News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by graeme on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:11PM (#6692792)
I'm all for space exploration, but this is the broken window fallacy. Those earth engineers could be doing other things. So if space exploration were in fact a worthless goal, then we'd be paying intelligent people to waste their time.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window

(I'm only addressing your first two paragraphs. Your third paragraph switches tact by arguing about the positive benefits of space exploration funding)

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:17PM (#6692829)
The broken windows parable is an argument against destruction to encourage the exchange of money. There is no analogous destruction in this case.

> "Those earth engineers could be doing other things."

I might as well point out that you could be working on a cure to cancer right now. You wouldn't buy that argument though, right?

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by codeflo on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:37PM (#6692951)
In the abstract, paying people to waste time is very similar to destroying windows: you're destroying the services that they could have provided.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:44PM (#6692995)
You are not paying them to waste time though. You are paying them to develop a very advanced (and valuable) skillset. You are paying to develop and mature your nation's scientific community and education system, to provide them access to facilities and capabilities they previously lacked.

The IRSO didn't sit on their asses twiddling their thumbs while consuming money for several years, only to have a rocket pop out of think air. They were working their asses off, developing new skill-sets and advancing their understanding of their field.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by codeflo on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:51PM (#6693026)
Just to clarify, I was addressing the general form of argument, not the concrete example of whether space research is a waste of time. Personally, I consider advancing science and the arts very worthwhile goals of public spending, but that's a different point.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by graeme on Friday November 08, 2013 @02:09PM (#6698407)
Right, but now you're arguing that their work is useful. That's a different argument than simply arguing we're spending the money on earth. If people think the space programs are wasteful, then presumably they don't think the work done is useful.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by rikacomet on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:16PM (#6692826)
and then we have no engineers who can accomplish anything related to space exploration when time comes for humanity to explore beyond earth majorly?

You are suggesting we weaken our foundations. A talent pool takes a lot of generations. No one can say America or some other country will do the space thingy, you go work on poor.

Mind you, these so called engineers and other workers are free independant INDIANS, who can do whatever they want, join any field they want to, work towards goal they collectively set.

There are many unproductive things, .. drugs/prostitution/trafficking has billions of $ involved each year. We would rather spend energy in making those people productive, if anything.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:26PM (#6692878)
There exists a strange notion that engineers have some form of responsibility that goes above and beyond what 'normal' people have. Anyone can do anything they like with their lives... unless they are an engineer, at which point they suddenly become obligated to work on charitable endeavors.

Decide to write novels? "That's nice, what a nice career choice." Decide to write iphone applications? "How the hell can you sit there programming iphone applications when you could be using your intellect to fight hunger!? There are more important things than iphone apps!"

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by rikacomet on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:52PM (#6693030)
Well a free man is free to even ignore his apparent responsibility. Which is the maximum case with children of successful people. Most of them never are able to come out of the shadow of their parents. Barely few have in the History.

Akbar in India, Kublai Khan of Mongolia, etc.

Anyways, nor you or I have the correct information, or any other basis enough to claim, that these engineers can be put to better use. WHo has that information? THE GOVT! So chances are that in all likeliness this is the most efficient use of that workforce.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by saraid216 on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:35PM (#6692932)
No, I've heard novelists get the same flak. And social justice activists, though I don't think I've ever heard privacy advocates take it. I was going to say I haven't heard bankers get it, but I think I recall a case or two.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:52PM (#6693034)
Well, my perspective may be biased since I naturally associate more with engineers, but it seems to me that engineers take a disproportionate amount of this sort of flack. It seems to me that the general public thinks that engineers have an unusual high obligation or debt to society.
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by saraid216 on Thursday November 07, 2013 @06:07PM (#6693129)
> the general public

Do you generally hear this sentiment from "the general public"? In my experience, it comes more from people who are disillusioned by their direct interactions with group X.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @08:09PM (#6693757)
I have heard it not necessarily often, but several times, from extended family members (there is one notable offender, my response to her is usually an exasperated comment about her not even having a job... holidays with the jlgreco family are interesting affairs...) and here it rather frequently online on places like reddit.

It is like they think talent in any STEM field is something that society has gives to people on the condition that they use said talent to cure cancer and solve world hunger, and anybody not using their talent to do those things is failing to hold up their end of the bargain. People with skill in the humanities seem to be largely free of this judgement.

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by sanskritabelt on Thursday November 07, 2013 @06:18PM (#6693204)
Didn't you ever read Spiderman comics? "To whom much is given, much is expected" -- Uncle Ben
Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by jlgreco on Thursday November 07, 2013 @08:02PM (#6693733)
This is exactly what I am talking about. Why do you think that "much was given" to the engineers of the world, but not to others? Engineers may be blessed with talents in engineering, but novelists are blessed with the gift of writing. Why should engineers be expected to engineer things for charitable causes anymore than writers should be expected to use their talents similarly?

Engineering isn't some uniquely special skill; it is one of many. Yet it uniquely is singled out as being a skill that bequeaths the holder with some extra responsibility to society. Engineers don't owe the world any more than anybody else does. (And if you think they do, then why do non-engineers not owe it to the world to become engineers?)

Re:Mythbusting India's Mars Mission by rikacomet on Friday November 08, 2013 @02:30AM (#6694979)
Yes I have read, but in real life.. not everyone is able to accomplish what is expected of him/her. Its not just a matter of choice, but also circumstances.