News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by kijin on Saturday October 12, 2013 @04:41AM (#6537896)
> Microsoft Word is a tyrant of the imagination, a petty, unimaginative, inconsistent dictator that is ill-suited to any creative writer's use.

Microsoft Word was never designed to be an ideal tool for creative writing, programming, or any such thing. It was designed to help office workers produce business documents (a) quickly, (b) in a format that integrates with all the other programs in the Office suite, and (b) in conformance with whatever formatting and workflow requirements their employer already had in place. Microsoft probably consulted with a bunch of Big Business customers when they designed Office. Yep, the kind of Big Business that uses Java classes like EnterpriseBusinessInterconnectInterfaceFactoryFactoryFactory.

Type a few word, hit "Save", and automatically get reasonable default fonts and margins? Check. Type a few more words, make some typos, have them fixed automatically? Check. Certain words need to be italicized or underlined? Check. Certain words need to be in a different font? Check. Who cares if it's consistent, the boss wants it bold so just make it bold. Indent the first line by X inches, double-space here, single-space there? Check. All accomplished with a few clicks of the mouse. No need to learn any command-line programs, formatting \Syn\{TaX}, or keyboard shortcuts. It's exactly what the majority of office workers need. Bonus points if it also helps clueless parents design their daughter's birthday party flyer in pink and purple Comic Sans, but I don't think MS really cares because that market is miniscule compared to Big Business.

> I hate Microsoft Word the way Winston Smith hated Big Brother.

At the end of that novel, <SPOILER> Winston loved Big Brother. </SPOILER> Because he probably realized that no other program but Big Biz MS Word would fit the use cases that it was designed for. LibreOffice? Call me again when it gets the Review function right. Your average college professor isn't going to learn how to use a version control system to suggest changes to his student's thesis-in-progress.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by GuiA on Saturday October 12, 2013 @04:55AM (#6537936)
> Your average college professor isn't going to learn how to use a version control system to suggest changes to his student's thesis-in-progress.

Word has version control though, and it's appreciated by many in academia. Version control for humans is a Big Startup Idea, I wouldn't be surprised if Dropbox and Github were trying to tackle it (from 2 different angles: Dropbox from the "how do we get average the user to get features for nerds", and Github from the "how do we get the average non-nerd to use us")

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by kijin on Saturday October 12, 2013 @06:44AM (#6538259)
Actually, that's what I was trying to say.

Word's review functions appear as pretty colored bubbles and a bunch of icons on the Ribbon. It's easy enough even for Humanities professors to use on a daily basis, despite the fact that as a VCS, it's strictly inferior to something like git. Actually, I think it's popular precisely because it ain't git. Most professors who are fluent in Word's review functions would be hopelessly lost when faced with a Dropbox conflict, let alone merging git repos.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by srikrishnan on Saturday October 12, 2013 @05:07PM (#6540317)
Totally agree that word's review functions are really simple. Which is why even all legal/contract documents are exchanged back and forth between companies in Word today. The hassle is that its done over email - sending versions of attachments back and forth. Nice naming convention helps, but there are definitely better solutions to do the same online today.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by eigenvalue on Saturday October 12, 2013 @08:12PM (#6540939)
Actually, most big law firms do not use the built in track changes function in Word, they use more specialized (and in my experience, better performing) software that take a "before" and "after" Word file and then generate a nice "redlined" version showing insertions, deletions, moves, etc. in different colors. Examples include Workshare DeltaView and Litera Change Pro.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by eru on Sunday October 13, 2013 @07:09AM (#6542196)
Word itself allows you to compare multiple files nowadays. (Though I don't know if it does three-way merges, yet.)
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by lallysingh on Sunday October 13, 2013 @05:10AM (#6541960)
I think you're absurdly underestimating people. A diff is a bunch of lines removed, and lines added. That's a pretty damn natural representation.

As for git's complexity, it's all in its completely opaque display of its internal state. A chain of deltas - diffs - isn't complicated. It's all git's (perverse) desire to follow the exact-same command-line interface as cat and awk, when neither contain persistent state.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by kijin on Sunday October 13, 2013 @08:03AM (#6542297)
It's not the concept of a diff that baffles ordinary people. It's (a) the lack of an intuitive interface, and (b) poor integration with natural languages, that make most VCS's difficult to use in the context of a word processor.

Word shows pretty bubbles next to sections that have been edited. The bubbles are color-coded so it's easy to tell who did what. The edits can be accepted, rejected, or further modified with a couple of clicks. There is no list of commands or keyboard shortcuts to memorize. Just a bunch of icons, menus, and clicking around.

Word doesn't require your content to be made up of neat lines of verse, either. Natural languages don't organize themselves into 78-char lines. It should be OK to edit a few words in a long paragraph of prose. Even Wikipedia's messy "Revision History" is probably better than git in this regard.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by read on Sunday October 13, 2013 @11:59AM (#6542998)
I liked what https://draftin.com did around version control.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by PeterisP on Sunday October 13, 2013 @09:10AM (#6542469)
'a bunch of lines removed/added' is a great representation for stuff that consist of semi-atomic lines, like code.

It is a horrible representation for stuff where edits may consist of both typo fixes, and separate wording changes in a single sentence - where you might want to accept change to one word and reject change to another word, despite that they came from a single "commit" to a single line.

For collaborative text editing both word's track changes and google docs features are far superior to git.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by jfb on Sunday October 13, 2013 @10:21AM (#6542667)
I'd argue that it's not that great a representation for code, which should be diff'd syntactically.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by lallysingh on Monday October 14, 2013 @06:21AM (#6546380)
You have the same problem with software.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by tripzilch on Sunday October 13, 2013 @02:27PM (#6543575)
FWIW, I don't often encounter diff output in my day-to-day computer usage, but when I do, I do not find them very intuitive to understand. A bit of UI magic would help here, it's not the concept that is hard (for me) to grasp, just all those lines with +'s and -'s and figuring out the contexts in which they apply. It's always a bit of a puzzle, especially if, for some reason, it's not highlighted with colours.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by jeltz on Sunday October 13, 2013 @05:56PM (#6544300)
git is good here since it by default has colored diffs.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by bentoner on Saturday October 12, 2013 @08:29AM (#6538474)
Our startup takes a third approach: automatically detect when one document is a new version of another, so that software can take care of the version control, while the humans can go on being human.

We're bringing version control to people who collaborate by email, starting with Gmail. All people have to do is exchange drafts by email (like normal!), and we infer the history, as if they've been using git.

We're looking for beta testers:

https://draftable.com

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by sammyo on Saturday October 12, 2013 @12:23PM (#6539230)
This looks quite interesting and quite topical to a discussion I had just yesterday during an interview. I almost clicked the installer but hesitated. A link that discusses the impact and especially any issues if/when your product was uninstalled would be reassuring.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by bentoner on Sunday October 13, 2013 @03:41AM (#6541823)
Sorry for the delay: busy weekend. I added a FAQ

https://draftable.com/gmail/faq

with the answer to your question (and more), but I'll answer here too:

We don't modify the data in your Gmail account, so if you try Draftable, then uninstall it, your Gmail account won't be altered. Furthermore, if you disable Draftable before uninstalling it, we'll delete our index and revoke our access to your account.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by monksy on Sunday October 13, 2013 @11:18AM (#6542868)
Why use Draftable when you can use google docs? That keeps version history automatically.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by bentoner on Sunday October 13, 2013 @11:58AM (#6542997)
Sure. If everyone you deal with uses Google Docs, then you don't need Draftable.

It's meant for people who exchange documents by email.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by redacted on Saturday October 12, 2013 @06:14AM (#6538159)
Version control in physics research: a pile of printed documents

Collaboration in physics research: hand-written notes on margins of said pile

The issue with git etc is that everyone involved has to understand how it works and accept and appreciate the benefits over the system outlined above (which works quite well for papers with few authors). If even one author doesn't care, you cannot implement the system. And good luck getting professors to care about things that aren't research or funding.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by agumonkey on Saturday October 12, 2013 @09:45AM (#6538716)
HoTT authors said that distributed version control helped a lot (for both productivity/creativity and spirit of scientific openness)

http://math.andrej.com/2013/06/20/the-hott-book/

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by r0muald on Saturday October 12, 2013 @05:48AM (#6538083)
Version control in Word (and pretty much any WYSIWYG editor) is fundamentally broken. I can't recall how many days of work I lost just because 1 out of 15 co-authors was not able to use it and fucked up everyone's text. And normally there's just 1 out of 15 that IS able to use it. If you're authoring papers on your own, heh, you could just be using pen and paper.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by raverbashing on Saturday October 12, 2013 @08:07AM (#6538434)
The problem there is having 15 co-authors. Really

And if some of them can't use it, teach them. And revert to the previously non-fucked up version (it's on someone's email by the name of Article_1_fixed_2_corrections_10_10.docx)

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by DennisP on Sunday October 13, 2013 @10:16AM (#6542650)
If our collaboration tools can't handle a mere 15 collaborators, we need better tools.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by lttlrck on Sunday October 13, 2013 @12:26PM (#6543095)
Can 15 people sitting in the same room with a single editor effectively collaborate on a single document?
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by DennisP on Sunday October 13, 2013 @01:54PM (#6543437)
Did I say that a single editor with fifteen people sitting around it is a good tool?
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by unsignedint on Sunday October 13, 2013 @04:38AM (#6541913)
I had to deal with that situation before but I was actually the middle of three parties. (I was B of A-B-C where. A and C was not talking to each other for political and linguistic reasons.) It was nothing but a mess, my inbox would be piled with revised document that often lost tracking, one party sending revised document based on outdated version. (And not sure which version was it.)

Something I like about version control is that it at least ensures continuity of the version.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by disgruntledphd2 on Saturday October 12, 2013 @09:29AM (#6538660)
Yes, but it only works when you use word.

Yours sincerely, a graduate student whose thesis is written in LaTeX and then converted to RTF and then hand edited so his supervisor(s) can give him comments.

I sent them a link to my github repository, but they never took me up on my offer :(

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by peatmoss on Saturday October 12, 2013 @11:36AM (#6539053)
You're much better off converting your latex--provided you don't have a bunch of kinky formatting--to docx via Pandoc.

I've found that collaboration on documents via Markdown is not too crazy bad. Otherwise, I ask for comments on the PDF or on hard copy. Going back to latex from RTF is an exercise in madness.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by pseut on Saturday October 12, 2013 @03:14PM (#6539871)
If you don't already do it, set up separate branches for each advisor/supervisor so you can add their comments there, then merge it back with your own work. i.e., just pretend that they're using git too, but do it for them.

And I second the pandoc recommendation if you can get it to work

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by tarre on Saturday October 12, 2013 @03:51PM (#6540014)
Did you try to send them just the pdf-file? That worked for me.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by disgruntledphd2 on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @03:58PM (#6555924)
I wish. Did that for a while, but when I told them when I wanted to finish, they demanded Word.

The worst part was that they didn't even use the track changes feature on anything I sent them.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by minor_nitwit on Saturday October 12, 2013 @06:04PM (#6540568)
Should have gone PDF. The comments in pdfs are some what manageable.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by unsignedint on Monday October 14, 2013 @07:27AM (#6546601)
+1 for PDF as well.

I actually do make bit of things in LaTeX through Org-mode at the office, and sending things in PDF actually makes it clear what kind of handling I'm looking for. If I'm actually expecting someone to revise my writing, then I'll just send them plaintext.

Now considering even Adobe Reader allows commenting, I don't think there are many of issues any more...

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by daned on Saturday October 12, 2013 @05:19AM (#6538006)
Couldn't agree with you more. My SO is a PhD candidate and she doesn't know what she's missing when it comes to collaborative version control. They spend a lot of time sending around modified office docs.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by kleiba on Saturday October 12, 2013 @05:42AM (#6538069)
Well, some people claim that tar balls and patches are a much superior source control management system than CVS. So you could say that unless you want every Joe User to master git, sending around modified office docs might not be the worst of solutions.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by iSnow on Saturday October 12, 2013 @06:43AM (#6538253)
No offense, but using git for collaborative writing? That's like using nukes to get rid of mosquitoes. SVN would be a poor but better choice, but you'd rather use stypi, google docs or something like that.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by Steuard on Saturday October 12, 2013 @08:45AM (#6538526)
Wow, do I disagree. I use version control (hg) for solo writing, and I'd love to use it for collaboration if I didn't think it would be an uphill slog to convince my coauthors to learn it too.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by lostlogin on Saturday October 12, 2013 @02:17PM (#6539669)
I'm guessing that you too have opened a recent-but-not-current doc, made changes, added polish etc, only to realise a few hours down the track that you opened a legacy version. Having multiple backups with numbered version names etc is all very well, but when you do it manually and you are working late at night, tired, it's way too easy to screw up up. Better document version control sounds excellent.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by Too on Saturday October 12, 2013 @12:41PM (#6539303)
I can not think of any scenario where svn would be preferable over a distributed vcs such as git or mercurial. They can both be used exactly the same way as svn if you feel for it but come with tons of other benefits. I even think there's less friction to start with for non techincal people because you are always working in "everything always checked out"-mode and there is no need for a common server. Just let them edit in peace and when you want to merge then pull from their local repo.

I don't know the state of visual tools for git but tortoisehg for mercurial is quite easy to get started with.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by iSnow on Saturday October 12, 2013 @02:25PM (#6539698)
>I can not think of any scenario where svn would be preferable over a distributed vcs such as git or mercurial.

After forgetting to push after commit and then dropping your laptop, you'll know.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by phaer on Sunday October 13, 2013 @07:46AM (#6542262)
What? The result would be exactly the same, right? You don't have your unpushed commit if your laptop is broken, neither with svn nor with git. The only difference is that you still can use your local git repository if your server burns down, but you can't do that with svn.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by iSnow on Sunday October 13, 2013 @01:25PM (#6543320)
>The result would be exactly the same, right?

Nope, like regularfry rightly pointed out.

>The only difference is that you still can use your local git repository if your server burns down, but you can't do that with svn. Even then I can `svn relocate`.

Look, I am not defending SVN for software development, I am a happy git camper. But git for technical writing is simply the wrong tool for the wrong job.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by regularfry on Sunday October 13, 2013 @09:44AM (#6542558)
With SVN a commit is a push. You can't forget to push after you've committed.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by jeltz on Sunday October 13, 2013 @06:01PM (#6544312)
No but when I used svn I committed way less frequently so it ended up to be the same thing. With git I forget to push with svn I forgot to commit.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by phaer on Sunday October 13, 2013 @08:24PM (#6544694)
Right. The last time i used subversion was about 7 years ago, so i forgot it. But it makes sense for centralized vc
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by CJefferson on Sunday October 13, 2013 @11:07AM (#6542825)
The biggest advantage of svn over git for non-technical users is that you can never end up with commit that then conflicts with another submit (as submits all happen on the server).

I have had various beginner git users get very confused when dealing with conflicts -- I have got myself quite confused on occasion too.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by scott_s on Saturday October 12, 2013 @06:53PM (#6540738)
I have always used source control for papers I write in groups - it's just assumed we're going to use source control. The only discussion is which one. I've used cvs, svn, git and mercurial when writing papers. Our papers are written in Latex. We often commit raw data and benchmark source code to the repository too.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by xshoppyx on Monday October 14, 2013 @01:32AM (#6545535)
Latex essentially has the same properties as source code in a VCS's eyes. .docx files would not work as well.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by reycharles on Monday October 14, 2013 @06:09AM (#6546346)
I wonder how true that is if the xml wasn't compressed.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by k3n on Saturday October 12, 2013 @10:43PM (#6541276)
Did you miss the story earlier in the year about the Princeton math students who did just that?

1. http://www.wired.com/wiredenterprise/2013/06/cades-witty-hea...

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by singingfish on Saturday October 12, 2013 @05:11PM (#6540336)
that's a dumb thing to say. It's reasonably frequent that the best tool for a job is one that scales from the smallest possible use case (individual) to the largest, smoothly and without hassle. Git fits this criterion. SVN is a real pain by comparison.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by iSnow on Sunday October 13, 2013 @07:46AM (#6542261)
Well, I believe in YAGNI. Throwing the biggest possible solution onto a small problem because it might get a large problem is speculative thinking. Which is bad.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by singingfish on Friday October 18, 2013 @09:16PM (#6574930)
That's different. YAGNI (e.g. starting with oracle where sqlite is probably all you need) is different to using tools designed to (reasonably transparrently) scale from the smallest use case to the largest.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by nawitus on Saturday October 12, 2013 @06:39AM (#6538239)
Dropbox already offers version control from their web UI.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by HillRat on Saturday October 12, 2013 @05:09PM (#6540324)
Yeah, our creative writing tool (backspacr.com) uses versioning at the scene/subchapter level, and it's definitely nontrivial to present diff and merge tools to end users. We're working through customer stories right now to try and do discovery on just this issue.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by pea on Saturday October 12, 2013 @01:43PM (#6539521)
That's actually what we are doing @ Kivo.com :p
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by Ygg2 on Saturday October 12, 2013 @07:05AM (#6538317)
>At the end of that novel, <SPOILER> Winston loved Big Brother. </SPOILER> Because he probably realized that no other program

Mostly because he was drugged, physically and psychologically tortured and reduced to his basic instinct and given option to experience its greatest fear or 'love' Big Brother. That's closer to real world than it being the only good option. LibreOffice needs a good compare function, not the whole review shtick.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by rbanffy on Saturday October 12, 2013 @02:02PM (#6539611)
> Mostly because he was drugged, physically and psychologically tortured and reduced to his basic instinct and given option to experience its greatest fear or 'love' Big Brother.

Sounds remarkably like using Microsoft Office.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by mcgwiz on Saturday October 12, 2013 @03:50PM (#6540010)
One way or another, you have to achieve product-market fit.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by stcredzero on Saturday October 12, 2013 @07:02PM (#6540762)
> Microsoft probably consulted with a bunch of Big Business customers when they designed Office. Yep, the kind of Big Business that uses Java classes like EnterpriseBusinessInterconnectInterfaceFactoryFactoryFactory.

Basically, you pulled this out of your butt because it hit the right notes and because it fit the preconceived notions of the readership of HN. WYSIWYG word processing was actually pioneered at Xerox PARC and MS Word has a direct lineage from there. Fitting the office correspondence conventions of the time was the obvious place to start. In a world that still operates off of paper, this is what makes sense at first.

Java classes like EnterpriseBusinessInterconnectInterfaceFactoryFactoryFactory are a direct result of the deliberate crippling of the Smalltalk runtime model that Java was based on. The very small and minimalist Smalltalk runtime model was another product of Xerox PARC, BTW.

Back in the day, even Java was one of these subversive back-door hacker/engineer things management wasn't hip enough to be a part of. (Unless you were one of the even hipper folks into Smalltalk, Dylan, Common Lisp, Eiffel, Tcl/Tk, Perl, Python, what have you, in which case, you knew better than to fall for Java.)

Heck even SQL, Fortran, and COBOL were the new hip thing back in the day. (Even if that came with corporate backing.)

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by pjmlp on Sunday October 13, 2013 @03:08AM (#6541777)
> Java classes like EnterpriseBusinessInterconnectInterfaceFactoryFactoryFactory are a direct result of the deliberate crippling of the Smalltalk runtime model that Java was based on. The very small and minimalist Smalltalk runtime model was another product of Xerox PARC, BTW.

Actually, they are a consequence how easy Java allows to write such type of code and how enterprise architects design software.

I have seen EnterpriseBusinessInterconnectInterfaceFactoryFactoryFactory examples in the enterprise done in lots of languages.

The same way there are developers that write FORTRAN in any language, there are those that make Skyscrapper designs in any language.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by stcredzero on Sunday October 13, 2013 @12:47PM (#6543165)
Whichever the case, the gp poster still pulled the alleged causation out of his/her butt for no other justification than that it feels "truthy."
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by Lagged2Death on Saturday October 12, 2013 @03:43PM (#6539990)
Microsoft Word was never designed to be an ideal tool for creative writing, programming, or any such thing.

Then indeed, its influence over those fields should be allowed to wane.

LibreOffice? Call me again when it gets the Review function right.

I was required to use the Review feature as a sort of half-assed collaborative editing system for tech specs on a couple of projects around 2008-2010. I found it to be a buggy, work-destroying trap of a feature. Things would actually have gone more smoothly for my project Microsoft had never implemented this feature.

I haven't tried any similar features in LibreOffice. If it doesn't do anything totally crazy (like randomly duplicating blocks of text in odd places) it's probably better.

I read an interview with some high-muckety-muck in the MS Office group years ago. He actually said, in response to a question about features vs. bug fixes, that he was sure users preferred new features to bug fixes for old ones. That features got people excited and no one really cared if they lost a little work every few hours.

He didn't say he'd asked any users. He was just sure.

I wish I could link to it, but I don't recall where I read it.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by blowski on Saturday October 12, 2013 @05:21PM (#6540378)
> he was sure users preferred new features to bug fixes for old ones

He's probably right (if you think of users as being the person who approves the payment). I can't imagine the CFO at a Fortune 500 company approving a few million dollars to be spent on bug fixes. The obvious question would be "why did we pay for defective software in the first place?".

So perhaps one side effect of the subscription model will be less buggy software, since the business model relies more on keeping users than getting them to upgrade.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by davidgerard on Saturday October 12, 2013 @07:01PM (#6540756)
Yep. This is why Excel is actually a really good spreadsheet: the people who approve the purchase are in fact the people using it - the bosses and the accountants.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by WinstonOrwell on Saturday October 12, 2013 @11:30AM (#6539036)
At the end of the book, Winston Smith is brainwashed by a "re-education process" of pervasive intimidation. He is subjected to the persistent threat of a death sentence, and the threat of rats-eating-your-face torture. He's behaviorally lobotomized and broken by coercive psychological manipulation. ...and oh yeah, they take away his QT 3.14 too.</SPOILER>

Don't bastardize the message and theme of the book.

  IGNORANCE IS STRENGTH.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by DanBC on Saturday October 12, 2013 @11:05AM (#6538956)
> Type a few word, hit "Save", and automatically get reasonable default fonts and margins? Check. Type a few more words, make some typos, have them fixed automatically? Check. Certain words need to be italicized or underlined? Check. Certain words need to be in a different font? Check. Who cares if it's consistent, the boss wants it bold so just make it bold. Indent the first line by X inches, double-space here, single-space there? Check. All accomplished with a few clicks of the mouse. No need to learn any command-line programs, formatting \Syn\{TaX}, or keyboard shortcuts. It's exactly what the majority of office workers need.

That's Abiword. A much smaller and cheaper piece of software.

That is all that most office workers need. So why is Office, a huge piece of software the default?

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by pmelendez on Saturday October 12, 2013 @11:47AM (#6539094)
>"That's Abiword. A much smaller and cheaper piece of software. That is all that most office workers need. So why is Office, a huge piece of software the default?"

Abiword's grammar checker is not nearly as good as Word's. That is specially in non-english laguanges. Also I would add to that list all the templates and design that Word brings out-of-box.

I am a weird case because I use Abiword at work and Office at home. And at least for short documents (10 pages max.) the experience on Word is just more enjoyable to me.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by sinkasapa on Sunday October 13, 2013 @12:18AM (#6541491)
> That is specially in non-english laguanges.

From a linguist's point of view, the language that English is grammar checked against in Word has always been a broken approximation of an uninformed prescriptivist's version of English.

An example opinion from the guy who wrote the book on English grammar:

http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/~myl/languagelog/archives/005061.h...

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by jeltz on Sunday October 13, 2013 @06:05PM (#6544320)
Last I used Word it did not have any grammar checker for Swedish and its spell checking was terrible (though better than LibreOffice). It has hopefully improved the last about 5 years though.

I have actually only used one working spell checker for Swedish: stava. And the ideas behind it are trivial, so I guess that nobody else has written a specialized spell checker for Swedish. Generalized ones like ispell, aspell, hunspell and Word's do not work for Swedish.

http://www.nada.kth.se/~viggo/stava/

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by roel_v on Sunday October 13, 2013 @03:50PM (#6543897)
"That's Abiword. A much smaller and cheaper piece of software."

LOL seriously? Look everybody, v2 even has footnotes and -gasp- tables! And they are 'very powerful' tables, too, because you can even merge cells (in a 'non-modal dialog', no less!)

(oh, and last release version - 2009).

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by coryfklein on Saturday October 12, 2013 @11:10AM (#6538977)
s/huge/expensive

Most users don't care so much about the "size" so much as the cost.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by normloman on Saturday October 12, 2013 @11:33AM (#6539046)
Again, AbiWord and Libre Office are free.

You both got it wrong. It's not about size. Not about cost. It's about compatibility. People use word because their boss, publisher, or professor uses word. Because an entire ecosystem of office software integrates in word. Because kids taking a computer class in school learn Word commands, and nothing else. Because a perfectly styled document in LibreOffice doesn't always look right in Word.

More than 20 years later, Microsoft still survives off the popularity of DOS on IBM compatible pc's in the late 80s and early 90s. Their strategy since has been to further entrench themselves into our daily lives.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by ChuckMcM on Saturday October 12, 2013 @01:57PM (#6539591)
"Call me again when it gets the Review function right. Your average college professor isn't going to learn how to use a version control system to suggest changes to his student's thesis-in-progress."

I suspect this is the ultimate longevity of Word. Retraining is a real pain. So the only way to kill Word is by a thousand cuts. One of those cuts seems to be Google's documents. A number of non-technical folks can now send me a document in Google Docs so I don't have to switch from my Linux desktop to something else to access it, and Google has done a reasonable job of auto importing Word.

So domain specific solutions, with "good enough" import/export may be the solution.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by walshemj on Saturday October 12, 2013 @01:37PM (#6539493)
The problem is that Publishers still tend to recruit Oxbridge first eng lit grads whose computer knowledge is probably about the same as Jenn from the IT Crowd.

Unfortunately as Publishing is now having to deal with online and electronic it means they are not best placed to deal with the changes.

And book publishers have sclerotic processes (makes teh Laudry service seem slick and efficient) to take a book from delivery to publication and extra month or so playing with word is't going to make much difference

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by wfunction on Saturday October 12, 2013 @05:14AM (#6537983)
> Microsoft Word was never designed to be an ideal tool for creative writing... Word was designed to help office workers produce business documents

And that's why they released a "Home and Student Edition".

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by kijin on Saturday October 12, 2013 @06:49AM (#6538273)
Home Edition: "People are familiar with using Office at work, so they'll probably want to use Office as well when it's time to design that Garage Sale flyer."

Student Edition: "Give them Office now at a discount, and they'll keep using (more expensive versions of) Office when they get a real job."

Office is named Office for a reason. Its entire existence revolves around the typical 20th-century white-collar office. All other use cases are secondary.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by wfunction on Saturday October 12, 2013 @10:51PM (#6541300)
Instead of being cynical, maybe consider the fact that students find it easier to type essays with Word than with other products, so Microsoft gave them a discount so they could afford it? Win-win.

Just a thought.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by el_muchacho on Sunday October 13, 2013 @11:39AM (#6542929)
Between Word and Wordperfect, the latter was the better product. But Word was easier to use for simple documents.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by TheZenPsycho on Sunday October 13, 2013 @07:36AM (#6542239)
what other products?
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by creatio on Sunday October 13, 2013 @10:42AM (#6542729)
latex?
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by dr_preston on Saturday October 12, 2013 @07:51AM (#6538394)
I purchased the "Home and Student Edition" for my wife to use on her new MacBook Air. A few months ago she started writing short fiction, which we have since self-published on Kindle. We had to switch to Libre Office, though, because when I contacted Microsoft support and asked them about the "Non-Commercial use" restriction, they told me writing a novel counts as commercial activity.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by Karunamon on Sunday October 13, 2013 @11:18AM (#6542870)
Wow. I always thought that the only restriction of the Home/Student edition was that it didn't come with Access or Outlook.

They prohibit you from making money with it? That blows my mind. Not only is it completely unenforceable (the PR backlash from Microsoft doing an enforced license audit of the likely purchaser of that version would be immense), it's completely pointless. Again, the products are differentiated by what they lack.

I wonder if the Microsoft legal department counts creating lemonade stand or yard sale signage to be "commercial use"...

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by tanzam75 on Saturday October 12, 2013 @11:19AM (#6539001)
Home and Business only costs $60 more than Home and Student.

However, I don't think there's a way to upgrade if you buy Home & Student and then discover that you need to do commercial work with it. You have to buy a new license.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by unsignedint on Saturday October 12, 2013 @09:47AM (#6538721)
Which it really confuses me as "Home" part. I can't think of so much case that full fledged WP useful in home context other than writing a letter maybe...
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by scholia on Monday October 14, 2013 @05:55AM (#6546301)
It's Home & Student, and a lot of students use it at home, as distinct from in the classroom. Also, it's not just WP. Plenty of people do stuff that benefits from using Office. They have hobbies or are members of local groups that produce fliers or newsletters (church, youth, etc).

By the way, Windows includes a free word processor, WordPad, that does what most home users need without them having to buy Office. There are also free viewers for Office docs...

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by jgamman on Sunday October 13, 2013 @03:54AM (#6541845)
I'm sorry but what did you just say? you can't write something on MS Word home edition and sell it for cash? seriously, i had no idea you could restrict something so basic as a word processor - FFS that's absurd!
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by scholia on Monday October 14, 2013 @05:47AM (#6546262)
It's not absurd: it's a perfectly reasonable and entirely rational deal.

Microsoft Office is commercial software costs roughly $300. If you want to use it for commercial purposes, you pay the price. However, there's a special deal where you get a Home & Student version for a third of the price, on condition that you don't use it for commercial purposes (ie as a replacement for the version you should be buying).

A lot of commercial programs are available in cheap student versions or in free versions for home (non-commercial) use. This is standard industry practice. It's not a Microsoft thing.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by mathnode on Saturday October 12, 2013 @07:07AM (#6538323)
Desktop application software for collaborative editing? No way.

Confluence? Twiki? Or equal such centralised documentaiotn and revision service, be it SaaS or locally hosted, Yes.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by Joeri on Saturday October 12, 2013 @07:15AM (#6538335)
As someone observing and partaking in the process of migrating a large svn repository of word documents into confluence I can tell you that confluence's markup and review functionality (even with add-ons) is a very poor substitute for word. It's still beneficial to do it for the ease of access and the improved searchability and document linking abilities, but it's definitely a trade-off where you lose while you gain.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by YeahKIA on Saturday October 12, 2013 @01:23PM (#6539445)
Wait. What? Have you tried collaboration with a Word before saying this? I make my living collaborating on documents in Word. Which part of it did you have a problem with? I have found only OneNote to be any better than Word but alas it lacks a bunch of Word features.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by roel_v on Sunday October 13, 2013 @03:54PM (#6543924)
Of course he hasn't, none of the people here claiming that 'emacs + git is better than Word' or 'LibreOffice does all 90% of people use' have. If actual users had only 10% of the problems with Word that are being described in this thread, they would have flocked to other products years ago. Fact is, they didn't, and it's because Word works well enough for the vast majority of them. Of course, they all bitch every now and then, but then again so do they (and I, this is not a 'stupid users' rant) about anything.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by sinkasapa on Sunday October 13, 2013 @12:08AM (#6541463)
I just finished writing a lengthy grant application where the humanities professor used Word and I used LibreOffice. We used the review functionality and I didn't even know there was supposed to be a problem. Though, I don't really do more than touch the surface with word processor programs because I don't personally like them very much.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by asdasf on Saturday October 12, 2013 @12:08PM (#6539183)
>Microsoft Word was never designed to be an ideal tool for creative writing, programming, or any such thing.

He pointed that out. And he pointed out that the industry was still foisting it on him. That is why he wants it to die. This was the summary at the end of the article in fact.

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by ShirtlessRod on Saturday October 12, 2013 @02:21PM (#6539679)
Then shouldn't he be far more mad at his industry, not the tool?
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by PeterisP on Sunday October 13, 2013 @09:17AM (#6542487)
Isn't that what he's doing? "X needs to die" quite clearly means "you people in industry need to stop using X", not "burn X at the stake".
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by ShirtlessRod on Sunday October 13, 2013 @06:06PM (#6544321)
I honestly can't tell if you're being sarcastic or not. I'll just assume you are and move on.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by Sagat on Sunday October 13, 2013 @04:42AM (#6541917)
Why blame the people you know when you can blame a piece of software that can't fight back?
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by YeahKIA on Saturday October 12, 2013 @01:17PM (#6539428)
Curious what kind of foisting. I'm sure people might have preferred things in word format. Its just a matter of convenience. But I doubt its foisted. I've seen PDF files to be as annoyingly common particularly in academia. I hate it but I get around by just saving my document as PDF and move on. He's just being overly dramatic.
Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by bediger4000 on Sunday October 13, 2013 @11:22AM (#6542876)
I assure you that "Word" is foisted on people who otherwise wouldn't touch it. It's foisted in many, many ways, from project managers who ask for "a word version", to software process methodologies whose official templates are in "Word" to requirement tracking systems that demand "Word" versions of every single document, because the tracking system produces "Word" docs.

I don't think most people distinguish "Word" docs from any printed doc, except those sophisticated enough to use "Excel" to produce columnar-format data ("Word" tables are hard to do and sucky looking).

Re:Why Microsoft Word must die by rbanffy on Saturday October 12, 2013 @02:02PM (#6539609)
Most likely when he sends a plain text file to his editor, he gets back a .doc file with the revisions and annotations.