I'm not sure nicer file copying is worth being pokes in the eye by Metro. Faster boot and power management sound interesting, but I would really need independent benchmarks before I would trust any such claims. A 5 seconds or less decrease in boot time (like http://www.zdnet.com/windows-8-vs-windows-7-benchmarked_p2-7...) would not be worth it for me. A significant power boost (+10%) for a laptop might be worth being poked in the eye, if said 10% can be gained while I use the computer (ie, not while sleeping/idling/suspended). For desktop however, power management is not really a feature Im looking for.
Well, let's say you can shave 10 seconds off of the boot time. Multiply that by five million users and thats 50 million seconds, every single day. Over a year, that's probably dozens of lifetimes. So if you make it boot ten seconds faster, you've saved a dozen lives. That's really worth it, don't you think?
The items are actually useful for administration/etc.
To me, win+r is all that is needed. If I can't remember the name of an msc winkey + start typing still works ok.
The fact that the metro start screen exists on the server OS is deplorable.
So, 8.1 comes out and here we have a new account (6 days old) with a glowing review. Pardon me if I'm a little skeptical. I've been had before.
[1] http://envoy510.wordpress.com/2013/07/19/windows-8-worst-win...
There's an alternative to your theory that requires fewer assumptions and only requires reasoning based on the types of people involved in the discussions you mention. People who like Windows 8 were comfortable using it in new ways, people who didn't want to change didn't like it. The people who don't want to change still don't want to change and so of course they are still complaining. Me? I'm tired of debating people on whether or not Windows 8 was an improvement over 7 or not. Usually it comes down to dogmatic beliefs over how they think Windows should work and those beliefs are at odds with how Microsoft thinks it should work. Why argue with dogmatism?
As evidence for the dogmatism of this belief, look no further than your own comment. You simply cannot believe anyone would think Windows 8 was good, or that Windows 8.1 is good.
You and the House stenographer would get along.
I'm fully comfortable changing how my desktop works. I've used Windows 98, Windows XP, Windows 7, and even Windows Vista on other computers. I've administrated Windows Server editions from 2000 to 2012. I've also used several Linux distros with varying desktop environments. I'm now using Debian Wheezy, after primarily using Windows environments my entire life.
I still say Windows 8 doesn't solve any problems that I have, and introduces several. That is why I don't use it and don't recommend it. The split-brain nature of the operating system makes it close to unusable, for both myself and a number of non-technical people I know.
Microsoft has been caught planting shills in online communities for 20 years.
http://web.archive.org/web/19980112192836/http://www.pjprime...
Go read the blog entry and tell me that's about change. You can't look at that large list of problems and tell me it's my problem.
No doubt that you may well be an outlier. Every piece of software has groups of people who use it differently, including some that are infuriated by it. That doesn't mean that everyone that posts a positive experience is a paid shill.
You know why I'm not on Reddit supporting Windows 8 any more? Windows 8 works for me -- it works _fantastically._
I'm a little preoccupied with enjoying my computer; I see no reason to surround myself with a stream of negativity about an OS that has worked flawlessly for me.
The bitching at it reminds me of people using Gnome 2 or at least complaining how great it was. It's people hating change. Gnome 2 is crap when it comes to usability and configurability. Its only advantage was speed.. but hey, Windows 2000 might be fast on today's machines as well.
And while it might look sketchy it's not a glowing review but rather a list of configuration options that user changed in order to avoid metro as much as possible.
I've used every single version of Windows since 3.1. I didn't like Vista because it had huge performance issues. I've never really bitched about Windows because I've always liked it. So, you couldn't be further from the truth.
Your post, not so much in the 'value-add' department.
Edit: Well damnit. For that matter, neither is mine :(
Mustn't feed the trolls. One never comes out ahead.
Someone would complain about the start screen or badly integrated metro apps and the chorus would start up about how anyone who didn't like the new menus and hot corners were luddites terrified of change. Absolutely ridiculous.
It was a surprising change of tone from how Windows users usually discuss things. The anger is usually reserved for inexplicable changes which don't work. The defenders usually shrug it off with a "Well, Vista always worked for me." Windows is not normally the sort of thing which attracts the sort of angry defensive passion which Mac or Linux users used to display.
So I can see how the abrupt change of tone would make people suspicious.
Because the majority of the initial complaints were - "start screen ugly, metro apps unusable" - I was busy answering - start screen not that intrusive if you use shortcuts, metro apps uninstallable.
But the real problems blossomed for me much later - the inability of GFWL to work on windows 8 so I cannot play the legally bought Bulletstorm, Arkham City and Assylum, some software working weirdly (Stroke it), the phantom french keyboard that appears from time to time (don't ask), the general locked-ness of the metro runtime (I was insisting close to a year ago that they cannot be that stupid and will just open the platform), problems with Cisco VPN, and so on.
So for me W8 turned from different to terrible gradually.
To be honest I'm not enamoured with windows 8.1. It's just marginally better for me than windows 7 was and I'm trying to spread some help for those who will be picking it up today who will no doubt expect it to work a bit like windows 7.
If I was a shill, surely I'd be saying "metro is fucking awesome!" and other such things which it clearly isn't based on the fact I want rid of it.
I've got 15 years of UNIX and Linux experience as well and would rather have my head in an old Sun workstation than this shit, but it's not where the world is for me unfortunately.
Yeah, that's what you'd do. You won't try and be subtle at all. I agree, you are no shill.
Look, I don't know if you are or not. Your post seemed odd to me, especially coming so quickly after the release of 8.1.
There is a CLI option but the GUI is gone.
But you don't need backup since you have SkyDrive now ;)
Oh what a fallacy this is. Cloud storage is at best a backup solution for some personal files you don't value too much, but in no way a replacement for a full-system backup.
1. This is probably a matter of running gpedit.msc (IIRC) and then enable disable lock screen somewhere.
2. This might be an option in inetcpl.cpl, perhaps under Advanced?
3. Task bar properties? Not sure if the "boot to desktop" option sits there, though.
4. That's probably using Windows Setup, so appwiz.cpl and select "enable/disable features" or something like that.
Asking because people often resort to me for their Windows problems even though I don't run it myself.
Look up the File History feature. It's essentially Time Machine for Windows.
http://www.hanselman.com/blog/Windows8Step0TurnOnContinuousB...
http://kitty.9bis.net ( http://www.9bis.net/kitty/ )
Is this the right website for what you were referring to?
If you mean launching apps with Winkey+number then it isn't new and is most definitely in Windows 7.
To do a full clean install on my Lenovo T400 with Samsung 840 Pro SSD off a fairly old Sandisk Cruzer took less than 10 minutes.
If you don't like Metro, it's pretty easy to get rid of now but not entirely (it occasionally pokes you in the eye). My setup guide:
1. Use group policy editor to get rid of lock screen.
2. Set IE to open tiles on desktop.
3. Set start menu to display apps only and turn off hot corners. Then set to boot to desktop.
4. Uninstall all the metro apps that come with it.
You will still get the "start screen" but in apps view and the search stuff but to be honest it's pretty good. I rarely see it though as everything I use is pinned to the taskbar.
Use Windows+X as your new start menu afterwards - it rocks. In fact I wish earlier versions of windows had that!
Reasons to upgrade: faster boot, power management seems more stable, Hyper-V, explorer UI enhancements, nicer file copying, new task manager, better Powershell integration.
PuTTY and Firefox still work which is the most important thing for me though...
Edit: just to add I haven't installed a start menu replacement or metro killer.
Edit 2: I haven't figured out backups yet. Windows 7 backup was trivial with an external disk.
Edit 3: to bypass microsoft account login/creation on installation (I did this on Pro edition):
1. When it asks you to sign in, click "create a microsoft account".
2. There is a link at the bottom to "use a local account" on the page this sends you to.