News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Goodbye Academia by 6cxs2hd6 on Monday March 03, 2014 @03:59PM (#7336406)
Not to sound like some crazy person with the word SOCIALIST written on the inside of my forehead in neon colors, but:

It should be possible for WhatsApp to get "only" $18 billion and scientific research gets the remaining $1 billion. About a 5% tax.

That way, venture capitalists could claim to fund innovation and would actually be truth-tellers.

Re:Goodbye Academia by ry0ohki on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:12PM (#7336508)
There's already a tax on that $18 billion, it's at least a capital gains tax of 20% (not to mention the income taxes on all the attorney's, accountants, etc... involved in the deal). You just need to fix the allocation of the tax dollars.
Re:Goodbye Academia by bduerst on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:42PM (#7336701)
That's only on cash dividends, selling equity, income on shorting, etc, right?

The actual transfer of equity isn't taxed, at least until they try to pull cash out.

Re:Goodbye Academia by ry0ohki on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:52PM (#7336777)
Without knowing the exact split of stock/cash that's difficult to answer, but we can at least say the cash portion is taxed at capital gains rates.
Re:Goodbye Academia by bduerst on Monday March 03, 2014 @09:30PM (#7338062)
Facebook only had 3.3 billion in cash, and I seriously doubt they spent more than a billion on this deal.
Re:Goodbye Academia by pyrrhotech on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:12PM (#7336517)
It's funny to me when people call companies like Twitter "tech companies". What technology has twitter invented? There are open source clones with 70% of the features in < 1k LoC. Bootstrap? give me a break.

It's time we got rid of this misnomer. Just because part of your company revolves around a piece of software you wrote doesn't mean you are a tech company. Writing software is not necessarily creating technology. Otherwise anyone who's written their own html site has just progressed technology.

Re:Goodbye Academia by simonw on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:29PM (#7336624)
"What technology has twitter invented?"

http://twitter.github.io/ currently lists 101 public repositories. Highlights include a SPDY library for iOS, Zipkin (a distributed tracing system), flockdb (a distributed, fault-tolerant graph database), Finagle (their own highly concurrent RPC system)... a TON of stuff.

Re:Goodbye Academia by hatred on Monday March 03, 2014 @05:15PM (#7336912)
No offence meant but that is like saying "Kia is also a car, does the same work. Why the hell even BMW exists"

May be BMW is doing things on the back that make it a better choice. Same is the difference between twitter and its thousand clones.

Re:Goodbye Academia by dajohnson89 on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @03:05PM (#7342711)
Do you have any idea the amount of engineering effort required to handle the scale of Twitter's service?
Re:Goodbye Academia by scrollaway on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:23PM (#7336575)
Companies like Twitter, Facebook, etc, regardless of what technology they invent that is of use for the public, often healthily contribute to the open source ecosystem. Twitter has contributed a lot to the Scala ecosystem, and Facebook to the PHP pseucosystem.

They also fund/maintain OS project they themselves use. Facebook, through their FriendFeed acquisition, obtained Tornado [1] and have maintained it very well since. I use Tornado every day.

I get your point but your anger is misplaced if you think the large "SV tech companies" don't "invent". You want tech companies that don't contribute anything to mankind? Look at purely closed source hardware companies.

[1] https://github.com/facebook/tornado

Re:Goodbye Academia by silverlake on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:18PM (#7336552)
You can write a superficial clone of any web app. But can you handle 8000 tweets/sec in real-time? The innovation is in the back-end.
Re:Goodbye Academia by pyrrhotech on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:22PM (#7336571)
It's been done notoriously badly at Twitter, no offense if you are an employee. Sure it's gotten better since they switched to the JVM, but still scaling to that size has been done by hundreds of companies now. Once there are textbooks out describing the techniques, you are simply implementing known methodologies with perhaps a few customizations and tweaks. I don't really see much innovation there TBH.
Re:Goodbye Academia by silverlake on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:42PM (#7336703)
I'm neither an employee nor a twitter user. But I've built phone networks and appreciate the absurd complexity of very large systems. If you believe you can build twitter, you're either a brilliant programmer or ignorant of the real challenges. Look at Twitter's code on github and tell me that's just a simple tweak on a known methodology.
Re:Goodbye Academia by AllTheThings on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:59PM (#7336817)
Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn (along with other big tech companies) all produce a lot of academic research that documents the architectures and protocols that they use, along with their performance. These companies innovate, and the material from their research often makes it into these "textbooks ... describing the techniques".
Re:Goodbye Academia by cnlwsu on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @11:50AM (#7341358)
Lets not trivialize a truly difficult problem just cause mongodb has some huge numbers on their marketing literature. Its naive to believe that scaling to the level of twitter is easy.

Sometimes you have to be innovative just to implement simple ideas in those text books or to make it actually efficient. Its easy to use type 1 UUIDs as ids but if its not practical to store 128bit ids for every value or you need to pack it into 64bits or need better ordering guarantees. you build something like snowflake.

Re:Goodbye Academia by tricolon on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:25PM (#7336601)
Surely you would consider at least some of Twitter's open source projects "creating technology": https://github.com/twitter
Re:Goodbye Academia by dredmorbius on Monday March 03, 2014 @05:18PM (#7336939)
As much as I find many of the past decade of Web / tech companies underwhelming, innovation can come from unusual places. Duff's Device, a method for unrolling loops in C for better performance, was created at Lucasfilm.

The challenges of scaling to very high levels has presented engineering challenges and solutions. I'm not sold that they're net beneficial in the greater order of things, but to say that there's been no significant innovation would be false.

Re:Goodbye Academia by abrichr on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:26PM (#7336603)
Twitter is one of the main contributors to Storm:

http://storm.incubator.apache.org/

Re:Goodbye Academia by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @04:20AM (#7339210)
>Not to sound like some crazy person with the word SOCIALIST written on the inside of my forehead in neon colors

Welcome to the party, comrade! Want a beer?

(No, seriously, it's not bad being a socialist. Turn off the American anti-applause-lights that are designed to make us look eeeeeeviiiiil and examine what our actual positions are. We're an ideology like more-or-less any other, with plenty of valid points even outsiders acknowledge.)

Re:Goodbye Academia by yetanotherphd on Monday March 03, 2014 @07:42PM (#7337677)
Funding science with taxes raised by income tax is socialist for me. Economic theory shows that income tax is the least distortionary kind of tax,

What you are advocating is populism. You see a large transaction, and say "we could use some of that!", without thinking about the relative efficiency of different kinds of taxation.

Re:Goodbye Academia by dnautics on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:44PM (#7336712)
How do you suppose that $1b would be allocated? Of course it will go to the top 1% of researchers, so the established top will stay at the top. Your proposal will make matter worse in exactly the way that "SOCIALISM" (OP's scare words) doesn't work.
Re:Goodbye Academia by a3voices on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:07PM (#7336462)
I didn't downvote you, but WhatsApp affects more people than obscure scientific research.
Re:Goodbye Academia by selmnoo on Monday March 03, 2014 @05:18PM (#7336948)
I don't know about that. NIH's annual budget a few years ago was about 20 billion dollars. WhatsApp was sold for almost nearly 20 billion. The studies funded by NIH cured diseases, extended lifetimes, made lives better. Why don't we get 5 more WhatsApp so that existed postdocs are paid better, and those thinking of academia actually join it and make discoveries to make human lives even longer and healthier.
Re:Goodbye Academia by ForHackernews on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:12PM (#7336513)
WhatsApp is just cheap text messages. If we had a sane telecom market to start with, SMS would already cost nearly nothing and there'd be no market for WhatsApp.

They've done a good job filling a niche in a broken market, and delivered real value for consumers, I admit.

Re:Goodbye Academia by fennecfoxen on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:12PM (#7337260)
Monopoly profits don't get redistributed back into the consumer surplus all by themselves. Somebody's got to do it.
Re:Goodbye Academia by cabalamat on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:14PM (#7336527)
If it wasn't for obscure scientific research, WhatsApp wouldn't exist.
Re:Goodbye Academia by bduerst on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:47PM (#7336738)
Slippery Slope: If it wasn't for obscure scientific research, almost nothing we know would exist.

It doesn't mean that obscure scientific research has the same market value as almost everything.

Re:Goodbye Academia by dredmorbius on Monday March 03, 2014 @05:37PM (#7337050)
Oxygen has little market value, nor does language.

Market value is a measure of many things. Net benefit to civilization isn't one of them.

Re:Goodbye Academia by Fomite on Monday March 03, 2014 @11:56PM (#7338554)
> Oxygen has little market value

Don't tell that to the atmospheric gas industry.

Re:Goodbye Academia by dredmorbius on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @03:46PM (#7342987)
What's the size of the atmospheric gas industry?

What's the size of the global food industry?

To a rough approximation: everyone who eats must pay for food (at least some of it).

To a rough approximation: nobody who breathes pays for oxygen.

I'm not saying there's no market at all for oxygen, nitrogen, CO2, etc. But that the vast amount of use for these gases is done without the mediation of a market, or the imposition of a market cost or fee.

According to the U.S. Census Bureau, the industrial gases industry shipped products valued at nearly $9.5 billion in 2007

http://business.highbeam.com/industry-reports/chemicals/indu...

For agriculture, wheat alone accounted for $10.6 billion, corn $48.7 billion, soybeans $32.4 billion. . The total value of U.S. wheat production in 2009 was $10.6 billion.

As was traditionally the case, in 2009 corn far surpassed other U.S. crops in value at nearly $48.7 billion. For comparison, soybean crops, the second leading field crop, were valued at about $32.4 billion.

http://business.highbeam.com/industry-reports/agriculture/wh...

http://business.highbeam.com/industry-reports/agriculture/co...

Total food expenditures? Somewhere north of $600 billion:

http://www.ers.usda.gov/amber-waves/2011-september/food-spen...

Your atmospheric gasses industry represents 1.6% of the value of food spending in the US. And again, virtually nobody who uses oxygen directly actually pays for that privilege. Which is to say: there is no market value.

Re:Goodbye Academia by Fomite on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @04:21PM (#7343255)
Regardless of whether or not most people spend money to breathe oxygen, any approximation that loses a 9.5 billion dollar industry to rounding errors is a poor approximation.

And while most people don't pay for their use of atmospheric gasses, those who do are paying for something mission critical. You might as well say there is no value to sunlight because I can go lay on my roof deck.

Re:Goodbye Academia by dredmorbius on Thursday March 06, 2014 @06:02PM (#7357194)
rounding errors

You're being obtusely blind to my point. It is a rounding error. Those who do pay (and, incidentally, with the reliance of most ag on industrial nitrogen fixation, that's probably pretty much all of us, indirectly) are doing so because the need they have cannot be met through the nontransactional atmospheric supply.

What you're missing with your fixation on the atmospheric gasses bit is the remainder of total economic output ($70 trillion, give or take rounding errors of a few trillion), every last dollar of which requires humans, animals, plants, factories, fires, and god knows what else to have access to an atmosphere. Your $9.5 billion? 0.013% of the total.

Again: air has, to any reasonable approximation, zero economic value. It has tremendous utility value.

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_economy

Re:Goodbye Academia by dredmorbius on Thursday March 06, 2014 @08:35PM (#7357920)
Apologies for dupe posts, was getting HN errors when this went through.
Re:Goodbye Academia by cabalamat on Monday March 03, 2014 @05:11PM (#7336896)
> It doesn't mean that obscure scientific research has the same market value as almost everything.

Of course not. Food, for example, has much more immediate use.

But it does mean that science is pretty valuable, and more valuable over longer periods.

Re:Goodbye Academia by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @04:22AM (#7339216)
>It doesn't mean that obscure scientific research has the same market value as almost everything.

Scientific research is not (by design) excludable property, so attempting to assign a market value to it is actually a category error. Markets can only assign prices after definitions of ownership and trade are given.

Re:Goodbye Academia by 6cxs2hd6 on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:13PM (#7336525)
I understand your point. Startups can be be obscure in the same ways as research: Interesting idea, but turned out to be wrong. Interesting, and right, but no significant application in the broad world. Or not even a very interesting idea.

There's value to a system where plausible things get funded, even if only 1 turn out to pay for the 9 that suck.

Re:Goodbye Academia by Dewie on Monday March 03, 2014 @05:00PM (#7336830)
> Not to sound like some crazy person with the word SOCIALIST written on the inside of my forehead in neon colors, but:

Oh give me a break.

Re:Goodbye Academia by 6cxs2hd6 on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:02PM (#7336430)
Fastest. Downvote. Ever.

\o/

Re:Goodbye Academia by skybrian on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:11PM (#7336503)
Why? What would be the problem with taxing large acquisitions? It seems relatively painless and with little dead-weight loss compared to other taxes.
Re:Goodbye Academia by gnoway on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:32PM (#7336650)
I don't know what the parent's reasoning is, but the problem I have with "let's just tax it!" is that there's probably already taxes being taken from that money somewhere along the line. The next response is usually "well that's fine" - no, it isn't always - or "well we'll stop some or all of those others," which doesn't necessarily happen. Finally, while a tax may ostensibly exist to pay for x, there's usually nothing stopping existing funding y from being reappropriated for z once the new tax is in place. So there can be a new tax to increase funding but there's no net gain. I don't have any sources but I firmly believe that this happens.

So, short answer: because politics.

Re:Goodbye Academia by 6cxs2hd6 on Monday March 03, 2014 @08:05PM (#7337774)
I'm the OP. I meant I'd never had something downvoted 30 seconds after I posted it.
Re:Goodbye Academia by yetanotherphd on Monday March 03, 2014 @07:37PM (#7337660)
>relatively painless and with little dead-weight loss

On what basis are you making this claim? Since you are familiar with the term deadweight loss, you must be familiar with the economic theory associated with taxation, and therefore the standard claim that the least distortionary tax is income tax. Taxes other than income tax are usually justified in terms of negative externalities.

Re:Goodbye Academia by nova on Monday March 03, 2014 @05:03PM (#7336851)
I think the problem is what to do with that money once collected. With taxes in general.

Currently we just let politicians spend it as they see fit.