The effects on the allocation of investment in a deflationary world are mathematically identical to an increase in interest rates. I.e., D=0, R=5 is the same as D=2, R=3.
The only notable economic effect is that black money can now earn interest (it's hard to invest black money in fixed income or other such things).
[edit: "Black money" is Hinglish for un-laundered money, i.e. cash profits from crime.]
The problem with deflation is nominal rigidities, i.e. sticky nominal wages or the prideful worker effect. Namely, workers will irrationally refuse to accept work below their previous nominal wage. People's real productivity fluctuates, and sometimes goes down. In an inflationary economy, you can wait a little and not give them pay raises until their real wage drops below their real productivity.
In a deflationary economy, the problem gets worse over time. Hence you'll need to fire the workers with wage > productivity, and those workers will refuse to accept new employment since new offers will have lower nominal wages than their previous job.
Contra mainstream academic economics, sticky wages are not actually the main reason deflation causes unemployment during recessions.
A sharp, unexpected deflation causes unemployment because of the non-neutrality of money. When deflation occurs, people first stop buying durable goods like cars or new homes or architectural blueprints. The reason workers get fired is because there is simply nothing for them to produce, because they are not worth being employed at even zero dollars. Many workers are quite willing to pay cuts in hard times, but get fired anyway because there is a glut of inventory and lack of buyers, so they are not worth employing at any price. You'll absurd that in a deflationary recessionary it's the workers in industries where spending is easy to cut that get hit the hardest.
Also, is also when wages are deflating or balance sheets are deflating that this is a problem. If nominal wages are steady, but the prices of goods are gradually decreasing due to technology driven productivity increases, then there will be no general ill effect on unemployment.
Concretely: One day, the price of everything has dropped 10%. After that day, things return to normal. Why would I not buy a new laptop? I'd feel bad if I bought one before the drop, but that's a different matter.
This is also quite unrelated to the article which discusses consistent and expected low deflation rates.
Many workers are quite willing to pay cuts in hard times, but get fired anyway because there is a glut of inventory and lack of buyers, so they are not worth employing at any price.
This is clearly not true. During the entire recession, I was happy to pay people $5.15 or even $7.25/hour to clean my house. Yet maids cost far more than that.
In any case, your claim that workers are fired because they have nothing to produce is the ZMP (Zero Marginal Productivity) theory. This falls into PSST/Austrian/Structuralist theories and is quite outside the purview of monetary economics. If a worker has zero real productivity, they will be unemployed regardless of monetary conditions.
There's lot of questions to ask about your $5.15 sample there. Were there maids out of work? What would have been the cost for those maids to go and clean your house? What's their alternative? In truly tough economical times pretty much any job at any salary was filled. We should be happy we weren't there.
As to why people lose their jobs in a deflationary environment I guess it's probably not one single reason but if the economy is doing poorly companies will adjust by reducing their expenses. Whether a single person is laid off because he has nothing to do or 10% of the workforce is laid off because sales are down 10% is pretty much the same thing, no? The point though is that job loss is a more likely outcome then salary reduction, at least I think so, not unlike a recession during an inflationary environment...
I'm only responding to bokonist's hypothetical, which is also not what the article is about (slow and steady deflation).
There's lot of questions to ask about your $5.15 sample there. Were there maids out of work?
There were lots of unemployed people during the recession who could have cleaned houses. I don't know why you think someone previously employed as an HR exec for $100k is incapable of cleaning houses at minimum wage.
The purpose of inflation is that in your hypothetical where a company needs to reduce employee costs by 10%, the company can sneakily hold wages fixed and allow the wages to inflate away. This gets around the prideful worker reactions to having their nominal wage cut.
The other thing is that from a behavioral/psychological perspective having an inflation of 1.5% with interest rates at 2% doesn't feel the same as having an interest rate of 0% with a deflation of 0.5%. In the latter people are probably going to be spending less/waiting for prices to come down.
[EDIT: Your salary example is the same effect. It's basically loss aversion. Either loss of income when your salary is decreased or loss of $ when paying more for something today than it will cost tomorrow. The fact that your salary reduction may be less than deflation or that what you're paying is more than if you'd invest doesn't matter to the way our minds treat loss, unless we try to trick it]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nominal_income_target
From a behavioral/psychological perspective, interest rates seem more likely to affect consumption choices. All of Keynesian and monetarist economics is predicated on the idea that people are ignorant of real prices and focus on nominal prices. So 2% nominal interest - 0.5% inflation looks like a 2% rate of return (invest more!) whereas 0% interest + 0.5% deflation looks like a 0% rate of return (consume more!).
[edit: the salary example is NOT loss aversion. If you lose your job for $100, and turn down a job paying $90, you "lose" $100. If you accept the job you "lose" $10.]
During QE the central bank can also acquire other assets that are riskier than bonds and take risk off other people's balance sheet, again hoping that money will be used to stimulate the real economy.
At 0% it pretty much stops working. Up to 0% some bond holders are still holding on because they are betting on that being the better investment. The other problem is how do you exit QE. We're going to find out how that works over the next few years...
But at a certain point, interest rates are low enough that lending is limited by the lack of creditworthy borrowers or by bank capital requirements, and so further reductions will have very limited impact.
You are correct - at a certain point there are no investments with a positive real rate of return. At this point all further resources should be devoted to consumption regardless of time preferences (interest rates). If consumption desires are also completely satisfied, then you are in a post-scarcity economy.
Almost by definition [1], when you reach that point, you are NOT in a recession.
What's the relevance?
[1] The technical definition of a recession is 2 quarters of negative growth, but for theoretical purposes it generally means a period when real resources are not fully utilized.
At a certain point there are no investments with a positive real rate of return. If consumption desires are also completely satisfied, then you are in a post-scarcity economy. Almost by definition [1], when you reach that point, you are NOT in a recession.
You don't have to be in a post-scarcity economy to have no lending opportunities at the margin. It is also very possible to have no additional lending opportunities, at any positive interest rate during a recession. This is especially so with the way that capital requirements work. If a bank doesn't have adequate capital ratios, they cannot lend, no matter what the rates.
The salary loss aversion I'm talking about is taking a 10% pay cut in a deflationary environment vs. not getting a raise in a zero inflation environment or getting a raise smaller than inflation in an inflationary environment.
The pay cut is going to feel much worse. That's loss aversion. From my exposure to behavioral economics through Dan Arieli I'd say the real loss of $1 is going to feel a lot worse than the nominal loss of $1 eroded by inflation. The latter feels like nothing which is why governments can use inflation as a tool so effectively. The imagery of high inflation is of people rushing with their bags of money to spend it before it becomes worthless... I've lived through some periods of high inflation and when interest rates were at over 10% I don't recall people rushing to invest, they rush to spend...
PS: Basically, the root cause of that kind of deflation is rolling defaults contracting the money supply.
Inflation or deflation with magnitudes exceeding 20-30% is generally a very bad thing, and is also not what the article is discussing.
krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/08/02/why-is-deflation-bad/
(Yes, the economy runs "hotter" with more risky investments, and more activity in general. Is this actually what we want while simultaneously talking about conserving energy? Also, inflation allows the government to implement a huge hidden tax, fund activities without a fiscal check, and directly distribute that money to government-connected private entities. I couldn't let this perverse incentive become obscured by a faulty implicit assumption that governments optimize for the interests of their citizens - I realize it was not your main point.)
When talking about economic affects on individuals, the problem with investing is it is only an option available to the upper class. Investing requires time and applied intelligence, otherwise it's called gambling. Furthermore, investments have a large overhead to deposit/withdraw.
The poor don't care about inflation, since incoming==outgoing. And the rich don't care much since managing investment is worthwhile, and their inflating liquid assets are a smaller fraction of their wealth.
These problems hit the middle class - they do not have enough savings to make it worthwhile to manage the investment (blindly throwing money at the Wall Street Casino is not investing), so they lose out. In order to have economic bargaining power, they need to keep a relatively larger chunk in liquid cash, which gets eaten away at a disproportionate rate.
So they're forced to choose between the two suboptimal strategies - act poor, spend all of their income, and enjoy their life in the present (while never gaining economic bargaining power to negotiate more favorably with their employer). Or to save, pretending to invest while giving their gains away to professional managers, and feeling poor the entire time as any wealth is illiquid.
For the most part I feel that my investment opportunities are similar to people a lot wealthier than me. Investment costs are way down than what they used to be and there are a lot of options that once weren't available to the average investor.
What's killing me is the low rates which are mostly a function of near zero inflation in the US. If I were in the US I would have almost certainly been invested in housing right now but being in Canada where house prices kept going up this is not a realistic option. Stocks are crazy expensive and super risky. Real estate is super expensive and risky. Bond yields are a joke.
Just give me the "standard" inflation/yields back!
The problem though is that without an increase in "consumption" (either individual or as infrastructure) we're stuck in this cycle. If there's no buyers the economy is slow, prices stay down and yields are down. QE/low yields have pumped up the stock market and maybe housing (at least in Canada it did for sure) but it remains to be seen where this money is going. Some of it must be pumped into the economy but it hasn't been enough yet to make a big difference. We'll see how it goes...
Your insights make me feel that a deflationary economy might be better, we're always running, rushing, we can't stop, we have to work harder all the time. To not move forward is to make less money, to be able to not afford this year what you could last year because the peg is always moving. A deflationary environment still rewards workers, because the dollars are worth more, but doesn't punish you for not constantly struggling. If you've gotten a house and you're happy where you are you won't have to worry about not being able to afford it in the future. Without being able to get into debt we would be forced to learn good saving habits.
In this inflationary environment, with a limited savings and limited ability to invest my value is constantly going down no matter how hard I work or how much I learn I am worth less every day than I was the day before. My minutes are worth less, my hours, my free time is worthless now. If you don't job hop, stay in one spot, if you made $100k as a software dev in the 90s, which wasn't out of the question, and you still make $100k now, you're making a whole lot less money.
It's true you get a small raise each year. But from the business owner's perspective, their costs go up each year. The salary stays the same number but you're paying them more. As you can charge less for your products (deflation means prices fall), you get less money to pay your employee with. So how do you stay in business?
And your employees find it hard to leave because other companies can't match their salary. So it hurts the flexibility of labor to move to more suitable jobs. The result is a stifling and suffocating business environment. Many companies go out of business during deflation.
And flip the coin, you are a bank with cash in your vault which is basically the depositors money.
Now as the bank your deposits become more valuable by doing nothing, than they do by lending them out to the entrepreneur to start his business. So you go with the 'safe' choice, you sit on the money.
The Entrepreneur either can't get a loan, or has to pay an extortionate interest rate because the bank doesn't care, if they don't lend they win.
People stop buying large purchases like dryers or refrigerators because if they just wait long enough the price will come down and they can get a much better refrigerator for their money. So large appliances and other large investments (cars for example) sit unsold, that idles factory workers since there is plenty of stock in the market place. So they get laid off.
Deflation has the effect of contracting the economy, modest inflation tends to expand it.
I don't agree that people will go without clean clothes, or food storage today to save a dollar tomorrow. I've thought about cars as well, car costs don't go up year over year, you get more for less value theoretically, why would the price go down?
The view that deflation is bad seems to always henge on a dramatic fall in prices and increase in the dollar value. Inflation doesn't work that way, it is very slow year to year, why would deflation be different?
Furthermore, you only needed the loan in the first place because despite material living expenses being at an all time low, housing rent is at an all time high (thanks to those zero risk loans!) and you do not wish to squander the little savings you have.
Your employer dismisses your idea of working 16 hours a week because it would simply confuse them and there is a long line of people still willing to work 50.
You either keep your day job and forget about your idea, bootstrap while being distracted with a separate consulting business, or set out for the Silicon Valley Casino where you will possibly win 5% of $1B or more likely 5% of $0B.
It's a superficially attractive option because who doesn't like stuff getting cheaper? but before long that turns into wage cuts or layoffs because there's less and less money to pay people with.
If you've gotten a house and you're happy where you are you won't have to worry about not being able to afford it in the future.
Sure - deflation is great if you already have all the fixed assets you want and are not dependent on cash flow. If you don't, it's just as bad as runaway inflation. If you have debt, it's a lot worse.
The problem exists any place there is a latency between when you buy your starting materials and when you sell the final product. In a normal (break-even or mildly inflationary economy) you start with capital that has some amount of value (purchasing power). Time passes as you make the product, and you can sell it at an equal or greater (profit margin) amount which allows you to regain your initial capital investment.
That completely breaks in deflation. The value of the money rises ,and yes, this means people are slightly less likely to spend it, but the problem comes when you want to sell your product. Say you invested $100 to make a product with the expectation being able to sell at a 50% profit margin. Except during the time it took to you to make it, money deflated, and the purchasing price of those same starting materials is now $50. Adding in the same 50% profit says your now can only sell your product at $75.
The deflation that happens between investing and selling not only eats your profit margin, it can easily eat your ability to recover your initial capital. Investment is ludicrous in an environment like that.
So we go with the "worst method possible, except for all the rest": mild inflation that is hopefully small, manageable, and trivial.
If money is "hidden under blankets" it is taken out of circulation. The value per unit currency still in circulation increases (due to lack of supply) and this will boost the purchasing power of the money remaining in circulation. For this reason the idea that "deflation causes a liquidity crisis" is a bit misleading- It causes a liquidity crises measured in "face value" but not in "purchasing power" of the currency. (Though some of your prognoses are probably still true but occur because of other, somewhat different mechanisms)
One other point: inflation is actually beneficial to people who are in debt[0], as it reduces the real value of their debt. (In other words, the dollar that they use to pay off the debt a year from now is worth less than the dollar today, so inflation literally allows them to use less money[1] to pay off their debt).
Conversely, deflation is terrible for people who are in debt, as it effectively increases the amount of money they have to spend to pay off the debt (this is on top of the compounding interest; it is looking at the real value of the same nominal dollar amount).
So, one of the biggest dangers of deflation is that it harms people with negative net worth (people deeply in debt)[2].
[0] Assuming fixed interest rates
[1] In real terms, not nominal terms
[2] The people who 'win' in this particular context are the people who own that debt (ie, the bankers). But as jandrewrodgers pointed out, there are a number of other ways that deflation harms them as well, so deflation is really a lose-lose situation.
If the inflation is expected, interest rates adjust accordingly. India has roughly a 10% inflation rate and interest rates on mortgages tend to be 11-12%. The US has inflation rates of about 1-2% and mortgage rates of 3-4%.
tl;dr; If inflation is I, you'll be paying interest rates of I+R where R is dependent on availability of capital, your risk factors, etc.
It is effectively like cash earning tax-free interest. And since it is cash, that "investment" is virtually risk-free because you'll always have the cash.
As a consequence, simply holding cash starts competing with the expected return of investing the cash in other ways, like real estate, government bonds, the stock market, or a startup. Relative to some traditional investments, you might maximize your effective risk-adjusted returns by doing nothing at all!
This sounds great (at least for people with cash) until you realize that this "investment" is one of the least productive investments possible. No infrastructure is built, no technologies invented, no products are created for customers. While people with cash might be nominally wealthier, there is greatly reduced investment of cash in things that improve the productivity and wealth of the entire economy.
Furthermore, real investment is how many jobs are created. Several million jobs in the United States are paid for with funds from speculative investments. If it no longer pays to make speculative investments on new technologies, new startups, or otherwise changing the world, what do you think happens to those jobs that are tacitly funded by that investment?
Mild inflation, for better or worse, incentivizes anyone with a bit of money to use that money to fund companies, infrastructure, technology, and jobs that may ultimately return higher value than the loss to inflation. Yes, if you sit on your cash in an inflationary economy, you slowly lose wealth. It incentivizes people to attempt to apply their assets toward productive ends.
Lastly, there is the question of what about people with little or no cash in an inflationary environment? On the surface, it looks like they get screwed. In practice, the productivity and technology advances created by the investment by people with money are often effectively neutral or deflationary. Not only are they more productive at their jobs, assuming they have one, but the costs of many goods decline thanks to the investment. This doesn't apply to all goods but it applies to many that almost everyone consumes. That said, if an economy inflates too fast it can quickly outstrip the earning potential of the people that operate in it. The flow of money through an economy has a significant viscosity and in extreme cases that causes much suffering.
In summary, the reason mildly inflationary economies are commonly preferred by most governments is that, on the balance, it optimizes incentives to maximize real investment which not only grows the economy in real terms but has quasi-deflationary effects for consumers as well. There are always tradeoffs but this is widely believed to have the "least bad" set of tradeoffs for a currency inflation/deflation policy.