News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by zackmorris on Friday May 02, 2014 @02:27PM (#7687287)
Converting sunlight to heat is trivial, at 1368 watts per square meter. The problem has always been energy storage. A single acre is 4047 square meters, or 5.54 MW (7429 hp). As a rule of thumb, I generally divide the area by 3 because collectors are usually arranged in troughs, slightly spaced for low sun angles. Still, thinking in terms of 1 MW of heat per acre, or 2000 hp, puts things in perspective. Dams and power plants are usually in the GW range, so it would take 33x33 acres to capture 1 GW of heat. Since an acre is about 209 feet on a side, that's between 1 and 2 square miles. At the quoted 1.73% efficiency, we'd have to multiply by the inverse, 58, to convert from heat to fuel. So we're talking 50-100 square miles to create the output of a GW power plant for say 8 hours of daylight. Figure a 200 square mile plant to withdraw 1 GW worth of fuel continuously. However, we get down to the 20-40 square mile range if they can get the efficiency to 10%. Of course this all ignores the combustion efficiency which is probably only about 25% so we have to multiply by a factor of 4 again.

Probably a more practical way to store energy, and in my mind the most likely way to power vehicles, is compressed air at 300-700 atmospheres, which is within the same order of magnitude energy/mass density as batteries, depending on the storage tank:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density

A solar plant can be built on top of an empty natural gas well and store energy in compressed air underground. Another possibility is compressed air in large bags at the bottom of the ocean, that would displace less water than a dam since the height difference can be several thousand feet (pumping water uphill is not very effective due to the elevation required). We’ll also never have enough batteries or supercapacitors to store that much energy.

I wish I had money to invest in fiberglass or carbon fiber wrapped storage tanks and micro turbines/pistons that convert the energy in compressed air to rotational energy. I think we’ll be using them instead of something more exotic like magnetic bearing flywheels, and future electric cars will have a small natural gas/hydrogen turbine that tops off an air tank that will take the car 10 or 20 miles without having to tap into batteries. Also, refilling air tanks at a fueling station can happen almost instantly, at least as fast as filling up with gasoline.

Still, I think making hydrocarbons is an exciting development for distributed generation, where people are only making a few liters of fuel a day from water basically. I imagine that it might be more efficient to make propane also, and this is a little off topic but propane engines are much easier to build/more efficient because they don’t have carburetors or fuel injection. I’m honestly surprised the world went with gasoline and diesel, although it was probably for safety reasons.

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by DaniFong on Friday May 02, 2014 @03:20PM (#7687582)
Hi Zack,

My company, LightSail Energy, is developing precisely this technology.

www.lightsail.com

We're also developing the world's lowest cost pressure vessels to store the air.

I wish you had the money to invest in us too ;-)

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by zackmorris on Saturday May 03, 2014 @11:46AM (#7691180)
Wow that's cool. I appreciate how you have some real numbers on your site, it seems approachable. Ya every day I kick myself for not generating a few Bitcoins when I first heard about them, so I could invest in companies like yours.
Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by dredmorbius on Saturday May 03, 2014 @08:51PM (#7692897)
I'm curious what the magnitude of thermal energy loss without capture and re-injection of heat loss is with CAES.

I've seen repeated mention of this in various sources, but no explicit quantification.

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by DaniFong on Saturday May 03, 2014 @09:36PM (#7693016)
It's hard to generate a strict apples to apples comparison -- not only do the numbers depend on operating parameters, but pure adiabatic operation causes both very high temperatures, imposing strict materials constraints and very difficult heat exchange and heat storage challenges, and very low temperatures, causing icing.

This means no working pure compressed air energy storage tech is in existence today -- a couple exist which add heat via combustion, one product used to exist which used an electric heater to keep a heat store warm. Both are thermodynamically non-ideal.

Based on pure theory, however, running two stages of compression to 200 bar (14.1:1 each), running perfectly adiabatically during compression and expansion, temperatures would reach to about 600 C during compression. If one didn't recover the heat of compression, and let the temperature of the compressed air drop to ambient, the temperature upon expansion would get to about -170 C. Pure thermal efficiency would be about 34%.

The results are so extreme / bad that one would choose a whole separate set of parameters and compromises. But that should show you the power of direct contact heat exchange.

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by dredmorbius on Saturday May 03, 2014 @11:01PM (#7693156)
Thanks.

I've seen some discussion of CAES using former natural gas wells for storage. I don't know the scale of operations there, but it could be large (meaning that relatively small amounts of energy would be stored or extracted at any given point in time.

Rock also serves as a pretty good insulator (R5 as I understand, and there's a lot of it), which might preserve some of the heat of compression.

In your example, is 200 bar a typical pressure for CAES? I see that as about 2900 psi for the imperial units types.

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by DaniFong on Monday May 05, 2014 @03:45PM (#7700704)
200 bar is an inflection point in the regulatory landscape for above ground tanks. A sweet spot. There's another sweet spot around 300 - 400 bar due to the physics of air.

Salt caverns melt at high enough temps (above 200 C) and injecting hot air into a methane reservoir is not terribly advisable...

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by dredmorbius on Tuesday May 06, 2014 @12:53AM (#7702905)
Took me a moment to realize you were talking CAES in salt caverns, not salt caverns for thermal energy storage, though that hadn't occurred to me either (I don't think it's necessary).

The constraints you raise on natural-formation CAES do raise some interesting challenges (or Hollywood movie plots).

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by NicoJuicy on Saturday May 03, 2014 @10:11AM (#7690823)
Do you have any finished products yet (just wondering)
Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by DaniFong on Saturday May 03, 2014 @09:38PM (#7693019)
Not yet, currently developing our systems to be pilot ready for field tests next year. It's a long, hard business developing new energy tech. Our first genuine products are likely to be our pressure vessels...
Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by nardi on Friday May 02, 2014 @06:23PM (#7688530)
People always underestimate batteries, even though we're in the middle of a battery technology revolution at this very moment.

In 5 years, people will laugh at the idea of using compressed air instead of just storing electrons. I imagine battery energy density will have doubled by then.

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by dredmorbius on Saturday May 03, 2014 @12:58PM (#7691432)
Battery technology is fundamentally limited by chemistry.

The best available battery techs (generally metal-air designs which consume the anode) offer about 1/10 the energy storage density of liquid hydrocarbon fuels. The best of these, lithium-air, offers a theoretical maximum of 11140 wH/kg (40 MJ/kg), excluding oxygen weight, which is actually close to that of gasoline, diesel, or fuel-oil (~46 MJ/kg).

But at practically attainable levels for rechargeable designs, you're down to 9 MJ/kg, and on a gross energy-density basis, while sufficient for some uses, including a fair number of ground-transport uses, but with some significant operational and technical constraints imposed by the battery's own operation. You also have the further disadvantage of having to carry around the full weight of the battery even when its energy content has been exhausted (fuels by comparison are burned off).

For other uses, particularly large bulk-good transport (ground or sea), or practical heavier-than-air craft, it's simply not good enough.

And that's the best possible designs. For more viable designs -- LiON or even hypothetical graphene / carbon nanotube batteries, you're looking at vastly lower storage densities -- 0.36–0.875 MJ/kg for LiON.

The prospect of synthesizing hydrocarbons using electrical energy from renewable or sustainable sources strikes me as a highly probable future path, though I'm partial to the US Navy's fuel-from-seawater proposals, given the much higher (140x) concentrations of CO2 available in dissolved and bound (carbonate, bicarbonate) form. For more: http://redd.it/22k71x

For discussion of energy storage see generally Wikipedia:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metal%E2%80%93air_electrochemi...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by nardi on Saturday May 03, 2014 @10:18PM (#7693085)
I'm well aware of the current limitations of battery technology. Nanotechnology processes are poised to destroy the existing best energy densities. [1]

[1] http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nanobatteries

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by nardi on Sunday May 04, 2014 @03:55AM (#7693674)
I felt bad for leaving such a horrible reference, so here are a few better ones:

http://techland.time.com/2013/05/23/amprius-begins-shipping-...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nanowire_battery

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by dredmorbius on Sunday May 04, 2014 @12:36PM (#7694828)
Your nanobattery reference cites a capacity of 580 WH/liter energy storage density.

This compares with 10,690 WH/l for liquid hydrocarbons (scaling a barrel of oil equivalent to liters and converting to watt hours).

That's roughly 5% the energy storage density of liquid fuels.

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by throwaway2048 on Saturday May 03, 2014 @04:54AM (#7690095)
amazing battery tech has been around the corner for a long time now, yet energy density hasn't changed significantly since the introduction of lithium ion.
Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by samstave on Friday May 02, 2014 @04:50PM (#7688041)
I would love to see very large floating rafts which use the rise and fall of waves/tides to pump compressed air into tans that can be released to turbines for energy. Let these rafts float up and down static pillars... this concept has been used in the past - but I don't think for the idea of compressing air... Make the pillar tall, add solar collectors and top it off with a windmill :)

Can you do any maths on that concept and determine the size of the rafts which would produce usable energy consistently?

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by XorNot on Saturday May 03, 2014 @03:27AM (#7689960)
The problem is that it's an oscillating mechanical load, which means all the materials you build it out of are subject to much more rapid fatiguing then in other situations.
Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by zackmorris on Saturday May 03, 2014 @01:49PM (#7691683)
Wow this got way too long, but what the heck, I’ll post it (I get about a 1 cubic mile float to extract 1 GW from tidal power).

There is a lot of power in waves, but one thing to keep in mind is that the amount of extractable energy is proportional to the head (height difference):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydroelectricity

http://www.reuk.co.uk/Calculation-of-Hydro-Power.htm

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low_head_hydro_power

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tides#Example_calculation

http://www.infoplease.com/encyclopedia/science/tide-the-magn...

So a dam uses a high head/low flow rate, and tidal or wave power uses a low head/high flow rate.

I’ve seen a few dams built around coves that work like a lock, filling up at high tide and draining during low tide, running a turbine to generate electricity. But if there is only a 1 or 2 meter head, it takes a huge water current to make more than a few MW.

I’ve also seen these snake-like creations that are big floating drums with hydraulics between them, that bend with the waves. So the head is about the same, but the period is a few seconds instead of a day, so a lower current is needed. However, the amount of current they capture is so small compared to a dam that they only generate on the order of a few kW.

The idea of using a large float is certainly compelling. Off the top of my head, maybe it could work similarly to having a bag at the bottom of the ocean with a pipe connected to an artificial floating island on the surface. It would pull on the bag as the tide rises to inhale air into the bag, and then let it exhale as the tide falls. A turbine in the tube would generate electricity in both directions. Water weighs 1000 kg per cubic meter (62.5 pounds per cubic foot), so if we use the dam formula for 1 cubic meter and +/- 1 meter of tide, the float would travel 1 m up, 1 m back down, then 1 m down and 1 m back up, for a total distance of 4 meters every 24 hours. So I think we can use the dam formula:

power P = phrgk

density p = 1000

height h = 4

flow rate = volume/time = r = 1/(60 * 60 * 24) = 1.16e-5

gravity g = 9.8

efficiency k = .6

so:

P = 1000 * 4 * 1.16e-5 * 9.8 * .6 = 0.27 W/m3

As a sanity check, the amount of energy required to raise 1000 kg of water 4 meters is:

E = mgh = 1000 * 9.8 * 4 = 39200 J

So power is energy over time, so:

P = E/t = 39200/(60 * 60 * 24) = 0.45 W/m3

So at 60% efficiency, power = 0.27 W/m3

This is one of the reasons why the head is so important, because it takes remarkably little energy to raise a ton of water, literally.

So if we want a 1 MW plant, we’d need a float about 3.7 million cubic meters, which would be a sphere with a radius of about 100 meters by V = (4 * pi * r^3)/3, or about 600 feet across. It would also need a bag of similar volume anchored to the bottom of the ocean.

Since the pressure is reversed for the bottom balloon, it would take on the shape of a tetrahedron, so would need strong anchors holding 3 corners to the ocean floor, with one of the corners connected to the float by a tube. The 3 edges touching the floor would need to be sealed against water leaking in. A bit of an engineering feat..

To make it worth our while, we’d probably want a float 1000 times bigger, or 6000 feet across to generate 1 GW. I have a little trouble picturing a mile wide float, its surface area would be:

Area = 4 * pi * r^2 = 4 * pi * 1000^2 = 12.6 million square meters

Although this doesn’t seem that bad, even at a cost of $10 per square meter.

Now that I write this, maybe a better alternative to the bottom bag would be a steel cable connected by a pulley to the ocean floor, that comes up on land and moves a meter or two forward and back each day. It could either be connected to a hydraulic system with a thin (high flow rate) tube, or perhaps a high gear reduction transmission that converts the motion to say, 60 Hz or something.

Unfortunately we’re talking 4 trillion kg of tension (4 billion m3 * 1000 kg per m) for a 1 GW plant, and a steel cable to carry that tension is infeasible, at 7500 kg per square cm (75 million kg per square m) of cross sectional area, which I calculated from the 11.5 mm cable which works out to a 1 cm2 cross section at 16540 lb (7500 kg):

http://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/wire-rope-strength-d_1518....

So when it’s all said and done, it’s possible to build the float but I don’t know how the power could be extracted practically.

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by dredmorbius on Saturday May 03, 2014 @02:10PM (#7691770)
NB: I walked through calculations for tidal power a ways back and it took me a while to realize that it's not the volume of the float which matters, but the area. Power is independent of volume.

Why?

Because the energy is derived from the tidal rise, not the amount of water you're displacing. The relevant volume is the area x the tidal displacement, which gives you the amount of water and how far it's been lifted (average: 1/2 the total displacement).

Or, if you prefer to have someone do the math for you, the City of San Francisco and EPRI did an analysis of how much total energy could be derived from tidal flows in and out of the San Francisco Bay, which I became interested in after an Internet crank suggested that the rise and fall of 30 typical ships could power all of San Francisco.

Not hardly.

http://oceanenergy.epri.com/attachments/streamenergy/reports...

The narrow passage under the Golden Gate Bridge, which connects the San Francisco bay to the Pacific Ocean is home to some of the most energetic currents in North America. In average 237MW of power is embodied in the tidal stream, of which about 35MW could be extracted without any negative impact on the environment. A plant of that scale could reach an electrical output of about 100MW at peak.

http://www.sfenvironment.org/article/hydro/tidal-energy

The study conservatively estimated that the Golden Gate site has 35.5 megawatts of total extractable average annual power, and that 15 to 17 average megawatts (MW) of this power could realistically be extracted by technologies currently in development. The cost of electricity generated, assuming incentives similar to those provided to other renewable resources, is estimated at six to nine cents per kilowatt-hour (kWh)—a cost competitive with current wind and natural gas generation, and about one-third the cost per megawatt of solar power.

As I recall, this works out to maybe 10% of the average power utilization of San Francisco proper, and a minuscule fraction of the energy used by the greater Bay Area. You'd do better to plaster the Bay with solar panels.

More: http://redd.it/1wefio

Tidal and wave energy are prodigious on a global scale, but they're simply too dispersed and too expensive to collect for present industrial-scale levels of energy use.

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by zackmorris on Saturday May 03, 2014 @02:55PM (#7691954)
Ya I think you're right, the float needs to be as thin as possible, otherwise most of it will be underwater and not affected when the surface rises. So a 1 MW float would have a volume of about 4 million m3, which is 2 km on a side if it's 1 m thick. It's probably better to just find large bays and install low head turbines. Kinda fun to do the math though!
Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by dredmorbius on Saturday May 03, 2014 @03:08PM (#7691996)
It's not that the float needs to be thin. It's that the thickness doesn't matter in terms of power generation.

The minimal requirement is that the float, well, float. Other than that, more material is simply excess cost to consider.

The EPRI study I mention is based on, IIRC, turbines installed at the gate. Maximum capture would require building a barrier dam, which has been done at a few limited sites, though it would be impractical in SF due to ship traffic requirements.

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by zackmorris on Saturday May 03, 2014 @02:33PM (#7691871)
Ok after writing this, I realized that a block and tackle pulley system might work:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Pulley3a.svg

A 200 m (600 ft) diameter, 4 million m3 float, generating 1 MW, would have a tension of 4 billion kg. That would need 533000 pulleys with 1 cm2 steel cable at 7500 kg tensile strength. So 266000 pulleys on each end, which is a 2D array of about 512 pulleys on a side. This doesn't actually seem that difficult to build on an industrial scale. The cable would travel about 2100 km a day, at 25 m/sec (about 55 mph). The cable would have a total volume of 2100000/10000 = 210 m3, or 6 m on side (20 ft), with the ends connected to the opposite sides of the pulley system. So that's quite a spool at the generator. It should be slightly mobile, either on wheels or a spring so that it can adjust to rogue waves. Also it should probably be made from a polymer that's resistant to seawater instead of steel.

Unfortunately we'd need 1000 of these plants to make 1 GW. Just goes to show how mindbogglingly much power humanity uses. Maybe we could at least try to conserve haha.

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by DanBC on Friday May 02, 2014 @02:44PM (#7687368)
Here is a demonstration of a focused beam of sunlight from a mirror that is just two square metres.

http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=z0_nuvPKIi8

http://youtube.com/watch?v=z0_nuvPKIi8

Focal point gets to > 3500 celcius.

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by abdullahkhalids on Friday May 02, 2014 @02:54PM (#7687420)
Temperature is only half the picture. Total energy transfer is the other half.

Consider heating a teaspoon of water vs heating a pot of water.

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by DanBC on Friday May 02, 2014 @03:32PM (#7687645)
Yes, that's a good point and it demonstrates the weakness of BBC educational material that they don't mention that.

For what it's worth they melt steel within a few seconds of putting it in the focal point and melt rock similarly fast.

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by olegkikin on Friday May 02, 2014 @06:56PM (#7688659)
They are wrong about materials not being able to withstand 3500°C. Carbon's melting point is 4030 to 4430 °C.

Tantalum hafnium carbide melts at 4215°C.

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by XorNot on Saturday May 03, 2014 @03:24AM (#7689951)
"Carbon" doesn't really have a melting point.

It'll start reacting with things depending on what it's surrounded by at much lower temperatures then that.

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by abdullahkhalids on Friday May 02, 2014 @02:57PM (#7687448)
But this is attractive from the point of offsetting global warming. I should do the calculations for how effective it really is i.e. how big a plant do I need to offset all the carbon dioxide I produce.

If it is, there would be a public incentive to fund development and plants of such a nature vs funding carbon neutral or carbon positive energy ventures.

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by whythehellnot on Friday May 02, 2014 @08:41PM (#7689034)
Given that their full scale solar concentrator could produce 20,000L per day. I think it would take around 10,000 of those concentrators just for aeroplanes to be carbon neutral. To be honest, that isn't too bad considering how much money we waste collecting other fuels much more dangerously. This would be worthwhile if we could construct them quick enough before our transition to our battery powered future.

To be honest this sort of technology would be better used for recycling agriculture fertilisers.

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by Dn_Ab on Friday May 02, 2014 @03:21PM (#7687592)
Wikipedia lists some active (in Germany and Iceland) and proposed demonstrations of the general concept.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon-neutral_fuel#Demonstrati...

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by sitkack on Friday May 02, 2014 @09:59PM (#7689206)
Really we should have funded this and a myriad of other technologies esp fusion instead of the Iraq and Afghanistan wars. When fusion finally comes online, we need to dump a serious amount of energy into pulling the carbon back out of the seas and the atmosphere. But without the seas, billions will end up starving.
Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by dredmorbius on Saturday May 03, 2014 @08:50PM (#7692894)
The sad truth is that fusion power remains a highly elusive and intractable technology after 50 years and billions of dollars of "research" (though much of that arguably was really rebranded weapons development).

The broad outlines of a potentially sustainable high-energy-yield future are well known. Solar is the clear standout winner, hydro, wind, geothermal, and possibly some biomass may contribute. Liquid hydrocarbon fuels synthesis via Fischer-Tropsch, Sabatier process, or similar processes looks potentially viable, and water as a feedstock for both hydrogen and carbon seems tractable.

It's not easy or cheap, but it's possible.

As for the billions -- I suspect that a future stable wealthy population level will indeed be some billions fewer than live on Earth today.

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by sitkack on Sunday May 04, 2014 @09:48AM (#7694268)
Solar has an absolutely $/watt right now. And edge deployed solar solves tons of problems with grid capacity. We really need to get on electric car grid intertie.

Billions is not an incredible amount of money. Fusion research has been horribly underfunded and has and is making great strides.

http://focusfusion.org/index.php/site/reframe/wasteful

So 27B USD (inflation adjusted) in funding over the history of fusion. Pennies.

http://nationalpriorities.org/cost-of/

Estimates for the total cost of the wars is around 4T USD with the current dollar cost of 1.5T USD. In Seattle we are building a 2 mile long tunnel for 4.25B. Our tunnel is 7% of the lifetime fusion budget.

We don't need solar and fusion to solve our fuel problem. We need solar and fusion to pull carbon back out of the atmosphere and the oceans.

Population has absolutely nothing to do with carbon output levels. North America and Europe account for the majority of carbon output and 20% of the worlds population.

edit: fixed number

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by dredmorbius on Sunday May 04, 2014 @12:25PM (#7694782)
Billions is not an incredible amount of money.

Billions with nothing to show for is.

Fusion energy is the first seriously pursued energy source which has never been proof-of-concepted for more than a few million dollars, and its only competition there is nuclear fission. Even there I suspect that the first criticality would have been achieved at even lower cost. I'm digging for references, though AFAIK first human-triggered criticality was at the University of Chicago in 1942 under Enrico Fermi (I'm not sure if earlier radiation workers achieved criticality). I can't find budgetary amounts for that project, but the entire Manhattan project was $26 billion in 2014 dollars, and it delivered sustained chain reaction, working reactors (at the very beginning of the project), and an actual stockpile of working weapons, two of which were used in combat.

By contrast, fusion research, while providing weapons, has not succeeded in delivering sustained net-energy-positive reactions.

And every single prior external energy source humans have utilized has been proven on a budget of at most a few dollars, if not freely in nature: agriculture, wood fire, coal, oil, gas, water, wind, solar, geothermal, wave, tide.

Another distinction which occurred to me some time back is that fusion is the first (on Earth) non-chain-reaction type material-based energy source.

That is: all other energy sources involving transformation of matter (whether by conventional molecular or nuclear chemistry) will proceed by themselves under proper conditions in which energy is sufficiently reflected or retained at the point of reaction.

In the case of solid fuels, a fire is achieved by piling fuel such that airflow is permitted (providing necessary oxygen), while the heat of burning embers is contained to allow more fuel to participate in the fire. Many sufficiently volatile fuels will burn without much or any concentration (e.g., candles, matches, twigs), though a coal or log fire generally requires _some_ assembly. Those conditions are readily and directly observable in nature.

Similarly, sustained nuclear fission is accomplished by ensuring that emitted neutrons have a sufficient likelihood of striking more atoms that the reaction is sustained. This is easy enough to achieve that nuclear industry workers have to take pains to not accidentally create critical masses of fissible materials (a task at which there have been multiple failures).

Wind, water, and solar energy demonstrations and practical application all pre-dated the Industrial Revolution.

By contrast, fusion technologies are all based on the principle of feeding more energy into the reaction chamber to continue the reaction, and absent that very active feedback (through very complex means). It's only when you, very literally, achieve stellar magnitude concentrations of mass that fusion occurs naturally at rates sufficient to provide substantial amounts of energy. And even the Sun, a third of a million times as massive as Earth, only undergoes hydrogen fusion at a rate per unit mass roughly equivalent to reptile metabolism. You, as a mammal (I presume), are releasing four times more energy per unit mass than the Sun is. The Sun just happens to be slightly more massive than you (or, of course, your mother -- or mine).

While exothermic fusion has been achieved on Earth, it's not been controlled, sustained, or utilizable for productive energy use. And I really don't see that changing.

When you contrast the billions to trillions in research that would have to be spent simply researching useful fusion technologies with the amount of actual energy infrastructure which could be constructed with an equivalent expenditure based on solar, wind, geothermal, and liquid fuels synthesis (among other known and proven technologies), there's really no argument in my mind.

Keep ticking the research along at low levels, sure, but in the near term (the next decades to century or so) we really have an exigent need that should be fulfilled first.

Finally: "Population has absolutely nothing to do with carbon output levels" is flat-out false, and misses the point. The accepted formula is in fact dependent on population, but also affluence and technology: I = P × A × T

That is: impact (including CO2 emissions) is a function of population, affluence (net resource consumption), and technology. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_%3D_PAT

The other problem is that it's not just CO2 emissions but total carrying capacity which are limited, as exemplified by "peak everything": oil, water, topsoil, phosphorus, uranium, copper, and many other inputs to both industrial and nonindistrial human existence. Estimates of what specifically a long-term sustainable carrying capacity might be vary, but a number that has been suggested (by the Ehrlichs among others) is around 2 billion. Last I checked we'd exceeded that slightly, and there might be a recruitment of volunteers in the near future.

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by sitkack on Sunday May 04, 2014 @05:16PM (#7695837)
So the Sun is big and fusion occurs at a low rate. Good thing, otherwise we wouldn't exist. The sun is contained by gravity and we are using magnetic containment. Gravity is the weakest force. All true.

I am not sure I fully understand your argument. Some energy storage, exploitation and transport mechanisms are as easy as falling off a log. That a continuous fission reaction occurred in 1942. Yeah using a pile of bricks. It also has been occurring naturally in Africa, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_nuclear_fission_reactor what does that have to do with limitless energy that will flow from a fusion reactor? How much has been spent on the oil economy in total? That number has no bearing on my argument either.

I am not sure what

| billions to trillions in research that would have to be spent simply researching useful fusion technologies

actually means. Sounds like throwing up the dangerous boogie-man of unknown costs. The US has spent ~30B in total on fusion research. And on ITER we will be contributing only 9% of the total, the same amounts btw as South Korea and India. Yes, further fusion research will cost billions, not trillions. I don't dispute that further research, it simply isn't that much money. At this point the billions is beneficial just for the science and engineering advancements.

Back to my original point is that these billion dollar numbers are paltry, that the perceived risks and dangers posed by Iraq and Afghanistan are also inconsequential compared to total collapse of the worlds oceans, drought and farm land loss by global warming. We wasted trillions of dollars, a small part of which could have funded human race saving science.

Of course population effects carbon output. The poorest 3 billion people on the planet will pay the price of the carbon output from the top 1 billion. It is the 1% of the western countries that will survive while the rest of humanity dies in trash heap of civilization.

We don't simply have an energy problem. That could easily solved with existing renewable tech. We have massive carbon problem that most likely can only be reversed by the massive power output of fusion power.

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by dredmorbius on Sunday May 04, 2014 @07:03PM (#7696188)
You're studiously avoiding my point: all other energy conversion pathways we've followed have been stupidly easy. Even the ones that are hard. I've explained that as clearly as I can, I'm not going to fault myself for your lack of comprehension.

I'd actually converted my earlier posts in this thread to a post (http://redd.it/24pnw6), in the process of which I turned up some more relevant funding details: the amount spent on fusion (about $29 billion in constant 2014 dollars) is roughly 25% of all US energy research spending (another significant chunk has been spent by way of tax benefits and incentives). Which is to say, again, a lot has been spent on this.

In terms of actual energy investment, that is, not research but capital expenditures in developing existing energy systems, the number is about $5 trillion, worldwide, spent on conventional petroleum development from 2005 - 2012, according to Steve Kopits (http://energypolicy.columbia.edu/events-calendar/global-oil-...). which is to say, we've got a baseline for what we're spending on real, present energy development.

That's also on the order of the capital expenditure which would provide, based on present-day, known, proven, and commercially deployed technologies, a sustainable energy infrastructure. Not pie-in-the-sky, 50 years out, might-work-we-think stuff, but Shit. That. Works. Now.

What's your best / most likely fusion technology? How long's it been in development? How far is it from break-even?

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by raverbashing on Friday May 02, 2014 @02:58PM (#7687456)
Trivial but expensive (and requiring some maintenance), at least with fotovoltaics

One of the reasons I think more people should be looking at solar-thermal rather than solar cells