Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by lazyjones on Thursday December 26, 2013 @11:11AM
(#6966666)
It's a good idea and apparently a slick package, but useless due to the restrictive license and binary-only distribution.
I certainly won't build and distribute mobile apps with whatever obscure (and non-removable according to ToS) "security features" Intel has decided to bundle with the runtime e.g. to comply with arbitrary requests by various rogue government agencies.
If they want us to build HTML5 apps for their own sake (Intel's, they want to fight back against native ARM binaries), they'll have to try harder. Make it Open Source and ask a lawyer who hasn't been stuck in corporate litigation and patenting stuff for several decades to write a modern license (or use the LGPL/BSD/MIT license...).
Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by xmnboy on Friday December 27, 2013 @12:14PM
(#6971501)
The license you are referring to (http://appcenter.html5tools-software.intel.com/TOS/) applies to the XDK itself, not to the apps you create with the XDK. Intel is not restricting how you choose to redistribute the apps you produce with the Intel XDK, they belong to you and you can redistribute them however you wish (in source form or binary form).
Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by cabbeer on Thursday December 26, 2013 @05:06PM
(#6968338)
Can you please explain what the restrictive licences and "binary-only distribution" are in layman's terms. I'm a front end developer this looks like a good introduction to developing and distributing mobile apps.
Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by lazyjones on Thursday December 26, 2013 @06:16PM
(#6968581)
For a complete analysis you'll have to ask a lawyer. But for me, the fact that you "may not reverse-assemble, reverse-compile, or otherwise reverse-engineer any portion of the Intel Materials provided solely in binary form" (http://appcenter.html5tools-software.intel.com/TOS/, see II.2.C) is enough of a red flag already. I'm not going to use or distribute something to my users for which I signed away my rights to examine and see what it actually does.
Furthermore, they want the right to disable access to some content somehow if they think it is illegal (i.e. they have rights to arbitrary censorship of content and apparently also some mechanism built into the runtime to enforce it). Am I going to distribute or even sell stuff to users that Intel can disable any time they like? Certainly not.
If they wanted a license that puts off developers who have plenty of choices nowdays, they succeeded.
Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by johnyzee on Thursday December 26, 2013 @06:23AM
(#6965965)
It is based on AppMobi that Intel bought some months ago. AppMobi was an alternative to PhoneGap, but it attempted to streamline the whole process of wrapping an HTML5 app into a native app, with an "IDE" (more of a GUI for the build process) and a cloud-based assembly and provisioning platform. And of course a lot of proprietary APIs for stuff like in-app payments, social integration, etc.
I tried AppMobi early on but as a developer I much prefer something open like PhoneGap, even if (or because) I have to glue the pieces together by myself. I don't really see the demographic that knows how to develop an HTML5 web application but prefers a closed black-box environment for putting together the mobile app.
The AppMobi XDK was pretty slick though. But from the announcement it seems like they pretty much tore it down and started over from scratch.
These days I hold higher hopes for real convert-to-native tools, that actually translates HTML5 (f.ex. the canvas API) to native code.
Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by phoboslab on Thursday December 26, 2013 @07:10AM
(#6966047)
AppMobi actually used Ejecta[1] for their Canvas2D rendering on iOS - which it seems also made its way into the Intel XDK[2]. I believe they have their own implementation for Canvas2D on Android, but sadly, it's all closed source.
I should really get a cross-platform effort for Ejecta going. We have CocoonJS and Intel's XDK, but afaik there's no Open Source alternative right now.
Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by notnowlewis on Thursday December 26, 2013 @07:34AM
(#6966085)
Ejecta is awesome. I remember helping out in the early days of it, fixing up some alpha and rotation bugs... it's a shame how badly intel's "accelerated" canvas performs on android. On the nexus 4, native canvas looks better and performs roughly the same.
Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by johnyzee on Thursday December 26, 2013 @12:02PM
(#6966855)
I've been praying for something like Ejecta and CocoonJS that is both cross-platform and open source. I always imagined that the canvas API should translate rather easily to native graphics mode, but it is probably not that simple.
Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by 0x0 on Thursday December 26, 2013 @09:51AM
(#6966392)
When Intel are saying they want to "promote cross-platform HTML5 app development - for all platforms, not just Intel's", I'm wondering if what they are really saying is they're not fans of the current processor-specific native apps (because they are compiled for ARM, not Intel CPUs), and they are trying to stop that avalanche before it grows into a huge pile of legacy making it impossible to compete in the mobile/phone space with a non-ARM CPU?
Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by caw on Thursday December 26, 2013 @09:27AM
(#6966325)
Kind of. They're actually footnotes (asterisks), referring to the same footnote. On this particular website it appears to be referring to the "*Trademark" link, which has the extended legalese.
In the standard Intel style (whitepapers, etc), trademarks to other companies are designated with an asterisk and a footnote to the effect of "These are trademarks from companies other than Intel. They own the rights to the name, and not us"
Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by fidotron on Thursday December 26, 2013 @01:23PM
(#6967229)
That's really because web apps are just slow.
Intel mistakenly believe that they'll have an easier time by forcing ARM to compete at full speed, which is brilliantly ignorant of history. The very first ARM outperformed contemporary x86s at computation, and just happened to be low power, it's that they've been diverted off into low power as their reason for existing for 20 years.
ARM can, and will, redefine their instruction set dramatically to suit their needs at any time, so while the x86 world is stuck with x86 the mobile world has been through several major changes to the ARM ISA since just the original iPhone.
The Intel PR has persistently been saying "but our next one" for the last few years, and each time it's gone nowhere. They are merely performing the role of a stick device makers can hit ARM with to control prices though, but seem oblivious to this.
Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by aplummer on Thursday December 26, 2013 @03:18AM
(#6965620)
After playing with it, seems like Brackets (anecdotal guess, though I'm pretty confident) wrapped with a bunch of mobile device stuff ala Ripple (does intel own ripple now?) combined with a pretty deep build system.
Could be really handy for making quick apps for conferences or hi-fi prototypes imo. Particularly the cross platform build system - seems really easy.
Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by anonyfox on Thursday December 26, 2013 @03:09AM
(#6965603)
Seems like the most advanced node-webkit [1] application so far. Great to see how node.js is used for more and more crossplatform non-web apps. Cites Atwoods law here...
Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by moondowner on Thursday December 26, 2013 @07:57AM
(#6966117)
Has anyone tried to develop node-webkit apps with XDK? I'm using IDEA at the moment with few workarounds, but if this works better I'll make the switch.
Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by xmnboy on Friday December 27, 2013 @12:27PM
(#6971566)
You cannot use the XDK to develop node-webkit apps. The XDK itself is a node-webkit app, but you use it to develop HTML5 hybrid apps for mobile devices.
Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by simplehuman on Thursday December 26, 2013 @01:01PM
(#6967124)
Am I the only one who finds the UI is horribly ugly? The tabs make no sense. Why is it all hogging the ide space when most of the things are rarely used (services, build) - why not put them in the menu?
Products likes these are what give HTML5 a bad name.
Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by jbeja on Thursday December 26, 2013 @02:44PM
(#6967669)
Yeah is ugly and dated and the users experience is not there, i don't know why a big company like Intel doesn't know that the first layer of conversion is the design. Make thing pretty and pleasant to use before launch!.
Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by marknadal on Thursday December 26, 2013 @04:06AM
(#6965701)
Really great engine, I highly recommend it. I'm even looking for somebody who would know how to write native bridge plugins for it (or convert existing phonegap ones) - I just want alarm clock controls that actually work on iOS (android is easy). Anybody?
Seems fairly permissive, but has provisions to do with de-compiling anything distributed in binary form so it looks fairly mixed.
This may though just be due to use of some legacy, licensed library somewhere rather than deliberately restrictive licensing. I haven't looked closely at what comes with XDK so I'm not sure what components are used.
Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by xmnboy on Friday December 27, 2013 @12:29PM
(#6971577)
The username and password is needed to manage your cloud account; a backend server that is used for build services and to manage the wireless test and debug features. If you are not connected to the Internet when you start the XDK it will still function, but you will, obviously, not be able to use those features that require access to the cloud services to function.
Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by malkia on Thursday December 26, 2013 @07:54PM
(#6968875)
I got it running on my HP pavillion Chromebook 14 (stable) in developer mode using croutonized debian jessie (64-bit). It works but I'm not exactly sure what I'm going to do with it :)
Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by xmnboy on Friday December 27, 2013 @03:47PM
(#6972551)
The XDK itself is available for Windows, OS X and Linux. When you go to the download page (http://xdk-software.intel.com/) it detects the OS you are using and provides you with the appropriate download. At the bottom of the download page are links to download the XDK for a "non-detected" system.
The XDK operates identically on all three platforms, one of the reasons for using node-webkit to create the app.
Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by michaelmior on Friday December 27, 2013 @04:45PM
(#6972767)
Interesting. I just assumed since it seems to have detected that my Linux machine is running Windows. The fact that they were using node-webkit did make me surprised that it appeared to be platform-specific.
Re:Intel XDK: An HTML5 development IDE
by michaelmior on Friday December 27, 2013 @10:47AM
(#6971022)
While there are certainly a lot of developers using Windows, I'm skeptical that it's as high as 95% given the number of developers using Mac OS these days.
I certainly won't build and distribute mobile apps with whatever obscure (and non-removable according to ToS) "security features" Intel has decided to bundle with the runtime e.g. to comply with arbitrary requests by various rogue government agencies.
If they want us to build HTML5 apps for their own sake (Intel's, they want to fight back against native ARM binaries), they'll have to try harder. Make it Open Source and ask a lawyer who hasn't been stuck in corporate litigation and patenting stuff for several decades to write a modern license (or use the LGPL/BSD/MIT license...).
How will the ToS hinder me from doing so?
Furthermore, they want the right to disable access to some content somehow if they think it is illegal (i.e. they have rights to arbitrary censorship of content and apparently also some mechanism built into the runtime to enforce it). Am I going to distribute or even sell stuff to users that Intel can disable any time they like? Certainly not.
If they wanted a license that puts off developers who have plenty of choices nowdays, they succeeded.
I tried AppMobi early on but as a developer I much prefer something open like PhoneGap, even if (or because) I have to glue the pieces together by myself. I don't really see the demographic that knows how to develop an HTML5 web application but prefers a closed black-box environment for putting together the mobile app.
The AppMobi XDK was pretty slick though. But from the announcement it seems like they pretty much tore it down and started over from scratch.
These days I hold higher hopes for real convert-to-native tools, that actually translates HTML5 (f.ex. the canvas API) to native code.
I should really get a cross-platform effort for Ejecta going. We have CocoonJS and Intel's XDK, but afaik there's no Open Source alternative right now.
[1] http://impactjs.com/ejecta
[2] http://www.html5dev-software.intel.com/amdocs/readmes/ios.ap...
How selfless of them ;)
In the standard Intel style (whitepapers, etc), trademarks to other companies are designated with an asterisk and a footnote to the effect of "These are trademarks from companies other than Intel. They own the rights to the name, and not us"
Intel mistakenly believe that they'll have an easier time by forcing ARM to compete at full speed, which is brilliantly ignorant of history. The very first ARM outperformed contemporary x86s at computation, and just happened to be low power, it's that they've been diverted off into low power as their reason for existing for 20 years.
ARM can, and will, redefine their instruction set dramatically to suit their needs at any time, so while the x86 world is stuck with x86 the mobile world has been through several major changes to the ARM ISA since just the original iPhone.
The Intel PR has persistently been saying "but our next one" for the last few years, and each time it's gone nowhere. They are merely performing the role of a stick device makers can hit ARM with to control prices though, but seem oblivious to this.
Could be really handy for making quick apps for conferences or hi-fi prototypes imo. Particularly the cross platform build system - seems really easy.
[1] https://github.com/rogerwang/node-webkit
Products likes these are what give HTML5 a bad name.
Seems fairly permissive, but has provisions to do with de-compiling anything distributed in binary form so it looks fairly mixed.
This may though just be due to use of some legacy, licensed library somewhere rather than deliberately restrictive licensing. I haven't looked closely at what comes with XDK so I'm not sure what components are used.
Intel, I won't be using it for my money making business. This corporate license thing is so 1990's.
Get with GPL alfaro. You will create way more wealth for the planet that way.
The XDK operates identically on all three platforms, one of the reasons for using node-webkit to create the app.