I think that is roughly what the gp is saying.
Eircom split into Eircom Wholesale and Eircom.. The last mile copper and core network is managed by Eircom Wholesale, while end users subscribe to Eircom.
The wholesale company offers its services to any phone or broadband company, with published (starting..) price lists. This seems to work well.
In Europe, we also have the notion of Internet Exchanges like INEX, LINX and AMS-IX. These are non-profits, typically owned by their members, who provide switching fabric at the major datacenters for ISPs and other internet companies to exchange traffic - without any per-peer fees. You simply pay a membership fee typically based on the number and type of ports you want.
This allows even the smallest companies to directly peer with the major ISPs. INEX requires members establish BGP peering with something like "at least 80% of other members".. Again, this seems to work well.
TL;DR for the following: [citation needed]
Designating broadband service as common carrier service, enabling the FCC to issue regulations of the type defined for common carriers to broadband providers would no doubt permit the FCC to set a non-zero price floor for peering, but I'd like to see what law would require the FCC to set a non-zero price floor if it designated broadband service as common carrier service.
Common carrier means multiple things, but one of them is that it sets a floor on the price for peering agreements. This means that currently free peering will have to become paid peering, and no one wants that.
It would actually give more money to the ISPs for something they are already doing.