News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by unsigner on Monday May 19, 2014 @06:22AM (#7766681)
I find the "no one knows" angle slightly amusing. It's the famed "military-industrial complex". Do you really expect to know EVERYTHING these guys do? To have a Snowden behind every filing cabinet and in every router?
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by icantthinkofone on Monday May 19, 2014 @06:56AM (#7766811)
Exactly. It's like people are surprised that countries have spies and their missions and it should be detailed in the daily paper.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by jacquesm on Monday May 19, 2014 @03:32AM (#7766165)
From the article:

"Plenty of conspiracy theorist have posed the question of X-37B carrying a nuclear payload, to guarantee a ‘first strike’ opportunity (or to have a counter-option in place).

If you have any hope for humanity, that can’t be right. The US is a signatory to The Space Treaty, which is no joke. Space-based weapons of mass destruction are banned."

That notion of being signatory to treaties still having some weight is so quaint. NPT, CTBT, Kyoto...

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by simonh on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:11AM (#7766281)
Russia's treaty obligation to respect the territorial integrity of Ukraine, etc... Indeed.

The problem with that theory is that being in a particular orbit locks you into a very limited choice of targets. The X-37B is unlikely to have much in the way of cross range capability, so any potential target would have to be within a narrow band of it's orbital track. Also suppose you want to hit a target and you just flew over it, you'll have to wait a full orbit before you can strike, which is likely to take a lot longer than launching an ICBM. It's even worse than that though because if your orbit is inclined to the equator (required if your target is not on the equator), the earth rotates under you so any target you fly over on this orbit will have moved and won't be under your orbital track on your next orbit. You might have to wait dozens of orbits before you fly over it again.

Unless you have hundreds of warheads in orbit, or are prepared to wait days between attacks, the orbital weapons platform concept is a non-starter.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by jacquesm on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:42AM (#7766399)
How much delta-v would a package the size of this plane still pack after getting into orbit? In other words, could a plane this size still appreciably change it's orbit post-launch?
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by throwaway_yy2Di on Monday May 19, 2014 @05:42AM (#7766564)
Wikipedia says an early requirement asked for a delta-v of 3,100 m/s:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_X-37#Development

You can estimate engineering limits from the rocket equation, delta-v = effective exhaust velocity * ln(mass ratio). In orbit, it probably uses hypergolic propellants, likely N2O4 and one of the hydrazines. These have exhaust velocities of about 3,350 m/s in vacuum. So, with the orbiter weighing 4.99 tonnes loaded, you could guestimate figures from 2,300 m/s (50% fuel fraction, payload+orbiter = 2.50 tonnes) up to 7,600 m/s (90% fuel fraction, payload+orbiter = 500 kg, if that's possible or useful).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsiolkovsky_rocket_equation

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquid_rocket_propellants#Bipr...

For comparison, the far larger (~100 tonne) space shuttle orbiter can do 300 m/s of delta-v, carrying about 20 tonnes of monomethylhydrazine + N2O4. (Note that's a factor of two lower than what the rocket equation allows; I don't know why that is).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Shuttle_Orbital_Maneuver...

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by MPSimmons on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:55AM (#7766436)
It launches on a DeltaV rocket, so I'm sure the launch system delivers it to the intended orbit, and from there, I'm sure it does orbital transfers into wherever it needs to go for whatever it is that it needs to do.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by mhandley on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:29AM (#7766351)
What's the point of a secret nuclear deterent? Surely it can only deter if everyone knows you've got it.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by icebraining on Monday May 19, 2014 @05:10AM (#7766485)
You don't need everyone to know, just the people you want to deter.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by jacquesm on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:41AM (#7766392)
I've seen that movie.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by arethuza on Monday May 19, 2014 @08:37AM (#7767084)
Arthur C. Clarke's has a rather splended wee short story called "The Last Command" that deals with space based deterrence.

NB I wouldn't recommend looking this up on Google as nearly every description gives away in the twist in the ending.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by icebraining on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:59AM (#7766454)
The US may have signed Kyoto, but they never ratified it, so I don't think they have ever broken any obligations in that regard. Same from the CBTB, as far as I understand from the Wikipedia page.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by jacquesm on Monday May 19, 2014 @06:10AM (#7766646)
The fact that US uses its internal politics to be a signatory to treaties and then fails to ratify them is as far as a good portion of the rest of the world is concerned a case of 'breach of contract'. Imagine you going to your bank and taking out a loan, then later defaulting on that loan stating that your spouse did not agree with your action and therefore your signature is null and void.

The fact that the US can do this because they are beyond being disciplined does not make it right. If a country enters into an international treaty after prolonged negotiations and influencing the terms of the treaty the that country ought to be bound by signing the treaty.

If that's not acceptable then you should either not exert influence over the process or you should internally negotiate the mandate with which the representatives of the country are being sent to the treaty negotiations with ratification being a formality after the negotiations end and the treaty is signed.

The current situation is one in which internal politics are used for international advantage, a questionable practice at best.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by sp332 on Monday May 19, 2014 @07:04AM (#7766831)
The US constitution says the executive branch cannot enter into treaties alone. They must be ratified by Congress, and every diplomat at Kyoto would have known that.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by jacquesm on Monday May 19, 2014 @08:41AM (#7767096)
Sure they do. But the world population in general does not and that is the bulk of the people exposed to this behaviour. In essence it looks as though the US reneges on its obligations and what the underlying cause is does not really matter. The usual attitude towards signatures is that they are somehow binding, signing something and then not abiding by it is very bad PR, it makes you look dishonest.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by nknighthb on Monday May 19, 2014 @10:39PM (#7770970)
If the world population in general is still ignorant of the long-standing distinction between signature and ratification of a treaty, that really isn't the US's fault. The division of responsibility is not unique to us.

Legislative action was involved in ratification of Kyoto by France[1], for example, as well as Japan[2], Russia[3], Serbia[4], and Germany[5]. I found all of this with just five minutes of Googling. I had difficulty finding a story noting the final ratification by the UK, but one assumes ordinary UK rules[6] were followed for Kyoto.

If you want to attack the US -- and as an American, I don't blame you a bit -- you should just be honest and admit you're mad about the result, not the method.

[1] http://legifrance.gouv.fr/affichTexte.do?cidTexte=JORFTEXT00...

[2] http://eneken.ieej.or.jp/en/data/pdf/128.pdf

[3] http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/3943727.stm

[4] http://www.b92.net/eng/news/politics.php?yyyy=2007&mm=09&dd=...

[5] http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/1887961.stm

[6] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ponsonby_Rule

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by jacquesm on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @07:04AM (#7771961)
Except of course that those other countries did ratify the treaty.

Afghanistan, Sudan & the USA are the only countries that did not. I don't particularly blame Afghanistan and Sudan for obvious reasons but the USA has no excuse.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by nknighthb on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @05:18PM (#7775262)
Like I said, your problem is with the result, not the method. You don't like the decisions our politicians make. I don't blame you. That doesn't mean we're being dishonest.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by ghshephard on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:06AM (#7766268)
Different countries treat their responsibilities to these treaties differently. History has shown that the united states, in particular, takes its responsibility to treaties very seriously, and would do it's utmost never to be in breach.

If they were considering placing nuclear missiles in orbit, they would almost certainly withdraw from the Outer Space Treaty first.

I'm wondering if there is any economic rationale for doing so - I would think that sub based missiles would be cheaper than placing them in orbit.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by devnonymous on Monday May 19, 2014 @05:12AM (#7766493)
> ...in particular, takes its responsibility to treaties very seriously, and would do it's utmost never to get caught being in breach.

There fixed that for you. (ref: http://www.laetusinpraesens.org/docs10s/unespion.php )

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by netcan on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:59AM (#7766457)
They could be exercising something similar to the "threshold capacity" of the NPT.

Under the NPT signatories are allowed to enrich and stockpile nuclear fuel for civilian purposes. Under this restriction, states can go almost nuclear.

The tech and materials for civilian and military nuclear use is similar enough that a country that can do power independently would be able to produce bombs within 2-5 years. Some countries have a "threshold strategy" where they stay within the bounds of the treaty but maintain an ability to withdraw and make up ground as quickly as possible. Japan & Australia, for example.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by blueskin_ on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:58AM (#7766452)
>Kyoto

Last time I checked, it was Russia, India and China that ignore that. The US definitely never ignored the NPT either.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by jcr on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:16AM (#7766305)
If I had to guess, and of course, I do have to guess, my bet is the X-37 has something to do with the DARPA Phoenix program.

http://www.darpa.mil/NewsEvents/Releases/2014/04/02a.aspx

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by adventured on Monday May 19, 2014 @06:01AM (#7766612)
This is a platform test to see if they can run small vehicles in space for extended periods of time, operate them safely, and bring them back. Next up will be real space operations once the capability to safely operate at a basic level is proven. This is more likely about putting robotics platforms into space that can stay there and go to work when needed (persistent presence).

It is not a first strike system. That's silly. Any use of such a strike system that has anything to do with nukes will result in massive retaliation from any enemy worth using it on (Russia, China specifically). The US doesn't need small scale first strike options. If you're going to hit China or Russia with nukes, you better destroy everything in the first wave, and that means hundreds of nukes; and it wouldn't just be China or Russia, you have to destroy both, for the same reason that Britain would likely nuke Russia, if Russia preemptively nuked the US.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by lugg on Monday May 19, 2014 @03:29AM (#7766156)
My guess is spy. Lesser possibility nukes.

Reasoning I say spy even though one commenter pointed out that there are spy satellites in orbit is that with the reusability of the craft the cost of getting newer and better spy tech into space faster is helpful on a few levels.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by arethuza on Monday May 19, 2014 @03:50AM (#7766224)
The Outer Space Treaty of 1967 explicitly forbids the placing of nukes (or any other WMDs) in orbit around the Earth:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Outer_Space_Treaty

Also, I'm not sure that having a weapon in orbit would actually be any better than existing ICBMs.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by dalke on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:21AM (#7766323)
I think it would be worse than an ICMB. Not only is it easier to maintain systems on the ground - though that could be what's being tested - but it takes a lot of energy to change an orbital plane and it takes time to make an orbit.

Considering just the last, an orbit in LEO takes about 90 minutes. Even if the target is close to the plane's orbital trajectory, that's an average of about 45 minutes to target. An ICBM takes about 30 minutes. So I can't think of any real advantage for an orbital nuclear weapon over even a small ICBM fleet.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by nknighthb on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:55AM (#7766441)
Decapitation strike. ICBMs are pretty easy to detect. Little tactical warheads being deorbited, not so much.

There is very little you could practically do to defend against such a thing. Even if you could reliably know every time the host vehicle was going to pass overhead (unlikely) and send the relevant leaders to bunkers (impractical), that's no use -- that little warhead could have been released at any time with just enough extra fuel to go into a slightly different orbit, leaving you with no idea when a strike might happen.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by arethuza on Monday May 19, 2014 @05:03AM (#7766470)
Given that the two times the world arguably came closest to nuclear wars (Cuban Missile Crisis and Able Archer 83) were, at least in part, caused by the deployment of weapons that looked like they were intended for decapitation strikes I suspect having such a weapon whirling about above our heads would do no good to overall world security.

Also, it's fairly easy to work around a possible decapitation strike - have the political leaders tell the military what to do in the event they are killed:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Letters_of_last_resort

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by nknighthb on Monday May 19, 2014 @07:46PM (#7770495)
Nuclear weapons in general do no good to overall world security, that doesn't seem to stop anybody.

The UK's strategy is unique, and, for the same reason, probably ineffective. Nobody else uses it because nobody else is willing to leave the matter in military hands. So long as a zombie Margaret Thatcher doesn't reclaim the PM's office, I doubt anyone believes that the letters instruct the captains to do anything other than report to an ally.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by arethuza on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @05:06AM (#7771734)
The Soviets (and possibly the Russians) had a system called Perimetr (AKA "The Dead Hand) that was supposed to be an automate a nuclear response.

I guess both the UK and the Soviets were terrified (for good reasons) of decapitation strikes - the UK because we are so close to the USSR and the Soviets because they knew how keen the US military was on "a Sunday punch" attack (as LeMay called it).

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by dalke on Monday May 19, 2014 @02:08PM (#7768849)
I considered that option when I wrote my comment. There are only a few countries with the resources to detect an ICBM launch. These are also countries which can detect orbiting satellites and determine their orbit. For that matter, there are amateur organizations which track satellite orbits, and are usually the first ones to report when the US has put up a new spy satellite; doing so within a few days.

Yes, it's possible to shift the plane of the orbit when over, say, the South Pacific, and get an element of surprise. "Just enough" is still quite a bit. The Shuttle and Soyuz use air breaking, and take about an hour from the deorbit burn to landing.

Any country that can detect an ICBM launch, with 30 minutes of warning, can likely also detect the ionization trail of a craft/vehicle/weapon going through reentry. Also, said craft won't be able to use any external targeting guidance like GPL until after getting through the blackout.

If I read http://www.spaceflight101.com/soyuz-tma-10m-mission-updates.... right, there's at least 10 and more likely 15 minutes of warning from ionization trail detection to hitting the ground. By comparison, https://www.princeton.edu/sgs/publications/sgs/pdf/3_1-2gron... lists a sub-launched Trident as being able to hit a target 3,000 km away in 9.8 minutes.

Also, it's easier to launch a missile from a sub, and easier to test sub launches than it is to test satellite-based attack deorbits.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by nknighthb on Monday May 19, 2014 @07:39PM (#7770469)
For the same reason it's difficult to hide an ICBM launch, it's difficult to hide a spy satellite launch. Such launches are routinely mentioned in the press before they even occur.

We know when new satellites go up, we just don't know their exact orbital characteristics until somebody actually spots them. They are then routinely lost again, either because their orbit was modified, or whoever spotted it didn't get its orbital characteristics quite right.

They're also a heck of a lot bigger than tactical warheads.

You don't really have to shift the orbital plane of the warhead at all, just raise or lower the orbit a hair so that after a while, the warhead's location has little if any discernible link to the host vehicle's location. Even if you did go for a plane change, it's really not "quite a bit", it's a question of how long you're willing to wait.

The blackout period is overblown. Look up TDRSS -- the Shuttle didn't have a blackout period at all for most of its operational life, thanks to the mind-blowing strategy of... not trying to broadcast downward through the ionization layer.

Soyuz is also a lot bigger than a tactical warhead. The comparison is off by probably 2+ orders of magnitude.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by dalke on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @05:37AM (#7771786)
Doesn't the press know about rocket launches, including spy satellite launches, because policy is to announce all rocket launches to minimize the chance that any foreign observers might think it's a preemptive nuclear missile strike?

And "we know" about orbital elements because of hobbyists. I assume that major nation states - those who have satellites in orbit which can detect ICBM and SLBM launches - also have their own space tracking systems. Eg, the Russian SKKP.

TDRSS - sweet! Yes, my primary interest in space flight was during the early shuttle years, back when there was a 30 minute blackout.

Still, can that hole be enough to provide accurate position targeting data? It doesn't seem like there's enough for triangulation, only communication.

Your point about size is completely apropos. There are too many things I don't know for me to guess how to scale down. Oh! What about using a Genesis comparison? http://genesismission.jpl.nasa.gov/gm2/mission/history.htm shows a reentry diagram, with STRATCOM (Strategic Air Command) able to detect the incoming probe at 32,000 km (and potentially up to 60,000 km).

http://www.nasa.gov/pdf/192937main_genesis_reentry.pdf says:

> This experiment demonstrated that a simple forward scatter radar system utilizing TV transmitters as the illumination source could detect the ionization trail left by the Genesis spacecraft as well as the ionization around the spacecraft itself—the “head echo” in meteor radar parlance.

What it's saying is that the ionization trail is easy enough that amateurs do it often, using a reflected signal from regular TV broadcasts.

What I can't find is how long it took to get from a visible plasma trail to when it crash landed. That would be roughly the same time it would take for a re-entering warhead to get to its target. (It came in faster than LEO speed, but its tumble would have slowed it down more than a designed warhead.)

My point stands that it's easier to test SLBMs than anything in LEO.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by serf on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:03AM (#7766261)
Yeah, it does forbid nukes.

Good thing it doesn't forbid Kinetic Kill Weapons. The kind of thing you need to keep in-orbit for long periods of time.

No/little launch signature, dynamic positions, and a quicker response than any ICBM.

(personally, I think it's a spy rig)

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by arethuza on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:08AM (#7766276)
"quicker response than any ICBM"

From what I can see it would be a lot slower than most ICBMs as you have to wait until it's orbit passes over or is close to the thing you want to hit.

This article seems to have details of its orbit:

http://forden.armscontrolwonk.com/archive/2742/x37b-orbit-fo...

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by serf on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:29AM (#7766352)
Although wikipedia isn't tremendously reliable :

"In the case of the system mentioned in the 2003 USAF report above, a 6.1 m × 0.3 m tungsten cylinder impacting at Mach 10 has a kinetic energy equivalent to approximately 11.5 tons of TNT (or 7.2 tons of dynamite). The mass of such a cylinder is itself greater than 9 tons, so it is clear that the practical applications of such a system are limited to those situations where its other characteristics provide a decisive advantage - a conventional bomb/warhead of similar weight to the tungsten rod, delivered by conventional means, provides similar destructive capability and is a far more practical method. Some other sources suggest a speed of 36,000 ft/s (11,000 m/s),[8] which for the aforementioned rod would amount to a kinetic energy equivalent to 120 tons of TNT or 0.12 kt. With 6-8 satellites on a given orbit, a target could be hit within 12–15 minutes from any given time, less than half the time taken by an ICBM and without the warning. Such a system could also be equipped with sensors to detect incoming anti-ballistic missile-type threats and relatively light protective measures to use against them (e.g. Hit-To-Kill Missiles or megawatt-class chemical laser)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinetic_bombardment

It's not the idea to have one single bombardment weapon, but many in an orbit. That's what makes it a quick reaction. A single unit could likely be a testing platform for such a system.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by dspillett on Monday May 19, 2014 @06:33AM (#7766717)
Slower for a retaliatory strike, yes.

But if you are hitting first and by surprise, you might be able to coordinate around this limitation. Once the object is in the right place it has the delivery speed advantage.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by DanBC on Monday May 19, 2014 @09:37AM (#7767329)
Slower than ICBM if the target is Earth, but if the target is massive satellite damage by spewing orbital debris then it's probably in the right place.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by MPSimmons on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:53AM (#7766429)
Seems like the perfect device for visiting foreign satellites and making changes.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by blueskin_ on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:57AM (#7766448)
Slower response than an ICBM if you have to move it into position first, although if they were deployed (they aren't; they are completely impractical with current technology), I guess they'd be stationed to always have coverage over Russia/China/North Korea/the US anyway.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by iwwr on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:13AM (#7766293)
Kinetic weapons would work better on an airless planet or for space combat.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by serf on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:32AM (#7766360)
far range space combat perhaps, otherwise the launch should be pretty detectable as the propulsion would need to be provided by the launcher, rather than the mechanics of the orbit (unless , perhaps, a slingshot maneuver was used to propel the mass through the enemy via an indirect route)
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by Shivetya on Monday May 19, 2014 @05:41AM (#7766563)
with the advances in rail guns being in orbit may not be a necessity.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by iwwr on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:06AM (#7766267)
>I'm not sure that having a weapon in orbit would actually be any better than existing ICBMs

That's kind of the point too. Suborbital ballistic missiles can reach any point on Earth. Putting them in orbit wastes energy and requires significantly larger rockets for the same payloads. Not to mention stuff in orbit is impossible to hide.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by arethuza on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:11AM (#7766286)
I think the only advantage of having a weapon go into a fractional orbit (rather than being ballistic) is to sneak up on your enemy from an unexpected direction:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractional_Orbital_Bombardment_...

Having your weapon sitting in a entirely predictable permanent orbit rather defeats the purpose.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by thret on Monday May 19, 2014 @05:37AM (#7766556)
I'm sure the USA will respect this treaty right up until they decide not to.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by lugg on Monday May 19, 2014 @07:04AM (#7766829)
Governments doing something forbidden. Never. /s

I find these kinds of treaties idiotic. Can't do that or. Or what? Who exactly is going to do something when the world police breaks the law? The people? Yeah right.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by grkvlt on Monday May 19, 2014 @10:39AM (#7767595)
Once a country starts reneging on its treaty obligations, its going to find international trade and diplomacy much harder, and it better not need money or imports...
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by samworm on Monday May 19, 2014 @03:31AM (#7766163)
"NO ONE KNOWS" - Really? No One? In a world of terrible link-bait headlines this one manages to impress with its idiocy.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by twic on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:10AM (#7766280)
This craft was bought by a government bureaucracy, right? So it's just about possible that nobody knows.

"Absolutely, we in the 67th Orbital Wing operate the X-37B, but it's there to fly missions for the National Space Operations Office"

"The National Space Operations Office's mission is to develop operational capabilities in support of our country's strategic priorities, as implemented by the Near Space Command."

"NSPACECOM is proud to be providing this unique Earth-to-Orbit capability in support of front-line forces. The X-37B is currently deployed with the 67th Orbital Wing. You'd have to ask them for details of the current mission."

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by lifeisstillgood on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:38AM (#7766384)
That has some intriguing possibilities - all I need to do is find five or more government departments and persuade each of them they are working for the other - and the project is the effect on UK citizens of being given a billion dollars (I of course am the first test subject, direct deposit on my please)
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by jacquesm on Monday May 19, 2014 @03:34AM (#7766172)
I think this may be because 'no one knows' is the media equivalent to 'nobody that will talk to us knows'. Effectively that in turn translates into 'nobody in the general public knows' and what with headline space being expensive (if you use shorter headlines you can use larger letters) that got shortened to 'no one knows'.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by frobozz on Monday May 19, 2014 @11:29AM (#7767897)
It could have been shortened even further to just "". Then there would be nothing misleading in the headline at all.

As it is, the headline suggests that some plane accidentally crossed the Kármán Line, has been floating out there for nearly 2 years, and not even the pilot or ATC could work out how it happened.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by vidarh on Monday May 19, 2014 @10:33AM (#7767575)
> what with headline space being expensive (if you use shorter headlines you can use larger letters)

At least one of the national newspapers in Norway found a way around the "need" for larger letters: "War type". Can't get larger letters in? Use a suitably aggressive looking font, and you'll make foreigners think you're writing about war when you're writing about a tax increase or the latest minor political scandal.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by michaelfeathers on Monday May 19, 2014 @08:16AM (#7767021)
Maybe it contains a vial of microbes that can be used to re-seed the planet in the case of an extinction event.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by chiph on Monday May 19, 2014 @10:05AM (#7767442)
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by josefresco on Monday May 19, 2014 @09:33AM (#7767308)
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by HackinOut on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:18AM (#7766317)
I have no idea how this thing could go into orbit. Anybody there who can enlighten me?
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by HackinOut on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:23AM (#7766334)
Apparently, the encapsulation cell seen in the article is of the Atlas V rocket which puts it into orbit http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlas_V
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by rplnt on Monday May 19, 2014 @08:19AM (#7767027)
So now we know why it won't land. There is no way to get it back up. I'm assuming this is the only rocket capable of doing so and the ban by Russia to use the engine for military missions is enforceable.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by jacquesm on Monday May 19, 2014 @08:45AM (#7767109)
You make an interesting point but there is a 2 year supply of engines already shipped so the ban will not have much immediate effect, and they are planning a transition to US only produced engines.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by spiritplumber on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:04AM (#7766262)
It's Jebediah Kerman.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by sergiosgc on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:16AM (#7766308)
No, Jebediah is stuck on Duna with half a fuel tank. Had he practiced landing in the simulator, I wouldn't have to mount a rescue operation now. I think I'll leave him there for a couple of years for good measure.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by misnome on Monday May 19, 2014 @05:52AM (#7766593)
I could have sworn he was stuck on Minmus, trapped in an upside-down pod with the solar panels on the top (so no way of righting it). Oh, Jebediah.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by freehunter on Monday May 19, 2014 @10:00AM (#7767410)
I'm still at the point of having just enough fuel to reach a circular orbit but not enough to de-orbit. Dozens of men floating around the planet, helpless and hopeless.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by jsmcgd on Monday May 19, 2014 @06:58AM (#7766819)
Does anyone else think that they've lost control of this vehicle and that's why, despite it having re-entry capability, it isn't doing a lot of re-entering?
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by tgb on Monday May 19, 2014 @07:26AM (#7766898)
The article claimed that it's sibling stayed in space for over 400 days before reentry, so no I don't think that's particularly likely.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by madaxe_again on Monday May 19, 2014 @08:57AM (#7767150)
No, it has repositioned and changed orbit repeatedly - while it may all be classified, much like other classified satellites, there's a horde of amateurs watching and tracking.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by ericcumbee on Monday May 19, 2014 @09:29PM (#7770803)
I'm going with something completely unsexy, this being what only the second flight? My money is on it was a long duration test, to see how well it held up.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by LukeB_UK on Monday May 19, 2014 @07:50AM (#7766963)
"A plane has been in space for 500 days, and no one knows why" (except the people who sent it there...)
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by jokoon on Monday May 19, 2014 @03:56AM (#7766239)
is this some sort of costly competition to space x in a way ?
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by narag on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:16AM (#7766306)
Or cooperation? This is a vehicle. Most news involving Space X are about launchers. Also:

It’s versatile, and has worked well enough that Boeing is contracted to create the next model, the X-37C. It will be at least 65% larger and have the ability to carry up to six astronauts, while operating unmanned.

Space X reusable rockets and this reusable vehicle seems a good fit.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by bane on Monday May 19, 2014 @07:51AM (#7766966)
My understanding is that the Air Force's Space budget is bigger than NASA's. Making news like this [1] make a lot more sense.

1 - http://www.stripes.com/news/air-force/air-force-spending-60-...

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by coldcode on Monday May 19, 2014 @09:05AM (#7767183)
I still think it makes no sense in a supposed democracy we spend billions on building stuff no one will say what it's good for. Especially stuff the manufacturer admits to building.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by josefresco on Monday May 19, 2014 @09:35AM (#7767322)
Democracy or not, national security depends on keeping certain things a secret to adversaries. Democracy != transparency.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by lifeisstillgood on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:42AM (#7766396)
There is a simpler explanation - Not getting over-shadowed by Elon Musk.

The success of SpaceX and all the private / not-in-military-industrial-complex companies is a direct threat to the budgets and livelihoods of those in the military-industrial complex.

This is a demonstration of "whatever they can do, we can do better"

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by MPSimmons on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:51AM (#7766424)
I don't see how this has anything at all to do with the mission profile for any current or projected SpaceX endeavors.

SpaceX is building launch and deployment vehicles. While I have no doubt that this plane could deploy satellites, it doesn't take 500 days to do that. There are clearly other goals.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by lifeisstillgood on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:56AM (#7766442)
I am sure there are many direct project goals - but one overriding meta-goal is to not stand there looking dumb whilst Elon eats your lunch in the minds of the politicians at least.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by lifeisstillgood on Monday May 19, 2014 @06:15AM (#7766658)
I am really not understanding the downvotes. Elon and SpaceX represent (though are not the whole extent of) a direct threat to the funding of and reputation of a whole slew of US government / closely-tied to US govt companies.

If Elon can demonstrate relaunch capabilities for a fraction of the normal cost, then the big question from Congress will be "So why are we paying you guys so much".

This is irrespective of whether its reusable space launches, or smaller "mission focused" space vehicles.

Any project that is capable of providing an answer to that question is worth tens of billions in continued funding - so the X-37B could be empty and it would still be a worthwhile investment (it isn't empty, of course, but it's value is budgetary defence, not national defence).

All of which to my cyncial mind is far more realistic than a secret project to put nukes in orbit.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by ubernostrum on Monday May 19, 2014 @07:58AM (#7766980)
You're being downvoted because you're bringing irrelevant fanboyism into the thread.

If you think a project aimed at (in relation to the current space industries) mass-produced cost-effective commercial launch vehicles is a threat to small-production-run projects aimed at defense missions, I think you have some horizon-broadening to do.

SpaceX is, for the most part, just taking well-trod ground and trying to make it more efficient. Classified defense stuff, on the other hand, tends to break a lot of new ground and do exotic things the civilian market hasn't even considered enough to debate whether they're possible.

It'd be kind of like someone working on a cheaper, more efficient jet airliner, and you coming in and saying "see, this is a threat to stuff like the SR-71 because it's so much cheaper than all the bloated contractors!"

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by josefresco on Monday May 19, 2014 @09:42AM (#7767349)
While I agree on some level (there's probably another level of secret launches we don't hear about), Space X is going after those military contracts too, and even with additional security measures still projects significant cost savings. Also military launches are quite regular and not all are unique "small-production-run" top secret jobs that require custom vehicles/equipment.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by ubernostrum on Monday May 19, 2014 @11:20AM (#7767848)
Not all of them are, sure. But year+ long reusable spaceplane flights are not exactly run-of-the-mill flights, which strongly suggests that these aren't the sort of thing a more mass-market-oriented vehicle would even be competing for.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by josefresco on Monday May 19, 2014 @11:43AM (#7767982)
Agreed, my point was that there are also run-of-the-mill military flights/launches which SpaceX is also interested.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by lifeisstillgood on Monday May 19, 2014 @09:54AM (#7767396)
Well, thank you for the reply.

No, I am not a fanboy, and yes I shall broaden my horizons.

Where do you recommend one get a intro to the "state-of-the-art" for space capabilities? What are the current parameters?

I had presumed there was one simple limiting factor - the rocket pushing you to orbit. Everything else seems like noise in that O(n) calculation. If there are envelopes being pushed, what impact do they have outside of that?

And, thanks for answering.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by ubernostrum on Monday May 19, 2014 @11:23AM (#7767862)
Go look at articles about how the Shuttle had to be changed to suit defense mission parameters -- defense missions seem like they do a lot of things that aren't just "put XXXkg of payload in orbit YYYkm up", and a vehicle designed to pop off an assembly line and just do that probably won't fit the mission.

Also, I'd argue that yes, the people who feel a need to inject Elon/SpaceX/Tesla/etc. into even the most tangentially-related threads are indeed fanboys, and are doing it out of fanboyism.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by lifeisstillgood on Monday May 19, 2014 @05:25PM (#7769840)
Well, there is a difference between fanboy and layperson - if you take 20 random people and ask them to name people who build (not fly) space ships I would be impressed if you get more than VonBraun and Musk. Maybe Branson :-). It is oddly an industry without many big names. This is in no way diminishing the big achievements.

Anyway - my first few googles lead me to the livingmoon where a seemingly well sourced article on shuttle military missions is on the same site as proof Santa Claus exists.

So from wikipedia / NASA.gov there are some reliable figures but we stand at 11 classified missions, 25 public and this seems to be still the most useful overview http://www.airspacemag.com/space/secret-space-shuttles-35318... In short the NRO / DOD made the shuttle design cope with larger payloads, different orbits, but still the same essential missions - put spy satellites up, preferably in a way thay cannot easily be tracked.

My issue is that it does still seem to be launching satellites - in unusual orbits, yes, in secret and possibly in some other clever way - but the shuttle is just a clever satellite delivery system - it does not seem to be being used itself as a defence system.

That might not be the point I grant you, but do please point me in the right directions.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by lifeisstillgood on Monday May 19, 2014 @06:56PM (#7770271)
aha - should have read your comment more closely - Whatever they are doing it's not likely any civilian project will want the space shuttle to stay up there for a year.

Ok - now I am intrigued as to what they are doing.