News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by rquantz on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @10:32PM (#7808095)
It seems like a mistake to remove manual controls entirely, not necessarily because of safety concerns, but because there are a fair number of times when you need the car to go somewhere without having a route. I'm thinking of things like:

Moving your car ten feet so somebody else can get out of the driveway; handling double parking during alternate side parking hours; moving the car because you were waiting to pick someone up in a no-standing zone and a cop just pulled up behind you; moving the car to just the right spot so grandma doesn't have to walk any more steps than absolutely necessary; parking on a lawn for a party or concert; backing up to just the right spot so you can hitch up a trailer.

The list could go on forever, and that's the point -- you can surely automate away some of these tasks, but there is an infinite multiplicity of things that need to be done with a car, and having to point them out on a map in order to get the car to do them, or even use a joystick to do it, sounds like an obnoxious chore.

Edit: to those who disagree with me by pointing to a utopian future of car sharing for everyone and no one even being able to drive, that's fine I guess, but this seems to be suggesting that the very first generation of these will be without a steering wheel, when very few people will have these cars and all of the problems I listed will still exist. Even if your ultimate goal is for passengers to be completely dependent on the AI for navigation, that's just not going to be an option when these things roll off the lot as soon as 2016.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by Mister_Snuggles on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @10:37PM (#7808107)
I think the eventual goal will be that most cars will be self-driving and that will negate most of those problems.

I imagine that the vision of the future is a giant car-sharing program made up of self-driving cars all coordinated by Google. Think about it - you fire up an app to request a car, one appears at your door within a couple of minutes, takes you to work, then disappears. After work, a different car picks you up, whisks you home, then scurries off to recharge/refuel/drive someone else. I suspect that in the long term the thinking is that things like "parking" and "owning a car" will be less common than they are today.

There will still be a place for manually driven cars, like ones pulling a trailer, etc.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by User9812 on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @12:04AM (#7808341)
I can't see that working. You'll require a ton of cars taking individuals or small groups to and from work in a big city. That's not very efficient, and the reason we have a metro system in the first place.

1. That's a lot of pollution. 2. You have twice as much traffic, since these cars need to come to your house every morning, and drive back to their charging station in the evening. They can take those trips off-peak hours, but you still have a lot more cars on the road. They could stay at your house overnight to save on wasting energy, but at that point you're just owning a car, or renting one full-time. 3. Do many people take a taxi to and from work daily? No, and this is quite similar. It's too expensive, people take public transportation, or buy a cheap vehicle (this could be that vehicle).

This is a replacement for the taxi, and for car rentals. If you live in a city and need to rent a car for a day, this would be a great situation. You don't even need a driver's license, so you just push a button, car appears, and you're taking it to your destination. I've lived in a dozen different cities, and this is something I'd use. I don't rent cars often because it's kind of a hassle, a little scary driving in a new city, and a little annoying searching for parking, but the convenience of pushing a button would encourage me to use it for certain trips. It should also be slightly cheaper than a taxi since you're not paying or tipping a driver.

They could probably get creative and offer monthly plans, where you get up to X trips, and Y kilometers, for a slightly better rate than renting on a per trip basis.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by prawn on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @12:39AM (#7808444)
1. Less pollution than what we have now given that many people spend time hunting for a park when they arrive, or drive five-seat vehicles even though they're alone or with 1-2 others. I read something saying that in a city centre, often 30% of traffic is simply people hunting for a park. I know when I arrive near my office, I can spend 5-10 minutes driving around trying to get an all-day park. Three times a week I'm driving an SUV that can seat five and has a large boot (passengers are my wife and toddler), the other days I'm in a five seat sedan (and solo).

2. I'd say that depots will be interspersed around the city and suburbs, for one thing. Cars might move from suburban depots over night to densely-arranged city parking/depots during the day, waiting for the evening rush. A car that dropped you at work after your run in from the South is then immediately free to take someone from the city centre down South again, or be available for a courier job, or a tourist leaving a city hotel for a day trip. The mesh of cars communicating will determine the most economical use of the vehicles and anticipate demand. Further, cars communicating with each other will mean that typical causes of congestion (like traffic lights) will be better handled and less of an issue.

3. Taxis are expensive partly because there are salaried humans driving them. If these are electric vehicles and solar charged, fuel and driver are largely out of the equation.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by User9812 on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @02:21AM (#7808648)
1. Not sure I agree with the first point. People hunting for a parking space once a day likely causes less pollution then a car driving itself to a charging station or depot twice a day. Plus, if these are an affordable method of commuting, you're going to be pulling people away from public transportation, and getting more vehicles on the road. If they're more expensive, then you'll just have people buying their own, and then they're in your situation, where they buy an SUV model since it's more versatile.

2. Moving some depots outside the city will definitely help. Yes, some of the cars going into the city will be used for courier jobs, or tourist day trips, but that's an incredibly small percentage. You might have 500,000 automated cars taking people to work. 450,000 sit in a depot waiting for the evening commute, and 50,000 are used for people active in the day. Once again 500,000 people take their car home, and about 450,000 sit idle again waiting for the next day. How does this work as a business? If you use one of these cars for work, you need to pay for 90% of the cost, because that car rarely gets used outside of taking you to and from work. Sure, you could do a ride share with a couple of other people, but still, the few of you are renting that car full-time. It doesn't work.

3. If these can be solar charged, then surely a taxi can be solar charged, so there's no difference in fuel cost. You're paying a driver, and someone in an office answering calls, so there is an extra cost, and I think they have a use case here.

In short, these cars need to be on the road all day long, that's how they lower their prices and raise efficiency. That doesn't work for daily commuting. However, they would be an incredible taxi service. Imagine you have a fleet of 100 automated cars, people use an app to set their pickup/destination, and the cars find the most efficient way of organizing the routes and schedule. A car breaks down, and another one automatically reroutes itself. You could give people the option of carpooling with a checkbox. Let people register on the app, and upload a photo. So, you set your destination, and it says it'll be $10 and 15 minutes, or you can carpool with John (25/male), and it'll cost your $7.50, and 20 minutes. This could even happen while you're in transit. You get a pop-up on the dash. Want to lower your rate and share a ride with the person in this photo? Say yes, we'll credit $5 to your account, and take a 5 minute detour to pick them up. Worried about safety? You could review passengers, and only car pool with people that have a high rating and good feedback. I think that's exciting, it should offer lower rates to consumers, and you get to socialize with new people at the same time, so you might make some friends on your next taxi ride.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by prawn on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @02:43AM (#7808699)
1. Public transport will still be cheaper, so it will still have its place. And I think we'll see small charging spaces that autonomous vehicles can use every block or so. Plus parking for these vehicles will be dense and save loads of space - it is obscene how much of our space is dedicated to parking.

I think we'll also see something in between a typical commuting vehicle and a bus. If 10 people in a specific area have regular bookings to go from a two block area to the CBD in a fixed time, then a van will do pick-ups and drop-offs either from houses or from fixed corners (think unmarked bus stops). It will be like demand-based bus routes.

I think we might also eventually see pod-based vans for people that don't want to socialise in any way with others in the vehicle. That said, people cope with the subway OK.

I don't think pollution from driving will be a significant factor with a serious influx in electric vehicles.

2. That's worse than what's happening now. I think we'll see peak pricing motivate changes in schedules and a decrease in the full complement of cars. I also think we'll see companies selling time-share in vehicles so you might buy one of these cars to have priority access, but then earn money from whenever it's available to work for you as part of a network. Those that want to keep one dedicated to themselves could.

3. Staff costs are significant in Australia so here and in similar places, I think taxis will be increasingly popular. Already it's not far off the case that commuting via taxi outside peak times could be more affordable for me with a second car I use twice a day, twice a week. Four taxi trips would cost me $12-17 each ($2500-3500/year). My second car, ignoring the cost to buy it would reach $2500 annually from registration, insurance and maintenance. That ignores depreciation, cleaning, hassle of parking, walking to my parking spot in the rain four blocks away, etc. Take away salary costs of taxis and make them easy to hail and pay by phone and I'd switch so quickly. And I think many people would prefer to travel by autonomous vehicle than with a driver who smells, listens to crappy radio stations or answers their phone the entire trip.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by User9812 on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @03:23AM (#7808816)
A bus is possible, but if this was a viable business, it should exist already. The only difference is the cost of the driver, so the automated bus might save passengers $5/day. Is that $5/day extra cost keeping this business non-existent at the moment? I'm a little skeptical.

Keep in mind your taxi service is cheap because it's on the road all the time. A taxi might make $250/day, and pay the driver half of that cost. That means the company is making $125/day per taxi. You're one of 15 or 20 people taking that taxi in a day, so the $15 trip is possible. If everyone was taking an automated car to work, they need to pay the majority of that $125/day price. Split it with 4 people, and that's just over $30/day each. Kind of expensive. Add more people and we're turning into a bus or public transit again.

Work schedules offset would help everything all around. If some people worked 7-3, 8-4, 9-5, 10-6, 11-7, etc, then we could decrease rush hour traffic, and use the cars multiple times to lower the price to $10/day, which starts to become interesting.

I like your idea of buying a car, adding it to a network, and getting money back when you're not using it.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by prawn on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @08:27AM (#7809540)
"A bus is possible, but if this was a viable business, it should exist already. The only difference is the cost of the driver, so the automated bus might save passengers $5/day. Is that $5/day extra cost keeping this business non-existent at the moment? I'm a little skeptical."

$5/day could be enough, especially if the parking situation changed for drivers at the other end. Take away street parking (no longer required when most cars are autonomous) near my office and I'd likely catch the bus. Have a bus that took me virtually door to door (rather than walking 3-4 blocks at each end) and I'd likely switch already.

I think lack of imagination might be one thing stopping a service like this existing now, and volume of passengers. If you wanted to start it now, you'd need coverage to justify the advertising campaign to build customers and to make it worthwhile. You'd need a fleet and then to hire and train drivers.

In the future, it will be APIs/software.

Imagine it's almost worth my while to pay $15/trip now. Then take out the driver and make it $10/trip plus pain-free bookings - I could read/work without feeling like I was being rude to the driver. Then imagine my booking app offers me $5/trip if I'm willing to car-pool, with the software automatically picking my ride-mates and most efficient pick-up and drop-off route. I'm pretty likely to do that. In dense areas and with time, manoeuvrable vans could be even more effective and the upgrade could be done with a software update.

Not to mention the bonus of taking cars off the street.

Autonomous vans on demand are going to be incredibly useful for wine tasting trips...

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by dzhiurgis on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @07:12AM (#7809318)
Everything relating to public transportation will be the major pain point. It is heavily regulated, subsidised, unionised, etc.

London isn't able to replace ticket sellers with machines yet, so you can imagine how long it will take to replace the drivers. Alternatively, they will see this a profit eating activity and resist until the people wouldn't take it anymore.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by jeremyjh on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @02:43PM (#7812019)
When I was in London in 2009 I bought metro and surface train tickets from a machine.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by dzhiurgis on Thursday May 29, 2014 @08:18AM (#7815822)
Humans are still an option. And there are few other roles that are redundant, but every two months workers strike to keep them.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by lmm on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @10:02AM (#7809914)
> A bus is possible, but if this was a viable business, it should exist already. The only difference is the cost of the driver, so the automated bus might save passengers $5/day. Is that $5/day extra cost keeping this business non-existent at the moment? I'm a little skeptical.

You're already seeing the much-maligned google (and other tech companies) buses in SF and area, so they're just-about-viable for some cases. I've seen a similar business model for hotel-airport shuttle services, and these kind of vehicles are everywhere in denser cities (Hong Kong, Firenze).

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by Joeri on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @02:47AM (#7808714)
You can price the car based on the time of the ride, to spread out rush hour and reuse vehicles for multiple trips. It will always be more efficient than privately owned vehicles due to the ability to choose the appropriate vehicle for the ride, instead of having to buy a vehicle for the most intensive purpose and underutilizing it a majority of the time.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by jfoutz on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @02:05AM (#7808611)
I think you're underestimating the amount of pollution/resources that go into making a car. Reducing the overall number of cars produced would offset a huge number of those extra trips.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by newaccountfool on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @02:43AM (#7808704)
I think people forget about this point, especially tyres. They take a ton of effort to make and you cant really resuse them for much afterwords.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by mikeloeb on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @10:32PM (#7814387)
I keep hearing the "there would be fewer cars" claim, but my counter-claim is that the mileage would be the same, so wear and tear would be the same. Look at how quickly taxis decay to see this.

Furthermore, I looked up reuses for tires. There is already a large, multi-stage chain of reuses and recycling for them, for all kinds of applications, from burning for cement kilns to civil engineering and agricultural products.[0] [1] [2] As one article put it "Those same characteristics, which make waste tires such a problem, also make them one of the most re-used waste materials"

[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tire_recycling

[1] http://www.designrulz.com/product-design/2012/12/20-ideas-of...

[2] http://www.earth911.com/living/travel-living/recycling-myste...

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by pwf on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @12:44PM (#7811274)
I imagine this working a lot like car2go, which I've used to commute in Austin. The cars are rarely at a central depot except for maintenance. They're left wherever you last used them until someone else gets in. This could only be better than that, as users won't have to walk to find one.

There's no reason for the cars to drive back into the city every evening. They could charge themselves while you're at work if they had to charge daily.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by facepalm on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @04:48AM (#7808987)
It will presumably be cheaper than taxis, that is kind of the point.

I think most people don't even realize how expensive their car really is (is there such a thing as a "cheap car", if you take into account taxes, insurance, gas prices, maintenance, time wasted looking for parking and waiting in traffic jams). Convenience of autonomous cars might quickly win them over.

Charging: maybe you have a point for people who commute from suburbs. But you could have charging stations in the suburbs. I think there will be algorithms for determining optimal distribution of cars and charging stations. Apparently the Tesla can be charged at a normal power socket. If that goes for other cars as well, there would be no reason not to have lots and lots of charging stations (contrary to gas which is explosive and toxic, so you don't want to have a gas station near your house).

Anybody with a house front could perhaps offer a charging station to earn some money on the side.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by lars512 on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @09:18AM (#7809718)
You're right, public transport isn't going anywhere and still has huge efficiency benefits. But these cars can make it better, by solving the first/last mile problem.

I imagine them ferrying people frantically to and from mass transit hubs, especially between low-density suburban housing and trains.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by danielweber on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @10:12AM (#7809975)
You are going to have to, first, make the mass transit so awesome that people voluntarily leave their cars behind to get on the train.

As you get more cars off the road, other people will use the open roads to travel into the city.

Note that "you have to make mass transit awesome enough that people use it" is not "make driving suck." You will never make any headway in a democracy by telling the majority of the people they should re-arrange their lives to follow your utopian model.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by digikata on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @04:42PM (#7812744)
If you have automated cars at either end of a rail system, you get rail efficiency in the middle. This alleviates one big reason not to use trains to commute - the stations are farther than walking distance at one end. If you get an automated ride to cover the gap between the station and your work - it complements both systems.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by anigbrowl on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @10:57PM (#7808174)
Correct. That's one reason I think that Chicago's decision to privatize parking was an inspired one. The city got a great deal of criticism for giving a decades-long revenue concession to a private operator for a relatively low up-front cost, but all the critics assume a constant or increasing demand for parking based on historical usage patterns. I think usage patterns are going to change radically and that we'll see far lower traffic densities in the not-too-distant future.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by ams6110 on Thursday May 29, 2014 @12:29AM (#7814734)
It was a desperation move, not an inspired one. Chicago and the entire state of Illinois are in terrible financial condition.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by vacri on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @01:54AM (#7808590)
Why not go the whole hog and just shuttle people to whichever house has an open bed for the night? With some smart scheduling software, you could ensure that families get shuttled to the same location.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by steffan on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @02:55PM (#7812087)
I realize you're being facetious, but these already exist.

They're called “hotels.”

It doesn't take a huge stretch of imagination to think that if the marginal costs of operation were similarly reduced by automation that it could become economically feasible to reside solely in hotels.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by timdorr on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @11:08PM (#7808199)
AAAS - Automobiles as a Service.

That could actually be pretty cool. Basically, a ZipCar + Uber that doesn't suck. That would be the dream.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by AJ007 on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @11:52PM (#7808317)
I miss the days when you could read science fiction and think, "none of this exists, I wonder what the future will end up looking like?" We are way past the conceptual stage for the future of transport, and I think it will look exactly like the mashup you are describing.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by masklinn on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @05:06AM (#7809021)
It could even be improved with printable self-driving cars, areas would have a base load of self-driving cars, but in case of need/rush the area center would just print new cars.

My biggest fear re. cars as a service is degradations, it's been an issue in at least some of the bicycle sharing systems.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by RaphiePS on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @11:39PM (#7808285)
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by ams6110 on Thursday May 29, 2014 @12:19AM (#7814705)
Google will be unable to centrally coordinate the transportation needs of everybody in any way approaching the ability of individuals to autonomously manage their own needs. What would actually happen in this scenario is persistent shortages of cars in times of high demand and long waits.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by slyall on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @10:55PM (#7808169)
For manual controls your could just plug in something like a PlayStation controller into a USB port or even a Phone app via Wifi/Bluetooth to control the car.

No need to have permanent wheels, levers and pedals cluttering the "passenger" compartment.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by atwebb on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @11:05PM (#7808191)
It's always nice to have an actual mechanical linkage to the steering and motion, if the electronics had issues it could just as well affect the BT link from the phone or controller. I'm not familiar enough with all makes and models out today and perhaps there are plenty of examples where wheels are already just "controllers".
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by Phlarp on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @11:17PM (#7808226)
Essentially every new consumer grade car made today comes with power steering and electronically controlled or assisted "mechanical linkage". To say nothing of the recent high profile cases of large auto makers having faulty engine control software or mechanically unsound ignition systems.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by jessriedel on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @12:56AM (#7808480)
It would almost certainly not be worth it for a robocar, but having an assisted mechanical linkage is valuable and very different from a pure electronic linkage (i.e. drive by wire). As emgee points out, drive by wire is essentially non-existent in consumer cars.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by sudhirj on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @01:01AM (#7808490)
Haven't recent cars and even aeroplanes shifted entirely to drive by wire? The mechanical linkage is already gone for the most part.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by emgeee on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @11:47PM (#7808308)
The technical term you're looking for is "drive by wire" and it actually only came onto the market in the last year on the Infinity Q50.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by jonah on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @12:05AM (#7808344)
Sure, Steer by wire is new. DBW generally refers to the connection between the accelerator pedal and the throttle. There, DBW has been the norm for many years.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by tantalor on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @12:41AM (#7808447)
Surely not the brake, though. Right? Right?

Edit: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brake-by-wire

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by robryk on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @06:29AM (#7809204)
Even if the pedal is physically connected to the brake cylinder ABS can do whatever it wishes to: ABS can apply and unapply brakes at any time, also asymetrically.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by mrtron on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @02:14AM (#7808636)
Mechanical failure was always possible with brakes.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by paulyg on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @12:09PM (#7811014)
This years F1 cars are brake by wire. It let's them control the kinetic energy recovery better.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by Pxtl on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @01:47AM (#7808571)
Kinect.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by Brakenshire on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @02:51AM (#7808729)
These sort of low speed manoeuvers are in my opinion quite awkward with traditional control and viewing systems, which is presumably why there has been so much development of parking sensors and cameras, and now automatic parking. I think many people would prefer being able to set where they want the car to go on a top down schematic/plan and let the automated control systems wrangle the car into place.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by Sanddancer on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @07:16AM (#7809331)
When you try to paint this as a beta of a marketable vehicle, yeah, it doesn't make much sense. However, this seems much closer to the long history of automotive concept cars, which have traditionally been impractical and designed to definitively show off certain features that may or may not make it to the final cut. By building a vehicle from the ground up without a steering wheel, they're much more readily able to get people asking the questions as to what's really needed in a car of the future.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by mentat on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @12:29AM (#7808418)
How about something simple like telling the car, "back up 10 feet" or "move to the spot across the street". This is dead simple short range routes...
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by Theodores on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @03:08AM (#7808778)
There also needs to be a 'pause for others' button so that a motorist in a side street can be let in to a congested road or for a motorist on the opposite side of the road wanting to turn can make their move. This is the usual scenario where a motorist flashes their lights to let someone through.

As a cyclist/pedestrian I am always amazed by this altruistic side of motorists and it would be a shame if 'the computer said no'. A little 'be nice' button could be a cool feature.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by ithkuil on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @03:58AM (#7808884)
Why does it have to be a button? Can't the computer just be programmed to be nice by default? Or then we'd need a "oh c'mon" button?
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by JackFr on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @12:48PM (#7811309)
Actually, if as you approach a traffic signal, you cede control of the car to the signal, you can avoid red lights altogether as the smart signal shuffles the cars through without any of them hitting each other, handing off control back to the car after it passes through the intersection. A similar technique could be used on on-ramps.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by alextgordon on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @01:40PM (#7811672)
I don't think the parent was talking about traffic signals, just a side road with a give way/yield.

If both roads are congested then "always let everybody in" and "never let anybody in" will both result in deadlock.

Another example is the pedestrian crossing outside my house. There's no traffic lights. Usually cars will drive right past and you (as a pedestrian) have to wait for a gap in the traffic, but sometimes they'll be nice and stop (especially for children).

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by threeseed on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @12:44AM (#7808455)
How does one "tell" the car what to do without controls ?

I hope you're not suggesting voice recognition because anything less than 100% accuracy will guarantee accidents and possibly deaths.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by amock on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @12:48AM (#7808466)
The car needs to know what's safe regardless of whether or not the instructions are via voice or another method, so inaccurate voice control does not guarantee accidents.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by ithkuil on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @03:59AM (#7808886)
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by qbrass on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @02:59AM (#7808748)
The same way you tell it drive anywhere else without controls.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by ceejayoz on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @02:04AM (#7808610)
A smartphone app would probably suffice, given that I can control a drone aircraft with one already.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by GotAnyMegadeth on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @08:30AM (#7809544)
I'm pretty sure current cars with controls guarantee accidents and deaths
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by krapp on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @12:59PM (#7811391)
How sure are you that cars without controls guarantee neither?
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by mentat on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @02:52PM (#7812073)
Because it's provably possible to make a car that drives better than the average human. It's not about guarantees, it's about improvement.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by krapp on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @03:00PM (#7812117)
It's not provably possible yet - the average human is quite capable of not killing themselves or others in any number of hazardous and random driving conditions which autonomous cars can't even manage.

I should probably mention since I typically bleed karma in these threads, that i'm not at all against autonomous vehicles in principle. I can see a lot of ways in which they could make driving safer, and transportation costs cheaper, and do a lot of good.

What I am against is the premise that people are so dangerous and terrible at something they've been, mostly, able to do safely for about a century that their freedoms need to be taken away. Autonomous cars are fine - trying to take for granted that personal freedom is dangerous and stupid and that people need to be controlled like herd animals is not necessarily a good thing. Where is this absolute certainty and conviction that I see in these threads coming from? Certainly not from having observed several million autonomous vehicles on the roads.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by learc83 on Thursday May 29, 2014 @12:52AM (#7814811)
>What I am against is the premise that people are so dangerous and terrible at something they've been, mostly, able to do safely for about a century that their freedoms need to be taken away.

People are dangerous and terrible drivers. There are 30k vehicle accident deaths each year in the US (1.3 million world wide), and it used to be much higher (especially per mile driven). Number of deaths per mile driven has been going down drastically in large part because technology has limited a driver's direct control of the vehicle.

> Autonomous cars are fine - trying to take for granted that personal freedom is dangerous and stupid and that people need to be controlled like herd animals is not necessarily a good thing.

ABS/traction control/drive-by-wire takes direct control away from the driver and gives it to a computer. Self driving cars are just the next layer of abstraction above this. You're still in control of the car, it's just that the interface is a touchscreen with a map instead of a steering wheel.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by mentat on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @02:47PM (#7812052)
Because it would have to immediately take the action without any sort of verification check?

I wouldn't want to ride in that car either, but that's not how anyone remotely intelligent would design it. We're not talking about unscoped directions either which is a much less harder problem then general recognition.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by jackvalentine on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @10:35PM (#7808102)
I agree with you, perhaps in the context of a personal vehicle there does need to be manual control.

However I can see these more as a form of private public transit, a fleet of driverless google cars cruising around and anyone with a subscription a la zipcar can hail them and go.

Perhaps in this context, Google could operate parking garages where they can be recharged and cleaned while keeping them off the street and out of people's ways.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by rquantz on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @10:41PM (#7808119)
That sounds cool, although most cities already have something similar in the form of buses, which are cheaper and more efficient than what you're talking about.

In any case, they will probably not start by having a huge fleet, but by selling them as personal vehicles.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by greeneggs on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @11:48PM (#7808310)
All the signs right now point to Google's self-driving cars being a fleet, not personal vehicles. A few points:

* Google has expertise in "big data" and algorithms: running a fleet would fit their expertise.

* On the other hand, Google has no expertise in designing or marketing pretty cars. They don't have any dealership or repair network. To release a personal vehicle, they'd have to team up with a car company (and that partnership would have to be in place by now given Google's aggressive timeline).

* A fleet lets Google control the deployment carefully. Nobody is going to buy a self-driving car that only works in Mountain View. (Or, worse, they would buy the car, and then complain loudly.) But with a fleet, Google can start on a corporate campus, expand to Stanford, say, then Mountain View, etc. No worries about driving in the snow. No worries about self-driving cars getting in well-publicized accidents after an owner ignored the maintenance schedule.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by Mister_Snuggles on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @12:25AM (#7808406)
These would be buses on steroids.

Imagine if you could fire up an app on your phone that would make a driverless car magically appear to take you somewhere. Once you get to that somewhere, it would scurry off to take someone else somewhere or recharge or go towards where Google's analytics show that it's likely to be needed next.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by jackvalentine on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @10:46PM (#7808138)
I wouldn't compare it to buses, I'd compare it to taxis combined with zipcar. Buses don't have the destination/pickup resolution that a small 2-4 seat vehicle has.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by Sami_Lehtinen on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @11:44PM (#7808300)
Buses don't need to be on fixed route. In Helsinki some buses are using dynamic routing based on demand. So basically those are shared taxis with drivers. When the driver can be dropped out of the equation service can be cheaper and there can be a lot more of these vehicles.

https://kutsuplus.fi/home

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by jackvalentine on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @11:58PM (#7808329)
You're going to need to translate some of this for me. How long in advance do I have to signal my intent to get the bus? How frequent are the busses/how long will I wait on average? How close will busses come to me, will they come to my house in a court where it needs to three point turn to get out? Will the bus wait 10 minutes while I load my things in it?

I don't think the google car will replace mass transit like busses, trains and trams. They're a far more blunt instrument. I do however see it as a more flexible hybrid of car sharing and taxis. A taxi fleet that doesn't have the overhead of keeping enough drivers active for small demand spikes and can be sent directly to the user.

Edit: Weird, was not showing up in English on my phone, does on my laptop.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by Sami_Lehtinen on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @03:26AM (#7808827)
I assume they're using accept-language. Because it's in Finnish on my work laptop, but on my home desktop and mobile it's in English. Anyway, here's link that goes always to English version. https://kutsuplus.fi/home?lang=en_GB
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by anigbrowl on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @10:53PM (#7808153)
People seem quite comfortable with the joysticks on those electric mobility scooters that are all over the place, and I certainly see more with joysticks than with handlebar steering nowadays so the market seems to disagree with you.

I'm not sure why you and a few others think a joystick will be problematic. Of course, there will be a bunch of tasks/use cases for which these cars won't be suitable, but so what? there's many use cases for which bicycles and motorcycles are unsuitable, but lots of people still use them.

I can certainly see using one of these things for local get-around driving, because I hate to drive and my wife can't.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by eurleif on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @10:42PM (#7808123)
If the car's display shows a map of the surrounding area, and that map includes not just static objects like buildings, but also includes other cars, people, etc. (based on sensor information), is touching a spot on the map to make the car go there really a chore?
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by gambiting on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @10:52AM (#7810250)
Have you ever played any 3D game on a 2D screen, where you had to click on a position to tell the on-screen character to go somewhere? Did they always go where you wanted, or did you encounter problems created by projecting 2D points into 3D space?
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by dunmalg on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @12:25AM (#7808405)
Touch-screen interfaces are inherently imprecise. Ever tried to select a destination on a GPS map?
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by eurleif on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @12:51AM (#7808473)
Ok, so how about if you can drag a representation of the car to the place on the map where you want it to go? This doesn't seem like a very difficult UI issue to me.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by ithkuil on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @04:04AM (#7808895)
That depends entirely on the quality of the touch screen interface. Most GPS navigators are just terrible. The precision you get with a normal tablet or smartphone is just astonishing in comparison. Sometimes I'm pissed because I have troubles aiming a link which is 1/10 the size of my finger (a desktop site rendered on my phone) ...
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by prawn on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @08:45AM (#7809599)
Ever used the equivalent system built into a 2019 model car where the absence of a steering wheel and other driving instruments mean that the interface could be two feet wide and easily zoomed for precise navigation?

Current GPS devices are built to be cheap, compact and work with limited connectivity. I think we'll see amazing things in 5-10 years.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by skierscott on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @11:54PM (#7808320)
Not to mention snow/ice. The software might be able to handle the nasty Minnesota roads, but not for a while (and what if people don't trust the cars in those conditions?). As far as I know, they've only been tested in sunny California.

That statement was probably a bit of a jump.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by leoedin on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @06:48AM (#7809255)
What is it that you think makes handling snow and ice more difficult? Feedback control systems can respond an order of magnitude quicker to loss of traction/unexpected behaviour than people can. Icy conditions are different, but not necessarily more complex than "ideal" road conditions. From the point of view of a driving control system it just requires a slightly different control law. Certainly there will be testing required, but I'd be surprised if it presents a major issue. Adverse conditions are one of the more obvious applications of driverless cars.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by jessriedel on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @11:05PM (#7808193)
Note that all those examples are very low speed uses (< 5 mph). It would be completely acceptable to control the car with a handful of dashboard buttons no larger than the buttons to roll the windows up and down. (As mentioned by other, pedals and a steering wheel would be overkill for these rare situations.) And there's really no need for Google to have mentioned it in this blog post, nor would you have seen it in their rendering, so the post is completely consistent with your concerns being addressed.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by IvyMike on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @10:40PM (#7808114)
Just download the Google Steering Wheel app.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by wamatt on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @12:24AM (#7808403)
Another option might be to use a collapsible steering wheel.

It could neatly and automatically retract into the dash, when not needed.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by gfodor on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @10:39PM (#7808111)
In the long run, if self driving cars work, people will no longer be qualified to operate their vehicles. Would you let your toddler move the car 10 feet to pick up grandma?

That said they will almost certainly have a manual override in these things, it will just be tucked away out of view.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by teraflop on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @12:19AM (#7808384)
I think there's room for a control system that gives a human a reasonable degree of direct control over the car's movements, while still having it be able to refuse potentially unsafe commands.

Compare it to a microwave oven. The microwave flux inside the oven is high enough to cause severe burns if you were exposed to it, but the system is designed so that it won't run with the door open -- and it's fail-safe, in the sense that any failure (or combination of failures) is overwhelmingly more likely to result in a safe shutdown than in unsafe exposure.

It's still possible to burn yourself on hot food, of course, but my point is that nobody thinks of a microwave as a dangerous piece of equipment that you need to be "qualified" to use, in the way that they think of a car or a table saw.

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by lilsunnybee on Tuesday May 27, 2014 @11:53PM (#7808318)
With approximately 30 thousand road fatalities every year, people today are barely qualified to drive. But with so few viable transportation options in most areas, we make do with a bad situation.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by Bluestrike2 on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @12:57AM (#7808483)
It's always possible that the end result will be a hybrid one that's somewhere in-between the two visions (particularly with other variants, as it seems like Google's primarily targeting an urban environment). There are already concepts for retractable steering wheels [1] that could be combined with retractable pedals to handle situations that require manual control. Hell, the movie Demolition Man had them way back in the 90s alongside with plenty of cheesy acting.

[1] http://www.webdev.trw.com/sites/default/files/TRW_OSS_SWS%20...

Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by orky56 on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @03:09PM (#7812164)
I would not associate the interface with the functionality. Even without a keyboard, a smartphone with a touchscreen allows one to use a virtual keyboard to type in a similar fashion to an actual keyboard with some definite compromises. With cars when the manual controls are removed, we have a chance to have even more robust functionality with opportunities to map a whole new set of controls to a fallback interface.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by 33W on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @05:10PM (#7812971)
Some alternative input systems can be useful for this type of maneuver, such as a gamepad or smartphone via app. Perhaps this is done from inside the vehicle, but in the case of attaching a trailer, this could be done from outside the rear of the vehicle to guide it precisely.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by melling on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @08:36AM (#7809570)
No one said that there won't be cars with manual controls in the future. There are certainly use cases for both. The market will decide which cars are more popular. There's no need to play pundit on the Internet.
Re:Just press go: designing a self-driving vehicle by tonylemesmer on Wednesday May 28, 2014 @03:16AM (#7808794)
you could just plug in a joystick