News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by jacquesm on Monday May 19, 2014 @03:32AM (#7766165)
From the article:

"Plenty of conspiracy theorist have posed the question of X-37B carrying a nuclear payload, to guarantee a ‘first strike’ opportunity (or to have a counter-option in place).

If you have any hope for humanity, that can’t be right. The US is a signatory to The Space Treaty, which is no joke. Space-based weapons of mass destruction are banned."

That notion of being signatory to treaties still having some weight is so quaint. NPT, CTBT, Kyoto...

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by simonh on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:11AM (#7766281)
Russia's treaty obligation to respect the territorial integrity of Ukraine, etc... Indeed.

The problem with that theory is that being in a particular orbit locks you into a very limited choice of targets. The X-37B is unlikely to have much in the way of cross range capability, so any potential target would have to be within a narrow band of it's orbital track. Also suppose you want to hit a target and you just flew over it, you'll have to wait a full orbit before you can strike, which is likely to take a lot longer than launching an ICBM. It's even worse than that though because if your orbit is inclined to the equator (required if your target is not on the equator), the earth rotates under you so any target you fly over on this orbit will have moved and won't be under your orbital track on your next orbit. You might have to wait dozens of orbits before you fly over it again.

Unless you have hundreds of warheads in orbit, or are prepared to wait days between attacks, the orbital weapons platform concept is a non-starter.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by jacquesm on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:42AM (#7766399)
How much delta-v would a package the size of this plane still pack after getting into orbit? In other words, could a plane this size still appreciably change it's orbit post-launch?
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by throwaway_yy2Di on Monday May 19, 2014 @05:42AM (#7766564)
Wikipedia says an early requirement asked for a delta-v of 3,100 m/s:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_X-37#Development

You can estimate engineering limits from the rocket equation, delta-v = effective exhaust velocity * ln(mass ratio). In orbit, it probably uses hypergolic propellants, likely N2O4 and one of the hydrazines. These have exhaust velocities of about 3,350 m/s in vacuum. So, with the orbiter weighing 4.99 tonnes loaded, you could guestimate figures from 2,300 m/s (50% fuel fraction, payload+orbiter = 2.50 tonnes) up to 7,600 m/s (90% fuel fraction, payload+orbiter = 500 kg, if that's possible or useful).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsiolkovsky_rocket_equation

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquid_rocket_propellants#Bipr...

For comparison, the far larger (~100 tonne) space shuttle orbiter can do 300 m/s of delta-v, carrying about 20 tonnes of monomethylhydrazine + N2O4. (Note that's a factor of two lower than what the rocket equation allows; I don't know why that is).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Shuttle_Orbital_Maneuver...

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by MPSimmons on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:55AM (#7766436)
It launches on a DeltaV rocket, so I'm sure the launch system delivers it to the intended orbit, and from there, I'm sure it does orbital transfers into wherever it needs to go for whatever it is that it needs to do.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by mhandley on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:29AM (#7766351)
What's the point of a secret nuclear deterent? Surely it can only deter if everyone knows you've got it.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by icebraining on Monday May 19, 2014 @05:10AM (#7766485)
You don't need everyone to know, just the people you want to deter.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by jacquesm on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:41AM (#7766392)
I've seen that movie.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by arethuza on Monday May 19, 2014 @08:37AM (#7767084)
Arthur C. Clarke's has a rather splended wee short story called "The Last Command" that deals with space based deterrence.

NB I wouldn't recommend looking this up on Google as nearly every description gives away in the twist in the ending.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by icebraining on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:59AM (#7766454)
The US may have signed Kyoto, but they never ratified it, so I don't think they have ever broken any obligations in that regard. Same from the CBTB, as far as I understand from the Wikipedia page.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by jacquesm on Monday May 19, 2014 @06:10AM (#7766646)
The fact that US uses its internal politics to be a signatory to treaties and then fails to ratify them is as far as a good portion of the rest of the world is concerned a case of 'breach of contract'. Imagine you going to your bank and taking out a loan, then later defaulting on that loan stating that your spouse did not agree with your action and therefore your signature is null and void.

The fact that the US can do this because they are beyond being disciplined does not make it right. If a country enters into an international treaty after prolonged negotiations and influencing the terms of the treaty the that country ought to be bound by signing the treaty.

If that's not acceptable then you should either not exert influence over the process or you should internally negotiate the mandate with which the representatives of the country are being sent to the treaty negotiations with ratification being a formality after the negotiations end and the treaty is signed.

The current situation is one in which internal politics are used for international advantage, a questionable practice at best.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by sp332 on Monday May 19, 2014 @07:04AM (#7766831)
The US constitution says the executive branch cannot enter into treaties alone. They must be ratified by Congress, and every diplomat at Kyoto would have known that.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by jacquesm on Monday May 19, 2014 @08:41AM (#7767096)
Sure they do. But the world population in general does not and that is the bulk of the people exposed to this behaviour. In essence it looks as though the US reneges on its obligations and what the underlying cause is does not really matter. The usual attitude towards signatures is that they are somehow binding, signing something and then not abiding by it is very bad PR, it makes you look dishonest.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by nknighthb on Monday May 19, 2014 @10:39PM (#7770970)
If the world population in general is still ignorant of the long-standing distinction between signature and ratification of a treaty, that really isn't the US's fault. The division of responsibility is not unique to us.

Legislative action was involved in ratification of Kyoto by France[1], for example, as well as Japan[2], Russia[3], Serbia[4], and Germany[5]. I found all of this with just five minutes of Googling. I had difficulty finding a story noting the final ratification by the UK, but one assumes ordinary UK rules[6] were followed for Kyoto.

If you want to attack the US -- and as an American, I don't blame you a bit -- you should just be honest and admit you're mad about the result, not the method.

[1] http://legifrance.gouv.fr/affichTexte.do?cidTexte=JORFTEXT00...

[2] http://eneken.ieej.or.jp/en/data/pdf/128.pdf

[3] http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/3943727.stm

[4] http://www.b92.net/eng/news/politics.php?yyyy=2007&mm=09&dd=...

[5] http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/1887961.stm

[6] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ponsonby_Rule

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by jacquesm on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @07:04AM (#7771961)
Except of course that those other countries did ratify the treaty.

Afghanistan, Sudan & the USA are the only countries that did not. I don't particularly blame Afghanistan and Sudan for obvious reasons but the USA has no excuse.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by nknighthb on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @05:18PM (#7775262)
Like I said, your problem is with the result, not the method. You don't like the decisions our politicians make. I don't blame you. That doesn't mean we're being dishonest.
Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by ghshephard on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:06AM (#7766268)
Different countries treat their responsibilities to these treaties differently. History has shown that the united states, in particular, takes its responsibility to treaties very seriously, and would do it's utmost never to be in breach.

If they were considering placing nuclear missiles in orbit, they would almost certainly withdraw from the Outer Space Treaty first.

I'm wondering if there is any economic rationale for doing so - I would think that sub based missiles would be cheaper than placing them in orbit.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by devnonymous on Monday May 19, 2014 @05:12AM (#7766493)
> ...in particular, takes its responsibility to treaties very seriously, and would do it's utmost never to get caught being in breach.

There fixed that for you. (ref: http://www.laetusinpraesens.org/docs10s/unespion.php )

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by netcan on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:59AM (#7766457)
They could be exercising something similar to the "threshold capacity" of the NPT.

Under the NPT signatories are allowed to enrich and stockpile nuclear fuel for civilian purposes. Under this restriction, states can go almost nuclear.

The tech and materials for civilian and military nuclear use is similar enough that a country that can do power independently would be able to produce bombs within 2-5 years. Some countries have a "threshold strategy" where they stay within the bounds of the treaty but maintain an ability to withdraw and make up ground as quickly as possible. Japan & Australia, for example.

Re:A plane has been in space for 500 days by blueskin_ on Monday May 19, 2014 @04:58AM (#7766452)
>Kyoto

Last time I checked, it was Russia, India and China that ignore that. The US definitely never ignored the NPT either.