Re:Analog's answer to FPGA opens field to masses (2008)
by mikepurvis on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:36AM
(#8589959)
Dev kit is $200. Chip is listed at Arrow for ~$10, but out of stock.
I wonder if you could do some interesting analog audio stuff, like building low part count multi-speaker crossover networks, etc. Then again, for $10 apiece, it probably still makes way more sense to just put a cortex or something on there and do it all digitally.
Re:Analog's answer to FPGA opens field to masses (2008)
by _-__--- on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @10:09AM
(#8590124)
You could market it to the analog-or-nothing crowd in the audio community. Decreasing production time of "boutique" analog clone effects pedals could make you some cash.
Re:Analog's answer to FPGA opens field to masses (2008)
by mikepurvis on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @10:53AM
(#8596045)
That would be neat— a reconfigurable effect pedal that you could download and install new patches for.
The _real_ trick would be providing the option to route the signals out of this thing and through vacuum tube stages, so you're not stuck trying to build a decent overdrive or compressor with silicon-only components.
Re:Analog's answer to FPGA opens field to masses (2008)
by imrehg on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:39AM
(#8589981)
They sell the dev kit for the current AN231E04 part, but at least the Asian distributor does not stock it (only back order), and over $200, but at least it is available from 1. If I'd just want the part, it comes in 1000 increments...
I'd have some more ideas for lab instruments, but under these circumstances it cannot really be used for product development, sadly
Re:Analog's answer to FPGA opens field to masses (2008)
by pinkyand on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @12:49PM
(#8591126)
With all the fake electronic parts coming from china, are those companies a trustworthy long term source for such companies ? Not sure.
One common advice is to buy from authorized sources, and looking through octopart[1], arrow is the only distributor of anadgim, with 1000 units minimum quantities.
Re:Analog's answer to FPGA opens field to masses (2008)
by agoetz on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @02:56PM
(#8591800)
Signal conditioning is still an important part of EE design. Not all signals are TTL level and unipolar.
For example, this appnote[0] uses a Delta-Sigma converter to digitize a load cell, with the ability to "detect one sheet of copier paper dropped on a stack of 20 reams". In order to do this, it relies on an intrumentation amplifier and custom correlated-double sampling to get a measurement accurate to 200,000 counts.
And even if your input signal can be directly input to your ADC, you'll still need an analog anti-aliasing filter.
Signal conditioning is an important part of signal processing that has to happen in the analog domain.
Re:Analog's answer to FPGA opens field to masses (2008)
by swamp40 on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @11:40AM
(#8590713)
I don't think they are talking about silicon designers.
The article quotes the professor as hoping FPAA's will allow "a wide range of less-skilled users to try out sophisticated, low-power (analog) techniques".
In other words, typical device-level design engineers.
Re:Analog's answer to FPGA opens field to masses (2008)
by otoburb on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @10:38AM
(#8590304)
Analog designer experience and skills are akin to "black magic", at least as whispered in the halls of electrical engineering schools 15 years ago.
Analog is just devilishly harder when compared to digital IC design; forget about hysteresis curve cutoffs and resulting 'clean' abstractions of 0 and 1.
Basically, it's four op amps, plus programmable circuitry for all the accessory stuff needed to build most of the things you can do with four op amps. This is neat, but four op amps isn't much analog computation. Here's the block diagram of a classic, very successful analog control system: the F-16's original stability control system: http://thelexicans.files.wordpress.com/2013/07/yf16fcs.png
So this isn't for analog computation, it's for front-ending digital systems where you need to do some filtering at a faster speed than a DSP approach can handle.
The Cypress PSoC line seems to be a whole ARM processor with a little analog stuff added.
Re:Analog's answer to FPGA opens field to masses (2008)
by drone on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @10:13AM
(#8590147)
Too bad the market is still tough for low-volume FPAA's (vs. FPGA's). A product I was working on last year desperately needed FPAA's in low volumes (think 1k-2k MOQ), and was shelved largely because the lack of market availability.
The design was changed to reflect the lack of availability of a low-volume FPAA at a reasonable price point, but this drove the feature set down and the price up until the product was shelved. Until they make them as easily available and as low-cost and many comparable FPGAs, it's going to be hard to design niche-market products around them.
Re:Analog's answer to FPGA opens field to masses (2008)
by drone on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @02:39PM
(#8591719)
In our experience, the primary issues was the available number of analog I/Os, we were doing large-scale matrix-like switching between analog sources. That is to say, the PSoCs contained a small number of analog I/Os that could be routed relative to a "dedicated" FPAA.
Re:Analog's answer to FPGA opens field to masses (2008)
by pistle on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @01:21PM
(#8591285)
This. I was about to bring up the Anadigm source and then saw the date. Not sure why this is news since there are products in the market and demand scale has not surfaced to help ramp up the supply availability and product variations that could make it a healthy market.
Re:Analog's answer to FPGA opens field to masses (2008)
by OnACoffeeBreak on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @12:24PM
(#8590976)
This may be completely not what you're looking for, but take a look at Cypress' PSOC devices. They have an interesting mix of analog and digital programmable blocks.
Re:Analog's answer to FPGA opens field to masses (2008)
by sitkack on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @02:49PM
(#8591766)
You can do digital control of analog circuits, PGA, digital pots, etc.
Just had a fun idea, you could use an LED to charge a rotating photoluminescent medium and then read out the intensity some rotation angle later, it be like a magnetic tape loop but have its own decay as well. Modulate the speed of rotation, the read angle and the intensity of the write.
I graduated before we got it releasable, and haven't had much time with my job to finish up the project. I don't have more time to add to this explanation, but if you want more info or implementation help, feel free to email me: alecdibble at gmail dot com.
Re:Analog's answer to FPGA opens field to masses (2008)
by boomlinde on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @12:03PM
(#8590855)
I believe I read a while that they demonstrated it in a synthesizer application at a music expo, and I've heard rumors that they are already used in some commercial analog synthesizers.
Re:Analog's answer to FPGA opens field to masses (2008)
by fit2rule on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @01:05PM
(#8591203)
Audio-synthesis has been using these kinds of technologies for decades. Its not unusual for synth/audio-processor manufacturers to make their own custom ASIC's, FPGA's, even small-quantity chipfab runs, to provide their IP to the customer. Synthesis is very promiscuous in this regard; you can make sound with a surprising number of things in the universe.
Re:Analog's answer to FPGA opens field to masses (2008)
by boomlinde on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @01:32PM
(#8591356)
I well aware of the prevalence of the technologies you list in the synthesizer industry, but custom ASICs or FPGAs are quite obviously not the same thing as FPAA.
This sounds like it could be a great fit for Software Defined Radio.
I wonder if you could do some interesting analog audio stuff, like building low part count multi-speaker crossover networks, etc. Then again, for $10 apiece, it probably still makes way more sense to just put a cortex or something on there and do it all digitally.
The _real_ trick would be providing the option to route the signals out of this thing and through vacuum tube stages, so you're not stuck trying to build a decent overdrive or compressor with silicon-only components.
I'd have some more ideas for lab instruments, but under these circumstances it cannot really be used for product development, sadly
http://www.alibaba.com/trade/search?fsb=y&IndexArea=product_...
One common advice is to buy from authorized sources, and looking through octopart[1], arrow is the only distributor of anadgim, with 1000 units minimum quantities.
[1]http://octopart.com/partsearch#!?q=anadigm&sortby=avg_price%...
That's the real order of magnitude of the number of analog engineers?
It used to be common up until about 10-15 years ago, but then DSP's came along.
Now, you take a signal, buffer it by the minimuum amount necessary to get it into the DSP, and call it a day.
The best case is, you don't touch the signal at all, because any caps, filters, op amps can all distort the original signal.
You can do it all digitally, and it's much easier to modify on the fly if your technique isn't working well.
Boards and boards full of touchy analog electronics have been replaced by a single DSP.
And not many people are looking back.
For example, this appnote[0] uses a Delta-Sigma converter to digitize a load cell, with the ability to "detect one sheet of copier paper dropped on a stack of 20 reams". In order to do this, it relies on an intrumentation amplifier and custom correlated-double sampling to get a measurement accurate to 200,000 counts.
And even if your input signal can be directly input to your ADC, you'll still need an analog anti-aliasing filter.
Signal conditioning is an important part of signal processing that has to happen in the analog domain.
[0] http://cds.linear.com/docs/en/application-note/an96fa.pdf
Your example however, doesn't really bolster your point.
Delta-Sigma modulation is a digital signal processing technique.
That particular chip is also using a digital FIR filters to reduce noise.
It's much less prevalent than digital logic, much harder, and slower moving industry as it doesn't benefit from Moore's law in the same way.
The article quotes the professor as hoping FPAA's will allow "a wide range of less-skilled users to try out sophisticated, low-power (analog) techniques".
In other words, typical device-level design engineers.
Analog is just devilishly harder when compared to digital IC design; forget about hysteresis curve cutoffs and resulting 'clean' abstractions of 0 and 1.
http://www.anadigm.com/_doc/DS231000-U001.pdf
Basically, it's four op amps, plus programmable circuitry for all the accessory stuff needed to build most of the things you can do with four op amps. This is neat, but four op amps isn't much analog computation. Here's the block diagram of a classic, very successful analog control system: the F-16's original stability control system: http://thelexicans.files.wordpress.com/2013/07/yf16fcs.png
So this isn't for analog computation, it's for front-ending digital systems where you need to do some filtering at a faster speed than a DSP approach can handle.
The Cypress PSoC line seems to be a whole ARM processor with a little analog stuff added.
The design was changed to reflect the lack of availability of a low-volume FPAA at a reasonable price point, but this drove the feature set down and the price up until the product was shelved. Until they make them as easily available and as low-cost and many comparable FPGAs, it's going to be hard to design niche-market products around them.
Interestingly they use a switched-capacitor design, which means you can only input signals lower than the clock frequency used for switching the caps.
I had a look for continuous-time FPAAs but couldn't find any.
My goal is simply to make a guitar FX pedal with them, as they can alter gain, perform filtering such band-pass etc.
Potentially I could see it having lower latency than DSP, if anyone knows more about that, I'd be very curious.
Just had a fun idea, you could use an LED to charge a rotating photoluminescent medium and then read out the intensity some rotation angle later, it be like a magnetic tape loop but have its own decay as well. Modulate the speed of rotation, the read angle and the intensity of the write.
http://www.identi-tape.com/photolum-tape.htm on the edge of a turn table
Here is my presentation poster which should explain the motivation and theory a little more clearly than the paper: https://www.ece.ucsb.edu/academics/undergrad/capstone/event-...
I graduated before we got it releasable, and haven't had much time with my job to finish up the project. I don't have more time to add to this explanation, but if you want more info or implementation help, feel free to email me: alecdibble at gmail dot com.
Link to my reply. :)