News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by brohee on Thursday October 16, 2014 @09:09AM (#8464659)
Last I checked, most people mated with a partner of their choosing.

That you call it love and not "selection of the most desirable traits" doesn't change the facts ;-)

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by readerrrr on Thursday October 16, 2014 @09:22AM (#8464710)
You are using the same mistake as most people when they associate the word eugenics with mass forced extermination of certain traits. Because of fear and certain individuals in the past.

The word can be used in a modern context, where eugenics is performed voluntarily, on a very small population, and under scientific supervision for causes that benefit the entire humanity. The rest can live and love whoever they want.

Genetic manipulation functionally falls in the same category, but it is better accepted because it doesn't have the negative history attached to it.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by pcrh on Thursday October 16, 2014 @10:30AM (#8465040)
"Eugenics" is actually currently practiced, but described as pre-implantation diagnostics. This allows parents who are carriers of a deleterious mutation, such as that causing Tay Sachs Disease, to avoid having children with the condition.
Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by chriswarbo on Thursday October 16, 2014 @10:15AM (#8464958)
> The word can be used in a modern context, where eugenics is performed voluntarily

Relevant http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tMz_tK4Q6Qs

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by theletterasdf on Thursday October 16, 2014 @11:47AM (#8465516)
So what you're saying is that attractive women are all in on a eugenics conspiracy designed to wipe out white gamers who watch wolf sex cartoons?
Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by Dewie on Thursday October 16, 2014 @09:50AM (#8464835)
It isn't voluntary for the offspring that are created through such efforts. Sure, that's not the case for procreation to begin with... but the difference is that these people would effectively be bred for a specific purpose. Then, to keep it voluntary, I guess we would lightly suggest to them at some tender age to consider going into field which requires high intelligence? Or do we not interfere at all, and just observe them from a distance (since you mention scientific supervision)?
Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by crazypyro on Thursday October 16, 2014 @10:03AM (#8464907)
Nobody has a voluntary choice in their birth and eugenics doesn't have to breed people for a certain position or job. It may be something as simple as egg/sperm analysis that calculates a favorable (in whatever way the technology designers determine that) gene sequence and then the child would be raised normally. Eugenics doesn't mean the decay of the moral fabric of society or the loss of basic ethics in research. Why is it so hard to imagine eugenics integrating into modern society?

This fear is really surprising to me.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by dkarapetyan on Thursday October 16, 2014 @11:08AM (#8465294)
It's not surprising at all. Eugenics on a large scale is also know as population control and it elicits negative visceral reactions for good reasons. Large undertakings usually require some kind of central control and the history of such control is not positive at all.

Now if the choice comes down to something between two individuals because technology makes it possible to make certain choices that's a different matter but even then you are treading in dangerous territory. Who gets access to the technology? How do you verify that the technology is safe? Is there a beta test period? Who gets to be a beta tester? Anyway the list is long and the technology is nowhere near where it needs to be for even these kinds of choices to be made between two individuals let alone at the population level.

I find the idea in general just intuitively unappealing. Humanity can't breed itself out of the problems it is in. Being smart is simply not enough. Anything worthwhile requires hard work. So are you going to breed for hard work as well now? I don't see these scientists looking for those genes though.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by judk on Thursday October 16, 2014 @08:06PM (#8468650)
Its like you didn't even notice that World War II happened.
Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by JoeAltmaier on Thursday October 16, 2014 @10:10AM (#8464934)
Why not treat them identically to any intelligent child born today? This doesn't have to be weird.
Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by socialist_coder on Thursday October 16, 2014 @09:27AM (#8464724)
I would be more than happy to raise a child that was not genetically related to me if it's genes were "better".
Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by elpachuco on Thursday October 16, 2014 @03:01PM (#8466787)
You also have to define "better". Here we are only talking about super intelligence. But what about creativity in music, film, writing, etc. Those things enrich our lives. Who is going to make the films and animes that I love?

What if the person does not fit your definition of a super intelligent person with a high IQ but instead is a genius in music. Also, how do we know that by focusing only on super intelligent people we won't be killing off the other traits that make life worthwhile, the arts, music, film. There are multiple perspectives that make a person a genius, high IQ is just one of them among many.

As somebody else mentioned, just like breeding dogs, you may be able to select for one trait at the expense of the others.

Frankly high IQ is overrated. It is probably biased anyway. i.e. Children that grow up in high income families have better IQ results than children living in poverty. It could simply mean that the differentiator is good education at an early age.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by peterfirefly on Thursday October 16, 2014 @05:34PM (#8467903)
> [...] Children that grow up in high income families have better IQ results than children living in poverty.

Yes, because high IQ parents tend to make more money and tend to get high IQ children (even if those children got adopted away or orphaned early on). On the other hand, if high income families adopt children of low IQ parents those children end up with an IQ resembling that of their low IQ biological parents.

The research has been done.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by elpachuco on Thursday October 16, 2014 @08:55PM (#8468832)
>>even if those children got adopted away or orphaned early on

Was race accounted for. i.e. Where there minorities and white kids in the group. If only white kids then that tells me that the problem is more systemic. i.e. racism.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by peterfirefly on Friday October 17, 2014 @02:53AM (#8469738)
By the way, I don't know if you have heard about these two papers before. They might interest you (or not).

Hopkins, Russell, Schaeffer, "Chimpanzee Intelligence is Heritable", Current Biology, 2014.

<way too many coauthors to list but the main guy seems to be P.M. Visscher>, "Genome-wide association studies establish that human intelligence is highly heritable and polygenic", Molecular Psychiatry, 2011.

The latter paper reports on a study (with N=3511) on unrelated people to see whether their genotype and their phenotype regarding intelligence had anything to do with each other. People were tested with DNA chip for SNPs and had their IQ measured. The interesting result was that people who had more similar DNA also had more similar IQs (and vice versa, of course).

Drop me an email @gmail.com for copies.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by peterfirefly on Friday October 17, 2014 @02:41AM (#8469705)
If it holds for white kids in white countries (i.e. before mass immigration) then you agree that it is not about racism?

(Which it does, btw.)

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by blackbagboys on Thursday October 16, 2014 @03:55PM (#8467229)
"Creativity" is correlated with higher IQ.

I understand the urge to resist reducing humans to a single numerical measurement, but the fact is that "IQ" or "g" or general "cognitive ability" or whatever you want to call it is strongly positively correlated with almost every trait and life outcome that people value.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by ozy23378 on Thursday October 16, 2014 @08:22PM (#8468709)
This child may even come to understand the difference between "it's" and "its".

Thanks to Paul Graham, Sam Altman, Paul Buchheit, John Collison, Patrick Collison, Jessica Livingston, Robert Morris, Geoff Ralston, and Fred Wilson for reading drafts of this.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by cscurmudgeon on Thursday October 16, 2014 @10:34AM (#8465074)
Is the corollary that one should not raise less "better" children? If this what we come to practice as a species, I would definitely hope that a superior one wipes us out soon.
Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by LLWM on Thursday October 16, 2014 @11:44AM (#8465505)
If this is what we come to practice as a species, we are in fact replacing ourselves with something superior. And unless you hope for your children to never be as successful as you were, that's a good thing.
Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by walterbell on Thursday October 16, 2014 @12:08PM (#8465645)
For whose definition of "better" and "superior"?
Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by LLWM on Thursday October 16, 2014 @06:22PM (#8468180)
The parents of each individual child, obviously.
Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by cscurmudgeon on Thursday October 16, 2014 @03:04PM (#8466813)
I sincerely hope you see the contradiction in your comment.
Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by Dylan16807 on Thursday October 16, 2014 @03:53PM (#8467219)
The corollary is that you would not go out of your way to conceive more less "better" children.

Once you are responsible for a child, you stay responsible.

Don't make this weird.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by Dewie on Thursday October 16, 2014 @09:55AM (#8464857)
I notice your use of scare quotes. Is the state of the art advanced enough to make a judgement on whether or not a person is better at the genetic level than another person? I'm not just talking about some specific category or skill, but also as a well-rounded person. Because these people will have to live their own lives, and would be subject to whatever other traits that might arise when you try to optimize humans for some kind of skill. I at least don't think that the state of the art is so advanced that they can predict that optimizing for some specific trait might have some unforeseen consequences when it comes other, perhaps seemingly unrelated traits.
Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by wolfgke on Thursday October 16, 2014 @12:14PM (#8465672)
Unluckily at least in Germany highly educated people often produce less children than low educated ones.
Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by ZenoArrow on Thursday October 16, 2014 @12:56PM (#8465963)
The goal should be to help encourage the next generation to do something meaningful (to them), regardless of what advantages they had at birth.
Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by aurelian on Thursday October 16, 2014 @03:14PM (#8466900)
If country A makes and achieves its goal to give the next generation an average IQ of 130, and country B makes its goal to encourage the next generation to do something meaningful (to them), B will serve A before long.
Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by ZenoArrow on Thursday October 16, 2014 @03:32PM (#8467071)
I somewhat doubt it. Let's use something you're likely to be familiar with, smartphone apps... Now it's arguable that the skills required to develop a smartphone app implies a reasonable level of intelligence, yet look at any app store and you'll see huge numbers of uninspired, lowest common denominator shovelware. Does the world really need hundreds of todo apps? Do you really think people are driven to make those apps for anything greater than the "prestige" of being an app developer or a desperate attempt at making money?

Compare and contrast with a society that values the outcome of the work rather than how book smart you need to be able to do it. For example nature conservation is pretty easy to understand how to do right, and there's a tangible lasting benefit.

Guess it depends on what you view as a society worth having.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by peterfirefly on Thursday October 16, 2014 @05:26PM (#8467857)
Maybe. Or lots of people from country B will get into country A as "refugees", bring along their families, and have taxpayers in country A pay for them while they do what they can to be racist and criminal against native people from country A.

It depends on the moral sensibilities of the A'ers.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by judk on Thursday October 16, 2014 @08:08PM (#8468657)
Your veil is a bit too thin there.
Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by peterfirefly on Friday October 17, 2014 @02:33AM (#8469692)
Am I wrong?
Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by ZenoArrow on Friday October 17, 2014 @02:33PM (#8472603)
Yes.