News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Breaking Spotify DRM with PANDA by tptacek on Friday July 04, 2014 @02:56PM (#7989854)
I understand where you're coming from (also, piracy repulses me).

However: it's worth knowing whether content protection is implemented soundly. Contrary to overwhelming popular opinion, there are content protection schemes that work. Generalist engineers mistakenly believe that content protection schemes must be unbreakable to provide value. They don't: all they have to do is cost more to break than the value of the content they protect (across all the users who might subsequently get access to it).

For an example of a content protection scheme that worked extremely well, see modern satellite TV smart cards.

Given that there are ways to implement content protection soundly, there's validity to research that determines whether a given content protection scheme is sound.

Re:Breaking Spotify DRM with PANDA by bri3d on Friday July 04, 2014 @03:32PM (#7989983)
I generally agree, but I think you're conflating two kinds of content protection.

One prevents the attacker from accessing something they aren't subscribed to, and relies on crypto and secure subscriber identity mechanisms. This is completely possible to implement soundly.

The other prevents the attacker from copying something they can see or listen to, and relies on bizarre mechanisms designed to prevent the user from learning the state of their hardware.

I find the latter awful, because it's an infinitely losing battle (you can always point a camera at your display in the end) which erodes consumer freedoms and encourages walled gardens.

Satellite TV is a funny example - since the communication is strictly one-way, the hardware state needs to be protected or it can be cloned, but I still think it's fundamentally a question of the transport protection variety rather than the copy protection one.

Re:Breaking Spotify DRM with PANDA by jrockway on Saturday July 05, 2014 @04:43AM (#7991367)
Indeed, the goal of DRM is to transfer the liability to someone else. If you make a product that plays back DRM'd content, you don't want to get sued when someone figures out how to use your system to pirate stuff. So you ask the copyright holder what to do, and they say "buy solution XXX that's already approved", and then you do. Then you're happy, because you don't get sued, the chip manufacturer is happy, because you have to buy their chips (and whatever other fun add-ons you may need for your product) from them, and the copyright holder is happy, because the chip company's lawyers convinced their lawyers that nobody can pirate stuff.

Meanwhile, it all works because nobody cares to break your DRM because audio is already widely distributed in lossless DRM-free formats (CDs), and Blu-Ray DRM is already broken. The pirates don't want Netflix's 5Mbps stream when they can just buy a Blu-Ray and get a 50Mbps copy instead. (Similarly, they don't want Spotify's Vorbis stream because they can just source material from the uncompressed CD.)

(Piracy works because it's a http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_cow_problem)

Re:Breaking Spotify DRM with PANDA by Steer on Friday July 04, 2014 @03:15PM (#7989921)
First, I'm a bit starstruck by getting a reply from tptacek, I feel validated that I wasn't totally off base. Silly, I know. Thank you for your reply and you are of course right, I appreciate you also putting this into context (tv smart cards). As I said, I was probably overly dramatic.

My point was that normally we explain piracy by "it is an easier way of enjoying ..." and I can agree with that, but few things are easier to use (and pay for) than Spotify. I can see your point about researching their content protection.

Edit: Wow, learned my lesson, don't express admiration. I guess I just don't get the downvoting without leaving a comment.

Re:Breaking Spotify DRM with PANDA by Zigurd on Friday July 04, 2014 @06:49PM (#7990460)
Having strong content protection on a system, and securing that system for its owner are not reconcilable goals. DRM and "trusted computing" is Big Brother Inside.
Re:Breaking Spotify DRM with PANDA by MichaelGG on Friday July 04, 2014 @07:00PM (#7990491)
Are there protection schemes that "work" on properly user-controlled hardware? DirecTV and Xbox and the like can get away with this since they can ship a big block of hardware. It requires some level of work (not click and play) to crack such a device, even if you know how to do it.

Whereas any software-based mechanism, without buy-in from the OS/OEM, is essentially going to always be one click away from being cracked, as far as end-users view it.