News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @04:07PM (#6692404)
One thing that space exploration detractors seem to have a difficult thing comprehending is exactly what happens to money spent on a space program. Seemingly, they are under the delusion that all that money gets stuffed into a rocket and blasted into space, never to be seen again.

Of course the material cost of the rocket stages and probes/satellites is quite small, the vast majority of money spent on space exploration is spent on earth. Paying earth engineers earth dollars that they will in turn spend on earth. That 25 Billion USD Apollo program? That money didn't get sent to the Moon, damn near all of that money was spent in America.

Hell, think of it this way: India needs satellites, so they can either dump money into another country that will build and launch those satellites for India, or they can dump that money back into India and develop those capabilities themselves. How could you possibly fault India for keeping their space money domestic?

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by Arjuna on Thursday November 07, 2013 @04:51PM (#6692662)
Well said.

From another perspective... I often look up at the night sky and think to myself: how many civilizations are gone, simply because they failed to have the vision to leave their home planet?

A great line from a t-shirt:

"Asteroids... are nature's way of asking: 'How's that space program coming along?'"

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @04:55PM (#6692695)
I fear that the "Great Filter" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_filter) is less likely to be a big rock or hunk of ice whacking planets full of the uninspired, but rather the speed of light necessitating dense civilizations to minimize communication latency. The sooner we expand, the better, because we are only going to become more addicted to information and instantaneous species-wide communication.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by wozniacki on Friday November 08, 2013 @06:49AM (#6695586)
Could you elaborate on

a) communication latency b) addicted to information and c) instantaneous species-wide communication.

and how those are greater risk factors?

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by bcoates on Thursday November 07, 2013 @04:20PM (#6692476)
How is consuming billions of dollars of the time of talented specialists a good thing in and of itself?

There's an argument that it's the best possible thing they could be doing, or that India's space program is extremely cost effective, etc. But an expenditure is a loss not a gain--otherwise we could make ourselves rich by breaking all the windows in the world.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @04:28PM (#6692525)
> How is consuming billions of dollars of the time of talented specialists a good thing in and of itself?

Well, I didn't say that it is, I just argued that it wasn't a negative thing. Wealth was not destroyed or sent away to some far off land, just shuffled around within the same country.

I will say that it is now though: One of India's greatest assets is their production of quality engineers and scientists. The more money they can dump into engineering and scientific endeavors, the better. Unlike breaking windows and then replacing them with identical windows, programs such as these actually create something: experience and expertise.

In evoking the broken windows parable, you are mistaking a rocket for a window. Space programs do not destroy wealth to move money around. Perhaps if we senselessly knocked down a few buildings every time we built a rocket, you might have a point; space programs aren't "cash for clunkers", we aren't destroying wealth (old cars) to encourage the exchange of money (buying new cars).

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by fspeech on Thursday November 07, 2013 @04:45PM (#6692632)
Opportunity cost is the equivalence of wealth lost.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @04:52PM (#6692669)
The opportunity cost of giving money to the ISRO is lower than what they would have done with that money otherwise. Money sent to the ISRO is an investment in India's domestic STEM talent. There are few better ways they could have possibly spent that money.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by mikeash on Thursday November 07, 2013 @04:57PM (#6692706)
Wealth was destroyed and sent to some far off land, specifically to space and to Mars.

The wealth is not the money, it's the spacecraft.

The return may well be worth the cost, but it's wrong to say that wealth was simply moved around within India. Money was moved around within India. Wealth was concentrated into a small package and then blasted into space, never to be seen again.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:04PM (#6692753)
"the vast majority of money spent on space exploration is spent on earth."

The wealth, or money, represented by the physical spacecraft is a rounding error. The thing isn't made of gold bullion. Wealth was used to develop and exercise engineering talent. Wealth was converted into talent, not a spacecraft. Those engineers were not sent to mars, some largely inconsequential piece of metal was. The wealth remains on earth, in India.

If I spend money to take a bunch of CS classes at community college, then at the end of that do `rm -rf ~/files/school/cs`, did I just delete wealth? Of course not. The wealth was not concentrated into that directory, it was not lost or destroyed when I sent it off into oblivion.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by auctiontheory on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:28PM (#6692886)
did I just delete wealth? Of course not.

Exactly. Because you were well-trained to protect yourself with aliases.

Now if you'd done '\rm <etc.>', it would be another story.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:47PM (#6693011)
Who uses aliases to prevent the deletion of directories?

The directory of source code created during my education is not something that wealth was poured into. Wealth was poured into my brain, that directory is just a byproduct. If I, and all of those engineers, technicians, and scientists, gave ourselves brain-damage, then and only then would all of that wealth be destroyed.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by quinnchr on Thursday November 07, 2013 @08:01PM (#6693724)
Well, you could argue the labor theory of value, and since that directory consumed your labor it theoretically has value. Does it have value to anyone but you? Probably not.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @08:15PM (#6693780)
It would have some value to me, but not much in the grand scheme of things. I don't look at that directory and think "Welp, that was [X]-grand well spent", because just getting that directory wasn't worth many thousands of dollars to me. That's not where the wealth represented by all of those thousands of dollars went, so the wealth represented by all of those thousands of dollars cannot be destroyed by deleting it.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by quinnchr on Thursday November 07, 2013 @08:23PM (#6693817)
I agree, I'm really just arguing technicalities here. The majority of your labor went into acquiring the knowledge, not writing the code in that directory. But that directory still holds value, however minuscule it may be, and it is still being destroyed.

If I deleted that directory I would think "Welp, that was [x]-hours of time well spent," which is where it derives it's value* not from the money I spent on my education.

*That is, of course, if you ascribe to the labor theory of value.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by eru on Thursday November 07, 2013 @09:54PM (#6694136)
And the labour-theory (or labour-definition) of value is not all that useful.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by quinnchr on Thursday November 07, 2013 @10:03PM (#6694166)
Speaking of not all that useful...
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by nitrogen on Friday November 08, 2013 @01:44AM (#6694832)
I do like how some distributions ship with an alias of rm to 'rm -i'. But, I prefer having the raw power of rm available at all times, because it led to a habit of checking everything into git, backing up critical files, and always thinking twice before I type -rf or hit Enter.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by mikeash on Thursday November 07, 2013 @08:24PM (#6693824)
The cost of satellites and rocket launches would tend to disagree. They are not cheap. I won't dispute that valuable talent was also developed, but the cost of the hardware is hardly "a rounding error".

The fact that you persist in confusing money with wealth makes me think you haven't really understood my point. Gold is not all that useful by itself, so launching a bunch of gold into space would not be throwing wealth away the way launching an expensive and fancy satellite is.

A Mars mission is not undergrad CS work. It's a serious project. If we deleted all copies of the Linux kernel from the world, have you destroyed wealth? Of course you have.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by vinceguidry on Thursday November 07, 2013 @09:28PM (#6694052)
The most commonly reported figure for the cost of the Mars mission is US$72 million.

There's apartments in NYC/London that cost more than that.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by mikeash on Thursday November 07, 2013 @09:29PM (#6694060)
At no point am I arguing that the mission was too expensive or anything like that.

I really wish that, just once, I could criticize a bad argument without everyone thinking that I support the opposing view.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by vinceguidry on Thursday November 07, 2013 @09:47PM (#6694118)
You said they weren't cheap. In this case, they were.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by mikeash on Thursday November 07, 2013 @10:24PM (#6694229)
$72 million is not cheap in my universe. And given the context, the relevant question is the cost of the hardware versus the other costs involved.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by kamaal on Thursday November 07, 2013 @11:01PM (#6694365)
Its not cheap compared to what?

What could you get in the equivalent of $72 million?

A holly wood movie? Series A funding for yet-another-photo-sharing start up? Opening ceremony for Olympic games?

Things like the Mars mission has profound implications on the very survival of human race over the next 1000 years.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by LaGrange on Friday November 08, 2013 @07:01AM (#6695616)
A school.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by nzp on Friday November 08, 2013 @09:00AM (#6695999)
How many schools could be built on a US DoD's Iraq war budget (just an example)? And how many lives would be spared if in fact that money went into building of schools? I think there are issues in our world today infinitely better suited for complaining about wasting resources than some country's space program.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by LaGrange on Friday November 08, 2013 @09:26AM (#6696136)
I’m not discussing that — things one could be done on the US DoD budgets are pretty much unimaginable.

The only thing I wanted to provide is that there are, actually, useful, measurably beneficial things one could do for „just” 72 megadollars — like a „boring” school, or a clinic. Or a stretch of a road and a clean well, maybe even a small stretch of railway. In many places those would be huge.

This doesn’t mean a space program is the best place to take money away from — not even in India, and definitely not in the United States. I just mean it’s not money one can wave away as small change.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by nzp on Friday November 08, 2013 @07:19PM (#6700005)
Yes, but then we are arguing about truisms, so what's the point the naysayers want to make? I don't mean you specifically, but on several threads on this page there are people arguing that: "oh, this is so much money wasted, other things could be done with it, but oh, I'm not saying we should take away from the space program, but, oh, this is so much money wasted..." ad nauseam. I mean what exactly is the point in pointing out that yes, obviously, other good things can be done with 72 million, and then disclaiming that it's an argument against India launching a Mars probe? Why point out such a trivial truth unless arguing against India doing this? If it's just about 72 million not being small change in general, why aren't people making such trivially true statements in discussions about other things?

Again, I am not singling you out, I get what you're saying, but I just have to ask: why aren't we having people pointing out how many schools can be built out of a budget for, for example as kamaal wrote, an Olympic opening ceremony? I don't think it's even some kind of closet racism, as some have argued, in general (though in this case there is also that, in this story's coverage by the Western media), because people go nuts over the US space program also. Even outside the US. :) It's a clear pattern of pushing the waste argument over just about any kind of space exploration anyone does, and it's not done just by "unwashed masses" but also by very educated people (e.g. here, I had a colleague, a theoretical physicist of all people, telling me how space programs are such a waste when there are people starving etc...). What the hell?

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by LaGrange on Friday November 08, 2013 @08:33PM (#6700281)
Actually, we do have quite a lot of people pointing out both that and the war effort, both counted in "schools" and "manned Mars missions". Not in this discussion, but that's probably related to the fact that India neither started a homophobic olympics nor invaded Iraq.

Mind you, I do think that a lot of complaints about this specific mission are of a racist nature - but that's because I suspect that many of the detractors wouldn't critique US space programs the same way.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by vidarh on Friday November 08, 2013 @05:34AM (#6695459)
You earlier wrote:

> The cost of satellites and rocket launches would tend to disagree. They are not cheap.

The cost of the material of hardware is a miniscule proportion of that compared to the investment of time of engineers etc. involved in the project, and ground based hardware that can be reused for other missions. That engineering time could have been used on something else, sure. But the time spent is not wasted: It increases the experience and thus value of those engineers for the future.

It's already a mission on a shoestring budget, but the bit that they actually threw away never to see again was much, much smaller.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by mikeash on Friday November 08, 2013 @10:52AM (#6696786)
I never said the time spent is "wasted". At no point in this discussion have I argued that any of this stuff is "wasted". I am simply arguing that it counts.

Yes, the time spent by the engineers has long-term benefits in increasing their experience. However, a large portion of that time is lost to the spacecraft. If that time could have been spent more productively elsewhere, then spending it on this was a bad idea.

Again, I'm not saying that the mission actually was a bad idea. I'm simply saying that "the money stays in the economy" is a terrible argument.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by nzp on Friday November 08, 2013 @08:50AM (#6695953)
> Gold is not all that useful by itself, so launching a bunch of gold into space would not be throwing wealth away the way launching an expensive and fancy satellite is.

At the point of launch the satellite would be even less valuable (in the use value sense, which is what you're referring to) than a bunch of gold. At least gold could be put to some use (it is a useful metal), while a satellite's only useful purpose is to be launched into and operate in space. It's why a satellite exists, you would lose wealth only if it wasn't launched.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by quinnchr on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:08PM (#6692774)
And a much larger percentage of that wealth was transferred to the engineers who worked on that project in exchange for their labor. The rocket itself represents a tiny percentage of the overall wealth transfer. So the majority of wealth was simply rearranged not destroyed, unless every single person who worked on the project puts every single cent they earned into a savings account never to be spent.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by mikeash on Thursday November 07, 2013 @08:42PM (#6693904)
Wealth is not money.

Let me repeat that.

Wealth is not money.

One more time.

Wealth is not money.

Now, if you'd care to try your comment again with that in mind....

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by quinnchr on Thursday November 07, 2013 @08:54PM (#6693951)
I never once mentioned, or alluded to the transfer of money being the transfer of wealth, so if you'd like to try reading my comment again with that in mind...

Also notice the part where I explicitly mentioned that if the money earned is never spent on good or services than the wealth is destroyed. Maybe try working on your reading comprehension before you decide to be a dick?

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by mikeash on Thursday November 07, 2013 @09:01PM (#6693968)
Yes, I noticed where you said that wealth is destroyed if the money is never spent. Thus I concluded that you conflated money with wealth, because that statement makes no sense. Hoarding money in a savings account does not destroy wealth.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by quinnchr on Thursday November 07, 2013 @09:03PM (#6693976)
Well then maybe brush up on your economic theory before rereading my comment?
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by cscurmudgeon on Thursday November 07, 2013 @10:30PM (#6694248)
> Wealth was destroyed and sent to some far off land, specifically to space and to Mars.

Really? What about the expertise gained? The knowledge gained?

Space exploration is vital for long-term survival of a country like India.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by mikeash on Thursday November 07, 2013 @10:39PM (#6694280)
Yes, some wealth was created and kept. That doesn't change the fact that other wealth was shot into space.

Why, why, why must people assume I'm being blindly antagonistic? I just don't get it. You quote me and then reply as if I said something stupid, and "correct" me by saying something I agree with and never contradicted.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by ruchir on Friday November 08, 2013 @04:21AM (#6695280)
Wealth is not fixed like energy. It can be created. Money can be used to create wealth when it is used to create new products for example. In this case you could argue there were no products in the traditional sense. But it got people's attention.

So a writer could write a sci-fi novel about mars and sell that to a ready audience.

An entrepreneur could create models of the planets and sell those to schools.

A movie maker could make a new movie with a space theme.

Not to mention actual technical innovations that could come out of new knowledge gained. Moreover, kids could be motivated to take up science and engineering for future jobs in 'STEM' fields. If this unlocks the imagination of even a few creative people, they could put back more than $100m of wealth into the economy.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by kamaal on Thursday November 07, 2013 @11:08PM (#6694391)
>>That doesn't change the fact that other wealth was shot into space.

No wealth was shot in to space, or literally negligible amounts of it. The wealth is the know-how, and expertise that can replicate such a mission again. Which exists in tact on earth.

One of the goals of the mars mission is - to develop the technologies required for design, planning, management and operations of an interplanetary mission.

In other words, this is just the beginning.

From -

http://www.isro.org/pslv-c25/mission-objective.aspx

The 'other wealth' you talk about is pocket change, in comparison to any public project.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by cscurmudgeon on Friday November 08, 2013 @06:43AM (#6695571)
Okaayyyyy... Let us be ridiculous. Why do you assume all of space will not belong to India for all of time?

Why do you assume Mars has zero wealth? Over the long term, this "loss" of wealth will result in helping humans (not just Indians) harness that wealth in Mars and other places.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by mikeash on Saturday November 09, 2013 @04:39PM (#6703375)
I'm not assuming any of these things. At no point do I say that it's not worth the expenditure. I'm just saying that there is an expenditure.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by cscurmudgeon on Saturday November 09, 2013 @08:59PM (#6704731)
there is an expenditure.

That is a trivially vacuous statement. Everything has an expenditure. It is the net benefit that counts. Even breathing takes energy.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by mikeash on Saturday November 09, 2013 @09:04PM (#6704745)
I was responding to a guy who said that no wealth was destroyed, which is another way of saying that there was no expenditure.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by cscurmudgeon on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @03:21PM (#6720674)
I believe he was talking about net wealth.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by kamakazizuru on Thursday November 07, 2013 @04:27PM (#6692523)
I really tried to understand this - but completely fail to. Can you try and make any sense at all? How in the world is something productive - that leads to mankind as a whole gaining knowledge and information AND to India bolstering national pride and marketing itself as a Space logistics provider to the world - even remotely comparable to breaking windows? Geez - by your logic everyone should keep money in their mattress and go to bed.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by anopows on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:00PM (#6692728)
I think what he refers to is the broken window fallacy: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window

It is not about, if the US space program was better/worse than the Indian one. But that we don't know the alternative outcome of a lot of smart people working, not on the space program, but on many different fields that could lead to a greater outcome than this one project (the work would be less visible to the public than one shiny big project but in the end there is (in my opinion) more gain for the people, because the market responds generally better to the needs of people than a bureaucracy)

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by kamakazizuru on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:16PM (#6692820)
yes but that makes a large assumption that those smart people would rather work on something else. there isnt much stopping them from going elsewhere and working on space programs - if thats what they'd rather do. this way the country is atleast keeping those folks around - and making sure the money stays within the economy.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by anopows on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:36PM (#6692942)
I will link to mikeash comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6692694

Money is not equal wealth. You can spend money in a circle of two people a thousand times, that doesn't make the two richer. Or you can add 0's at the end of all bills, that doesn't make anyone more rich either.

I think it's more reasonable if we focus on wealth and not on money in this discussion.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by fspeech on Thursday November 07, 2013 @04:50PM (#6692657)
The leading comment stated that expenditure is not cost. In that context the response is to the point. Your argument that it is a cost-benefit analysis is of course correct. But that is consistent with arguing that one can not simply wave the cost away as if it is not real.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by gsk on Thursday November 07, 2013 @04:39PM (#6692597)
An oft-repeated well-meaning but rather ignorant objection. Read this http://www.lettersofnote.com/2012/08/why-explore-space.html
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by mkr-hn on Thursday November 07, 2013 @04:54PM (#6692691)
History. It's rare to put a lot of smart people on the same program and not produce something with enormous social and commercial benefit. DARPA's little side project still produces new things decades after the initial investment.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by graeme on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:11PM (#6692792)
I'm all for space exploration, but this is the broken window fallacy. Those earth engineers could be doing other things. So if space exploration were in fact a worthless goal, then we'd be paying intelligent people to waste their time.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window

(I'm only addressing your first two paragraphs. Your third paragraph switches tact by arguing about the positive benefits of space exploration funding)

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:17PM (#6692829)
The broken windows parable is an argument against destruction to encourage the exchange of money. There is no analogous destruction in this case.

> "Those earth engineers could be doing other things."

I might as well point out that you could be working on a cure to cancer right now. You wouldn't buy that argument though, right?

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by codeflo on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:37PM (#6692951)
In the abstract, paying people to waste time is very similar to destroying windows: you're destroying the services that they could have provided.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:44PM (#6692995)
You are not paying them to waste time though. You are paying them to develop a very advanced (and valuable) skillset. You are paying to develop and mature your nation's scientific community and education system, to provide them access to facilities and capabilities they previously lacked.

The IRSO didn't sit on their asses twiddling their thumbs while consuming money for several years, only to have a rocket pop out of think air. They were working their asses off, developing new skill-sets and advancing their understanding of their field.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by codeflo on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:51PM (#6693026)
Just to clarify, I was addressing the general form of argument, not the concrete example of whether space research is a waste of time. Personally, I consider advancing science and the arts very worthwhile goals of public spending, but that's a different point.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by graeme on Friday November 08, 2013 @02:09PM (#6698407)
Right, but now you're arguing that their work is useful. That's a different argument than simply arguing we're spending the money on earth. If people think the space programs are wasteful, then presumably they don't think the work done is useful.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by rikacomet on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:16PM (#6692826)
and then we have no engineers who can accomplish anything related to space exploration when time comes for humanity to explore beyond earth majorly?

You are suggesting we weaken our foundations. A talent pool takes a lot of generations. No one can say America or some other country will do the space thingy, you go work on poor.

Mind you, these so called engineers and other workers are free independant INDIANS, who can do whatever they want, join any field they want to, work towards goal they collectively set.

There are many unproductive things, .. drugs/prostitution/trafficking has billions of $ involved each year. We would rather spend energy in making those people productive, if anything.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:26PM (#6692878)
There exists a strange notion that engineers have some form of responsibility that goes above and beyond what 'normal' people have. Anyone can do anything they like with their lives... unless they are an engineer, at which point they suddenly become obligated to work on charitable endeavors.

Decide to write novels? "That's nice, what a nice career choice." Decide to write iphone applications? "How the hell can you sit there programming iphone applications when you could be using your intellect to fight hunger!? There are more important things than iphone apps!"

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by rikacomet on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:52PM (#6693030)
Well a free man is free to even ignore his apparent responsibility. Which is the maximum case with children of successful people. Most of them never are able to come out of the shadow of their parents. Barely few have in the History.

Akbar in India, Kublai Khan of Mongolia, etc.

Anyways, nor you or I have the correct information, or any other basis enough to claim, that these engineers can be put to better use. WHo has that information? THE GOVT! So chances are that in all likeliness this is the most efficient use of that workforce.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by saraid216 on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:35PM (#6692932)
No, I've heard novelists get the same flak. And social justice activists, though I don't think I've ever heard privacy advocates take it. I was going to say I haven't heard bankers get it, but I think I recall a case or two.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:52PM (#6693034)
Well, my perspective may be biased since I naturally associate more with engineers, but it seems to me that engineers take a disproportionate amount of this sort of flack. It seems to me that the general public thinks that engineers have an unusual high obligation or debt to society.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by saraid216 on Thursday November 07, 2013 @06:07PM (#6693129)
> the general public

Do you generally hear this sentiment from "the general public"? In my experience, it comes more from people who are disillusioned by their direct interactions with group X.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @08:09PM (#6693757)
I have heard it not necessarily often, but several times, from extended family members (there is one notable offender, my response to her is usually an exasperated comment about her not even having a job... holidays with the jlgreco family are interesting affairs...) and here it rather frequently online on places like reddit.

It is like they think talent in any STEM field is something that society has gives to people on the condition that they use said talent to cure cancer and solve world hunger, and anybody not using their talent to do those things is failing to hold up their end of the bargain. People with skill in the humanities seem to be largely free of this judgement.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by sanskritabelt on Thursday November 07, 2013 @06:18PM (#6693204)
Didn't you ever read Spiderman comics? "To whom much is given, much is expected" -- Uncle Ben
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @08:02PM (#6693733)
This is exactly what I am talking about. Why do you think that "much was given" to the engineers of the world, but not to others? Engineers may be blessed with talents in engineering, but novelists are blessed with the gift of writing. Why should engineers be expected to engineer things for charitable causes anymore than writers should be expected to use their talents similarly?

Engineering isn't some uniquely special skill; it is one of many. Yet it uniquely is singled out as being a skill that bequeaths the holder with some extra responsibility to society. Engineers don't owe the world any more than anybody else does. (And if you think they do, then why do non-engineers not owe it to the world to become engineers?)

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by rikacomet on Friday November 08, 2013 @02:30AM (#6694979)
Yes I have read, but in real life.. not everyone is able to accomplish what is expected of him/her. Its not just a matter of choice, but also circumstances.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by mikeash on Thursday November 07, 2013 @04:55PM (#6692694)
Money is the wrong thing to look at.

You can observe this by how easy it is to fall into the trap of thinking that destroying the money would be a huge waste. It wouldn't. Money, by itself, has no value. It's only useful in how you can use it to obtain goods and services. Destroying money reduces your own ability to obtain goods and services, but doesn't actually destroy wealth, as everyone else's ability to obtain goods and services increases to compensate. While wealth is typically measured in money, wealth consists of goods and services.

The fact that the money recirculates in the economy is irrelevant to the question of waste. If they wasted the money, it essentially means that the goods and services purchased with it were squandered.

So, forget the money for a moment. Analyze it like this: a bunch of engineers and technicians spent thousands or millions of collective hours. High quality aluminum, steel, electronics, etc., were used. And the result is a spacecraft. That time and those resources could be used to do something else. Perhaps something better, like build schools or factories.

That is the argument being made. I'm not saying it's necessarily correct (this mission doesn't seem like it's very expensive in the grand scheme of things, and the benefits for science, technology, and just plain prestige seem well worth it) but it is at least sensible in its foundations.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:01PM (#6692735)
This is little more than "why are we spending money on electronic gadgets when cancer still needs to be cured", an argument that has zero traction in this community. It doesn't suddenly start making sense when the topic is space.

Factories and schools are not failing to be built because of a deficient in engineering talent caused by the IRSO.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by venomsnake on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:45PM (#6692998)
There was interesting exchange between Krugman and Ezra Klein few years back - Krugman insisted that macro models show that the Obama stimulus should have been 3-4 times bigger to take effect. The guy is probably right. But Klein replied that even if that big stimulus was passed into law, there just weren't enough quality projects in US which to absorb the stimulus.

So next time someone ask this - the proper reply is - where is the cancer research infrastructure and promising leads which could absorb what we spend every year on smartphones and tablets.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:49PM (#6693018)
Add enough corruption and fat to those cancer research programs and they would happily consume all the wealth you could ever dream of throwing at them. Eventually you'll reach a point where you realize that instead of throwing those millions at wasteful cancer research, you could get more bang for your buck funding some other startlingly efficient programs.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by 7952 on Thursday November 07, 2013 @06:23PM (#6693234)
It may be better to look for quality projects in basic research into fundamental science. Understanding more about biology and physics helps cure cancer and could devoir almost any budgets (see cern).
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by eru on Thursday November 07, 2013 @09:51PM (#6694130)
American infrastructure is creaking. There's lots that can absorb resources. (Though probably not in a very short time, it takes a while to get projects shovel-ready.)
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jrs99 on Thursday November 07, 2013 @11:07PM (#6694390)
It could easily go into a project such as something like Masdar City.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by mikeash on Thursday November 07, 2013 @08:26PM (#6693831)
I agree, that other argument is bad. However, just because an argument is bad does not mean any counterargument must be good. The counterargument presented, that the money spent doesn't matter because it recirculates within the economy afterwards, is also bad.

I agree that this is probably a net gain. But you can't demonstrate that by saying that the money keeps moving within the economy, and you especially can't demonstrate that by holding up destruction of cash as some sort of worst-case scenario for waste.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by paganel on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:30PM (#6692893)
> This is little more than "why are we spending money on electronic gadgets when cancer still needs to be cured", an argument that has zero traction in this community. It doesn't suddenly start making sense when the topic is space.

Then the people that criticize space exploration based on similar arguments would be stupid to do that. In the long run (which may not be that long after all) we do need to get off this planet in order to survive as a species. This is just a fact, is how the observable Universe works.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by tmbsundar on Friday November 08, 2013 @10:16AM (#6696474)
This argument presumes that Schools, Factories are better investment of talent hours than Space (high quality aluminium, steel or electronics)

This is not always true. There are some areas of governance from a sovereign country's point of view which it cannot neglect and should develop indigenous capability. Areas like defense which is non-negotiable and other strategic areas like space.

A good government always tries to balance investment in different areas. If India stops investing in Defense and Space and keeps building only schools and toilets, that will be a lopsided, weak development to say the least.

Even in other non-strategic areas, societal development cannot be dictated to flow in a single direction.

Consider this for contrast:

India's top 3 high budget movies - 86 million USD [1]

Mukesh Ambani's house - 2 Billion USD [2]

India's education budget for 2013 - 11 Billion USD [3]

India's health care budget for 2013 - 6 Billion USD [4]

[1] http://www.therichest.com/luxury/most-expensive/top-10-most-...

[2] http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/business/international-bu...

[3] http://www.livemint.com/Politics/7EmPAMBANzkPDAPuyruQ1I/Chid...

[4] http://in.finance.yahoo.com/news/budget-2013-hikes-spending-...

Edit : alignment

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by mikeash on Saturday November 09, 2013 @04:41PM (#6703382)
"This argument presumes that Schools, Factories are better investment of talent hours than Space (high quality aluminium, steel or electronics)"

It does no such thing. It merely presumes that if you want to justify the mission, that is what you must compare it to, not a ridiculous scenario of taking the cash spent and burning it.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by mattlutze on Friday November 08, 2013 @08:42AM (#6695913)
That is still a money argument though, right?

Beyond the "is there necessary infrastructure for alternative project X so the diverted funds aren't wasted" question, the argument for me is: that time and those resources were spent in India, by India, and the result is an increased knowledge and capacity to leverage some highly technical skills and technologies.

You don't add rocket scientists to your workforce by building schools, you do it by adding/increasing the capacity for such work. Being trained to do the work doesn't make the work to do, if that makes sense.

I definitely agree that the question of "why is X needed when the first-order benefits of Y has such a larger impact" is relevant and important, insofar as X is the space program and Y is a collection of social programs.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by comrade_ogilvy on Thursday November 07, 2013 @04:31PM (#6692542)
It is true that the cost may well be less than sending a check to some American farmers to ship over rice, because the monies circulate locally.

But ultimately that money could have built a big dam, or a few beautiful bridges, or a small power plant in a country with lots of power outages.

I personally think it is money well spent, because it heralds the arrival of India to the world of first class satellite launching, by doing something Russia failed at the first few attempts. But that payoff is over the long term.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @04:49PM (#6692648)
What bridge or power plants programs have been defunded because of the IRSO?

The reason the IRSO is able to accomplish so much is because it is so efficient and damn good at what it does. The reason why other agencies and organizations in India have such a hard time keeping bridges safe or the lights on is because they are massively inefficient in comparison. These other programs, given the IRSOs budget, would have accomplished approximately "fuck all" more than they did without it. The IRSO should not be punished for the failings of other aspects of the Indian government.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by dopkew on Friday November 08, 2013 @07:12AM (#6695657)
It is ISRO: Indian Space Research Organisation
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by kamaal on Thursday November 07, 2013 @11:18PM (#6694421)
>>But ultimately that money could have built a big dam, or a few beautiful bridges, or a small power plant in a country with lots of power outages.

Why can't they be in parallel?

And this is some what unfair to the people at ISRO. India spends a great deal of money on infrastructure too, bulk of that money is either stolen brazenly or sunk to corruption.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by wtbob on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:11PM (#6692793)
That's the broken window fallacy rearing its ugly head yet again. That money could be spent on a Mars program, or it could be spent on feeding people, or on fancy dinners for rulers, or on anti-corruption investigations, or on a sports stadium, or...
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by seanlinmt on Thursday November 07, 2013 @07:07PM (#6693471)