News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by enoch_r on Sunday October 27, 2013 @11:26PM (#6624935)
Absolutely no discussion of inflation is complete without recognition of the fact that inflation and inflation expectations are at historically low levels[1] right now. Economists aren't arguing that we should inflate our way out of debt--they are arguing that we should return to the historical norm. Of course, it's possible that these economists are secretly just pushing inflation as the "hidden tax" we're all up in arms about. But I find this unlikely. I find it far easier to believe that most economists actually believe that moderate inflation is good for the economy.

Why do economists believe this? Prices are sticky, and some prices are stickier than others. Prices for labor are especially sticky, which means that when growth expectations fall, it's very difficult to decrease wages, which in turn makes it difficult for supply and demand of labor to balance. In the Cliff Note version, inflation helps because people are willing to take real pay cuts when they're disguised as a nominal pay increase. There's a vicious cycle during a recession, where falling output causes the price level to fall, which in turn causes more imbalance in the labor market.

It's important to recognize that the standard argument for inflation has literally nothing to do with "the government printing money to pay for things." Does the US government make money from seignorage? Yes, it does. Is it a significant source of income? No, not in the context of US government spending or revenue--it's roughly $30 billion dollars a year. Are these crazy inflationary economists suggesting policies that would increase seignorage to a significant level? No, they're not.

Finally, most of these arguments are disputed by the so-called "Austrian school" of economics. It's important to recognize that this school is much, much, much more popular with laymen than with professional economists. This doesn't mean that the school's arguments are wrong, but it does raise questions about why the school's arguments which seem so utterly convincing to so many people, don't manage to gain many converts among people who research the subject professionally. Once again, I don't find "conspiracy" a particularly good argument.

[1] http://www.clevelandfed.org/research/data/inflation_expectat...

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by eli_gottlieb on Monday October 28, 2013 @05:19AM (#6625926)
>Finally, most of these arguments are disputed by the so-called "Austrian school" of economics. It's important to recognize that this school is much, much, much more popular with laymen than with professional economists. This doesn't mean that the school's arguments are wrong, but it does raise questions about why the school's arguments which seem so utterly convincing to so many people, don't manage to gain many converts among people who research the subject professionally.

It doesn't automatically mean the Austrian School arguments are wrong, but it does make it much more probable that they are wrong. When trained and educated economists think something is bullshit economics, we should consider it to probably be bullshit.

So why don't we? Because for so many of "us" on Hacker News, deflation is a class interest: "we" hold "our" assets mostly in cash and land. An Austrian-style neofeudal economy thus suits "our" portfolios.

Personally, this reminds me that I need to call Vanguard about my actual investments today. Fuck cash and land, I want my wealth in something productive, and a productive investment will have more to gain from inflation eroding away private debt and a steady pick-up in demand from a stronger labor market than from Austrian-style deflation.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by mbesto on Monday October 28, 2013 @06:16AM (#6626122)
> When trained and educated economists think something is bullshit economics, we should consider it to probably be bullshit.

On the other hand, well-trained and educated economists could perhaps be incentivized to call something bullshit for reasons outside of academia. Like let's say, hmmm, I don't know, for personal gain?

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by eli_gottlieb on Monday October 28, 2013 @06:18AM (#6626130)
Let's imagine what happens in a world where Austrian Economics is true, but economists are lying to the rest of us for personal gain.

First prediction: the economists will tell us that Austrian economics is wrong, but then use the Austrian theories they secretly know are actually true to invest their own assets.

Anyone got an economist's portfolio to look at?

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by mbesto on Monday October 28, 2013 @09:08AM (#6626632)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glenn_Hubbard_(economist)#Insid...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CaXNqGgIc-g

It's also worth noting that economics is arguably a pseudo-science, as the theories themselves cannot be reproduced independently by external parties. So it's really hard to argue whether Austrian economics is "right" or "wrong".

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by eli_gottlieb on Monday October 28, 2013 @11:36AM (#6627545)
I find it pretty hard to count him as evidence for anything, considering that he comes from the supply-side school. They're kind of known for being paid propagandists for particular business and political interests. Hell, he doesn't even seem to use Austrian Economics, or any other economics, himself, if he mixes himself up with entirely conventional financial firms like Blackrock and MetLife.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by nl on Monday October 28, 2013 @06:14AM (#6626114)
Upvoted, but with a note that you are wrong about deflation being good for land owners. Generally speaking land is a good hedge against inflation.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by eli_gottlieb on Monday October 28, 2013 @06:16AM (#6626119)
On third thought, I partially retract the comment about land. I've been confusing credit-backed conventional real estate markets with cash-backed land investing.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by Retric on Monday October 28, 2013 @05:53AM (#6626039)
Inflation does not hurt land values only cash and cash equivalents like debt and fixed income annuity's.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by eli_gottlieb on Monday October 28, 2013 @06:15AM (#6626115)
That would be a pretty good point, except that the real-estate market is currently gunked up with private debt. Eroding private debt with inflation can unlock a whole lot of markets that some asset holders don't want unlocked, because they're using the assets as a store of value (which can be transformed into other people's debt) rather than as a means of production.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by dredmorbius on Monday November 04, 2013 @02:41PM (#6670675)
"we" hold "our" assets mostly in cash and land.

I suspect more HN readers likely hold their assets in future income and earning potential. Which is fairly immune to inflation (as it rises with prices).

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by cotsuka on Sunday October 27, 2013 @11:40PM (#6624980)
Austrian school not holding much weight with academics is like wondering why creationism doesn't hold much weight with academics. Lots of things can be explained with creationism, but it doesn't mean it's right. Many Austrian economists rail against the use of quantitative models and such. But without them, how can you measure the efficacy of your policies? Faith that the policy works... But most academics like to be able to test things.

I'm also not saying creationism isn't right. I can't prove anything.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by 7Figures2Commas on Monday October 28, 2013 @12:53AM (#6625221)
> ...the use of quantitative models and such. But without them, how can you measure the efficacy of your policies?

Here's a better question: if you measure the efficacy of your policies and find that they have not achieved the intended effect, on what would you base the extension and expansion of those policies? Faith? Insanity?

The reason I ask is that a few months ago, two senior economists at the SF and NY Feds published a letter, "How Stimulatory Are Large-Scale Asset Purchases?"[1]. Their conclusion:

"Asset purchase programs like QE2 appear to have, at best, moderate effects on economic growth and inflation."

Emphasis mine. For reference, QE2 involved $600 billion of Treasury purchases.

[1] http://www.frbsf.org/economic-research/publications/economic...

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by jswinghammer on Monday October 28, 2013 @12:59AM (#6625242)
Right. There's no way to disprove theories that are tested in this way. Proponents of the theories being tested could always say that the attempt wasn't large enough, that the officials didn't believe enough in the policy, that the gods were angry that quarter, etc., etc. At some point you need a sound theory to draw back on that does not require this sort of testing to stand on its' own.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by greeneggs on Monday October 28, 2013 @12:04PM (#6627740)
What is your argument exactly? You say, "If you measure the efficacy of your policies and find that they have not achieved the intended effect, on what would you base the extension and expansion of those policies?" But then your example, QE2, achieved the intended effect. As you say, it had a moderate effect on economic growth, and with only a moderate effect on inflation. Nobody claimed it would be a magic bullet. Monetary policy without coordinated fiscal policy can only have moderate effects.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by eli_gottlieb on Monday October 28, 2013 @05:28AM (#6625959)
And strangely enough, nobody outside of neoliberal bank-interest lobbyists has actually wanted quantitative easing. Keynesians want the labor market and consumer demand propped up, social democrats want infrastructure investment towards those ends, and radicals are looking for a debt jubilee.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by judk on Monday October 28, 2013 @11:57AM (#6627691)
Indeed, the term Keynsian has been uselessly spread to cover both New Deal style stimulus spending and printing money and giving it to the banks.

The two are not the same, they are connected only by the theory of trickle down Reaganomics.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by jswinghammer on Monday October 28, 2013 @12:51AM (#6625213)
So far the predictive value of these models has been zero and Austrians tend to have a much clearer understanding of what is happening on a macro level. That's been my experience over the last decade or so. After awhile it helps to notice such things.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by ekianjo on Sunday October 27, 2013 @11:58PM (#6625039)
Academics being funded by Keynesian politicians has surely nothing to do with it.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by TreyS on Monday October 28, 2013 @12:15AM (#6625107)
Anecdotal but I would imagine it's similar in reputable state schools in red states: Texas has very few Keynesians yet economics professors at the University of Texas are overwhelmingly Keynesian.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by jswinghammer on Monday October 28, 2013 @12:46AM (#6625192)
Virtually everyone you encounter in the government subscribes to Keynesian economics to the degree that they understand anything at all about economics. When economics is explained in the media at all it is through the lens of Keynesian economics.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by eli_gottlieb on Monday October 28, 2013 @06:21AM (#6626139)
Yes, well, Keynesianism is an important piece of the neoclassical synthesis. To be droll: "mainstream theory is mainstream."
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by tzs on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:58AM (#6625429)
University of Chicago and the other "freshwater" schools show that non-Keynesian schools can get funded.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by mistermann on Sunday October 27, 2013 @11:53PM (#6625021)
I'm not sure how this casts doubt on the Austrians or supports the Keynesians, or vice versa.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by cotsuka on Sunday October 27, 2013 @11:58PM (#6625037)
I'm saying calling something Austrian or Keynesian is inherently political. We should come up with economic models, whether they're Austrian, Keynesian, alien, or dumb, test them against data to see if they hold up, and refine until we get close. Aka, what scientists do.

Great article the other day from Krugman about this very topic. Economics might be a science, but economists are not being scientists about it. http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/10/21/maybe-economics-...

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by mistermann on Monday October 28, 2013 @12:28AM (#6625136)
You can make models all day, and I think it should be done in the pursuit of knowledge, but to imply these models can accurately predict behavior is a bit naive IMHO.

Economics in a globally integrated economy are of similar complexity as weather, if not worse.

Keynesians have been driving the bus for quite some time now, if they have it all figured out as many seem to imply, why do so many things (deficits and debt plus extreme government interference in the bond market, as just a few examples) seem to continue to deteriorate.

I don't know if Austrians would do a better job, but to look down one's nose at them seems a bit delusional to me.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by bermanoid on Monday October 28, 2013 @04:31AM (#6625796)
Austrians, for the most part, make no testable predictions. They essentially reject math as a tool, and insist that unless you implement their preferred systems 100%, then they won't work at all, and then explain all observed failures by claiming that it would have worked better if things had been pushed further.

Even if they're on to something, they don't give the unconvinced very much to work with. Most of their arguments push every economic dial in a single direction no matter the current state of the world, which says to me that there's no way that approach could lead to a reasonably balanced economy.

I think econ is messed up in all sorts of ways, but I don't think the Austrian school has the answers, they strike me as far too religious and unbalanced to be believable, and quite frankly I see way too many words and far too little math coming out of their camp to buy any of it. Every other science leans on math to great benefit, I refuse to believe that econ is somehow the one exception where it's not useful, especially since at its core it's about optimizing certain numbers.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by mistermann on Monday October 28, 2013 @07:36AM (#6626329)
I'd suggest any unwillingness to make specific mathematically testable predictions is correct acknowledgement that the field is too complicated to do so. As I've said, you can make a model and tweak it by picking and choosing inputs until you can make it successfully back test with historic data, but any comprehensive correctness is likely tenuous if not specious.

Having a complex model that appears correct but is actually wrong is quite dangerous. Observe long term charts (debt, debt to gdp, etc) in various countries throughout the world. We're told by economists and the federal reserve in very serious tones using large words and complex models that everything is all figured out, but the charts continue to get worse. Even during the glorious Clinton years of supposed robust surpluses, debt increased every year. Hindsight being 20/20, we now know we were just in a bubble.

Austrians speak in broad principles rather than specific mathematical formulas, and in my opinion, their broad (vague) predictions of what will happen if you do <x> are far closer to honest reality than any other camp.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by shard972 on Monday October 28, 2013 @06:28AM (#6626160)
> They essentially reject math as a tool, and insist that unless you implement their preferred systems 100%, then they won't work at all

What? What Austrian has ever said that?

Austrian's very rarely deal with absolutes in the real world and mainly deal with relative analysis (If you go with X bad policy, these negative things can occur).

> then they won't work at all, and then explain all observed failures by claiming that it would have worked better if things had been pushed further.

What occurrences are you referencing when an Austrian got policy control?

> and quite frankly I see way too many words and far too little math coming out of their camp to buy any of it.

They reject the idea that maths is a useful tool in economics due to it being a social science.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by sien on Monday October 28, 2013 @02:20AM (#6625503)
Economics forecasting is harder than the weather.

How do you build an economic model that can deal with the introduction of mobile phones? What about some new energy source that cut the cost of energy dramatically? What about the fall of Communism?

Also the weather doesn't have expectations that react to the weather forecast. Economic models get incorporated into people's expectations and this feedback can actually alter the economy. If you read up on The Phillip's Curve and stagflation you can see an example of this interaction.

Weather is actually decent for forecasting. You can constantly get new data to verify your model against. If you are forecasting for a week you have hundreds of tests to do per week.

Any forecasting where the predictions matter over the scale of decades is harder because the time span means you will have less data available for validation.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by jswinghammer on Monday October 28, 2013 @12:50AM (#6625206)
The basic problem is that the models are not testable in the way you think they might be. Economics is inherently a deductive discipline and anything you can think of as coming from economics that is valuable in any way came from someone's head and not from testing models. Economists get into trouble by trying to pretend they are physicists.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by dwaltrip on Monday October 28, 2013 @05:41AM (#6625998)
Economics is not a science. You can't test hypotheses rigorously. Which makes these debates 100x harder.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by nl on Monday October 28, 2013 @06:36AM (#6626183)
This is true, but it is also true for other sciences (eg meteorology, mentioned elsewhere).

I'm not sure what the solution to the untestable hypothesis problem is.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by phyalow on Monday October 28, 2013 @02:46AM (#6625554)
Krugman<-Spew
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by kriro on Monday October 28, 2013 @09:04AM (#6626617)
Austrians distinguish between theory and "history" and Hayek has argued that you can at best make "trend predictions" due to the uncertainty of the world.

I do not understand why there seem to be no Austrian quantitative models and the like as part of the "history" (bad name as it includes both application of theory towards historical periods and predictions). Predicting the future is an entrepreneurial act in the Austrian sense and if the Austrian model is good/better one would expect better predictions from someone working from these foundations.

I agree that there's quite a few laymen and not all that many pure Austrian theorists (and the few that exist seem to be working in management science and the like not in economics).

I'm not sure what defines a proper science in the science theoretical sense these days but if you take something like Lakatos (which is basically what I'm roughly comfortable with don't know about newer developments) I'm not sure mainstream and Austrian economics would differ all that much (probably both non-science by his criteria)

The most tilting thing about Austrians in general (and I'd certainly say I sympathize with their core ideas alas I don't have enough time to investigate properly) is that they attack "mainstream economics" based on a view that is pretty far removed from current mainstream economics. Most are stuck at thinking "ZOMG Keynes" at least I haven't met all that many that knew what a DSGE model is for example.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by mistermann on Sunday October 27, 2013 @11:43PM (#6624990)
I don't see the similarity.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by cotsuka on Sunday October 27, 2013 @11:45PM (#6624999)
Just edited my comment for clarity.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by TreyS on Monday October 28, 2013 @12:09AM (#6625082)
"it does raise questions about why the school's arguments which seem so utterly convincing to so many people, don't manage to gain many converts among people who research the subject professionally."

I think it would be easier to convince people with no physics knowledge that a bowling ball falls faster than a golf ball. Intuitively, it seems that bowling ball should fall faster. Austrian economics seems to follow a similar thread. It's more intuitive and easier to grasp than the economics taught in the textbooks, but doesn't have much data to validate it.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by ef4 on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:25AM (#6625339)
> data to validate it.

You've accidentally illustrated the disconnect. Because the fundamental disagreement between the Austrians and the more mainstream academic schools of thought is epistemological. Data can only settle differences when both sides agree on the epistemological ground rules.

I have an advanced science degree. I'm not afraid of math, and I've plowed through Keynes "General Theory". It doesn't come close to passing the sniff test for basic scientific rigor. It can't.

Economists can't control their variables, and they have no way of knowing what their error bars are. They can make empirical models that work most of the time, but they can't know what regime those models are valid for, and where the breaking point is. There is every indication that economic systems are chaotic, and prone to sudden discontinuous phase changes.

Worse, unlike a chaotic system like weather, the underlying primitives are not at all primitive. We can say very precisely how a cubic meter of air (for example) behaves under widely varying conditions. This is why our weather and climate models keep getting better -- you can use more processing power and better algorithms and use the basic laws of physics to get the right answers, despite a system of incredible complexity.

But economists have nothing like that to work with. There is no meaningful sense in which we have good statistical models of human economic behavior. We have very limited snapshots, that are invalidated the moment customs or conditions change beyond the originally observed regime.

All of this means that you can't even build empirical models unless you have a preexisting, a priori theory of economic cause and effect, and you have no experiments strong enough to falsify bad a priori assumptions. The Austrian argument is simply that all economists are actually engaged in a priori theorizing, despite their protestations claiming to be empiricists.

I find the assertion that the Austrian school is more "intuitive" and accessible to be silly. Nobody who has actually tried to study the primary texts would claim so. It takes a pretty strong background in philosophy just to follow the first several chapters of Human Action -- precisely because they focus on epistemological issues.

It doesn't require a conspiracy theory to explain the popularity of econometrics. Lots of social sciences spent the whole 20th century pretending to be as rigorous as physics and chemistry, to bask in the reflected glow of progress. Nobody likes to admit that their field has no experimental lodestone, and so drifts along as a popularity contest.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by eli_gottlieb on Monday October 28, 2013 @06:25AM (#6626149)
The whole problem with Austrian economics is that they reject scientific epistemology entirely by waving a big flag on which is written, "Human Free Will makes everything unpredictable!"

And then they go ahead and make predictions anyway, out of sheer ideology.

If Keynes is epistemologically worthless, fine, but so are von Mises and Hayek. More so, in fact, because they adamantly refuse to employ an empirical method.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by ef4 on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:57PM (#6628544)
> "Human Free Will makes everything unpredictable!"

Well in practice it currently does. That's not to say that in principle we won't eventually develop a real quantitative science of human behavior -- but it's going to require some major advances in neurobiology.

> And then they go ahead and make predictions anyway, out of sheer ideology.

Yes, but the Austrian response is that all other economists are doing the same, while deceiving themselves that they have no ideology at all. So most economists' axioms and deductions remain unexamined and unchallenged.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by jswinghammer on Monday October 28, 2013 @12:44AM (#6625188)
Most Austrians understand mainstream economic theory much better than mainstream economists understand Austrian theories. Evidence being Krugman's disastrous attempts to discredit Austrian Business Cycle Theory. It isn't a perfect theory but Krugman can't even explain it let alone criticize it.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by tzs on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:49AM (#6625404)
> I think it would be easier to convince people with no physics knowledge that a bowling ball falls faster than a golf ball. Intuitively, it seems that bowling ball should fall faster.

Do you have any reason to believe that their intuition is wrong? If the bowling ball and golf ball were both spheres, so they differed only in size and mass, the bowling ball would have a higher terminal velocity. The golf ball's dimples reduce its air resistance, and I have no idea how to calculate if they reduce it enough to let it have the same terminal velocity as the bowling ball.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by TreyS on Monday October 28, 2013 @11:20AM (#6627450)
Perhaps I should have used a different example, but the main point was that Galileo's supposed Leaning Tower experiment (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galileo's_Leaning_Tower_of_Pisa...) is counter intuitive and it's harder to convince laypeople of counter intuitive ideas especially when the "competing" idea is more intuitive.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by clarky07 on Monday October 28, 2013 @02:54AM (#6625576)
there is no data to validate either model. there are far far too many variables, and you can't test both of them side by side by definition. If one fails in a certain environment, you can't say the other would have succeeded. We've been doing keynes for quite awhile now, and it has mostly been going poorly. There is no way to say that doing the opposite would have gone better though. It might have, it might have gone the same, it might have done worse. We don't know, and we can't know, because we can't go back to 2008 and try it.

We could switch tomorrow, and again it wouldn't matter if it succeeded or failed. You couldn't say that doing the opposite would have a different total outcome.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by ra on Sunday October 27, 2013 @11:38PM (#6624972)
My (layman's) understanding of it is that central banks seek to keep inflation within a target range; in Australia this is between 2 and 3 percent [1].

The primary tool to manage inflation is interest rates, however interest rate movements also have other effects, positive and negative, so it's not as simple as turning on a tap.

It's important not to let inflation get too high because that makes new investment unattractive, the cost of living go up, and retirement savings worth less.

[1] http://www.rba.gov.au/inflation/

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by cotsuka on Sunday October 27, 2013 @11:55PM (#6625026)
The other important thing is to reduce uncertainty as much as possible. You don't want your inflation rates to bounce around like crazy from day to day. Instead, you'd like to be able to keep them within certain limits so people can plan ahead to the future.

If I'm not sure what inflation will be day-to-day, I can't make an accurate prediction as to whether I should save my money or spend it.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by sien on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:05AM (#6625262)
And if inflation is really high and fluctuating everyone makes the decision to never save in cash which isn't healthy.

But a bit of low level inflation is generally seen as a good thing. The questions over the efficacy of monetary policy as a stimulus tool in all situations is certainly questionable though.

It's also worth noting that independent central banks are a fairly new thing. Inflation levels used to be set by politicians who would notoriously let short term interest over ride price stability.

The Bundesbank was the first independent bank drawing lessons from the horrors of hyper-inflation. Most (all?) developed countries now follow that model.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by nhaehnle on Monday October 28, 2013 @05:25AM (#6625952)
For your last point, I do wonder. How does high inflation make investment unattractive? It should do the opposite, since holding cash is very unattractive under high inflation.

As to the cost of living going up: in nominal terms, sure. But it depends on the type of inflation. Usually wages grow to keep up with inflation, so in the end, it's a wash.

I'm sure there are costs associated with extremely high inflation, e.g. restaurants having to print new menus all the time. However, I'm not aware of any serious work being done to quantify that effect. It seems that even at rates of inflation that we would consider very high - let's say 15% anually - those costs would still be irrelevant.

Volatile inflation would probably hurt more than merely high inflation as long as the latter is stable.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by ra on Monday October 28, 2013 @08:04AM (#6626411)
Well, simply put, we don't live in a single economic regime.

If inflation is much higher in one country than another, then exports from the country with lower inflation will be more competitive on the global market.

Inflation also alters consumer behaviour.

If inflation is very high people tend to buy goods way in advance for fear of further price increases. This "bringing forward" of consumer spending means less will be consumed in the months ahead.

The general uncertainty created by very high inflation undermines business confidence and reduces investment. Basically, you're money is better off in another country where inflation is lower.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by nhaehnle on Monday October 28, 2013 @10:00AM (#6626935)
If inflation is much higher in one country than another, then exports from the country with lower inflation will be more competitive on the global market.

Depends on what the inflation actually does. For global trade, it's only relative prices that matter. If relative prices did not change in the inflation, the exchange rate would adjust and that's all that would happen. This is because exchange markets react much faster (orders of magnitude) than export/import markets.

If the inflation reduces the real wages of workers in the country, then high inflation actually means that the country's exports will become more competitive. (But the workers in that country might not like it... so much for the benefits of "competitiveness").

As to the question about international investments, let me put the caveat that most of what people talk in that arena is nonsense. That said, even accepting some of the rather absurd premises: it is still a question of relative prices. If you have 0% inflation domestically, but also 0% interest, then perhaps you may want to put that money in an account abroad where you have 5% inflation but get 8% interest.

Again, it is not the high inflation itself that makes investment unattractive. Volatile inflation is another beast, but stable and high inflation has so far not been shown to be a problem.

Also note that in your last paragraph, you simply rephrased your original claim without giving an argument.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by 7Figures2Commas on Monday October 28, 2013 @12:41AM (#6625178)
Here's a question: how many "professional" economists sounded the alarm about the last bubble?
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by rz2k on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:59AM (#6625433)
Clearly meant as a rhetorical question, what do you really mean by it?

How many auditors caught the problems with Worldcom, Enron or Tyco? Extremely small minorities did, and yet people don't question whether 'accounting works, but they may question the incentives for companies to provide honest books to auditors, and the compensation awarded independent auditors.

Let's say that you need someone to think that it will be sunny tomorrow, and you believe that it will be sunny tomorrow. The meteorologist's forecast is for 20% chance of a thunderstorm. You tell your investor that meteorology is not a science. The real probability of a thunderstorm, given the conditions and the most accurate model possible is 18%, or maybe 4% or 93%.

What does any of this mean? Have you ever heard someone say that economics is not a science? Unfailingly, it comes from someone who has a bias toward a specific conclusion, and has no method explaining how they arrived at their conclusion other than something like "common sense".

There was a renaissance for economic data collection in the wake of the 1929 crash, and the collapse of classical economics (How could the same capital equipment and human capital in 1932 produce about 48% of the industrial output it had in early 1929?). That was when most of the data collection programs were created, and the industrial classifications that were only revised again in the late 90s and early 2000s.

It is about as difficult to imagine the world of 7B people without modern economics as it is without integrated circuits or container ships or antibiotics or industrial and agricultural advances of the past 70 years.

Often in medicine, advances have met strong resistance from the respected people and overwhelming expert consensus (a very long list including how to prevent Pellagra, Yellow Fever, stomach ulcers, etc), and yet that is not a sane argument for abandoning medical research funding, condemning the practice of medicine as unscientific, or for choosing folk or "traditional" remedies instead.

And yet, that is what has happened over the past six years. To understand the value of this proposition regarding inflation requires an understanding of the mechanisms and justifications they describe, and then an attempt to assess the most likely outcomes of a course of action. In other words engagement, not people throwing up their hands and stating that it is impossible to choose any actions as better than any other, as though defeatism and fatalism are wise.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by shard972 on Monday October 28, 2013 @02:42AM (#6625544)
> Clearly meant as a rhetorical question, what do you really mean by it?

I think he means, out of the establishment economists (eg: Federal reserve members, Columnists, Government economists, etc.)

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by vinceguidry on Monday October 28, 2013 @12:56AM (#6625236)
How would an economist get information about a bubble? Magic? Until they burst, anything you could say about them is speculative. Everyone talks about how education is the next big one, but education and real estate are such different markets they might as well be on different planets. It's impossible to know what's going to happen until it happens.

The housing bubble caught a lot of really smart people off guard. Housing was overpriced, but it's been overpriced for years. You had to have special, insider information about just what sorts of crazy tricks were being pulled behind the scenes, and you had to understand that it wasn't sustainable and what would happen once people started defaulting. Looks easy in hindsight, but you go out there and try to predict what's going to happen in two years.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by 7Figures2Commas on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:23AM (#6625325)
Interesting comment. If I am to understand it correctly, and follow it to its logical conclusion:

1. Economists have no tools for studying the topics that they're supposed to study, such as asset prices.

2. They are unable to make predictions because doing so would be "speculative."

3. Because we can't know what is going to happen until it happens, we might as well do away with professional economists because they can provide no input of practical (read: forward-looking) use. They can only try to explain why what happened happened.

As for the requirement that one have "special, insider information" to have predicted the housing bubble, this is simply not true. There were a number of people from a variety of professions who recognized the housing bubble. One, Robert Shiller, to answer my own question, is an economist who also predicted the .com collapse[1].

There were also politicians[2] and market participants who predicted a collapse. Some of the latter, like John Paulson, who made billions betting against subprime, didn't publicly promote their beliefs, but others, like Peter Schiff[3], did.

[1] http://www.nytimes.com/2005/08/21/business/yourmoney/21real....

[2] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mnuoHx9BINc

[3] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jj8rMwdQf6k

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by noloqy on Monday October 28, 2013 @02:50AM (#6625566)
According to the first article, Shiller said in 1996 that stock prices were at irrationally high levels. In 2005, he predicted a real estate bubble. Noticing that a bubble is developing, I would say, is the relatively easy part; predicting when it will collapse is the difficult part. As Keynes said, "Markets can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent", so there is limited value in betting against bubbles. Paulson may have made billions, but undoubtedly there have been people that followed similar shortly before he did, but lost it all. The reason we know Paulson is because of the survivorship bias.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by natrius on Monday October 28, 2013 @02:47AM (#6625556)
The vast majority of economics is about how to avoid past mistakes, not necessarily how to avoid making new ones. This doesn't mean the science isn't valuable. There are plenty of terrible mistakes I hope we never make again.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by gruseom on Monday October 28, 2013 @02:27AM (#6625520)
Dean Baker called the housing bubble as early as 2002:

http://www.cepr.net/index.php/reports/the-run-up-in-home-pri...

By 2004 he even sponsored a $1000 contest for whoever could make a good case that there wasn't a bubble:

http://www.nytimes.com/2004/01/18/business/personal-business...

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by clarky07 on Monday October 28, 2013 @02:59AM (#6625596)
That means he was at least partly if not mostly wrong. As far as markets go, you have to be right in both direction and timing. He was 4-5 years early, and frankly 2002 prices weren't that insane. Especially compared to 2006-2007 prices. He was really early, and if bet against housing at that point, he likely went bankrupt before the crash.

That's really neither here nor there though. What's the famous saying, something to the effect of "economists have predicted 10 of the last 3 recessions". Somebody is always calling for a crash, and somebody is always calling for a bull market. After the fact you can always find someone who was right about it, but that doesn't mean they were right about the why, and it doesn't mean they are going to be right about the next thing.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by gruseom on Monday October 28, 2013 @03:33AM (#6625667)
That means he was at least partly if not mostly wrong.

I don't agree. You'd have to look at his reasons for calling it the way he did.

Your "betting" objection is a red herring. To identify a bubble does not require predicting exactly when it will pop.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by clarky07 on Monday October 28, 2013 @10:18AM (#6627048)
Look at my comment above. Prices weren't even close to bubble levels. They were lower than anything we've seen post crash.

Also I was clearly not talking about "betting" but rather investing. It's just not useful for someone to say something is happening far before it actually is happening. Perhaps he could have said the conditions are right for a bubble to start in the near future. In which case the correct play would be to make a lot of money in housing in 2002. There was no bubble then though.

http://us.spindices.com/indices/real-estate/sp-case-shiller-...

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by eli_gottlieb on Monday October 28, 2013 @05:22AM (#6625941)
>He was 4-5 years early, and frankly 2002 prices weren't that insane.

Define "weren't that insane", please. Were they sane when compared with the incomes being leveraged to buy them? Compared with some shortage of supply that would naturally push prices up?

Because the story I've heard is that the mid-late 2000s housing bubble was just the peak of a vast secular inflation in real-estate values that had little to no tie to the actual feasibility of housing purchases for real families, and was fuelled largely by speculative lending.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by clarky07 on Monday October 28, 2013 @10:12AM (#6627009)
Well, in 2002 the prices were not even remotely close to the peak, and they were lower than anything we've seen post crash to this point. I guess you could try to argue that we are still in a bubble, but I don't think most would agree. Now, suggesting things needed a correction in 2002 might have been reasonable, but it was bubble like yet.

http://us.spindices.com/indices/real-estate/sp-case-shiller-...

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by davidw on Monday October 28, 2013 @04:54AM (#6625849)
They're journalists more than economists, but the folks at The Economist were talking about a housing bubble in the US and elsewhere.

Also, this kind of article adds little to this site: it's basically round 4348388282998271193 of "mainstream economics vs Austrians and other heterodox schools of thought" on the internet. It's all been said.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by jayfuerstenberg on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:25AM (#6625338)
The more interesting question is: How many "professional" economists lost their jobs, or at least the esteem of their industry, for not seeing the housing bubble?
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by elchief on Monday October 28, 2013 @03:00AM (#6625597)
Krugman, Schiller, Roubini were the prominent ones.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by hannibal5 on Monday October 28, 2013 @12:31PM (#6627908)
There was long main article in the Economist about housing bubble few years before the bubble bursted. I remember reading it and being somewhat worried because arguments were convincing. I then forgot it because it was not in other news.

It would be nice to find it again. The issue in question had picture of green? man/gigant weighted down with heavy weights.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by Mikeb85 on Monday October 28, 2013 @10:49AM (#6627241)
It wouldn't surprise me if many did. Certainly anyone with a little common sense would have known that when housing prices rise so dramatically so quickly, it can't possibly be sustainable (even if in the long run prices return to that level).

But as is the case in all bull markets, the naysayers are always drowned out by the crowd. Voicing a contrarian opinion is always frowned upon.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by enoch_r on Monday October 28, 2013 @08:25AM (#6626474)
Economics is not about predicting the movements of asset prices. In fact, the unpredictability of asset prices is one of the more fundamental findings of economics. Criticizing economics for not identifying a bubble is a little like complaining that physicists haven't built us a faster-than-light spaceship.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by gaius on Monday October 28, 2013 @04:34AM (#6625803)
Here in the UK, Gordon Brown claims he foresaw it all. Mysteriously tho', as the Chancellor of the Exchequer of the then-4th-largest economy in the world, he did nothing whatsoever about it.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by jswinghammer on Monday October 28, 2013 @12:54AM (#6625228)
Zero unless they are rewriting history to claim they saw it 6 months to a year out when it was obvious to anyone who wasn't drunk on soaring home and equity prices.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by jayfuerstenberg on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:19AM (#6625311)
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by jswinghammer on Monday October 28, 2013 @07:01AM (#6626245)
He's an Austrian economist and yes he like all of them saw this coming in 2001 and maybe earlier.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by judk on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:35AM (#6625370)
That was immediately before the crash.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by dangrossman on Monday October 28, 2013 @04:42AM (#6625825)
The book he wrote about the coming crash was published by Wiley in February 2007, which means he must've been formed the idea some years before to have written it early enough for that publication date. A quick Google search turned up CNBC interviews with him in 2005 and 2006 about the topic.
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by shard972 on Monday October 28, 2013 @05:10AM (#6625892)
This has him here as far back as 2006 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2I0QN-FYkpw
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by syshax on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:11AM (#6625284)
Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by hannibal5 on Monday October 28, 2013 @12:35PM (#6627948)
Many.

Here is multiple lists with sources:

http://investorhome.com/predicted.htm

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by newman314 on Monday October 28, 2013 @04:20AM (#6625767)
Inflation is fine as long as salaries maintain an appropriate growth ratio. I see too many companies take advantage of the relative uncertainty of the last 5-7 years as an opportunity to continue to eek out profits at the expense of compensating the average worker.

More and more I am convinced that a purely capitalistic model for companies does not work.

Re:In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps by judk on Monday October 28, 2013 @01:11PM (#6628197)
Cutting real wages is in no way the intended desirable effect of inflation. Inflation is a disincentive to sittin on imaginary cash, am incentive to productive activity/investment.

In an inflationary stimulus theory, wages rise with inflation, and cash-rich spend cash to move a worker to produce.