News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Breaking up with America by kelukelugames on Monday September 08, 2014 @11:32AM (#8285318)
Rough.

I know a handful of talented developers stuck at a large company because of visa issues. They are too afraid to look for a better job because of immigration.

Re:Breaking up with America by billbrown on Monday September 08, 2014 @12:13PM (#8285575)
Every time I encounter the way our immigration policies treat various co-workers of mine, I'm ashamed and scandalized.

They are the last people to be a "drain on our economy" and they're effectively chained to their jobs, which seems so archaic.

Re:Breaking up with America by dllthomas on Monday September 08, 2014 @12:20PM (#8285610)
"they're effectively chained to their jobs, which seems so archaic."

Not just archaic, but wrong. And even if we say "but they're choosing to be here, so it still must be better than what they came from" - which isn't entirely false, but ignores some things - it still means that the rest of us are competing with these extra-abusable workers which some companies might not mind paying a premium for on paper.

Re:Breaking up with America by owenmarshall on Monday September 08, 2014 @12:20PM (#8285612)
Reserve some blame for your company: the reason H-1B programs are so widely abused is because industry can't give up cheap labor.
Re:Breaking up with America by zabraxias on Monday September 08, 2014 @12:32PM (#8285672)
That's an oversimplification since the valley is the leading proponent of immigration reform (yes since the companies there will get better access to foreign workers) but every other developed nation seems to have a more sensible policy like allowing "work status" and not tying it to a specific company. Green cards effectively do that but unless you're Bieber or can afford the $1M investment visa you don't get one on day 1.
Re:Breaking up with America by syntern on Monday September 08, 2014 @12:43PM (#8285752)
Green card is not a work permit, it is a residency status. People focus on the work part, but with choosing the green card, one is choosing between the US and the rest of the world for a very long time.

First of all, it requires you to reside in the US, permanently (hence the official name). You don't move home for longer periods (e.g. years), as getting back in the US is not automatic. I understand that the US sees entering in the US as privilege, but these people usually help the US economy, and not burden it, so there is that.

Second, it really limits your options. Suppose you decide to go outside of the US in just a few years after the green card, giving it up, and suddenly, for the rest of your life, whenever you enter in the US, you need to tell you life's story to the immigration officer and why you have applied for immigration status and what happened with it.

And if you have connections, properties or investments in Europe, you will be always in limbo whether the European bank will decline business with you based on your US tax status.

Going for a green card is a no-brainer for everyone who is going for US citizenship. Everyone else, take a better look on it, before you go for it.

Re:Breaking up with America by CodeMage on Monday September 08, 2014 @02:52PM (#8286494)
> Going for a green card is a no-brainer for everyone who is going for US citizenship. Everyone else, take a better look on it, before you go for it.

So what's the alternative? I'm asking out of honest curiosity, because H-1B seems to have at least two serious drawbacks: 1) if you want to switch jobs, you have to go through the lottery again (as far as I understand), and 2) your dependents are on H-4 visa, which means that they aren't allowed to get a job (except as a volunteer).

Re:Breaking up with America by abraham_s on Monday September 08, 2014 @04:29PM (#8287035)
1) Is not true. If you change jobs you don't have to go through the lottery again. It is just paperwork. 2) Is true and it is a big issue. It is sad to see educated spouses wasting their time here in the US
Re:Breaking up with America by syntern on Monday September 08, 2014 @03:08PM (#8286567)
I'm on H1B too with H4 spouse. My alternative is just to go back to Europe, and live there - and considering several factors, it may not be that different from the US (in terms of overall better vs. worse).
Re:Breaking up with America by tsycho on Monday September 08, 2014 @01:41PM (#8286117)
+1 to what you said. In addition, green cards take 6-12 years to process for those born in India or China (6+ years for EB-2, 10+ years for EB-3), so even if people want to get them, the wait duration is insanely long. And while your green card is being processed, you have significant restrictions in changing your company, job title or location, else you might be put back to the beginning of the queue.
Re:Breaking up with America by geebee on Monday September 08, 2014 @02:22PM (#8286330)
I agree that the US badly needs immigration reform, and that stories like this are painful to read. I see nothing productive about keeping someone like the author of this post out of the US, and I see plenty of harm.

I do think the US needs a skilled immigration system (perhaps a points based system like Australia), and perhaps we should increase the allotment (the US currently takes in about 1.2 million immigrants a year through a fairly byzantine system that makes it difficult for someone with no close US citizen relatives to immigrate here).

That's where my agreement with the lobbying efforts of large silicon valley companies ends, though. I'm not in favor of granting the HR departments of large silicon valley corporations control over the immigration system under the guise of immigration "reform". And while I do favor general skilled immigration, I don't think it should be specifically based on the notion of a tech or stem worker shortage, as I don't think the evidence supports this claim.

Re:Breaking up with America by jleyank on Tuesday September 09, 2014 @10:58AM (#8290443)
This was not the case 6-7 years ago in Canada. US-ians entering on a NAFTA visa were tied to their particular employer. They were able to apply for Permanent Resident status on this visa, which was helpful. The only change I am aware of is a shift from 1-year to 3-year visas. PR applications require multi-year time-in-Canada (and Quebec Selection if applying from Quebec).
Re:Breaking up with America by mycodebreaks on Monday September 08, 2014 @05:53PM (#8287536)
So many engineers/professionals with H1B are hired by Microsoft, Google, Facebook and many others. Are you saying those programmers are getting paid lower than their non-H1B counterparts?
Re:Breaking up with America by owenmarshall on Monday September 08, 2014 @09:32PM (#8288296)
I can't speak to specific companies.

On aggregate, H1B workers are being paid less than non-H1B workers. It doesn't take long to see this in action: http://www.foreignlaborcert.doleta.gov/performancedata.cfm#s... -- click around and ask yourself if those average wages look right. My state's average wage was what you'd pay a person coming straight out of college.

I'd definitely wager that if you compared all Microsoft H1B software engineers to all non-H1B MS SE's, you'd see a drop in wages. But I don't have a reliable indication of non-H1B salaries at MS, so I can't say for sure.

Re:Breaking up with America by seanmcdirmid on Monday September 08, 2014 @09:44PM (#8288335)
> I'd definitely wager that if you compared all Microsoft H1B software engineers to all non-H1B MS SE's, you'd see a drop in wages.

Why would you think this?

That information is publicly available; e.g. http://www.myvisajobs.com/Visa-Sponsor/Microsoft/356252_Sala...

I'm not sure what the "average salaries" for non-immigrants are, but you can get an idea here:

http://www.salarylist.com/company/Microsoft-Salary.htm

It doesn't look that different.

Re:Breaking up with America by owenmarshall on Monday September 08, 2014 @11:37PM (#8288633)
> Why would you think this?

Because that's been the pattern for most businesses. I doubt Microsoft is any different - why do you think it would be?

> It doesn't look that different.

The two pages you present compare "all MS salaries, globally" to "all MS H1B salaries, globally" - that's a meaningless comparison. A software engineer H1B is going to make more than a non-H1B tester.

Note again, I'm not trying to indict MS for anything here: I'm simply betting that MS is enjoying lower worker costs by employing H1B workers, just like many IT companies do.

I hope that's not the case, both for the H1B worker AND non-H1B workers.

Re:Breaking up with America by seanmcdirmid on Monday September 08, 2014 @11:48PM (#8288652)
From my limited experience, H1Bs seem to make as much as non-H1Bs. But then I work in China as an American on a work visa.
Re:Breaking up with America by shenoybr on Monday September 08, 2014 @12:51PM (#8285787)
While I've heard this argument over and over again that H1Bs are cheap labor, there is little hard evidence to support this. And while I agree, that there are cases of US visas (any visa, not just H1s) that are abused, generalizing the H1Bs as cheap labor is going too far. I speak from my own personal experience.
Re:Breaking up with America by owenmarshall on Monday September 08, 2014 @01:48PM (#8286173)
The salaries of the average H1B worker compared to the average American worker are probably relatively close.

But when I say H1B workers are "cheap labor" I'm claiming this on aggregate. If we take a charitable view that an H1B worker is paid $5K less than a non-H1B worker per year - and that's very charitable based on the numbers I've heard thrown around - a company like Tata or Accenture is looking at tens of millions of dollars in savings.

Note also my characterization was not on the quality of the work produced by H1B workers: I've seen some good and some bad, just like everyone else really. But having artificially cheap labor is inherently bad, both for the laborers that can't negotiate something better & workers in the rest of the industry whose wages are deflated to match.

Indeed, cheap labor is really only good for one group: the one that's constantly pushing to increase the H1B cap.

Re:Breaking up with America by scottlocklin on Monday September 08, 2014 @04:40PM (#8287102)
There is also the matter which was discussed in the original post: there are countless ways for employers to take advantage of immigrant workers. This makes them more desirable than native workers, who have more options.
Re:Breaking up with America by Retric on Monday September 08, 2014 @01:19PM (#8285954)
I have spoken to HR people that say H1Bs's are 15 to 20k/year cheaper on average. The trick is disconnecting what they do from what their job title is. After that you just pay them less for the same job.

That's not pure savings as there are plenty of paperwork costs etc, but you still end out ahead after ~1 year of work. O and just submit a lot of names to the lotto.

Re:Breaking up with America by sbilstein on Monday September 08, 2014 @01:08PM (#8285878)
It's not always cheap labor, but when perusing the publicly listed wages for engineers on h1-b visas, they seem on average lower than the offers I've received for the same title at the same companies. It's hard to make any strong conclusions however, since most salaries are not published and just a job title does not say too much about how someone was hired into a company.

I agree generalizing it as cheap labor is not fair, but I do feel sorry for my friends just starting their careers with a serious lack of job mobility.

Re:Breaking up with America by omegaworks on Monday September 08, 2014 @03:54PM (#8286838)
>they're effectively chained to their jobs

Any restriction on the movement of free labor puts us all down. Their employers are less likely to treat them well because they know how dependent they are on the job just for the visa.

Re:Breaking up with America by lambdasquirrel on Monday September 08, 2014 @11:58AM (#8285486)
The U.S. seems much like the late Roman Empire in this sense. Whereas the growth and expansion of the Roman Empire was fueled by its wars and conquests, which brought back slaves and material wealth, the American Empire's growth has been fueled by skimming off the top of the middle and upper classes wherever there's been socioeconomic troubles elsewhere.

The U.S. can get away with policy inefficiencies like this because there's so many people who want to get in right now, and it actually works in favor of the Powers That Be, because they can get decent talent that's easy to "keep them in their place" because of said policy inefficiencies.

That having been said, the U.S. doesn't going blowing stuff up in Europe to make this advantages happen. For a lot of people, it is a beacon of opportunity. It's not all blue skies and roses though.

Re:Breaking up with America by coldtea on Monday September 08, 2014 @06:01PM (#8287571)
>That having been said, the U.S. doesn't going blowing stuff up in Europe to make this advantages happen.

No, just in the third and developing world.

In Europe they just push and abuse diplomatically lesser states (up to the point to having supported or even established specific goverments and even dictatorships over the last 60 years) to get the trade agreements and diplomatic support they want.

Re:Breaking up with America by dredmorbius on Monday September 08, 2014 @12:41PM (#8285735)
The US has done its share of economic imperialism as well, just not through colonies-in-name.
Re:Breaking up with America by nolite on Monday September 08, 2014 @12:36PM (#8285703)
no, they just blow stuff up everywhere else in the world.. either literally, or politically..
Re:Breaking up with America by nilsimsa on Monday September 08, 2014 @12:27PM (#8285646)
Where are they located?
Re:Breaking up with America by tomwilde on Monday September 08, 2014 @01:15PM (#8285929)
It seems like the author is a Briton.

As a Swiss citizen I don't understand how anyone from a first-world country would like to move to the USA. It's a downgrade in every aspect.

Giving up democracy, social-security, the practical absence of crime for a job in a country where every other Tuesday someone goes on a killing-spree, where people go to the doctor for moar Vicodine, where police will kill you for a donut. Nope.

Edit: changed englishman to briton. Thank you, commenters.

Re:Breaking up with America by kareemm on Monday September 08, 2014 @01:38PM (#8286089)
As a Canadian who's lived in many parts of the world, including the US, it's the unbridled friendliness, optimism, hustle, and (generally speaking) caring only what you can do and not where you're from that made living in the US preferable to other countries.

The downside, of course, being the trade-offs you mention.

Re:Breaking up with America by jwhitlark on Monday September 08, 2014 @01:59PM (#8286227)
I had a friend of mine who had emigrated from Iran to England, (obtaining English citizenship). After 6 years in England, he came to the US and eventually got citizenship here. I asked him the same question, "Why would someone move to the US from a first world country?" I found his response interesting: "Because in Europe, you stay where they put you."
Re:Breaking up with America by soperj on Monday September 08, 2014 @02:23PM (#8286336)
Heard the same about a co-worker from China who'd first moved to Germany and then to Canada. Moved to Canada because no matter how long you are in Germany, you will always be a foreigner.
Re:Breaking up with America by robrenaud on Monday September 08, 2014 @02:10PM (#8286263)
I am an American who has a pretty strong desire to leave, at least for a few years. But your post is such a laughable caricature.

Maybe they want to live somewhere that people have the freedom to build mosques with minarets and where nearly every women born in the country had suffrage for their whole lifetime?

Re:Breaking up with America by HarryHirsch on Monday September 08, 2014 @03:23PM (#8286650)
Switzerland is pretty special, but so are the swathes of America that aren't on the coasts.

Only from flyover America comes this constant trickle of reports of yet another female principal standing at the school door checking the hemlines of her charges. As for mosques with minarets, I saw this mosque (a big one) in a large Southern city that looked vaguely like a church, didn't have a minaret, didn't even mention that it was in fact a mosque, it just had a three-letter acronym on the side in green letters. This is a strong statement for a religion that actively seeks converts. John 8:7 please.

Re:Breaking up with America by Thrymr on Monday September 08, 2014 @01:28PM (#8286014)
> It seems like the author is an Englishman.

A UK citizen, probably, but I'd not assume that a guy named "McDowell" from Belfast is English.

Re:Breaking up with America by carlob on Monday September 08, 2014 @01:45PM (#8286139)
> It seems like the author is an Englishman.

Northern-Irish, so technically a Briton, but not an Englishman.

Re:Breaking up with America by cryoshon on Monday September 08, 2014 @02:45PM (#8286457)
What do you mean about giving up democracy? It's unclear what you're referring to.
Re:Breaking up with America by tomwilde on Monday September 08, 2014 @03:33PM (#8286708)
You don't get to vote.
Re:Breaking up with America by cryoshon on Monday September 08, 2014 @03:52PM (#8286826)
Technically, we do get to vote. The way our votes are counted makes them less valuable, and our votes aren't as strong as special interests, though.

But, the US is a democracy by name. I'm not sure where you're coming from by saying it isn't.

Re:Breaking up with America by tomwilde on Monday September 08, 2014 @06:36PM (#8287709)
A foreigner working in the USA doesn't get to vote for the laws they live under. That's what I'm trying to communicate.
Re:Breaking up with America by ahomescu1 on Monday September 08, 2014 @06:41PM (#8287728)
Does a foreigner working in Switzerland get to vote in any election? It's my impression that all countries restrict voting to their own citizens.
Re:Breaking up with America by c_plus_minus on Tuesday September 09, 2014 @06:23AM (#8289445)
I'm sure the Swiss do, but just an aside that plenty of EU countries allow members from other countries to vote in their elections. E.g. here in Ireland I think we only restrict constitutional referenda to Irish citizens.
Re:Breaking up with America by ahomescu1 on Tuesday September 09, 2014 @04:05PM (#8292581)
It seems it does vary heavily by country [1]. My country (Romania) does not give any voting rights to foreigners (AFAIK), and I thought the US didn't either.

1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_of_foreigners_to_vote

Re:Breaking up with America by ahomescu1 on Monday September 08, 2014 @05:30PM (#8287421)
> for a job in a country where every other Tuesday someone goes on a killing-spree

As a European living in California (Orange County currently, but have spent some time in Silicon Valley too), I strongly disagree with that. Most parts of California are safer than my home country, and people definitely do not shoot each other "every Tuesday" (I know you were exaggerating, but still...)

Re:Breaking up with America by nilsimsa on Monday September 08, 2014 @08:28PM (#8288114)
Does Switzerland have any restrictions to people for work permits or immigration?
Re:Breaking up with America by kelukelugames on Monday September 08, 2014 @03:11PM (#8286582)
Redmond. ;)