I strongly doubt this will significantly affect the level of piracy in music; instead it's a really interesting application of a pair of interesting things, PANDA and the difference in 'randomness' between encrypted and unencrypted streams.
I wonder if we'll start to see more crypto methods that deliberately avoid looking like encrypted data to make this sort of attack harder. ISTR agl's pond did something like this, but I could be imaging it, and I've not seen it widely implemented.
Because DRM sucks. Why can I only listen to Spotify through their player? Why am I restricted to using it only on computers/devices that they've ported their player to?
It's not exactly the same, but back when iTunes sold DRM encrusted music files, I used to strip all the DRM from the files I legally purchased, so that I could play them on my Linux system, stream them to my Philips wifi speaker system, etc.
Being locked in to a single vendor's ecosystem sucks. This is part of the reason why I currently refuse to purchase video from iTunes or Amazon. When the industry wises up and drops DRM from video, I will happily start patronizing them.
Spotify is a bit different—it's more like Netflix than iTunes or Amazon. Still, if I'm paying for it, it's still frustrating to only being able to use their players [1].
[1] My TiVo has a built-in Netflix player, but it really sucks. Much of the newer content doesn't actually decode properly. Being locked into their system means I'm at their mercy. If I could get at the stream I could use a computer somewhere to transcode it into something the TiVo could reliably play... But the DRM prohibits me from doing that, and that's frustrating.
However: it's worth knowing whether content protection is implemented soundly. Contrary to overwhelming popular opinion, there are content protection schemes that work. Generalist engineers mistakenly believe that content protection schemes must be unbreakable to provide value. They don't: all they have to do is cost more to break than the value of the content they protect (across all the users who might subsequently get access to it).
For an example of a content protection scheme that worked extremely well, see modern satellite TV smart cards.
Given that there are ways to implement content protection soundly, there's validity to research that determines whether a given content protection scheme is sound.
One prevents the attacker from accessing something they aren't subscribed to, and relies on crypto and secure subscriber identity mechanisms. This is completely possible to implement soundly.
The other prevents the attacker from copying something they can see or listen to, and relies on bizarre mechanisms designed to prevent the user from learning the state of their hardware.
I find the latter awful, because it's an infinitely losing battle (you can always point a camera at your display in the end) which erodes consumer freedoms and encourages walled gardens.
Satellite TV is a funny example - since the communication is strictly one-way, the hardware state needs to be protected or it can be cloned, but I still think it's fundamentally a question of the transport protection variety rather than the copy protection one.
Meanwhile, it all works because nobody cares to break your DRM because audio is already widely distributed in lossless DRM-free formats (CDs), and Blu-Ray DRM is already broken. The pirates don't want Netflix's 5Mbps stream when they can just buy a Blu-Ray and get a 50Mbps copy instead. (Similarly, they don't want Spotify's Vorbis stream because they can just source material from the uncompressed CD.)
(Piracy works because it's a http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_cow_problem)
My point was that normally we explain piracy by "it is an easier way of enjoying ..." and I can agree with that, but few things are easier to use (and pay for) than Spotify. I can see your point about researching their content protection.
Edit: Wow, learned my lesson, don't express admiration. I guess I just don't get the downvoting without leaving a comment.
Whereas any software-based mechanism, without buy-in from the OS/OEM, is essentially going to always be one click away from being cracked, as far as end-users view it.
I see the "problem" as a simple one. If there is chance that a systems DRM can be broken by merely one person, all efforts by that provider, and now most other providers, at least those that share methodologies, is pointless.
If a song, book, or movie are locked down, only legitimate subscribers can use that media under the terms the owner or distributor of that media define. But if only one person of the potentially millions is able to break that encryption, one person has now made all the work and man hours of into said encryption completely worthless.
If it takes a few weeks to break encryption that took months of multiple man hours to create, was that time wisely spent? Once it's broken, the data is now open to everyone. That being the case, I feel were in a "why bother" scenario.
The main reason I see illegally pirated material not proliferating even more is the technical barrier to acquiring the files. And often times, applications and protocols like bit-torrent, tor, VPN's, SSL links, etc. have too high a technical barrier for the common user to start pirating their media.
Once that burden is removed, it's game over and everything will be free at a click of the mouse, until something new comes along or a better business model that works with the fast changing technology world we are in.
When you are waging a war of one against millions and the one can actually win without putting themselves in harms way, you have a war that many will think is a sure fire win for the millions. A million against one is a pretty good ratio. But in this case, the one has a very good chance of annihilating the millions.
Eventually we will learn there is no point. In the meantime, people do this type of reverse engineering for a number of reasons I imagine. Curiosity, the challenge, making a political statement, and most importantly, to learn.
From this, perhaps something new is learned. And from that a new library is made which then gets adapted to detect intrusions on our personal computers and embedded devices. Who knows what may come of this research.
In the end, my position on piracy doesn't matter. What I do know is it will happen, encryption will be reverse engineered or broken, and those who can't learn the technology to use the new research will continue to find the barrier to piracy too high. Others won't, and will get their media freely, sans any lockdown from what you want to do with what you purchased.
Cars can go well over the speed limit. Some to speeds that make no sense to even exist. But they are legal, and most people follow the speed limit laws. The cost and barriers of breaking those laws are too high so people follow the rules. With DRM, the cost is negligible, so the rules will be broken.
But mainly, I think the answer to your question is that curiosity drives a lot of this. Aside from curiosity it could be a lack of trust. Researchers want to know what is going on with their media and hardware.
How do you know an encrypted file is not up to nefarious deeds? The common user never will. But a researcher like this would discover that the file was up to more than just DRM, and that could potentially help those millions of people become more aware of security, and learn to be more skeptical of what they buy.
I have a PPC computer running Linux. It is impossible for me to use Spotify on this computer. I am happy to pay for the service. Is it irresponsible for me to reverse-engineer the protocol so that I may use a service I have paid for on a device they do not support?
Reverse-engineering the protocol doesn't necessarily mean I want to pirate the content.
Right now I'm listening to an audiobook. I would LOVE to listen to that on my Linux machine. How..? I would DEFINITELY prefer not to lose that access (again?), when I decide that the subscription for crappy DRM'd content isn't worth my money.
Still, I'm annoyed at the DRM, I can't listen to what I want where I want, and there are alternative DRM-free alternatives, so I'm also seriously considering cancelling my account. Glad to hear they still let you access your previous purchases (it was my main worry).
Also, DRM is not necessarily intrinsically linked with payment. For example, people release DRM-free games on the Humble Bundles, and they make millions for charity. There are some business models that don't work well without it, yes (Spotify's particular model of streaming, for example), but plenty that don't need any DRM at all (digital radio stations, for example).
I would even argue that Spotify only needs to include DRM to pacify the labels it has deals with. Because you can get basically any specific mainstream song via Youtube and if you want to have huge collections of some music genre there are torrents for that, too. The main selling point of Spotify is its implicit promise of rewarding the authors and the comfort of music selection it offers.
The albums are The Hands that Thieve by Streetlight Manifesto and The Hand that Thieves by Toh Kay, but I'm not sure if there's a detailed writeup anywhere. The band posted this: http://streetlightmanifesto.com/update-the-continued-struggl... and eventually had to cancel all of the preorders. They also posted this about their label: http://streetlightmanifesto.com/streetlight-manifesto-proudl...
Purchasing drm-free downloads, physical CDs, cassettes, and vinyl are the reasonable ways.
It's a damned convenient service though.
My iTunes library is huge. I still end up listening to the same albums with my (paid) Spotify subscription for the pure convenience alone.
Edit: I've just remembered the boxes upon boxes of CDs I have in storage in the uk. That's five years, doubt I've given them a second thought for at least the last four.
Is this what we've come to? No one should get paid for anything if we can enjoy it for free regardless of the hoops we will have to jump through to not pay?
Sorry if I am too dramatic. I can often see the point of pirating things, but in this case I just don't get it.
Edit: I would appreciate an explanation of the downvotes.