If every merchant you patronize today accepted Bitcoin, would you rather have Bitcoin in your bank account or dollars? I'd rather have Bitcoin. They're easier to transfer, they can't be counterfeited, and their supply can't be manipulated.
If every merchant accepts Bitcoin and every consumer agrees with my logic, hyperinflation of the dollar would occur. Coinbase and its 0% transaction fees will lead to rapid adoption of Bitcoin on the merchant side. I'm less confident about the consumer side, but I see that happening as well.
I am also baffled by "they're easier to transfer" than dollars. Yes you can email BTC. But I can literally hand you dollars. No smartphone needed! And large amounts are trivially easier - I squiggle some lines on a piece of paper and hand it to you. Or if you want to stick to smartphones I can pull one out and send you dollars using one of dozens of e-payment platforms.
Interesting thesis though.
Transferring large amounts of dollars takes days. Transferring Bitcoin takes 10 minutes or so.
Transfers are slow because there is little need to transfer large amounts of money quickly, and slower transactions help address issues with fraud. If you are buying a car, or paying for a house there is little need for a fast transactions. So with BTC or USD, transferring large amounts of money will take days.
My debit card/square/venmo might have something to say about that...
You just don't notice it because they pay the miners by printing money. I'll be really interested to see what happens when they stop that and start relying on up front transaction fees to fund the network.
If 90% of the network is powered down to reduce transaction fees, that gives someone the opportunity to buy up 20% of it on the cheap and corrupt the network. Bitcoin has to use as many resources as possible to stay secure.
Right now the mining rewards being minted increase the Bitcoin supply at a rate of 11% per year. If demand for Bitcoin were constant, this would amount to 11% inflation. Demand for Bitcoin is currently increasing, so it is net deflationary, but this only lasts as long as the demand for Bitcoin is growing constantly. If you kept mining rewards high after the demand for Bitcoins had stabilized, you'd have five times the inflation of the dreaded US dollar, as you paid for your infrastructure costs through inflationary taxation.
(Which Benjamin Franklin and I actually like, but that's another issue entirely.)
[1]: http://www.economist.com/blogs/economist-explains/2013/05/ec...
So Bitcoin could be valuable in disrupting payment systems:
Step 1: Bitcoin becomes superior to traditional payment systems.
Step 2: This becomes relevant enough in the large scheme of things
that Bitcoin gets serious adoption outside of speculation.
Step 3: Traditional payment providers up their game.
Step 4: Traditional payment providers win, because their intrinsic costs are lower
(mining is inherently costly and not needed for traditional payment systems).
So - there's a buck to be made in Bitcoin, but it's implausible that Bitcoin should remain superior to more traditional systems in the long term (except for illegal purposes).If everyone adopted bitcoin, the velocity of the dollar would approach zero. Which means that inflation would go down, not up.
And yes, I would rather have my [savings] account in a hard, non-inflationary currency. On the other hand, I can only earn interest when someone is willing to take a loan in the currency and pay interest on it. And I am not about to take out a loan in a hard currency when perfectly good inflationary currencies are easily at hand. So, you're going to have a hard time finding a bank that pays interest on bitcoins. This is why "bad money drives out good", aka Gresham's law.
Sadly it is not so easy to make money this way, the forward exchange rates will cancel out any gain from the interest earned in the inflationary currency. Otherwise everyone would do this.
You can make money doing this but really you are just taking a bet on exchange rates, you can easily lose money as well if the fx goes the wrong way during your investment period.
There are very few risk free ways to make more money than investing in US Treasuries.
Assuming the interest rates are the same, I'd agree. Would they be?
I doubt they'd be the same in either nominal or real terms. But that's a side issue.
You could already do what you're talking about with gold. A bank could offer gold savings accounts that pay interest on gold loans. They don't do it. Borrowers are deflation-averse and no one wants to deal with the exchange rate fluctuations.
BTC has some legit uses (like buying unjustly banned consciousness-expanding products over the internets) but the built-in deflationary death spiral in its design pretty much ensures that it will never be a serious full-spectrum parallel currency, much less a replacement for the dollar and euro.
When Bitcoin is the primary currency, there will be interest-bearing Bitcoin deposits.
http://bitcoin.org/en/faq#wont-bitcoin-fall-in-a-deflationar...
Same goes for the borrower and deflation risk.
Edit: I guess if the deflation risk tolerance for the borrower and the inflation risk tolerance for the bank are asymmetrical, then you would just end up with being able to loan one or the other. I suspect, per Slurry's point, that it's BTC that loses here.
At this point, and in the foreseeable future? Dollars. I'm not sure where people find all this friction relating to using dollars in the real world. I have no problems whatsoever. Besides, it's all virtual currency.
As far as your theory of widespread adoption of bitcoin leading to hyperinflation of the dollar, I'm don't even begin to understand how you see that working.
It's still vulnerable to computational attacks (no matter how impractical they may be) and miner collusion.
There's no need to regulate computing capacity when you have the power to tax enough wealth to ensure that the government always has more computing capacity. It's an arms race without the nuclear winter, and with the side effects of increased pollution and rapidly advancing processing power.
There's something you're overlooking though: the dollar was backed by gold until 1971, and that's where our problems really started mounting.
Even if this is true, where is the evidence that we're in imminent danger of hyperinflation? Despite mounting public debt, U.S. inflation has remained incredibly low since the start of the financial crisis four years ago, as has the interest rate that must be paid by the government to issue new debt.
From what I can tell, we have on the one side a dollar that has endured as a value store and medium of exchange for hundreds of years, and which has proven remarkably resilient (valuable) by any objective measure throughout the worst economic implosion since the Great Depression (which the dollar also survived). On the other hand we have Bitcoin which is intriguing in many ways but which has demonstrable volatility even just in the short span of its existence. And which, as a feature, is not backed (in the hard economic sense) by any nation or bank. I mean it's cool and all but I see where Krugman is coming from.