News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by shawabawa3 on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @11:18AM (#7264305)
The article seems to miss out a very key point: How do they seize them?

Do you knock on your door and demand your private keys? How can they do that if you've broken no laws? How do they even know you have them in the first place?

Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by andrewfong on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:46PM (#7264880)
> Do you knock on your door and demand your private keys?

Pretty much. If you're storing your bitcoin with something like Coinbase, they could also knock on Coinbase's door.

> How can they do that if you've broken no laws?

Buying stolen artwork is not a crime if you don't know it's stolen. But the government can still seize the stolen artwork and return it to its original rightful owner. The only recourse you have is to go after the person who sold you the stolen artwork -- which may not be very feasible for you to do in the case of semi-anonymous bitcoin transactions.

> How do they even know you have them in the first place?

If you use a third-party service like Coinbase, they could just ask them. If you're using your own wallet, they'd have to rely on good-old fashioned deduction -- e.g. if the previous holder of the coins has an accounting log showing payment to you in bitcoins, that's probably enough to infer that you have or did have possession. It might be enough to shift the burden of proof so that you have to show that you don't have possession of the bitcoins.

Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by AJ007 on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @03:25PM (#7265985)
If individual A steals artwork, sells it to individual B, and then uses the cash to buy a car from individual C, and individual C uses the cash to buy a house, is the only person who loses anything individual B? (Assuming individual C didn't break any money laundering regulations)

If the stolen property is BTC rather than art, there would be no reason you couldn't follow a perpetual chain of transactions after it.

Curiously, that could be viewed as a very big strength for BTC rather than a weakness. I think a lot of trouble is saved by calling BTC a programmable currency rather than an anonymous one.

Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by andrewfong on Thursday February 20, 2014 @12:24PM (#7272119)
Yes, Individual B is probably the only one hosed in that scenario.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by tlrobinson on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:55PM (#7264941)
> you have to show that you don't have possession of the bitcoins

How exactly do you prove you don't possess something?

Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by andrewfong on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @01:15PM (#7265085)
More accurately, you have to refute the evidence that's already been produced that you do possess something.

For example, if someone says "I paid tlrobinson 2 bitcoins for mowing my lawn on Sunday," you could produce evidence that you were on a business trip on Sunday and therefore couldn't be the same tlrobinson referenced in the previous statement. Or argue that the person making that statement is a liar. Or point out that 2 bitcoins is an absurd amount to pay for mowing a lawn. Etc.

Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by dllthomas on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @01:10PM (#7265055)
This isn't really any more of an issue with bitcoin than with Caymans accounts. It already leads to some messiness, but it doesn't stop them from throwing people in jail.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by garrettgrimsley on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @11:48AM (#7264491)
To use their example: You own a lawn care company and do lawn maintenance for a client in Deleware for Dr. Olivia Bolles[1]. Unbeknownst to you Dr. Bolles is a drug dealer on Silk Road. She pays you for your services in bitcoin. The bitcoin wallet that her payment is posted to is publicly linked to you or your company through your website or perhaps your payment page. It is reasonable to assume that you are the benefactor of funds that go to this address otherwise you would be exchanging a service for naught! The government raids Dr. Bolles, seizes her wallets and while going over the transactions associated with these wallets discovers your wallet. They could then order you to surrender the funds based on the "nemo dat quod non habet" that they mentioned. Someone else will have to chime in with court cases that support/contradict my reasoning because that's beyond me. [1]http://thedailyrecord.com/2013/12/13/judge-silk-road-doctor-...
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by natrius on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @11:52AM (#7264518)
You don't have to seize them. You can just declare that funds will not be accepted from any wallets that receive Bitcoin from the flagged wallet. If an entity with enough market power started flagging wallets, services would quickly build in functionality to reject funds from flagged wallets.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by gst on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:04PM (#7264586)
And how would this work in practice. Let's assume you have one "clean" Bitcoin and I have one stolen/flagged Bitcoin. I'm now sending you 0.1 Bitcoins and you don't know that those are flagged.

So how would this influence your remaining Bitcoins? If you send 0.1 Bitcoins to someone else: Would you sell the stolen Bitcoins first? Would you sell the clean Bitcoins first? Are all of your coins tainted by a given percentage?

(Yes, I know that just receiving those coins would create a separate input that you can ignore in order to avoid tainting your coins. But at some point clean and flagged input will be merged together into a single one.)

Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by eterm on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:12PM (#7264634)
You sell the clean first. You are assumed to always be holding 0.1 dirty coins, so you must keep a balance > 0.1 at all times to avoid spending the dirty coins.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by gst on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:18PM (#7264676)
So now let's assume I'm selling something on an auction site and someone pays me with coins where I assume it's likely that they are stolen (but I don't have any definite knowledge about that).

For some reason I now need to refund the buyer. Do I now first need to transfer all but 0.1 coins to somewhere else, so that I can send the remaining 0.1 coins back?

Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by Dylan16807 on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @03:20PM (#7265948)
>Do I now first need to transfer all but 0.1 coins to somewhere else, so that I can send the remaining 0.1 coins back?

You make it sound like this is a burden. It seems easy to me, as long as you track taint per-output rather than per address. Just pretend people followed best practices and used a unique address for every output.

So let's take eterm's suggestion that clean coins always come out first. So all we need to do is build a transaction with at least .1 tainted coins, put the non-refund coins as the first output, and put the .1 tainted coins as the second output. First output is an address we control, second output goes back to the person we're refunding.

That's assuming you already mixed up your coins and can't just send back the exact same transaction they sent you in the first place.

Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by eterm on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:35PM (#7264805)
Why are you dealing with money that you're assuming that is likely stolen? If they turn out blacklisted then you're out of pocket. Because bitcoin does not support refunds or chargebacks you must transfer clean money to refund them. Bitcoin has weaknesses, the way it deals with "change" and indeed the need for change is one of them. Bitcoin should have dealt with the change issue by instead of the splitting happening at the receiver end and sending back change, the splitting should have happened at the sender end so only the correct amounts were ever sent.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by yebyen on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:48PM (#7264888)
That's not really how it works. The sender does the splitting, but he has to send the change somewhere, and customarily it's sent to a new address. The receiver doesn't even have to be online, you don't get your change from them, so the only way you'd get blacklisted coins in change is if you already had some blacklisted coins in the inputs you were using to begin with.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @08:16PM (#7268100)
Can't you do two simultaneous transactions? At all times you're doing a transaction with an untransacted balance > 0.1.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by natrius on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:36PM (#7264814)
Every wallet that receives funds from the flagged wallet is tainted until they send it back to that wallet. All of the funds, not just the tainted amount.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by gst on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @01:06PM (#7265036)
This doesn't work in practice. Transactions using Bitcoin "addresses" are just one (out of many) transaction types. As far as I understand the protocol it's possible that you receive those coins via a transaction type that doesn't have an associated Bitcoin sender address.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by dllthomas on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @01:14PM (#7265079)
"Every wallet that receives funds from a tainted wallet becomes tainted" doesn't (in any way I see) conflict with the notion that there are transactions without a sender.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by gst on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @01:17PM (#7265100)
I meant the "until you send it back part". If "every wallet becomes tainted" and "you can't send it back" this would make it trivial for an attacker to taint a large number of wallets in the Bitcoin network.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by dllthomas on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @01:42PM (#7265285)
If there is no sender, how does the receiver become tainted?
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by TheLoneWolfling on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @04:49PM (#7266480)
So then anyone with tainted coins can completely lock down arbitrary wallets?
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by dllthomas on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @01:44PM (#7265298)
"[...] until they send it back to that wallet."

Or forfeit it to the feds, at which point they can mark them untainted before they auction them off.

Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @08:06PM (#7268042)
Doesn't tainting then become "assigning to the USA government"? Why should that be the case?
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by dllthomas on Thursday February 20, 2014 @07:45AM (#7270457)
It doesn't have to be, in principle. It depends what organization is doing the tainting. In practice, it is comparatively likely to be the case because tainting of this sort is likely to relate to the criminal justice system, and I don't expect the relevant portions to be privatized anytime soon. If you mean the US rather than other governments, mostly because we seem comparatively eager to enforce our laws abroad, though I expect other governments would get in on the game.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by Houshalter on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @01:15PM (#7265086)
That would be a disaster. People would immediately dump all the worthless "flagged" coins on markets and services that haven't had time to respond to the new protocol. Those people would go bankrupt overnight, possibly before they even have time to realize it's happening and shut down.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by driverdan on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:10PM (#7264621)
There is no way this kind of feature would be added to the Bitcoin protocol.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by natrius on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:14PM (#7264643)
I'm not suggesting that it'd be in the protocol. It'd be in wallets. If you send Bitcoin to my wallet from a tainted address, my client would automatically send it back to you.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by yebyen on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:51PM (#7264908)
Not every client or wallet supports ownership of addresses. You could be sending coins back to a hot wallet, where they're indistinguishable from coins that I don't own and they don't even come back to my wallet balance. You could say "not my problem" but that's adding a lot of overhead to the brain of my wallet's mixing service that we didn't have to deal with before :)
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by whyenot on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @02:35PM (#7265683)
If you buy something at Overstock.com or cash out at Coinbase or an exchange they can find you.

Related: I've met several people who are planning to use bitcoins to avoid paying taxes. I'll leave it as an exercise for the reader why that could be a very bad idea.

Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by evacuationdrill on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @03:31PM (#7266017)
At the least, isn't the IRS able to come look at your possessions to approximate your tax liability, or something along those lines?
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by wmf on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @11:30AM (#7264383)
Maybe they'd require US exchanges to seize blacklisted Bitcoin when it gets deposited.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by jackgavigan on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @11:52AM (#7264516)
Such a requirement may not be limited to US exchanges. AML provisions require that any exchange (not just those in the US) that support the conversion of Bitcoin to/from USD register with FinCEN. If they were to refuse to cooperate with US LE agencies' efforts to confiscate bitcoins that were the proceeds of crime, they could be judged to have assisted in criminal money laundering.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by gst on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:08PM (#7264611)
Many international exchanges don't really care about US AML provisions and/or about transacting in US dollars. And as long as they don't maintain US bank accounts they probably also don't care about being sued in the United States.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by jackgavigan on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:41PM (#7264846)
Given the United States' track record when it comes to pushing out the boundaries of its extraterritorial jurisdiction, it would not surprise me if such exchanges were to encounter difficulties in finding a bank that was willing to provide them with banking facilities.

Also, it would be inadvisable for the staff of such exchanges to travel to (or transit through) the United States. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Carruthers#Arrest_during_...

Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by gst on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:50PM (#7264901)
If you don't find a bank account you could always operate a P2P-style exchange like bitmarket used to: The exchange acts as an escrow for the Bitcoins, but the fiat transaction happens directly between market participants. Once the fiat arrives at the receiver the coins are released. In case there are any disagreements the exchange can ask both sides for proofs. This won't prevent 100% of fraud, but seems to have worked well for bitmarket.

The reason why those P2P-style exchanges aren't common in the United States is because it's hard to directly transfer money between two people. With SEPA transactions in Europe you can directly transfer money to any recipient, usually for free (or at a very low cost).

Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by PeterisP on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @09:06PM (#7268318)
And at that point you have perfectly traceable transactions, since the 'fiat transaction' part has personally identifiable information of both participants.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by PeterisP on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @09:04PM (#7268309)
AML laws are not US-specific - as soon as the current regulation catches up, any international exhange will either comply with their local AML laws doing the same thing, or will have trouble handling the 'real currency' part of their transactions.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by coldtea on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:24PM (#7264720)
I don't think that works well for people who are not drug barons.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by gst on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:38PM (#7264826)
Why not? Many European countries don't extradite their own citizens [1]. So you only need to comply with the local laws, which are often much less strict in terms of AML provisions. Of course you wouldn't want to do any international travel as an exchange operator who violates US law, but otherwise you're safe.

[1] Instead, they can sue you locally, even if they crime happened in another country. However, this lawsuit will be according to local laws. So if the crime is only illegal in the other country they can't sue you.

Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by PeterisP on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @09:09PM (#7268332)
From what I see there has been a great, successful push to "harmonize" AML provisions, so I believe they are at their core pretty much the same throughout the 'civilized world' and the semi-dictatorships have much stronger controls than that - so all the big economies and major currencies are affected in the same way as USA/USD.

Can you elaborate on which countries do you have in mind for "comply with the local laws, which are often much less strict in terms of AML provisions" ?

For extradition you mention Europe, but the EU AML directive is already comprehensive enough to make illegal most suggested bitcoin-for-laundering use cases; and it can be expected that if there are major loopholes found, then (continuing with their existing AML policy) EU legislation will be quickly adapted to close them.

Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by quack on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:24PM (#7264726)
This is the biggest joke since the HSBC scandal broke. Feds dont care about real criminals laundering money. They just like it as a convenient scapegoat when it involves an enemy of the state.

Also the US is not the world power anymore. They have no authority to 'flag' any currency.

Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by wehadfun on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @11:55AM (#7264531)
If people can't find stolen bitcoins how can the FBI find bitcoins from illegal activity?
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by corin_ on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:19PM (#7264683)
I can't find who stole my mobile phone, it doesn't necessarily mean the FBI couldn't (if they wanted to). Obviously this is not relevant to the technical specifications of Bitcoin, but my point is that this comparison isn't really relevant.