1. Economists have no tools for studying the topics that they're supposed to study, such as asset prices.
2. They are unable to make predictions because doing so would be "speculative."
3. Because we can't know what is going to happen until it happens, we might as well do away with professional economists because they can provide no input of practical (read: forward-looking) use. They can only try to explain why what happened happened.
As for the requirement that one have "special, insider information" to have predicted the housing bubble, this is simply not true. There were a number of people from a variety of professions who recognized the housing bubble. One, Robert Shiller, to answer my own question, is an economist who also predicted the .com collapse[1].
There were also politicians[2] and market participants who predicted a collapse. Some of the latter, like John Paulson, who made billions betting against subprime, didn't publicly promote their beliefs, but others, like Peter Schiff[3], did.
[1] http://www.nytimes.com/2005/08/21/business/yourmoney/21real....
The housing bubble caught a lot of really smart people off guard. Housing was overpriced, but it's been overpriced for years. You had to have special, insider information about just what sorts of crazy tricks were being pulled behind the scenes, and you had to understand that it wasn't sustainable and what would happen once people started defaulting. Looks easy in hindsight, but you go out there and try to predict what's going to happen in two years.