News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by thatthatis on Sunday February 23, 2014 @10:51PM (#7288993)
Paraphrasing

> the FCC has no good solutions.

Yes they do, declare broadband to be a common carrier. Force comcast to sell wholesale access to their retail pipes to other companies who then compete for the end users. We've seen this show before and have good solutions to the problem. It's time to treat the Internet as a mature public utility and regulate it as such, i.e. regulate it to maximize social good

Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by jedberg on Monday February 24, 2014 @12:54AM (#7289309)
People keep saying this, but you have to dig deeper. Even the content producers don't want this.

Common carrier means multiple things, but one of them is that it sets a floor on the price for peering agreements. This means that currently free peering will have to become paid peering, and no one wants that.

It would actually give more money to the ISPs for something they are already doing.

Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by eggnet on Monday February 24, 2014 @02:04AM (#7289488)
You have to carve out the local access portions of the current ISPs into their own companies. Make those local access providers common carriers.

I think that is roughly what the gp is saying.

Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by kiallmacinnes on Monday February 24, 2014 @05:17AM (#7290010)
This is what happened in Ireland with traditional phone services and the infrastructure they depend on.

Eircom split into Eircom Wholesale and Eircom.. The last mile copper and core network is managed by Eircom Wholesale, while end users subscribe to Eircom.

The wholesale company offers its services to any phone or broadband company, with published (starting..) price lists. This seems to work well.

In Europe, we also have the notion of Internet Exchanges like INEX, LINX and AMS-IX. These are non-profits, typically owned by their members, who provide switching fabric at the major datacenters for ISPs and other internet companies to exchange traffic - without any per-peer fees. You simply pay a membership fee typically based on the number and type of ports you want.

This allows even the smallest companies to directly peer with the major ISPs. INEX requires members establish BGP peering with something like "at least 80% of other members".. Again, this seems to work well.

Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by simonh on Monday February 24, 2014 @06:47AM (#7290263)
Sure, but that's Europe where non-profit != communism.
Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by dragonwriter on Monday February 24, 2014 @12:10PM (#7291890)
> Common carrier means multiple things, but one of them is that it sets a floor on the price for peering agreements.

TL;DR for the following: [citation needed]

Designating broadband service as common carrier service, enabling the FCC to issue regulations of the type defined for common carriers to broadband providers would no doubt permit the FCC to set a non-zero price floor for peering, but I'd like to see what law would require the FCC to set a non-zero price floor if it designated broadband service as common carrier service.

Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by thatthatis on Monday February 24, 2014 @08:00AM (#7290498)
I'd like to investigate the price floor claim more, you have a link?
Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by cdash on Sunday February 23, 2014 @10:57PM (#7289010)
That people are still fighting this I just can't believe. How can the internet not be viewed as an essential utility in the modern world is just crazy to me.
Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by anigbrowl on Monday February 24, 2014 @12:07AM (#7289199)
Stupidity and greed. Many people arguing about this at the Wall Street Journal, for example, are convinced that there are no such things as broadband caps or QOS levels and that everyone who uses Netflix streaming is freeloading without paying for the bandwidth they use. In their mind companies like Netflix and people who argue for net neutrality are identified with welfare cheats and socialism. I wish I were making this up.
Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by espadrine on Monday February 24, 2014 @04:46AM (#7289916)
For the purpose of comparison, we have the same issue in France, although we do not have Netflix there. ISPs are slowing down Google services / Cogent / … and asking them to pay[1]. One went so far as to remove Youtube ads on-the-fly without telling (let alone asking) the consumers beforehand. And slowly, not limiting bandwidth becomes an argument for the customer to pay more, as well[2].

They are looking for a target to increase their revenue. Given the targets they pick, I'd say they're mostly driven by envy.

[1]: http://www.lemonde.fr/technologies/article/2012/09/20/free-a...

[2]: http://imgur.com/aHxjUOz

Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by tim333 on Monday February 24, 2014 @07:05AM (#7290335)
I think link 2 shows an ad for unlimited youtube over 4G wireless and presumably is referring to unlimited data usage, which is a different thing to wired broadband. I think all countries have similar restrictions - I don't know anywhere where you get unlimited mobile data on the cheap deals.
Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by lucideer on Monday February 24, 2014 @07:24AM (#7290389)
Both referenced links deal with mobile broadband specifically.
Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by interstitial on Monday February 24, 2014 @01:26AM (#7289379)
Let me tell you about vested interest, rent-seeking, and regulatory capture. Three things that should be taught in elementary school, but never will be, because public education has all three in spades as well.
Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by btbuildem on Sunday February 23, 2014 @11:03PM (#7289021)
Because they profit from it.
Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by Shivetya on Monday February 24, 2014 @06:04AM (#7290151)
Hell no.

We will go back to a day where whatever speed you get is all your ever going to see. I know people hate Comcast/etc but where I lived all I had was what the phone company, THE COMMON CARRIER, wanted to offer us until the cable companies came in.

We got a wonderful choice of dial up, ISDN, and T1. Eventually they gave us DSL but the roll out was so slow and the initial installs so buggy it was mind boggling. Then one day I get a flier in the mail, try cable! Five times the speed and what do you know, the phone company suddenly cut their prices and offered deals to get people back.

Common carrier means no competition at all. As in, your area may get an upgrade AFTER all the important people get theirs first, namely those with political connections or in tony neighborhoods. The rest of us, well its like waiting for the roads to be plowed.

Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by bicknergseng on Monday February 24, 2014 @12:58PM (#7292242)
I live in San Francisco and only have one choice (AT&T Uverse). I am in a new building with fiber connections, but I'm stuck paying $150+ a month for 15MB internet and middle of the road TV. My Netflix is heavily throttled. My service hits 1000+ ms pings at least a few times an hour for minutes at a time. I often get download speeds far less than the rate I pay. I can't believe I'm saying this, but I even miss Comcast.

I honestly don't see how it could get worse with internet regulated as a utility. Imagine if my gas and electricity decided to not show up for a day.

Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by flaviusb on Monday February 24, 2014 @07:42AM (#7290444)
This is the opposite of the common carrier model. In the common carrier model, there are many companies that you can choose from as a consumer from the get go, because the network is unbundled from a single company.
Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by jtc331 on Monday February 24, 2014 @09:59AM (#7291089)
You're missing the point: the last mile network is shared across all of those companies. Ergo, the company that actually owns the last mile network has no competition on that last mile network and no incentive to upgrade that network.
Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by flaviusb on Monday February 24, 2014 @12:13PM (#7291912)
Firstly, the last mile company still has QoS agreements with the companies that buy from it, and they can plausibly choose to simply go elsewhere if the last mile company does not give them good enough QoS terms; whether that means building their own network, or simply pulling out of that area. Basically, a small group of companies can more plausibly apply joint pressure to a single company than many millions of people can, purely because of coordination costs.

Secondly, part of the common carrier model is that if the government is not convinced that the common carrier is acting in the public's best interest - for example, if they are delaying needed upgrades - then the government can simply confiscate the common carrier's assets, and sell them to a company that will actually meet its QoS and upgrade obligations, or spin the whole thing off as a SoE.

Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by emn13 on Wednesday February 26, 2014 @04:19PM (#7307927)
Sure they do: consumers will pick the best last-mile providers, because in this model, consumers actually have the power to choose.
Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by pktgen on Monday February 24, 2014 @11:29AM (#7291625)
Ideally that last mile network would be point-to-point FTTP though, eliminating this entire issue.
Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by Aqueous on Monday February 24, 2014 @12:01AM (#7289180)
There is no way in hell the aggregate interests of the telecom industry will allow broadband to be declared a common carrier.
Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by jimbokun on Monday February 24, 2014 @09:50AM (#7291037)
Unless the Internet companies (Netflix, Google, Amazon, Apple...) suddenly realize they, also, have their entire business models at stake and start lobbying just as hard as the telecom companies.

Netflix is there. The rest don't seem to realize how screwed they are, yet.

Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by digikata on Monday February 24, 2014 @11:52AM (#7291758)
Netflix is there, but what does the Comcast deal imply? Maybe Netflix's calculation is that they're big enough to sustain paying Comcast's toll, and that agreeing to pay it helps add a barrier to competitors behind them. If that's the case, then the consumers lose because they're paying higher, hidden, overhead vs what they would pay in a more competitive market. With insufficiently transparent choices for the end consumer, one big driver for efficiency disappears.
Re:Comcast’s deal with Netflix makes network neutrality obso... by jcalvinowens on Sunday February 23, 2014 @11:11PM (#7289046)
YES