Re:JP Morgan files for anonymous online payment system
by nh on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @04:25PM
(#6883824)
I would think BBC would do some fact checking. I posted this comment in another blogger's article. [1]
"The author's entire premise is off. The recent filing is a continuation of an application filed on Feb 3, 2000 (see patent 6,609,113). So, Chase wasnt taking a 'swipe' at Bitcoin because the original application was filed 13 years ago."
Re:JP Morgan files for anonymous online payment system
by jasonwatkinspdx on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @08:33PM
(#6885314)
Patent applications filed before the end of 2000 were not published. You can in effect file a continuation as many times as you like, and rewrite the patent substantially as you do. This leads to a tactic called submarine-ing, where you keep filing continuations on a patent that is repeatedly rejected for being overly broad. Then once a concrete target appears on the horizon, you narrow the patent to cover it before prior art, etc is well established.
It's no longer possible to do this with patent applications filed after the end of 2000 due to reform. The period the patent is in force no longer shifts forward with the continuations. But previous applications were grandfathered in.
Re:JP Morgan files for anonymous online payment system
by ripberge on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:39PM
(#6884344)
The author's premise is not off because it's a continuation of an existing patent. My company does the same thing because its much easier to get a continuation through the patent office than a whole new patent (which will take several years). Shockingly the continuation doesn't even have to be that closely related to the original patent in my experience. So if we have an idea even remotely related we just do a continuation.
Re:JP Morgan files for anonymous online payment system
by aklein on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:11PM
(#6884150)
Bitcoin is continually referred to as "anonymous" in the press, but it is just the opposite [1]. Maybe confusion over what cryptographically secure identification is? Some simple network analysis on the public ledger can reveal a whole lot of "identifying" info ...
Re:JP Morgan files for anonymous online payment system
by mrobot on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @03:04AM
(#6886496)
Owning anonymity is an attack on privacy. It means if i want to set up a system where people pay for things without being tracked i have to pay the guys who are tracking all purchases.
Theoretical full ownership of all anonymous payment processes means consumers cannot own their own behaviors without paying a tax on doing so.
If i can hold on to my anonymity i can actually own and even sell my own behaviors. As one example, I could prove to someone that a bitcoin wallet was my own.
Re:JP Morgan files for anonymous online payment system
by wbl on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @01:10AM
(#6886189)
Can people read? The patent claims are very distinct from Bitcoin: claim 1 requires 2 institutions with customers at each. Bitcoin has no such institutions.
Re:JP Morgan files for anonymous online payment system
by newsmaster on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @04:46AM
(#6886772)
Call me paranoid but sounds like they're trying to stop institutions adopting bitcoins as payment to each other otherwise they'll sue? What's the definition of institution anyway? If it's got customers then isn't it the same as a company/business?
"The author's entire premise is off. The recent filing is a continuation of an application filed on Feb 3, 2000 (see patent 6,609,113). So, Chase wasnt taking a 'swipe' at Bitcoin because the original application was filed 13 years ago."
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6878442
It's no longer possible to do this with patent applications filed after the end of 2000 due to reform. The period the patent is in force no longer shifts forward with the continuations. But previous applications were grandfathered in.
[1] http://bitcoin.org/en/faq#is-bitcoin-anonymous
http://letstalkbitcoin.com/jpmorgan-chase-building-bitcoin-k...
Theoretical full ownership of all anonymous payment processes means consumers cannot own their own behaviors without paying a tax on doing so.
If i can hold on to my anonymity i can actually own and even sell my own behaviors. As one example, I could prove to someone that a bitcoin wallet was my own.