News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by cmelbye on Sunday October 19, 2014 @08:35PM (#8480173)
This is inaccurate alarmism. It shouldn't be surprising that the search bar makes autocomplete requests to Apple as you type. The address, phone number, and map link that popped up when you typed in the name of a local business, for example, didn't just appear out of thin air.

However, it seemed suspicious to me that Apple would make it impossible, as the author claims, to type in the Safari address bar without sending queries to Apple. So, I fired up Charles proxy to confirm my suspicions.

When using Safari default settings, typing in the address bar resulted in a few requests to Apple and Google autocomplete APIs. Then, I turned off "Include search engine suggestions" and "Include Spotlight Suggestions" in Safari search preferences. (Safari -> Preferences -> Search)

As I initially believed, no requests were sent whatsoever when typing in the address bar after those settings were disabled. Can we put out our pitchforks yet, or am I missing something?

Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by jsmthrowaway on Sunday October 19, 2014 @08:46PM (#8480208)
Landon feels that disabling Spotlight Suggestions in OS X System Preferences would have an effect on Safari. I'm as mystified as you.
Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by cscurmudgeon on Sunday October 19, 2014 @09:30PM (#8480327)
Why doesn't Apple read my thoughts and disable everything?
Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by ljfuller on Sunday October 19, 2014 @09:41PM (#8480364)
Howdy,

There are two "Spotlight Suggestions":

- "Spotlight Suggestions" in Safari

- "Spotlight Suggestions" in Spotlight

Both query the same servers, both use the same name, and both return the same information.

A reasonable person might believe that, having followed Apple's instructions for disabling "Spotlight Suggestions" (the Spotlight kind), they'd disabled "Spotlight Suggestions" (the Safari kind) -- especially if you didn't actually see any suggestions appear in Safari (I didn't!).

Mark Rowe, Safari developer at Apple: "That’s probably a fair complaint." https://twitter.com/bdash/status/524005838743035904

There needs to be a single checkbox: "Do not share my Spotlight data with Apple".

There's already a single checkbox for "Diagnostics & Usage Data", and that should be respected too. The network query posted here is actually a search metrics POST, not a live search query, and it's used as metrics for local and remote search performance.

p.s. It was also just pointed out to me that, having selected a specific search engine, a user would not be remiss in believing that their searches would be sent to the only the search engine they had selected.

Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by cmelbye on Sunday October 19, 2014 @09:48PM (#8480388)
Perhaps it would make sense to update your Gist to make it clear that Apple isn't trying to force people to funnel their searches through their servers, and that the real issue here is confusing UI?
Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by ianlevesque on Sunday October 19, 2014 @10:00PM (#8480422)
It's not even that confusing. This is just alarmism for pageviews. Of all the large tech companies right now, Apple has made the most moves to protect user privacy. Disabled 3rd party cookies by default in Safari, randomized WiFi queries, full device ios encryption, opt-in only crash reporting, restricted MAC and UDID access, zero information shared with ApplePay, etc. And yet we're supposed to get out the pitchforks over an autocomplete feature that's disableable with two checkboxes in the UI? Give me a break.
Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by blinkingled on Sunday October 19, 2014 @10:20PM (#8480460)
> randomized WiFi queries

You know that the iOS 8 mac randomization feature doesn't actually work right? From imore.com - http://www.imore.com/closer-look-ios-8s-mac-randomization

Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by alexweber on Monday October 20, 2014 @01:12PM (#8483237)
>alarmism for pageviews

on github...

Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by blinkingled on Sunday October 19, 2014 @10:00PM (#8480419)
Real issue isn't confusing UI although that is part of it - the real issue is that they are misleading the user as if their queries are going only where they want - to the search engine they configured. There is no indication that Apple is receiving a copy of every one of their queries to display Maps results that the user may or may not need.

A privacy conscious implementation would ask the user on startup if they would like to include Maps results in their inline suggestions and if so do they agree to sending their queries to Apple.

Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by bo1024 on Sunday October 19, 2014 @08:54PM (#8480229)
It's not at all inaccurate.

Might be alarmism, I don't know. But I think it just demonstrates the ways in which users' expectations about privacy are mismatched with the products they use. For example, your average non-tech-savvy user would never realize that an important privacy setting is in a search setting marked "suggestions".

It's hard to say more without seeing the text of Apple's Privacy Documentation that is referred to at the top of the article.

Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by jsmthrowaway on Sunday October 19, 2014 @08:59PM (#8480242)
> For example, your average non-tech-savvy user would never realize that an important privacy setting is in a search setting marked "suggestions".

Is this not clear enough?

http://i.imgur.com/i1Zq3E4.png

Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by ljfuller on Sunday October 19, 2014 @09:31PM (#8480333)
Apparently not :-)

Those instructions disable "Spotlight Results" only in Spotlight-as-in-desktop-Spotlight.

Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by bo1024 on Monday October 20, 2014 @09:32AM (#8482002)
It sounds like this is what the author of the article was reading. But there's nothing there about Safari.
Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by dvhh on Sunday October 19, 2014 @09:34PM (#8480342)
Let's imagine that the name would be replaced by a slightly let popular company, say one which name begin by an F or a G even one with an M, pichfork would have been already out.
Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by kingnight on Sunday October 19, 2014 @09:32PM (#8480336)
Would you be able to confirm what occurs with the default settings on (suggestions on for both spotlight and Safari) and the browser is kicked into private mode. I'd presume nothing is sent to Apple but can't test at the moment.
Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by cmelbye on Sunday October 19, 2014 @09:39PM (#8480356)
Sure: No requests are made while typing in address bar in private mode with default settings.
[dead]
Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by jsmthrowaway on Sunday October 19, 2014 @08:49PM (#8480214)
Yeah, Spotlight privacy options. He didn't touch Safari's; I did, and I got the same as cmelbye.

To be honest, I feel like Landon found something that confirmed what he already suspected, and ran with it, rather than taking a moment to look at what he had (which is wrong). That makes me wonder about his goals, since I've been watching his work play out over the last few days. Why is the sky falling, again?

Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by mikeash on Sunday October 19, 2014 @08:58PM (#8480239)
Maybe he did touch Safari's, but foolishly only looked in the "Privacy" section of Safari's preferences, rather than in the "Search" section where any normal person would know the privacy-related settings are actually found.

OK, that's highly sarcastic, but I just went looking for these options and was gobsmacked to discover that no relevant options were present under Privacy.

Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by threeseed on Sunday October 19, 2014 @09:08PM (#8480266)
Why would you look under Privacy ?

Sending my search term to Apple which then simply does a back end aggregated search and returns the results does not invade my privacy. Unless of course you have some evidence that Apple is collecting those search terms.

Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by mikeash on Sunday October 19, 2014 @09:23PM (#8480306)
I completely disagree. Sending my search terms to Apple is an invasion of privacy. I feel like "don't share your info with other people" is such a basic aspect of privacy that I don't even know how to argue the point. I'm at a loss, as if you had said that trees are made out of meat, or that cars are delivered by storks.
Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by cscurmudgeon on Monday October 20, 2014 @12:44AM (#8480733)
Is sending your search query to Google for Google instant an invasion of your privacy?
Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by scintill76 on Monday October 20, 2014 @01:30AM (#8480810)
Yes, if it was without consent or at least knowledge that it was happening.
Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by cscurmudgeon on Monday October 20, 2014 @01:33AM (#8480819)
Google automatically turned on Google Instant without explicit constent.
Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by scintill76 on Monday October 20, 2014 @01:49AM (#8480857)
Are you talking the Chrome omnibar suggestions, or google.com search bar? I'm not sure the difference matters. Anyway, a thoughtful person can probably tell that means their partial queries are being sent to Google ("knowledge that it's happening", as I said above), and adjust it if that bothers them.

With this Safari thing, it sounds like your queries are silently sent to Apple, in addition to Google or whoever your preferred search engine is. So, not only are they being sent somewhere without explicit consent, they are sent somewhere other than the place you explicitly consented to, in a way you won't see unless you dig into config dialogs/manuals and/or packet sniffers. Am I factually wrong on how this behavior works?

Am I being too flexible in ethical gymnastics to avoid condemning Google, while condemning Apple? It was hard to articulate the difference, so frankly maybe it's just that I like Google more. But I think it's fair to say that for me personally, Google Instant is more transparent and fair than how this Apple behavior sounds.

Also, to be honest, I haven't used Yosemite. I don't know if that invalidates my opinion. Maybe I should at least not form an opinion in this flame-fest of half-baked arguments from both sides.

Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by eclipxe on Sunday October 19, 2014 @09:55PM (#8480407)
Oh come on.
Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by mikeash on Sunday October 19, 2014 @10:13PM (#8480448)
If you think what I said was so absurd, I'd like to know what you think "privacy" entails, if it's not "don't share my info with other people."
[dead]
Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by threeseed on Sunday October 19, 2014 @09:06PM (#8480261)
What on earth are you talking about ?

The preferences aren't scattered through several dialogs. It's simply open Safari, goto Preferences, click on Search tab and uncheck the requisite Smart Search feature.

Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by scintill76 on Monday October 20, 2014 @01:29AM (#8480805)
... then, head on over to Spotlight, and disable its similar feature, apparently distinct but named the exact same thing.[0] And hope there are no other instances of this type of thing. That's what on earth I'm talking about.

People have pointed out that this option is kind of hard to find, even if you're looking for it (under Search, not Privacy.)[1] Also, if I chose the "Google" option, I might reasonably believe my searches were only being sent to Google, not Apple.[0] If this was a Microsoft computer, I'm pretty sure we'd all be angry if they had a default-on option phoning home Google queries!

Is [0] downvoted because he is factually wrong about the two options, or because everyone is determined to prosecute him to fullest extent of the HN downmod, for originally being sensationalist/mistaken and/or for having certain views on privacy?

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8480364 [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8480239

[deleted]
Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by TylerE on Sunday October 19, 2014 @09:19PM (#8480293)
> Wow so in other words feature with privacy violation or no feature at all? I.E. if you need search engine suggestions you have to give your search queries to Apple then? How is it not problematic?

How the hell else would you expect it work? It's like saying you expect to drive your car forever and never need to refuel.

Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by blinkingled on Sunday October 19, 2014 @09:21PM (#8480301)
> In Yosemite, all Safari web searches are sent to not only the search engine you've selected (e.g., Google, DuckDuckGo), but also to Apple

It would work perfectly fine if Apple only sent the search query to the search engine I have configured. Just like Chrome and Firefox do it.

Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by jsmthrowaway on Sunday October 19, 2014 @09:22PM (#8480304)
And then where would the Maps suggestions come from? The App Store suggestions? Have you used the feature at all?
Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by blinkingled on Sunday October 19, 2014 @09:25PM (#8480311)
I don't need Apple Maps to suggest anything to me. Where do I go to disable that? I don't see anything Maps related in any of the Safari or Spotlight options. Forcing it on by default so Apple gets all my queries is bad in itself - but not having an easy to find option to disable it is worse.

Edit: Found it in Include Spotlight Suggestions in Safari options - that seems to stop the Maps results. It's a mess - Safari has an option that relates to Spotlight results which invisibly relates to Apple Maps results but there is no mention of Apple Maps in any of the Spotlight options. _And_ it is on by default - not enabled at first run after user consent.

Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by ctdonath on Sunday October 19, 2014 @10:03PM (#8480427)
So don't use Spotlight. The whole point is to search EVERYWHERE IT CAN which requires asking a whole lotta services about what you're asking about.

Remember, the UI is intended for most of many millions of users, not the tiny number of people wound up about each and every nuance of a given UI action. Most users either want Spotlight to tell everything it can, or they just don't use it; few indeed want a detailed list of every service involved and a switch for disabling each one (never mind the symbiosis between many of those services).

Re:Safari is sending every search query to Apple by blinkingled on Sunday October 19, 2014 @10:07PM (#8480436)
> So don't use Spotlight.

Oh phew - there's a solution - I can as well stop using a Mac!

>Most users either want Spotlight to tell everything it can, or they just don't use it; few indeed want a detailed list of every service involved and a switch for disabling each one (never mind the symbiosis between many of those services).

I guess there is solid research around this? Good to know everyone wants everything or nothing!