN.

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by seanmcdirmid on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:38PM (#8647289)
They already own the kill switch. Haven't you ever been subject to a road block before? Beijing was closing down a bunch a ring roads a couple of weeks ago because of visiting dignitaries; and there is always the occasional land slide/avalanche backing up traffic when travelling between cities through mountains.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by mikerichards on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:57PM (#8647354)
They already own the kill switch. Haven't you ever been subject to a road block before?

You seriously want to compare a government controlled kill switch to a landslide or a roadblock?

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by seanmcdirmid on Saturday November 22, 2014 @08:29PM (#8647450)
Whatever you want to compare against or not compare against, the point is that the kill switch is already there; cars are useless without roads, and roads are fairly easy to shutdown.
Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by mikerichards on Saturday November 22, 2014 @09:56PM (#8647651)
Except the kill switch isn't already there unless you think that there's a way for the government to shutdown every road.

If you're fine with governments having real kill switches, then please make that argument, but please don't make these silly comparisons that are obviously false.

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by seanmcdirmid on Saturday November 22, 2014 @10:53PM (#8647743)
> unless you think that there's a way for the government to shutdown every road.

Isn't that what they* did in NYC during 9/11? And whenever the president comes to town, they'll shut down whole corridors. Now, it is inconvenient (not to mention expensive), and so they don't do it often. Also, our road systems are pretty fragile outside of cities, there are very few corridors where your car becomes basically useless if they happen to be shut.

* I assume you are being US-centric here, correct me if I'm wrong.

Re:In a self-driving future, we may not even want to own cars by mikerichards on Saturday November 22, 2014 @11:29PM (#8647808)
I assume you're being very non-US-centric since you brought up Beijing.

But you're still not getting it. This isn't about martial law, which is what you're essentially describing. Even with martial law, the U.S. way too many road, way too many people, for that to be effective, but that's besides the point, so let's focus on the kill switch.

Assume that self-driving cars would be not be really autonomous in the sense that you would have a very detailed local map or GPS that the government doesn't have their hands in. I think that's pretty reasonable considering what we know about government (at least the U.S. government and many other western governments).

If that's a reasonable assumption say 45-50 years from now, then any individual, groups of individuals, any area (big or small), any groups of area can be kill-switched with the press of a button. That is not ANYTHING like what you are describing as possible now with "roadblocks".

Don't you find that in the least bit disturbing, in that a fundamental of travel is very easily disabled for just about everybody and anybody?

I love the idea of self-driving cars. Driving is a nuisance for me as well as most people out of their teens, but for people that value freedom, you have to take a realistic look at what the cost will likely be.