News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by mikeash on Thursday November 07, 2013 @04:55PM (#6692694)
Money is the wrong thing to look at.

You can observe this by how easy it is to fall into the trap of thinking that destroying the money would be a huge waste. It wouldn't. Money, by itself, has no value. It's only useful in how you can use it to obtain goods and services. Destroying money reduces your own ability to obtain goods and services, but doesn't actually destroy wealth, as everyone else's ability to obtain goods and services increases to compensate. While wealth is typically measured in money, wealth consists of goods and services.

The fact that the money recirculates in the economy is irrelevant to the question of waste. If they wasted the money, it essentially means that the goods and services purchased with it were squandered.

So, forget the money for a moment. Analyze it like this: a bunch of engineers and technicians spent thousands or millions of collective hours. High quality aluminum, steel, electronics, etc., were used. And the result is a spacecraft. That time and those resources could be used to do something else. Perhaps something better, like build schools or factories.

That is the argument being made. I'm not saying it's necessarily correct (this mission doesn't seem like it's very expensive in the grand scheme of things, and the benefits for science, technology, and just plain prestige seem well worth it) but it is at least sensible in its foundations.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:01PM (#6692735)
This is little more than "why are we spending money on electronic gadgets when cancer still needs to be cured", an argument that has zero traction in this community. It doesn't suddenly start making sense when the topic is space.

Factories and schools are not failing to be built because of a deficient in engineering talent caused by the IRSO.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by venomsnake on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:45PM (#6692998)
There was interesting exchange between Krugman and Ezra Klein few years back - Krugman insisted that macro models show that the Obama stimulus should have been 3-4 times bigger to take effect. The guy is probably right. But Klein replied that even if that big stimulus was passed into law, there just weren't enough quality projects in US which to absorb the stimulus.

So next time someone ask this - the proper reply is - where is the cancer research infrastructure and promising leads which could absorb what we spend every year on smartphones and tablets.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:49PM (#6693018)
Add enough corruption and fat to those cancer research programs and they would happily consume all the wealth you could ever dream of throwing at them. Eventually you'll reach a point where you realize that instead of throwing those millions at wasteful cancer research, you could get more bang for your buck funding some other startlingly efficient programs.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by 7952 on Thursday November 07, 2013 @06:23PM (#6693234)
It may be better to look for quality projects in basic research into fundamental science. Understanding more about biology and physics helps cure cancer and could devoir almost any budgets (see cern).
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by eru on Thursday November 07, 2013 @09:51PM (#6694130)
American infrastructure is creaking. There's lots that can absorb resources. (Though probably not in a very short time, it takes a while to get projects shovel-ready.)
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jrs99 on Thursday November 07, 2013 @11:07PM (#6694390)
It could easily go into a project such as something like Masdar City.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by mikeash on Thursday November 07, 2013 @08:26PM (#6693831)
I agree, that other argument is bad. However, just because an argument is bad does not mean any counterargument must be good. The counterargument presented, that the money spent doesn't matter because it recirculates within the economy afterwards, is also bad.

I agree that this is probably a net gain. But you can't demonstrate that by saying that the money keeps moving within the economy, and you especially can't demonstrate that by holding up destruction of cash as some sort of worst-case scenario for waste.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by paganel on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:30PM (#6692893)
> This is little more than "why are we spending money on electronic gadgets when cancer still needs to be cured", an argument that has zero traction in this community. It doesn't suddenly start making sense when the topic is space.

Then the people that criticize space exploration based on similar arguments would be stupid to do that. In the long run (which may not be that long after all) we do need to get off this planet in order to survive as a species. This is just a fact, is how the observable Universe works.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by tmbsundar on Friday November 08, 2013 @10:16AM (#6696474)
This argument presumes that Schools, Factories are better investment of talent hours than Space (high quality aluminium, steel or electronics)

This is not always true. There are some areas of governance from a sovereign country's point of view which it cannot neglect and should develop indigenous capability. Areas like defense which is non-negotiable and other strategic areas like space.

A good government always tries to balance investment in different areas. If India stops investing in Defense and Space and keeps building only schools and toilets, that will be a lopsided, weak development to say the least.

Even in other non-strategic areas, societal development cannot be dictated to flow in a single direction.

Consider this for contrast:

India's top 3 high budget movies - 86 million USD [1]

Mukesh Ambani's house - 2 Billion USD [2]

India's education budget for 2013 - 11 Billion USD [3]

India's health care budget for 2013 - 6 Billion USD [4]

[1] http://www.therichest.com/luxury/most-expensive/top-10-most-...

[2] http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/business/international-bu...

[3] http://www.livemint.com/Politics/7EmPAMBANzkPDAPuyruQ1I/Chid...

[4] http://in.finance.yahoo.com/news/budget-2013-hikes-spending-...

Edit : alignment

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by mikeash on Saturday November 09, 2013 @04:41PM (#6703382)
"This argument presumes that Schools, Factories are better investment of talent hours than Space (high quality aluminium, steel or electronics)"

It does no such thing. It merely presumes that if you want to justify the mission, that is what you must compare it to, not a ridiculous scenario of taking the cash spent and burning it.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by mattlutze on Friday November 08, 2013 @08:42AM (#6695913)
That is still a money argument though, right?

Beyond the "is there necessary infrastructure for alternative project X so the diverted funds aren't wasted" question, the argument for me is: that time and those resources were spent in India, by India, and the result is an increased knowledge and capacity to leverage some highly technical skills and technologies.

You don't add rocket scientists to your workforce by building schools, you do it by adding/increasing the capacity for such work. Being trained to do the work doesn't make the work to do, if that makes sense.

I definitely agree that the question of "why is X needed when the first-order benefits of Y has such a larger impact" is relevant and important, insofar as X is the space program and Y is a collection of social programs.