News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by dalke on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:21AM (#7766323)
I think it would be worse than an ICMB. Not only is it easier to maintain systems on the ground - though that could be what's being tested - but it takes a lot of energy to change an orbital plane and it takes time to make an orbit.

Considering just the last, an orbit in LEO takes about 90 minutes. Even if the target is close to the plane's orbital trajectory, that's an average of about 45 minutes to target. An ICBM takes about 30 minutes. So I can't think of any real advantage for an orbital nuclear weapon over even a small ICBM fleet.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by nknighthb on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:55AM (#7766441)
Decapitation strike. ICBMs are pretty easy to detect. Little tactical warheads being deorbited, not so much.

There is very little you could practically do to defend against such a thing. Even if you could reliably know every time the host vehicle was going to pass overhead (unlikely) and send the relevant leaders to bunkers (impractical), that's no use -- that little warhead could have been released at any time with just enough extra fuel to go into a slightly different orbit, leaving you with no idea when a strike might happen.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by arethuza on Monday May 19, 2014 @05:03AM (#7766470)
Given that the two times the world arguably came closest to nuclear wars (Cuban Missile Crisis and Able Archer 83) were, at least in part, caused by the deployment of weapons that looked like they were intended for decapitation strikes I suspect having such a weapon whirling about above our heads would do no good to overall world security.

Also, it's fairly easy to work around a possible decapitation strike - have the political leaders tell the military what to do in the event they are killed:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Letters_of_last_resort

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by nknighthb on Monday May 19, 2014 @07:46PM (#7770495)
Nuclear weapons in general do no good to overall world security, that doesn't seem to stop anybody.

The UK's strategy is unique, and, for the same reason, probably ineffective. Nobody else uses it because nobody else is willing to leave the matter in military hands. So long as a zombie Margaret Thatcher doesn't reclaim the PM's office, I doubt anyone believes that the letters instruct the captains to do anything other than report to an ally.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by arethuza on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @05:06AM (#7771734)
The Soviets (and possibly the Russians) had a system called Perimetr (AKA "The Dead Hand) that was supposed to be an automate a nuclear response.

I guess both the UK and the Soviets were terrified (for good reasons) of decapitation strikes - the UK because we are so close to the USSR and the Soviets because they knew how keen the US military was on "a Sunday punch" attack (as LeMay called it).

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by dalke on Monday May 19, 2014 @02:08PM (#7768849)
I considered that option when I wrote my comment. There are only a few countries with the resources to detect an ICBM launch. These are also countries which can detect orbiting satellites and determine their orbit. For that matter, there are amateur organizations which track satellite orbits, and are usually the first ones to report when the US has put up a new spy satellite; doing so within a few days.

Yes, it's possible to shift the plane of the orbit when over, say, the South Pacific, and get an element of surprise. "Just enough" is still quite a bit. The Shuttle and Soyuz use air breaking, and take about an hour from the deorbit burn to landing.

Any country that can detect an ICBM launch, with 30 minutes of warning, can likely also detect the ionization trail of a craft/vehicle/weapon going through reentry. Also, said craft won't be able to use any external targeting guidance like GPL until after getting through the blackout.

If I read http://www.spaceflight101.com/soyuz-tma-10m-mission-updates.... right, there's at least 10 and more likely 15 minutes of warning from ionization trail detection to hitting the ground. By comparison, https://www.princeton.edu/sgs/publications/sgs/pdf/3_1-2gron... lists a sub-launched Trident as being able to hit a target 3,000 km away in 9.8 minutes.

Also, it's easier to launch a missile from a sub, and easier to test sub launches than it is to test satellite-based attack deorbits.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by nknighthb on Monday May 19, 2014 @07:39PM (#7770469)
For the same reason it's difficult to hide an ICBM launch, it's difficult to hide a spy satellite launch. Such launches are routinely mentioned in the press before they even occur.

We know when new satellites go up, we just don't know their exact orbital characteristics until somebody actually spots them. They are then routinely lost again, either because their orbit was modified, or whoever spotted it didn't get its orbital characteristics quite right.

They're also a heck of a lot bigger than tactical warheads.

You don't really have to shift the orbital plane of the warhead at all, just raise or lower the orbit a hair so that after a while, the warhead's location has little if any discernible link to the host vehicle's location. Even if you did go for a plane change, it's really not "quite a bit", it's a question of how long you're willing to wait.

The blackout period is overblown. Look up TDRSS -- the Shuttle didn't have a blackout period at all for most of its operational life, thanks to the mind-blowing strategy of... not trying to broadcast downward through the ionization layer.

Soyuz is also a lot bigger than a tactical warhead. The comparison is off by probably 2+ orders of magnitude.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by dalke on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @05:37AM (#7771786)
Doesn't the press know about rocket launches, including spy satellite launches, because policy is to announce all rocket launches to minimize the chance that any foreign observers might think it's a preemptive nuclear missile strike?

And "we know" about orbital elements because of hobbyists. I assume that major nation states - those who have satellites in orbit which can detect ICBM and SLBM launches - also have their own space tracking systems. Eg, the Russian SKKP.

TDRSS - sweet! Yes, my primary interest in space flight was during the early shuttle years, back when there was a 30 minute blackout.

Still, can that hole be enough to provide accurate position targeting data? It doesn't seem like there's enough for triangulation, only communication.

Your point about size is completely apropos. There are too many things I don't know for me to guess how to scale down. Oh! What about using a Genesis comparison? http://genesismission.jpl.nasa.gov/gm2/mission/history.htm shows a reentry diagram, with STRATCOM (Strategic Air Command) able to detect the incoming probe at 32,000 km (and potentially up to 60,000 km).

http://www.nasa.gov/pdf/192937main_genesis_reentry.pdf says:

> This experiment demonstrated that a simple forward scatter radar system utilizing TV transmitters as the illumination source could detect the ionization trail left by the Genesis spacecraft as well as the ionization around the spacecraft itself—the “head echo” in meteor radar parlance.

What it's saying is that the ionization trail is easy enough that amateurs do it often, using a reflected signal from regular TV broadcasts.

What I can't find is how long it took to get from a visible plasma trail to when it crash landed. That would be roughly the same time it would take for a re-entering warhead to get to its target. (It came in faster than LEO speed, but its tumble would have slowed it down more than a designed warhead.)

My point stands that it's easier to test SLBMs than anything in LEO.