News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by jknupp on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @03:47PM (#730847)
And here I thought the reason the Segway never caught on was because it was prohibitively expensive to own and didn't fulfill any real need.
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by brk on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @04:01PM (#730886)
What is your definition of "caught on"? They're doing about $50MM/yr in business, so there is a market.

The problem with Segway, IMHO, is that the initial hype was completely misdirected and Dean Kamen drinks far too much of his own Kool-Aid.

Segway has made a good inroads in the police and security market, as well as the tourism markets.

For what it does best, it's really not that prohibitive, but for consumer transportation, there is less ROI in most cases.

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by _pius on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @06:24PM (#731223)
Just a point of information: the original essay did not use the phrase "caught on." PG said: "The Segway hasn't delivered on its initial promise, to put it mildly.

Given that the hyped promise of the Segway was literally to revolutionize public transportation as we know it, I'd say the statement is accurate.

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by jacquesm on Thursday July 30, 2009 @03:32AM (#731812)
Plenty of that hype was media speculation and did not come from DK. 'IT' and 'Ginger' and a veil of secrecy were just about the only pre-release things that came from there, the hype blew it up way beyond reasonably expectations. The segway - which is innovative in many ways and has done a lot for robotics - could only dissapoint by the time it was released, no matter what it really was.
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by DannoHung on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @04:23PM (#730948)
I wonder what would Segway's market be like if they could make a 20mph version that was safe to drive on city streets.
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by mbrubeck on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @04:28PM (#730957)
For the price of a segway you can get a motorcycle or a scooter or a moped or an electric bike, and drive it on city streets. Yet most Americans still drive cars. What benefits does a turbocharged Segway offer that these other options don't?
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by jpwagner on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @04:43PM (#730995)
If you could flip a switch and the segway could go operate in the 10-70mph range, and flip it back to operate in the 0-10mph range, you could transition from street to sidewalk (vehicle to pedestrian.)

This would be worth the extra money and not be uncool.

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by JacobAldridge on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @06:07PM (#731197)
Even at 70mph you'd still run into the problem pg expouses - looking like an effortless dork.

As for this bit - "imagine something that worked like the Segway, but that you rode with one foot in front of the other, like a skateboard. That wouldn't seem nearly as uncool." - have you seen the Scarpar? It's only 35mph, but definitely, definitely cool.

http://www.scarpar.com/video.html

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by jhancock on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @09:01PM (#731460)
at 70mph, you'd look like a dork committing suicide.
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by jdbeast00 on Thursday July 30, 2009 @08:57AM (#732078)
are you serious? this may be what the segway needs. Extreme segway sports. If i saw someone going 70 mph on a segway, my first thought would certainly not be 'what a square'.
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by jodrellblank on Thursday July 30, 2009 @01:27PM (#732629)
It's cool and looks fun, but I can't imagine people doing city tours or Mall security on it - that is, it's not in the same market as the Segway.

This similar idea, though:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gm_2PnSkWck

... maybe. Looks a bit wobblier, but look at it in context - they are on a cycle path and they fit in perfectly well. Someone on a Segway would stand out quite a lot.

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by bkudria on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @10:21PM (#731556)
Thanks for that link - that looks incredibly cool!
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by kirse on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @05:42PM (#731143)
operate in the 10-70mph range

I had to laugh at the thought of a Segway doing 70mph. I'm all for taking risks, but have you ever done 50mph+ on just a moped?

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by run4yourlives on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @05:40PM (#731139)
But most likely illegal in most cities.
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by brk on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @04:40PM (#730987)
The i2 model can fit through a doorway. It can be picked up and moved by a reasonably fit person. It can be used indoors or out, and with some accessories can carry a small amount of cargo.

The general public bias against Segways is kind of understandable. Most people aren't capable of thinking outside the box. I'm always a little surprised when the hacker/entrepreneur community seems to jump on that bandwagon though. Even moreso today when so many people claim to be "green" advocates and will proclaim that we need to explore other modes of transportation, yet bash anything that doesn't have 4 tires and a steering wheel.

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by mbrubeck on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @04:52PM (#731015)
A bicycle can fit through a doorway, be picked up and moved, and carry a quite large amount of cargo. For the price of a Segway it could be equipped with a motor of similar speed and efficiency, or it can be run on human power. Unlike the Segway, the bicycle can go in the street and on dirt trails, has much greater maximum speed and range, and is cheap and easy to repair.

Sure, the Segway has advantages too - but when people suggest that it should go at 25mph in city streets, it's worth considering whether the Segway's unique properties actually contribute anything. Different tools are better for different jobs.

I'm all in favor of thinking outside the box, but things like cargo bicycles are more practical and interesting (though less sexy and high-tech) for my own city transportation needs: http://www.xtracycle.com/cargo-utility-bicycles.html

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by brk on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @06:16PM (#731210)
I don't think Segways were ever really intended to compete with bicycles. People make that comparison alot, but it's really not valid.

A closer comparison is a scooter or moped type of device. Those will fit through some doorways, but being gas-powered they are generally excluded from use or storage in most indoor areas. Cost is comparable, although the scooter would win out on distance and top speed. Most scooters are also too heavy for a single operator to pick up and move, and they also don't generally break down to fit easily in the trunk of a vehicle.

Segway's, even the non off-road models do quite well on dirt/trails, so that isn't an advantage for the bike. They could go in the streets as well, the only limitation there is erratic legislation, so it's hard to make a direct comparison.

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by tokenadult on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @05:31PM (#731110)
My feet can fit into all kinds of places where Segways can't, and when I use them to move around I get the benefits of aerobic exercise and whole body movement.
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by easyfrag on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @04:42PM (#730993)
Can you take a Segway into a pubic building?
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by dougp on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @07:34PM (#731349)
Yes I go up and talk to people that ride segways whenever I see them usually in malls and the like and most use them because they are partially handicapped and have trouble walking and the segway makes them look normal.
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by nocman on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @11:44PM (#731655)
I'll second that. I have a relative who can stand fine, but can't walk for long distances. The Segway makes it possible for him to travel distances that he otherwise would not be able to travel. He doesn't look like a dork when he rides it (in my opinion). Perhaps everyone just assumes that if you own a segway you are a pompous windbag with more money than sense. I wouldn't be surprised if most people see it as a luxury item that only the "elite" can afford, and therefore they resent the device's presence (as well as the rider's). Perhaps calling the person lazy is the best thing they can come up with which is derogatory. "Get that thing off the sidewalk you rich jerk" probably doesn't seem to have as much sting.
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by dandrews on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @05:44PM (#731144)
Posters on e.g. segwaychat.com have often said they'd like to have more speed. But I can't imagine falling at 20mph... it's bad enough falling at 12.5mph, believe me.

(The "dork factor" is what prevents me from doing the smart thing and wearing a skate helmet. Instead I only wear a pair of wraparound shades. Stupid peer pressure...)

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by jodrellblank on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @06:01PM (#731186)
Maybe if you had a helmet that looked like it took more work to wear...
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by jrockway on Thursday July 30, 2009 @01:09AM (#731707)
But I can't imagine falling at 20mph... it's bad enough falling at 12.5mph, believe me.

I've never ridden a segway, but I have crashed my bike at this speed. I imagined that it would be really bad, but having done it a few times, it is really not that bad. You are moving parallel to the ground, so most of the energy is absorbed by the pavement slowly grinding the top layer of your skin off. Somewhat painful, and very bloody, but not life threatening.

I imagine that riding into a wall at 20mph would be pretty bad, though. All that energy instantly acting to crush your bones and internal organs. I haven't actually tried it, so this is just speculation. (Please report back if you try it ;)

(Oh, and as for the helment; I always wear one, but I have never landed on it while crashing. Let your arms and legs do the work :) I think you have to do something weird to land on your head.)

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by billswift on Thursday July 30, 2009 @02:50AM (#731779)
I managed to land on my head n the middle of the road from a bicycle accident when I was in high school. I hit a pothole and me and the bike went slightly different directions, I was tucking to roll when the top bar of the bike came down across my ankle and stopped the roll. That was the closest I have ever come to being knocked out, and it was very, very close.

EDIT: Although I was very dazed at the time, my ankle was actually injured worse than my head.

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by jrockway on Thursday July 30, 2009 @03:57AM (#731829)
I hit a concrete block in the road once, and I think I went over the handlebars. I hit my face, though, not the helmet :(

Hey, I even have a picture: http://rants.jrock.us/post/55729583/good-idea-riding-your-bi...

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by billswift on Saturday August 01, 2009 @04:43PM (#736644)
This was a long while back, I wasn't wearing a helmet, no body I knew back then even had a bike helmet.
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by gdee on Thursday July 30, 2009 @03:09AM (#731795)
>> I think you have to do something weird to land on your head.

Not weird, just reckless. Like tolerating faulty rear breaks for a little while. What was I thinking :)... Anyway, the helmet took it and the dog that prompted the full stop got away unscratched...

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by jrockway on Thursday July 30, 2009 @03:55AM (#731826)
Yeah, gotta be careful with respect to maintenance. I crashed earlier this summer because I shifted my chain into the spokes, locking the rear wheel in a turn. I knew the limit screw was set improperly, but I figured it was not enough to cause any problems. Well, I was wrong. I landed on my leg, though, and unclipped quickly enough that I didn't even scratch myself too badly. (Threadlock is your friend, BTW, so the limit screws don't unscrew themselves. I still pull the derailer cable before each ride to make sure the chain can't be shifted off the cogs, though.)

Also, did you use your front brake? I tend to see my rear brakes as a backup; I use it if the front brake fails, if the front wheel has poor traction, or if I'm descending and just want to slow the acceleration. The front brake can develop about 5x more stopping force, since the front wheel can't skid. And, if you are used to using it, you won't go over the handlebars in an emergency. http://sheldonbrown.com/brakturn.html

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by gdee on Thursday July 30, 2009 @06:00AM (#731907)
>>Also, did you use your front brake?

I used both but only the front worked. So I landed on my helmet, bike on top. Quite the other way than you, I tend to use mostly the rear break. Not being used to rely on the front, not in a "to the floor" way anyway is what got me. That and the lack of proper adjustment tolerated to the rear one.

Also, nice link. Thanks.

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by davidw on Thursday July 30, 2009 @06:14AM (#731916)
You have to use them both and learn how to apply more or less of one or the other depending on the circumstances.
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by kobs on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @06:36PM (#731244)
Just an anecdote, but I saw an older gentleman riding a Segway in the street on Lexington avenue in Midtown Manhattan!
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by gaius on Thursday July 30, 2009 @07:13AM (#731951)
A couple of weeks ago in Paris there were a dozen or so people riding black Segways near the Eiffel Tower. Must've been a meeting of the local chapter or something.
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by vidarh on Thursday July 30, 2009 @07:37AM (#731973)
They're used for some guided tours for tourists.
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by khafra on Thursday July 30, 2009 @08:12AM (#732000)
Not just in Paris--here in the fairly unremarkable town of St. Petersburg, FL, they have Segway guided tours.
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by quellhorst on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @10:36PM (#731577)
Actually he drank his own urine (after going through his water purifier).
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by alexsolo on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @05:35PM (#731124)
I think it ultimately comes down to price. When the Segway first came out, it was available for pre-order on Amazon for $10000! This is an extremely high price, which is orders of magnitude higher than the alternatives: bicycles, motorized bicycles and scooters, motorized skateboards, etc.

The high price instantly relegated the product into a niche. At that price, the Segway is only viable for businesses (consumers can't afford it) that can really justify the need for the product.

Imagine for a second that the first Segway came out at a price of $1000, and that the price gradually dropped to $400 - $500. I think a good number of early adopters would have bought the first dorky-looking version. These people would have used the Segway, and some would have complained about the look. Some people would have started customizing it and making it look cooler, go faster, attach jets to it, etc. Gradually, the manufacturer would have listened to the customers, and would have started making many versions of the product, some for kids, others for teens, adults, etc. They would have created off-road extreme versions of it and one-wheel versions of it.

Basically, I believe that there is a healthy demand for getting around town quickly, and that if the price of the Segway was right, the mass market would adopt it. Mass market adoption would then quickly iron out the dorkyness of the Segway though many iterations of the product.

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by pg on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @04:55PM (#731027)
That's why I wrote

"There are several reasons why, but one is that people don't want to be seen riding them."

instead of

"The reason is that people don't want to be seen riding them."

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by jknupp on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @08:25PM (#731409)
True, but you also wrote "So there may be a way to capture more of the market Segway hoped to reach [by redesigning it to make the operator look more active]".

In all honesty, for how many people do you think "how I look while riding it" is the single factor stopping them from buying a Segway? Your statement implies that this is not the vanishingly small number of people I would expect it to be.

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by pg on Thursday July 30, 2009 @02:51AM (#731784)
That's why I wrote

"capture more of the market Segway hoped to reach"

instead of

"capture the market Segway hoped to reach"

I know firsthand that Segways aren't that useful, because for a couple years I could ride the Segwell whenever I wanted, and all I ever did with it was tool around on the street in front of YC. That is why I qualified these passages the way I did. And that's enough; I'm not going to start cluttering essays with clauses to head off every misinterpretation someone might post on a forum.

I suppose I could create a separate page for each essay, answering in advance all the mistaken objections I knew people would raise about it. ("Note that I did not claim that this is the main problem with the Segway, just one of many" etc, etc.) It seems like a waste of time, but it would take less than this discussion has.

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by timdellinger on Thursday July 30, 2009 @10:17AM (#732248)
"Note that I did not claim that this is the main problem with the Segway, just one of many"

I think the title of the essay (The Trouble with the Segway) kinda does imply that this is the main problem. The title suggests that the essay will explain the Segway's lack of success. Perhaps a different title would have prepared the reader for what was actually in the essay. How about "The Segway's other problem". Personally, I'm starting to think that the real problem is this: it lacks dignity.

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by messel on Thursday July 30, 2009 @09:31AM (#732156)
I'd wager responding to the vultures is unproductive. The majority of readers follow your point. Respoding just fuels their linguistics lawyering further.
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by caffeine on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @09:53PM (#731519)
Most probably think it's nice, but:

- I can't ride it up an 80 degree slope covered in ice with unreasonably intense instrumental metal playing in the background.

- It cannot carry the enormous frozen mammal I just picked up at Sam's Club, let alone the metric ton of salsa that was on offer.

- People would laugh and call me Mall Cop, and I'd feel like a twat.

- I would be broke after buying this, and being broke, mocked, hungry, and unable to go off-road is just too frustrating.

.. on the other hand, it's really neat.

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by zck on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @10:23PM (#731559)
People do consider other people's reactions. Since people riding a Segway are seen as "uncool", many people won't even consider buying one. They don't get to the point where they're looking at pros and cons; buying one isn't even a consideration.
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by gaius on Thursday July 30, 2009 @04:54AM (#731872)
That isn't true and that's easy to prove: old ladies don't care what anyone thinks about those upright cloth shopping carts with the little wheels they use, I don't even know what the right name for them is. The Segway could be a motorized one of them.

Hip urban web 2.0 Ruby rockstar ninjas are not the only market for tech.

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by Retric on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @08:40PM (#731432)
From a utility standpoint a Segway's would be perfect for traveling around a Zoo / Disneyland. Rent them for ~30$ a day and it could be vary popular and profitable.

However, there seems to be little gain from owning one because they have the same downsides of a bike. Plus, you need to charge them, and you need to more concerned with them getting stolen.

So, the consumer Segway market is basically an expensive vanity item. But, few people actually want to be seen on them due to look and feel issues.

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by mrtron on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @09:59PM (#731528)
No way. The majority of people going to zoos/disneyland are families. What are you going to do with your 5, 3 and 1 year old children?
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by lnguyen on Thursday July 30, 2009 @10:32AM (#732289)
There are city tours that use Segways (see http://citysegwaytours.com for instance). The dork factor isn't that big of a deal if you're already easily flagged as being a tourist (fanny pack, camera hanging off your neck, etc.).

It also makes a lot of sense in that it allows you to cover significantly more territory than you'd otherwise be able to on foot and you're not trapped in the same kind of bubble as you would be on a tour bus.

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by olefoo on Thursday July 30, 2009 @12:38AM (#731689)
When you add up the negatives, the cost, the limited range, the fact that it's awkward in many common situations, and it's going to make you look like a dork... I think that's one of the things that would tip the balance for me.

Of course I wouldn't even consider a segway, because the range and cargo capacity are not sufficient for a motor vehicle; and I prefer a bike for local motion.

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by greendestiny on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @10:23PM (#731560)
I don't think anyone would have that thought process. However, if it was released initially without a pole and ridden sideways it would have been taken up by a young early adopter base who would have made it seem cool. People aren't immune from cultural effects, and for most people the thing the segway has over walking is being fun, cool and futuristic.
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by messel on Thursday July 30, 2009 @08:50AM (#732061)
I think there's a market need for physically handicapped folks but thr segway was never designed for them. Agreed the market targeted Was hallucinated
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by erlanger on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @10:22PM (#731558)
> In all honesty, for how many people do you think "how I look while riding it" is the single factor stopping them from buying a Segway?

Many people, especially those in the market for a new form of walking (people with serious dough), will spend money on impulse, not based on practical utility. Image is a huge selling point for most consumers, though they may not acknowledge it.

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by donaq on Thursday July 30, 2009 @05:19AM (#731886)
Image is a huge selling point for most consumers, though they may not acknowledge it.

Agreed. I mean, look at Macs. Granted, Macs have technical merit, but how many people who use Macs actually bought them for technical superiority and how many others bought them because Apple makes them look cool?

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by bkovitz on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @06:20PM (#731216)
"People on Segways look smug" is a good observation, but it's a strange and confusing emphasis in an essay titled "The Trouble with the Segway".
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by diego on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @06:41PM (#731257)
How do you know that it's a reason and not a consequence?
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by avinashv on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @04:00PM (#730882)
Came here to say this, with just one addition:

I think there is a select group of people for whom the Segway has a legitimate use--I'm thinking along the lines of people who have trouble walking long distances (say, more than 5-10 minutes). I've seen a lot of people using the Segway for this purpose.

But as a normal means of transportation? No. Price, need, rules for usage etc. are pretty big hindrances for purchase.

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by ShabbyDoo on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @09:00PM (#731457)
IIRC, Kamen was contractually prohibited from marketing the Segway as a health aid after selling the wheelchair with similar technology to J&J. One Segway dealer told me that a 3rd party retrofits them with seats for use by those who can't stand/walk for long periods but don't really need a wheelchair.

Those who say, "Well, you could use a bike, wheelchair, etc." don't understand the use case. A person who can't walk long distances might use it in the mall to go from store to store. Then, when he sees something he wanted to look at, he could get off and browse around for a few minutes. It's the walk from the parking lot to the shoe section at WalMart that gets them -- it's not the few minutes spent perusing the boots.

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by Afton on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @07:35PM (#731351)
Actually, electric wheelchairs are superior for this purpose. People with mobility issues generally aren't going to want to stand for the 5-10 minutes. I've never ridden one, but if it requires core strength at all to lean-steer, then that rules it out for most people with disabilities.
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by trominos on Thursday July 30, 2009 @02:07PM (#732707)
I'm not sure.

Americans in the middle class and above aren't strangers to spending substantial amounts of money on stuff that they don't need. Segways are useful enough that I could imagine them gaining a substantial market share if it were fashionable to use one.

Now, that doesn't mean that they would catch on if they weren't dorky. But even at the outrageous price that they were marketed at, I think it's conceivable that they could -- I think they'd have similar chances to other potential fashions. So I actually think I agree with PG more than you. Price and insubstantial benefit are both major problems with the Segway (and frankly I'm being a little devil's advocate here, the price was ridiculous -- but cut it in half or so and I think it stops being prohibitive), but the aspect of Segway that made it impossible for the thing to succeed was its dorkiness.

Re:The Trouble with the Segway by vaksel on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @06:52PM (#731286)
It's not prohibitively expensive, most people can afford the $5.5K price tag. It's just that for 1/10th of the price, you can buy a bicycle that does the same exact job.
Re:The Trouble with the Segway by weaksauce on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @03:58PM (#730876)
Not to mention that you look like a tool and they are banned from the sidewalks of SF.