News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by sitkack on Sunday May 04, 2014 @05:16PM (#7695837)
So the Sun is big and fusion occurs at a low rate. Good thing, otherwise we wouldn't exist. The sun is contained by gravity and we are using magnetic containment. Gravity is the weakest force. All true.

I am not sure I fully understand your argument. Some energy storage, exploitation and transport mechanisms are as easy as falling off a log. That a continuous fission reaction occurred in 1942. Yeah using a pile of bricks. It also has been occurring naturally in Africa, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_nuclear_fission_reactor what does that have to do with limitless energy that will flow from a fusion reactor? How much has been spent on the oil economy in total? That number has no bearing on my argument either.

I am not sure what

| billions to trillions in research that would have to be spent simply researching useful fusion technologies

actually means. Sounds like throwing up the dangerous boogie-man of unknown costs. The US has spent ~30B in total on fusion research. And on ITER we will be contributing only 9% of the total, the same amounts btw as South Korea and India. Yes, further fusion research will cost billions, not trillions. I don't dispute that further research, it simply isn't that much money. At this point the billions is beneficial just for the science and engineering advancements.

Back to my original point is that these billion dollar numbers are paltry, that the perceived risks and dangers posed by Iraq and Afghanistan are also inconsequential compared to total collapse of the worlds oceans, drought and farm land loss by global warming. We wasted trillions of dollars, a small part of which could have funded human race saving science.

Of course population effects carbon output. The poorest 3 billion people on the planet will pay the price of the carbon output from the top 1 billion. It is the 1% of the western countries that will survive while the rest of humanity dies in trash heap of civilization.

We don't simply have an energy problem. That could easily solved with existing renewable tech. We have massive carbon problem that most likely can only be reversed by the massive power output of fusion power.

Re:‘Solar’ jet fuel made out of air by dredmorbius on Sunday May 04, 2014 @07:03PM (#7696188)
You're studiously avoiding my point: all other energy conversion pathways we've followed have been stupidly easy. Even the ones that are hard. I've explained that as clearly as I can, I'm not going to fault myself for your lack of comprehension.

I'd actually converted my earlier posts in this thread to a post (http://redd.it/24pnw6), in the process of which I turned up some more relevant funding details: the amount spent on fusion (about $29 billion in constant 2014 dollars) is roughly 25% of all US energy research spending (another significant chunk has been spent by way of tax benefits and incentives). Which is to say, again, a lot has been spent on this.

In terms of actual energy investment, that is, not research but capital expenditures in developing existing energy systems, the number is about $5 trillion, worldwide, spent on conventional petroleum development from 2005 - 2012, according to Steve Kopits (http://energypolicy.columbia.edu/events-calendar/global-oil-...). which is to say, we've got a baseline for what we're spending on real, present energy development.

That's also on the order of the capital expenditure which would provide, based on present-day, known, proven, and commercially deployed technologies, a sustainable energy infrastructure. Not pie-in-the-sky, 50 years out, might-work-we-think stuff, but Shit. That. Works. Now.

What's your best / most likely fusion technology? How long's it been in development? How far is it from break-even?