News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by onion2k on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:14AM (#7473073)
I'm sick of people having prescriptive definitions of how language ought to be used. The term 'hacker' in a media piece about someone 'remotely abusing a computer system' is entirely understandable and consequently perfectly alright to use. Language is a beautiful, dynamic, living organism that evolves depending on how it's used by everyone every day. There is no 'wrong way' when it comes to language. There are ways that work and ways that don't work; which way you go for depends on how well you want to be understood.

Try to delight in the way people use language. Defining a word strictly and pedantically is showing off by demonstrating that you know more about a word's etymology and usage than someone else. Don't do that.

Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by hamburglar on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @11:20PM (#7478392)
I'm pretty well convinced that the motivation for getting upset over the "wrong" use of this word is usually just a desire to claim special knowledge and feel superior about being part of the elite group that knows the true meaning. It's disingenuous moaning about "confusion" while ignoring the fact that the rest of the world seems to get along just fine with the occasional word that has (gasp) more than one meaning.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by 3villabs on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:10AM (#7473418)
Noted thanks for the advice
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by czbond on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:49AM (#7473289)
You do understand that usage has been around longer for that context than the recently popular way of describing anyone that can touch a keyboard?
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by pabb on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:13AM (#7473436)
Precisely. I've read the counter sentiment multiple times from black hats who are exasperated seeing "hacker" tied to any notion of someone who programs or likes to "tinker with shit". I'd much rather keep the word definition at its root. (disclosure: I'm not a hacker)
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by clef on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:30AM (#7473590)
>"tinker with shit". That's gold!
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by 3villabs on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:12AM (#7473427)
Agreed that is my point. It has been around a long term, and yes we are in danger of overuse. Thus the comment on "Sex Hackers" indicating we have gone to far.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by czbond on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:30AM (#7473588)
Agreed - great blog post bringing up points I hadn't considered.... Love the opening line too.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by clef on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:52AM (#7473304)
Spot on.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by stonogo on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:22AM (#7473116)
When people say "cowboy," they don't mean the hundreds of thousands of working-class guys driving cattle for a living. They either mean Wild Bill or they mean some guy at a rodeo. When people say "trucker" they don't mean the hundreds of thousands of guys driving food deliveries to grocery stores; they mean Jerry Reed from Smokey and the Bandit. When people say "princess" they don't mean Lady Di, they mean any number of Disney characters.

In a similar vein, when people say "hacker" they don't particularly give a shit what side the guy's on, and "black hat" as a term is only acceptable in IT communities -- everyone else smirks at the nerd shit and continues using the terminology accepted by the vast majority of human society.

You're going to have to get used to it.

Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by Jtsummers on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:21AM (#7473108)
It's been this way for (EDIT: at least) 30 years. And the discussion has been going on just as long. Though it used to be, especially on /. back in the day, rants about "hacker" versus "cracker". I once tried to point this out to my parents, never again. It just doesn't matter. We've elected to continue applying a label to ourselves that the media uses in a totally different way. Language changes, often in ways counter to what we want, accept this and move on.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by 3villabs on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:14AM (#7473446)
I am not trying to change the world but when a potential business partner hears I am a hacker I don't want them thinking I am going to steal their credit card info.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by coldtea on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:18AM (#7473485)
So why don't you introduce yourself as a "programmer" or a "computer wizard" or a "tinkerer" or a "developer" or any other term and opt to use a term that's been synonymous with breaking into computing systems for 3-4 decades?
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by freehunter on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:23AM (#7473530)
Any why would you want to introduce yourself to a business partner as a hacker anyway? If they understand what you mean, you're telling them that you're going to give them a product that works, but only because of magic and duct tape, not because it's a professional product. If they don't understand what you mean, they'll think you're a criminal.

Either way, in the business world, hacker has only negative connotations. Only within hacker circles does the term become a positive.

Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by rainsford on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:31AM (#7473605)
It seems much easier to use a different word to describe yourself than it will be to convince everyone else to define hacker the same way you do. The whole point of language is to communicate ideas to people. Choosing a word you know in advance your audience is likely to misinterpret doesn't seem like very effective use of language to me.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by Jtsummers on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:25AM (#7473545)
Qualify it then. "I'm a computer hacker, I take <tools> and apply them to <domains> to create <solutions>." Or use it as a weed-out phrase, to find the potentials that are more familiar with computer culture and able to distinguish your meaning from society's meaning.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by StudyAnimal on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:32AM (#7473611)
A true hacker would be pleased at the idea of making a potential business partner uncomfortable about his talents, and relish the challenge of meeting their goals despite that discomfort.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by peterwwillis on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:22AM (#7473117)
I'm sick of the media saying "skinhead" when they mean "neo-nazi/white supremacist", but I don't go around whining about it. The use of words is controlled by popular opinion, not only one subclass of people that refer to themselves using the word.

Some words just need to be retired.

Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by pekk on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:38AM (#7473218)
But you did just whine about it. And many skinheads ARE white supremacists or nativists.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by johnward on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:47AM (#7473279)
Many black hats are hackers
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by qbrass on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:43AM (#7473712)
Many hackers are black hats. All black hats are hackers, they're a subset of the larger group.

And that's what the problem is. Calling a cracker a hacker is technically correct, but lead to the assumption that all hackers are black hats.

Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by vacri on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:35AM (#7473635)
Whining in one place does not constitute "going around" whining.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by Cuuugi on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:26AM (#7473152)
Forgive my ignorance, but wasn't the word made to describe "black hat" activities?

Everything else is a new definition (white hat etc.)

Language evolves, especially with created words.

Will your opinion win? Possibly, i dont know ( or care). I just get sick of people thinking their way of thinking is accepted fact.

Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by georgemcfly on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:45AM (#7473263)
The modern, non "black hat" use of the word originates with the MIT Tech Model Railroad Club (http://www.gricer.com/tmrc/dictionary1959.html) who define "hack" as '1) an article or project without constructive end; 2) work undertaken on bad self-advice; 3) an entropy booster; 4) to produce, or attempt to produce, a hack (3)."

Quite a few words in the "computer geek" lexicon were borrowed from the TMRC.

Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by 3villabs on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:14AM (#7473450)
Great answer!
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by blakesterz on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:19AM (#7473103)
As much as I agree with this we have lost this battle. For most people the definition of hacker is black hat, all the blog posts and comments in the world won't change that. People who get their news from newspapers and TV now know hackers break into things and steal stuff. They know that hackers are the bad guys.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by 3villabs on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:15AM (#7473460)
I understand, but as I plan to use the word a lot and take ownership of it this post is designed to inform those whom might read my stuff that I am not intending to steal their credit cards... yet... (jk)
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by StudyAnimal on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:22AM (#7473526)
So what is the other type of hacker then? And is the difference really substantial enough to warrant a separate word?
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by sssilver on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @12:26PM (#7474492)
And that's awesome. Because that's what hackers are, not just some mediocre Javascript coders :P
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by badman_ting on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:43AM (#7473247)
Language is fluid, and sadly we don't control it. Sorry.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by 3villabs on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:13AM (#7473437)
Oh nothing to be sorry about. Just merely making note of it.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by clef on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @08:56AM (#7473001)
>4) a person who illegally gains access to and sometimes tampers with information in a computer system

>This is the last one because it is the least accurate and has been created only in recent times by the media.

By recent times, you mean since the mid/late 80's when hacking sort of got known in the mainstream after phreaking?

>"Anyone that takes a look at a goal and a given set of resources then figures out an unconventional way to achieve that goal"

I want to be rich! therefore I choose to rob a bank (my unconventional way of achieving that goal), does that make me a hacker too? (Like a bank hacker)

Awesome article nonetheless!

Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by icantthinkofone on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:22AM (#7473121)
You are confused as many people grow up and enter this field. The original term for the bad guys was "crackers" and all crackers are hackers but not all hackers are crackers.

The media doesn't understand that and now all the young people growing up have the term 'hacker' all confused and messed up and ruined for the rest of us.

Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by roel_v on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:56AM (#7473327)
Pray tell, when was this mythical era when a sizable group of people actually made this distinction and used them as two separate concepts? Warning: this is a trick question, I'm almost old, so I have actual first-hand recollection of these days of yore you seem to be lamenting.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by icantthinkofone on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @08:08AM (#7514915)
I'm probably older than you but, based on your question, far more experienced in the field.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by krapp on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:39AM (#7473220)
The media communicates in the language that its audience understands. It isn't their job to enforce linguistic referential integrity, and "crackers" carries some negative connotations, at least in the US.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by bitsteak on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:33AM (#7473183)
Ask any random person what they think of when you say "hacker." PROTIP: it's not your typical employee of some random consumer web startup, working 12 hour days and pounding redbull. It's someone who bypasses technical security controls through mastery of the underlying technology.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by StudyAnimal on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:29AM (#7473586)
Does anyone think the former should be considered a good description of a hacker? To me it is someone using their intelligence, to do something clever (or at least in a clever way) to disrupt or destroy something, make someone uncomfortable or piss someone off, or challenge something, for some result that satisfies them or someone else in some way. And the essence really lies in that first bit. A random programmer isn't a hacker unless that first bit is there, the unorthodox, challenging or subversive bit.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by Jtsummers on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:42AM (#7473699)
So in your mind this site is about news concerning disrupting, destroying and irritating things and people? "Hacker" is entirely combative and offensive in your view. That seems weird to me.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by StudyAnimal on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @01:22PM (#7474860)
Yes, I think it should be. I think most things on the site qualify, but not all. However your second statement is a mischaracterization. It is not "entirely" combative or offensive. I just think that is the essential ingredient before the word hacker is appropriate. If you are modifying a device meant for one purpose to use it in another purpose that is hacking because you are subversively defying the intentions of the devices creators. If you are merely using an Arduino or a 3d printer to make something, that is not hacking. If you are founding a startup to disrupt an existing business model, and put a dinosaur out of business you are hacking. If you are just churning out another iPhone game, that is probably not hacking.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by Jtsummers on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @01:43PM (#7474986)
Using an (as an example) LCD projector to make a 3D printer is hacking. But it's not necessarily subversive. It's not what it was designed for, and not what it was intended for, but it's not necessarily in opposition to the will of the original creators/designers. And that opposition is the key ingredient to subversiveness.

> To me it is someone using their intelligence, to do something clever (or at least in a clever way) to disrupt or destroy something, make someone uncomfortable or piss someone off, or challenge something, for some result that satisfies them or someone else in some way.

All of those (destroy, disrupt, make uncomfortable, piss off, now subvert) except for "challenge" are combative things, especially if, as you keep doing, you relate it as being opposed to other people or entities. Hackers don't have to have the intention of undermining anything to be hackers. Making an HTTP server entirely in forth written entirely in assembly is a hacker thing to do, but it's not undermining anyone's authority, the closest it gets to your categorization (but not your apparent meaning) is as a challenge.

EDIT: forgot a word

Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by kaeruct on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:49AM (#7473294)
but those aren't mutually exclusive
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by StudyAnimal on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:21AM (#7473516)
I used to think there were two separate uses of the word, and one was less correct than the other. I used to insist people distinguish between a good "hacker" and an evil "cracker". Now I understand the essence of the term, there is no distinction between the two. Its all the same. Central to the essence is this notion that good and bad are subjective, and anything characterised as hacking should probably be both good (for someone or something) and evil (for someone or something) combined. Destruction and creation are both equally implied. I think if something is purely 100% good for everyone, I don't think the word hacker applies.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by rainsford on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:26AM (#7473556)
Language is ultimately defined by popular usage, and the majority of the usage of "hacker" means "black hat" type activities. You can argue for a different usage until you're blue in the face, but the black hat usage is pretty clearly the dominant one and has been for quite a while. Insisting on a different usage and using the word that way yourself just leads to confusion and makes you sound pedantic, no matter how correct you feel your definition is.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by stronglikedan on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:43AM (#7473241)
Context is important. Most laypersons reading an article don't know the terms "Black Hat", "White Hat", and so on. A good article should differentiate the intentions of the "hacker", so that the reader can imply the morality of those intentions by the context.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by Kurtz79 on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:42AM (#7473234)
Dozen of years of movies and video-games have cemented fairly well the use of the word.

"Look at you, hacker: a pathetic creature of meat and bone, panting and sweating as you run through my corridors. How can you challenge a perfect, immortal machine?"

Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by coldtea on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:15AM (#7473456)
Well, you don't control language. Language is language as it's used.

Furthermore, the whole "hacker is the good kind, no the black hat kind" screams "no true scotchman" to me. Lots of black hat's self identify as hackers.

Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by burtonlang on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:25AM (#7473548)
My understanding of the No True Scotsman fallacy involves changing a definition during an argument in order to hold on to some assertion.

This is not the same thing as a person feeling that a particular word should have a particular meaning.

Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by coldtea on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @03:45PM (#7476003)
The problem is the person seen as "changing a definition" could very well have had the second definition in his mind all along.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by CmonDev on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:42AM (#7473233)
To me it's someone who creates a messy working solution quickly. This is opposite to developers, who have to care about maintainability.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by olssy on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:52AM (#7473305)
Whatever kind of hacker you are there's a great convention for us all this summer in NYC, Hackers On Planet Earth: hope.net
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by 3villabs on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:19AM (#7473502)
Thanks! I'll check it out
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by skrowl on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:12AM (#7473065)
Obligatory HACK THE PLANET!
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by 3villabs on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:19AM (#7473496)
Love the reference!
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by chippy1337 on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:15AM (#7473081)
Actually, they mean "Cracker".
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by rrouse on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:49AM (#7473293)
To some people, that means "one who removes copy protections from software"
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by stonogo on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:22AM (#7473119)
In fact, they mean "hacker," because you don't get to define the words they use.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by theandrewbailey on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:36AM (#7473199)
But if you said that, people would think you're making an epithet against white people.
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by icantthinkofone on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:24AM (#7473129)
You are totally correct!
Re:I am sick of the media saying "Hacker" when they mean "Bl... by 3villabs on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @10:18AM (#7473490)
Agreed but that could be confused with other definitions used in the derogatory.