News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by gst on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:04PM (#7264586)
And how would this work in practice. Let's assume you have one "clean" Bitcoin and I have one stolen/flagged Bitcoin. I'm now sending you 0.1 Bitcoins and you don't know that those are flagged.

So how would this influence your remaining Bitcoins? If you send 0.1 Bitcoins to someone else: Would you sell the stolen Bitcoins first? Would you sell the clean Bitcoins first? Are all of your coins tainted by a given percentage?

(Yes, I know that just receiving those coins would create a separate input that you can ignore in order to avoid tainting your coins. But at some point clean and flagged input will be merged together into a single one.)

Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by eterm on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:12PM (#7264634)
You sell the clean first. You are assumed to always be holding 0.1 dirty coins, so you must keep a balance > 0.1 at all times to avoid spending the dirty coins.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by gst on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:18PM (#7264676)
So now let's assume I'm selling something on an auction site and someone pays me with coins where I assume it's likely that they are stolen (but I don't have any definite knowledge about that).

For some reason I now need to refund the buyer. Do I now first need to transfer all but 0.1 coins to somewhere else, so that I can send the remaining 0.1 coins back?

Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by Dylan16807 on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @03:20PM (#7265948)
>Do I now first need to transfer all but 0.1 coins to somewhere else, so that I can send the remaining 0.1 coins back?

You make it sound like this is a burden. It seems easy to me, as long as you track taint per-output rather than per address. Just pretend people followed best practices and used a unique address for every output.

So let's take eterm's suggestion that clean coins always come out first. So all we need to do is build a transaction with at least .1 tainted coins, put the non-refund coins as the first output, and put the .1 tainted coins as the second output. First output is an address we control, second output goes back to the person we're refunding.

That's assuming you already mixed up your coins and can't just send back the exact same transaction they sent you in the first place.

Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by eterm on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:35PM (#7264805)
Why are you dealing with money that you're assuming that is likely stolen? If they turn out blacklisted then you're out of pocket. Because bitcoin does not support refunds or chargebacks you must transfer clean money to refund them. Bitcoin has weaknesses, the way it deals with "change" and indeed the need for change is one of them. Bitcoin should have dealt with the change issue by instead of the splitting happening at the receiver end and sending back change, the splitting should have happened at the sender end so only the correct amounts were ever sent.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by yebyen on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:48PM (#7264888)
That's not really how it works. The sender does the splitting, but he has to send the change somewhere, and customarily it's sent to a new address. The receiver doesn't even have to be online, you don't get your change from them, so the only way you'd get blacklisted coins in change is if you already had some blacklisted coins in the inputs you were using to begin with.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @08:16PM (#7268100)
Can't you do two simultaneous transactions? At all times you're doing a transaction with an untransacted balance > 0.1.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by natrius on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @12:36PM (#7264814)
Every wallet that receives funds from the flagged wallet is tainted until they send it back to that wallet. All of the funds, not just the tainted amount.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by gst on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @01:06PM (#7265036)
This doesn't work in practice. Transactions using Bitcoin "addresses" are just one (out of many) transaction types. As far as I understand the protocol it's possible that you receive those coins via a transaction type that doesn't have an associated Bitcoin sender address.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by dllthomas on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @01:14PM (#7265079)
"Every wallet that receives funds from a tainted wallet becomes tainted" doesn't (in any way I see) conflict with the notion that there are transactions without a sender.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by gst on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @01:17PM (#7265100)
I meant the "until you send it back part". If "every wallet becomes tainted" and "you can't send it back" this would make it trivial for an attacker to taint a large number of wallets in the Bitcoin network.
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by dllthomas on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @01:42PM (#7265285)
If there is no sender, how does the receiver become tainted?
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by TheLoneWolfling on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @04:49PM (#7266480)
So then anyone with tainted coins can completely lock down arbitrary wallets?
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by dllthomas on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @01:44PM (#7265298)
"[...] until they send it back to that wallet."

Or forfeit it to the feds, at which point they can mark them untainted before they auction them off.

Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @08:06PM (#7268042)
Doesn't tainting then become "assigning to the USA government"? Why should that be the case?
Re:How Bitcoins Involved in Crime Can Be Seized by the Feds by dllthomas on Thursday February 20, 2014 @07:45AM (#7270457)
It doesn't have to be, in principle. It depends what organization is doing the tainting. In practice, it is comparatively likely to be the case because tainting of this sort is likely to relate to the criminal justice system, and I don't expect the relevant portions to be privatized anytime soon. If you mean the US rather than other governments, mostly because we seem comparatively eager to enforce our laws abroad, though I expect other governments would get in on the game.