News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by pjscott on Saturday December 21, 2013 @10:07PM (#6949166)
There's a lesson here. I genuinely don't mean to sound smug, but -- remember how confident the Telegram guys were? Remember how sure they were that their protocol would be able to resist the eavesdropping efforts of the NSA and whatever other nefarious interlopers may come along? Remember how they said they'd been working on it for years, and presumably expected for it to last many more years?

Remember how that was, like, five days ago?

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by onedev on Saturday December 21, 2013 @10:14PM (#6949173)
Never forget.

RIP Telegram (2013-2013).

This whole thing has been interesting to follow because it seems this same thing happens every time someone make macho Crypto-claims. From seeing how confident the Telegram team was to reading all the detractors who were so ready to criticize. It's an interesting dynamic in the Crypto community.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by yatsyk on Sunday December 22, 2013 @02:56AM (#6949710)
Hate tone discussion makes me sad.

Telegram is very young project and it has bugs for sure. Some guy found potential issue in protocol and developers committed to fix it soon. There is no information that any messages were revealed due to this bug but Telegram should go away and developers should do something else.

Whatsapp is less secure then Telegram but I have not seed “Whatsapp RIP” messages. Not so hard to save videos in snapchat but no one propose to close the application. About a year ago YAML vulnerability was found but no one proposed dhh to stop development and focus on race driver career.

I think that we need more competition for TextSecure.

Terms of bug bounty are very hard to satisfy even with bad protocol but Durov seems decided to play safe with such amount of money. Guy that found problem in MTproto doesn’t win money according to conditions of the bug bounty because message is not decrypted.

Disclaimer: I don’t have any affiliation with telegram besides living in the same city as telegram developers.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by sillysaurus2 on Sunday December 22, 2013 @03:13AM (#6949738)
You must not have followed Telegram much. From the beginning they've done nothing but pretend their protocol is absolutely secure ("military-grade encryption", "world's most secure protocol", etc) and rejected any attempt from the crypto community to help them fix problems before they endanger people.

So, let's put it this way: Was it ok of them to lie through their teeth to users? If so, then that's a sad state of marketing. If not, then what are you proposing here?

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by yatsyk on Sunday December 22, 2013 @04:38AM (#6949869)
I’m not security expert, but I believe that:

- military-grade encryption – true

- world's most secure protocol – I’d consider this statement as false, I don’t know what they mean by most secure and what protocols were considered. May be messengers available at app store, better to ask them

Why do you think that they “rejected any attempt from the crypto community to help them”, especially after bug bounty proposition?

Why do you think that they lie more then TextSecure advocates? Each of these messengers is safe to passive listening. But unsecure to similar degree if user downloads them from app store and runs on hardware and software that could be easily patched. Current implementation of telegram api is prone to MiM attack but I would not consider TextSecure completely safe app and that every other app should be thrown out.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by sillysaurus2 on Sunday December 22, 2013 @04:55AM (#6949889)
Why do you think that they “rejected any attempt from the crypto community to help them”, especially after bug bounty proposition?

I've written about this pretty extensively: https://www.hnsearch.com/search#request/all&q=by%3Asillysaur...

It's an interesting contrast in cultures that you phrase it like "Why do you think Telegram lies more than TextSecure advocates?" .... As far as I'm aware, TextSecure advocates haven't lied at all. TextSecure's interest is in security, whereas Telegram's interest seems to be in money and power.

Current implementation of telegram api is prone to MiM attack but I would not consider TextSecure completely safe app

I just don't know what to say to this. Telegram has been proven insecure, TextSecure hasn't. Telegram isn't designed by cryptographers, TextSecure is. There is absolutely every reason to assume Telegram is broken.

Each of these messengers is safe to passive listening.

This is mistaken because Telegram has been proven vulnerable to MITM attacks. Even after they patch this latest security problem, it would be very unwise to trust them.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by DanBC on Sunday December 22, 2013 @05:16AM (#6949921)
> Current implementation of telegram api is prone to MiM attack but I would not consider TextSecure completely safe app

> I just don't know what to say to this. Telegram has been proven insecure, TextSecure hasn't. Telegram isn't designed by cryptographers, TextSecure is. There is absolutely every reason to assume Telegram is broken.

Textsecure is designed by cryptographers, and hasn't been broken yet, but that doesn't mean that it is secure. People need to risk assess when they're using any software.

> If you want to be secure from the NSA, use TextSecure [...]. It's really that simple.

That claim is far too confidant! If you want to be secure from NSA you need to do many things - have a look at the specifications for buildings that handle secret documents for example, as well as just using a piece of well designed but relatively untested software.

Most people do not have nearly enough operational discipline to withstand investigation by well funded government agencies. Merely using this software is not enough.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by sillysaurus2 on Sunday December 22, 2013 @05:17AM (#6949926)
> If you want to be secure from the NSA, use TextSecure [...]. It's really that simple.

That claim is far too confidant! If you want to be secure from NSA you need to do many things - have a look at the specifications for buildings that handle secret documents for example, as well as just using a piece of well designed but relatively untested software.

That's why I removed it 15 seconds after I wrote it. But perhaps it could be downgraded to "if you want to live in a world where it's very difficult for governments to vacuum up all your data by default, then use TextSecure, because it's the first step towards that." Telegram offers no such protection since it's vulnerable to MITM attacks (even after they fix this one).

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by Twirrim on Sunday December 22, 2013 @06:52AM (#6950065)
If you rely on a single secure (for certain values of the word 'secure') messaging system or protocol you're absolutely insane. You'd want to be splitting your communication across multiple communication sources, with none of them ever seeing enough data to compromise whatever it is you're worried about. Deep and computationally expensive is great; deep, computationally expensive and broad is better. If one form (e.g. Telegraph) falls they've not got the full message, and they've still got a lot more work to do to get the whole thing.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by yatsyk on Sunday December 22, 2013 @06:30AM (#6950028)
I've not found any attempts to help them apart from this bug report.

>TextSecure's interest is in security, whereas Telegram's interest seems to be in money and power

I can't read minds or even their messenger logs so I can't comment what is their interest but I'd be interested to know why you think so

> TextSecure completely safe app

Just wrong. How could you call something "completely safe" or bug free?

>Each of these messengers is safe to passive listening >This is mistaken because Telegram has been proven vulnerable to MITM attacks

How Telegram is prone to passive listening?

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by biafra on Sunday December 22, 2013 @06:57AM (#6950079)
>> TextSecure completely safe app

> Just wrong. How could you call something "completely safe" or bug free?

Where did he say that "TextSecure [was a] completely safe app"?

Why are you misrepresenting his words?

He said TextSecure was not proven insecure (As was Telegram). That does not mean or imply that it is safe or secure.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by sillysaurus2 on Sunday December 22, 2013 @06:41AM (#6950042)
Telegram seems to be interested in money and power because they've turned down offers from Moxie (the creator of TextSecure and a well-known cryptographer) to join forces. There's no reason to do that unless they were interested in money or power more than security.

I didn't say TextSecure is completely safe. I said Telegram has been demonstrated to be broken.

Telegram is prone to passive listening because their design doesn't prevent it. There's nothing stopping someone from MITM'ing every Telegram secret chat when it's first initiated. It's in the design.

Their contest means nothing, because due to the way the contest is designed, it's impossible to MITM or other side channel attacks like timing attacks. These are the real attack vectors, yet the format of the contest prevents anyone from employing them.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by danabramov on Sunday December 22, 2013 @07:20AM (#6950119)
>Telegram seems to be interested in money and power because they've turned down offers from Moxie (the creator of TextSecure and a well-known cryptographer) to join forces.

Is there a cause-effect relationship I'm missing here?

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by yatsyk on Sunday December 22, 2013 @07:12AM (#6950108)
> I didn't say TextSecure is completely safe.

Yes you do. "TextSecure completely safe app" was copied from your message before you or someone else edited it. I've not typed it but copied exact phrase from your message.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by sillysaurus2 on Sunday December 22, 2013 @07:24AM (#6950124)
You copied it from your own message, not mine. http://i.imgur.com/pxMVDwA.png
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by garethadams on Sunday December 22, 2013 @08:21AM (#6950220)
The best part was when he copied it from your quoting of his message, but removed the "not" that came before it
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by jessedhillon on Sunday December 22, 2013 @04:53PM (#6951939)
You seem to be missing the larger point. Nobody is proposing that secure messaging apps should not exist. Everyone is better when more people try, iterate and fail (then recover and fix) to create secure messaging solutions.

What's unsafe and unproductive is when bozos jump in the pool, apparently ignorant or otherwise misrepresentative of the reality of how difficult it is to create a correct solution -- and confidently declare their implementations to be trustable.

If the messaging on Telegram had been, the world needs a secure messaging solution and we're committed to building it starting with this thing which we think is pretty good for XYZ, nobody would be objecting. Instead, these guys presented themselves as having solved a problem which is known to be difficult, and moreover using an unlikely method.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by eps on Sunday December 22, 2013 @03:22AM (#6949752)
Hey, you forgot to plug TextSecure.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by DanBC on Sunday December 22, 2013 @04:30AM (#6949854)
> Whatsapp is less secure then Telegram

Whatsapp never claimed to keep your chat secure. Telegram did. Many people offered gentle advice to Telegram, and they ignored it.

Maybe it's a cultural thing? Not just domains-of-expertise (mathematicians going into crypto) but international?

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by yatsyk on Sunday December 22, 2013 @04:58AM (#6949894)
Snapchat creators claim (at least imply) that messages could not be saved which is untrue.

Most advices to telegram developers at previous HN discussion were to stop doing crypto and do something else. I would not consider them as “gentle advices”. The only help from the community to their application is the bug report x7mz user from habrahabr site.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by girvo on Sunday December 22, 2013 @06:10AM (#6950000)
Crypto is life and death. I have spent a lot of years learning it as a hobby... Its a dangerous field to play in. It's super complex, and all it takes is one tiny mistake anywhere in the program (be it at the protocol level or implementation) and then bam: game over. So, when you release something, you are nervous about it. Telegram wasn't, and as it turns out, they should have been. That is bad.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by chmike on Sunday December 22, 2013 @03:24AM (#6949756)
Thank you yatsyk, I share your opinion. The app name is really great. I hope they fix it and come back with a stronger app.

I would suggest they hire security consultats to check the security in a first stage. Review by third parties is the best method to avoid things we overlooked. The prize shoud be for after all these consultancy options have been exhausted.

As a side node I see there is still a lot of room to improve automatic translation. It's difficult to understand in some places.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by girvo on Sunday December 22, 2013 @06:15AM (#6950009)
Everyone who has been criticising Telegram would actually love for them to do what you've suggested. We want good, secure encrypted messaging. Telegram is not it, and people are worried, as their actions so far smack far too much of a project that ignores best practices...

In the crypto world, projects like Telegram have popped up over and over again. A new protocol, designed by non cryptographers, that turns out to be heavily insecure. I wish that wasn't the case, but that is why people have reacted the way that we have. This is literally life and death, so it pays to be cautious.

I hope Telegram learn from all this, and go and get audited and tested by reputable experts. Then, fix all the issues raised. Then release their apps to the public, when they are proven secure. Until that time I personally will not trust their application.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by danabramov on Sunday December 22, 2013 @06:36AM (#6950037)
>Terms of bug bounty are very hard to satisfy even with bad protocol but Durov seems decided to play safe with such amount of money. Guy that found problem in MTproto doesn’t win money according to conditions of the bug bounty because message is not decrypted.

The guy gets $100 000:

https://vk.com/wall-52630202_7858

You may want to check before you post.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by yatsyk on Sunday December 22, 2013 @06:49AM (#6950059)
At first my statement is still valid even after Durov decided to pay for bug report. This bug report has no connection with extracting plain message I've written.

Apart from that I can't check Durov's posts that from the future. My post was written before Durov's announcement.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by danabramov on Sunday December 22, 2013 @07:25AM (#6950126)
Technically you're right. I thought that “decided” wasn't the right word to use before you give him a chance to decide. In other words, I read your post as conveying the idea that Pavel actively dismissed the bug report as unworthy of rewarding, when in fact the opposite was true. Perhaps I misread your post being a non-native English speaker. Apologies for that.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by yatsyk on Sunday December 22, 2013 @08:20AM (#6950218)
Sorry if I have not been clear, I am non-native speaker too.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by makomk on Sunday December 22, 2013 @07:01AM (#6950087)
It's impossible to tell whether any messages were revealed due to this bug - that's what makes it so nasty. Users would have had the same level of security if Telegram had no end to end encryption whatsoever and simply promised they wouldn't log or read the messages they had access to; it's seriously that broken. (Worse, there's a good chance this is an intentional backdoor since the way they combine the nonce and Diffie-Hellman result is incredibly fishy.)
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by girvo on Sunday December 22, 2013 @06:06AM (#6949994)
Whatsapp doesn't say that it's the most secure messaging app in the world. Telegram did. And they were wrong.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by zobzu on Sunday December 22, 2013 @06:30AM (#6950029)
you don't go tell you got the best thing in the world while its just another random thing that doesn't do what you say - its just for fame/ego/money - without getting hateful feedback.

And guess what, hate isn't always wrong.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by hawkharris on Saturday December 21, 2013 @10:36PM (#6949223)
RIP Telegram (2013-2013) would make an interesting T-shirt. No one except a few cryptography buffs might understand it, but it would be a funny way to start conversations about information security.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by flux_w42 on Sunday December 22, 2013 @03:29AM (#6949760)
Would indeed be interesting to get to know some other cryptography-interetsted people on the bus, metro and other public places, so here you go: http://teespring.com/riptelegram
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by hawkharris on Sunday December 22, 2013 @04:47PM (#6951913)
Haha. I love it!
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by jlas on Sunday December 22, 2013 @06:40AM (#6950040)
HN readers might also understand it.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by paveldurov on Sunday December 22, 2013 @04:10AM (#6949818)
By that logic, Linux, Chrome, Android are RIP at least a hundred times.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by golergka on Sunday December 22, 2013 @11:15AM (#6950658)
While I'm not saying that Telegram "is RIP" (whatever it means in this thread), Linux, Chrome and Android don't have crypto as their main killer feature.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by notastartup on Saturday December 21, 2013 @10:43PM (#6949241)

    RIP Telegram (2013-2013).
omg made me lol super hard
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by GigabyteCoin on Sunday December 22, 2013 @01:33AM (#6949570)
I see you've only been here for 33 days so I'll lend you a hand.

This is HN, and we don't make posts like that.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by aaronbrethorst on Sunday December 22, 2013 @02:07AM (#6949624)
Counterexamples:

1) Every Bitcoin thread

2) Every NSA/Snowden thread

Source (cough): I've been around for 6.3 years, am in the top 40 users in terms of net karma, and am actually very frustrated with the unfortunate turn the community has taken in the past 12-18 months. And am considering leaving, which makes me sad.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by Semiapies on Sunday December 22, 2013 @02:39AM (#6949684)
I've only been here slightly under five years, but I've lost track of how many people have made "unfortunate turn"/"this place is going downhill all of a sudden"/"Oh no, the proles have discovered the site" complaints over those years.

That behavior certainly doesn't add anything to the site.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by aaronbrethorst on Sunday December 22, 2013 @02:47AM (#6949694)
It's not all of a sudden. It's been the past couple years
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by Crito on Sunday December 22, 2013 @02:09AM (#6949627)
Not sure what either of those two topics has to do with this thread..
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by saraid216 on Sunday December 22, 2013 @02:32AM (#6949676)
There is an unstated willingness to have content-less congratulatory posts on threads of those two topics. Usually puffed up with a few "look how smart I am" sentences.

That said, I'm pretty sure my highest karma (~50) comment was a joke about Tau Day back in 2008. Soooooooo.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by aaronbrethorst on Sunday December 22, 2013 @02:48AM (#6949695)
My highest scored comment ever was a one line throwaway at 250 or so. So I hear you.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by aaronbrethorst on Sunday December 22, 2013 @02:10AM (#6949630)
Absolutely nothing, so downvote away. I'm just expressing my overall frustration with this board.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by kordless on Sunday December 22, 2013 @02:20AM (#6949654)
I think it would be sad if you left.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by aaronbrethorst on Sunday December 22, 2013 @02:23AM (#6949660)
thank you. i'd be very sad if i left, too.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by sillysaurus2 on Sunday December 22, 2013 @02:30AM (#6949672)
I, too, would be sad. Why do you want to leave?
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by aaronbrethorst on Sunday December 22, 2013 @02:56AM (#6949711)
For the two reasons I mentioned in my OP. Thanks, too. It's very nice to hear.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by nilkn on Sunday December 22, 2013 @11:24AM (#6950688)
I think it's going to become more necessary to moderate through downvotes. I've almost never downvoted anybody on HN ever, especially not in comparison to reddit where downvoting is extremely rampant, but I think, sadly, the times might be changing.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by GigabyteCoin on Sunday December 22, 2013 @02:14AM (#6949640)
Maybe they need to turn down the account-ghosting requirements a few notches?
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by aaronbrethorst on Sunday December 22, 2013 @02:15AM (#6949644)
I'm not actually familiar with that one. Clue me in?
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by GigabyteCoin on Sunday December 22, 2013 @02:25AM (#6949666)
Well chances are that the OP I responded to (I can't even see his name well enough to repeat it he's so faded now) will have his account ghosted if he keeps this up. One too many mega-downvote-comments by a new user and you end up being ghosted. Where you still think you're posting to HN, and you are, but nobody else can read it.

All I was saying is perhaps if pg et all decreased whatever threshold they have set for account ghosting, that we may see less of these pointless comments in the future.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by SwellJoe on Sunday December 22, 2013 @03:34AM (#6949771)
It is not automatic, as far as I know. It requires human intervention for someone to be hellbanned, or "ghosted". It isn't very systematic, and I've seen people hellbanned who probably didn't deserve it (and it usually does get fixed when that happens).
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by GigabyteCoin on Sunday December 22, 2013 @08:52PM (#6952658)
Perhaps it would make sense to automatically hellban possibly problematic posters and then hand review those hellbans later. Worst case scenario is a good posters posts aren't seen for a short period of time.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by yareally on Sunday December 22, 2013 @02:27AM (#6949668)
They're referring to "hellbanning"
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by jimmytucson on Sunday December 22, 2013 @12:55AM (#6949518)
Did you write the encryption algorithm? Did you have the balls to put 200 grand on the table for anyone who could break it? Did you rise to the challenge and claim the cash?

No, you just stood on the sideline and waited for somebody to fail so you could come down off your branch and peck at the corpse.

Indeed, there is a lesson here. Don't expect anybody to pat you on the back when you put it all on black and win. Because, sure as shit, they'll be there to kick it in your face when you lose.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by thom on Sunday December 22, 2013 @01:05AM (#6949531)
Are you suffering from testosterone poisoning or something?
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by pvnick on Sunday December 22, 2013 @01:12AM (#6949537)
Why would you post such an inane one-liner like that? Jimmytucson made a very good point, which is that the very intelligent Telegram authors tried really hard to make a solid product, made a huge gamble that didn't quite pay off like they wanted, and that all we see now are the smug, told-you-so vultures swooping in to pat themselves on the back for being oh so much smarter than the stupid crypto guys.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by daeken on Sunday December 22, 2013 @01:24AM (#6949554)
The problem is that if the authors had actually consulted crypto guys, none of this would have happened. Their lack of security shouldn't be excused.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by GigabyteCoin on Sunday December 22, 2013 @01:38AM (#6949582)
The author of the hack himself declares at the very bottom of the article: "An expert in cryptography [I] am not, please correct [me] if I'm wrong."

How embarassing for telegram if what he says is true.

This excerpt was taken from the google translate version of the article.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by jalada on Sunday December 22, 2013 @07:05AM (#6950092)
Yeah you're right, the 'crypto guys' would've probably just said "Don't even try it because you'll kill people and even we wouldn't want to try and do it".

Crypto is hard to get right, that doesn't mean anyone shouldn't even bother trying.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by jbri on Sunday December 22, 2013 @07:24AM (#6950122)
If you want to build new crypto, people would be absolutely happy for you to design and present a new cryptographic scheme - hopefully with some advantages over existing ones. People will analyze it, tell you where the weaknesses are, and if they're not critical flaws you can fix them and come out stronger - and if they are critical flaws, you know your scheme is broken before it's been used for anything important.

Likewise, building a hot new secure messaging app with existing well-analyzed, battle-tested cryptographic schemes is generally going to be welcomed.

If you try to do both at once, you're building your application on shaky, untested cryptographical foundations. Cryptographers would similarly probably warn you not to base your application on a new cipher someone else announced at a cryptography conference last week - give it a bit of time for others to analyze it and spot any flaws it might have before you entrust anything sensitive to it.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by Morgawr on Sunday December 22, 2013 @08:05AM (#6950184)
You're welcome "try" crypto, like everybody else is. Just don't go market your product as "the most secure" encryption ever when you don't even bother to put it to the test beforehand and get it reviewed by actual experts.

I could go and try to play around with real time systems for flying planes, it still wouldn't make sense for me to sell you the "safest" plane in the world without going through the proper steps to get such system certified beforehand.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by ics on Sunday December 22, 2013 @02:13AM (#6949638)
The reason for these comments is because you're exactly right– they are gambling. Putting $200k on the line in the hopes of winning mindshare, reputation, etc. Of course if you lose, you'll lose all of that and your money. I'm really happy that more people are getting into crypto and not browbeating themselves out of creating new stuff because it's necessary for any field to grow. These negative responses are also necessary so that those people stop trying to raise their own victory flags prematurely, making it even harder for outsiders to be appreciated for their work.

Note: This is not so much in response to thom's comment, but rather the criticism of jimmytucson's comment (which actually has some substance).

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by chmike on Sunday December 22, 2013 @03:40AM (#6949779)
I'm not sure they were gambling. My feeling is ghat they were victim of the bias of self judgment regarding the security of the protocol they designed.

They overlooked some security weakness and didn't see it. They didn't do it on purpose like the NSA. In their eyes, the protocol was perfectly secure and most of it is of course.

The only way to avoid this self judgment bias is to use review by other people.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by ahomescu1 on Sunday December 22, 2013 @04:53AM (#6949885)
> In their eyes, the protocol was perfectly secure and most of it is of course.

That there is exactly the problem. There is no reason to believe the protocol is secure, and when looking at crypto you start from the assumption that it's "maybe broken", not "perfectly secure". Assuming that some new crypto is secure is hubris.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by makomk on Sunday December 22, 2013 @06:01AM (#6949990)
Actually, this security hole is almost exactly what you'd expect well-done deliberate sabotage of the protocol to look like - it's a small, easy to miss and just about plausibly deniable modification of a standard crypto primitive that totally destroys its security. (Though it's a bit weak in the area of plausible deniablity - why use xor rather than some more sensible key derivation function?)
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by danabramov on Sunday December 22, 2013 @07:33AM (#6950135)
Actually, I'm pretty sure they weren't gambling at all.

Pavel previously set up contests with monetary rewards about half the same value for developing a mobile VK app for iOS, Android and WP.

It's not a gamble—it is really an expensive way to find holes. What I don't understand is why they don't hire a crypto consultant instead.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by phaus on Sunday December 22, 2013 @03:46AM (#6949788)
The problem is, people who know better told them they were in over their heads and gave them some constructive criticism. Sure moxie can sound condescending, but he was right about telegram.

Telegram's response was basically, "LOL. We know better cuz' we got binders full of mathematicians and I'm not listening unless you win our rigged contest designed purposefully to instill a false sense of security in our customers."

Cryptographic software isn't developed the same way as ordinary software. A normal program is launched with tons of bugs and gets fixed over the course of years. Custom crypto solutions should not be delivered to customers in a similar state without explicitly telling them that it hasn't been proven secure.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by gohrt on Sunday December 22, 2013 @01:39AM (#6949583)
> stupid crypto guys.

Because it is dangerous to everyone when non-crypto guys call themselves crypto guys.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by XorNot on Sunday December 22, 2013 @01:28AM (#6949557)
No one cares that you tried really hard before failing, doubly so with security products.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by gohrt on Sunday December 22, 2013 @01:44AM (#6949590)
This comment seems to harshly dismiss failures, but that's not the heart of the issue.

Failure is celebrated -- if you make an effort, and try, and you fail, and you learn, and you share what you learned, people care.

But when you (Telegram, not you, XorNot) have a bad idea, and people smarter than you patiently explain why its broken, and you try to buffalo and bluster and bullshit past them, and your product's entire purpose is to provide a security, then your product is worse than a buggy tool; it's worse than not using the product at all. It's the modern-day equivalent of patent-medicine snake oil, and it hurts people.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by rimantas on Sunday December 22, 2013 @09:10AM (#6950329)
No, the exact problem is that Telegram guys did not try really hard, and did not listen to crypto experts. There are no "stupid crypto guys": there are smart Telegram guys who are not crypto guys and there are smart crypto guys who told why Telegram's solution if lame. Alas, smart guys from Telegram probably considered themselves too smart to listen. That's why they should fall: security is not the field where each lame effort should be cheered and encouraged just for the sake of it.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by saraid216 on Sunday December 22, 2013 @02:41AM (#6949685)
jimmytucson's point is valid in the case of business risks.

What you have here is homeopathy.

Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by thom on Sunday December 22, 2013 @06:51AM (#6950064)
I don't think the response to catastrophic hubris should be back-slapping, crotch-grabbing praise.
Re:Telegram protocol defeated. Authors are going to modify c... by Nursie on Sunday December 22, 2013 @08:32AM (#6950236)
I didn't write the algorithm, and neither did they, that would have been another bad move on their part. They used public, known algorithms and did it wrong.

They also didn't put 200k on the table for anyone that could break it. They put 200k on the table for anyone that could break it in a very specific way that proves nothing.

They used a combo of known bad and unproven stuff in weird ways and then claimed it was the best thing ever, which is just crazy.