* Zombie giant banks, addicted to bailouts
* Currency pushed and pulled by Yen carry trade
* Complete efficiency collapse. Workers work very long hours accomplishing little
* Eye watering debt ( worlds largest on many measures )
04/08/2013 - http://thecommonsensecapitalist.com/2013/04/08/kyle-bass-on-...
06/31/2013 - http://seekingalpha.com/article/1473301-should-we-allow-kyle...
01/21/2013 - http://www.forbes.com/sites/stephenharner/2013/01/21/whither...
05/23/2013 - http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-05-23/boj-bond-buying-to-...
Per capita GDP doesn't help if there are not enough new entrants in the workforce to replace departing workers. With no immigration, there won't be enough people to carry the load.
I love Japan, and the deflation made it cheaper to visit, but it's a cultural attraction more than anything else.
Rising Sun was written when a lot of people were worried that Japan would overtake the US as an economic power. We all know how that turned out. It's also why I'm sceptical when people talk about China being the next economic superpower.
Frankly, the age of democracy is over, and we now have the age of the permanent civil service. The good news is, it is almost certainly an improvement. China, Japan and Singapore are run exclusively by their civil services (democracy in the latter two is an irrelevant sideshow), and they are run much better than most western countries, or at least with more long term strategy. In fact, pretty much everything wrong with Japan can be blamed on the idiot government trying to save face by not admitting reality. The USA would be pretty well served, IMO, by taking control of budget away from congress and giving it to - well, almost anyone. The GAO, maybe. The Fed, the SEC, the commerce dept, anyone, so long as they're not elected. Being accountable to the electorate turns out to be the worst idea ever for people who are actually trying to do their jobs. It means never being able to admit you're wrong.
I don't mind if they keep parliament/congress around for show but they're going to go the way of the Queen of England - a figurehead, kind of a sounding board for the people, a super-ombudsman. A hundred years from now we're going to look back and wonder how we ever could have been so mad to think that giving politicians the reigns of power could ever have been a good idea.
Japanese Govt, like that in Singapore and South Korea, is characterised by the extreme strengths of their bureaucracies. It would be fair to say that the Japanese Diet, their government, is basically a peer to the JR railway company or MOFA. Imagine if in the USG, all the departments basically operated at the level of the DoD or Dept of State - frankly at the same level as congress. Congress can declare war on the DoD, sure, but would only do so under the most dire circumstances. In practise they cooperate.
Well, in Japan, that's how it is. Basically, the government could probably, if it came down to it, fire the heads of the bureaucracies, but it won't come to that and never has. They are peers for all practical purposes. They are like competing departments in a large corporation. You might think that is a recipe for wastefulness and corruption, and you would be absolutely right, but in a crazy sort of way they keep each other honest, somewhat, and it's better than Fox News making all your decisions.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not some fanatical Japanophile - I don't even live there anymore. But man, at least they can get at least some stuff done. In the west we could not even dream of having a 50-year high speed rail plan. Just think about that. What does that say about us? Look, we're not a dystopia, but we're still basically coasting on past success. The car is still moving, but it's slowing down. Maybe we ran out of gas, or maybe we're so caught up in fight about which way to drive we can't even put our foot on the accelerator.
Corporations that lose the ability to invest in or even think about the long term go out of business. I don't believe countries are any different. We are going to have to change, radically, or we'll simply be taken over - it's only a matter of time.
China's economic central planning has worked so well to date because they have had larger, more successful economies to plan against--the U.S. and Europe. They have focused on exports, infrastructure, and exfiltration of intellectual property, in the hope of creating the foundation for a strong domestic economy.
Whether it will work remains to be seen. The 20th century clearly taught the world that central planning cannot maintain a consistently strong domestic economy; innovation happens too slowly. China's greatest challenge will be the transition to a more open and permissive society that is capable of bootstrapping its own innovations. This could be a very difficult transition for them culturally. Central planners very rarely give up their control and power peacefully.
Key word here is "free". America's self-defeat will come from its misunderstood idea of "freedom" - really, just a self-centered attitude that hampers cooperation.
The last few decades of research in psychology and neuroscience are pointing at all sorts of issues with that part.
Whereas in most democracies the party in power always has to worry about the next election.
If that's not a good point against it I don't know what is.
moldbuggery.blogspot.in
Not that his point is valid, but he did say economic superpower and the USSR was certainly not.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_of_Fear
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Crichton#The_Case_for_S...
http://scienceandpublicpolicy.org/images/stories/papers/comm...
For one, Japan never had more than 50% of the US population. For their GDP to have eclipsed ours, their average citizen would have had to produce and consume twice as much as the average US citizen. The Japanese are highly productive, but not that much.
China on the other hand has four times our population. It's an entirely different dynamic here, and somewhat uncharted territory. No comparison.
I'm not an expert in economy, just a Civilization V player :) but I think these examples are very different. China is, simply put, orders of magnitude bigger. Even at a lower efficiency, they could output so much more "stuff", in any field of activity.
At this point, the only way they could go down in flames (or stay crawling at a low level) is self-sabotage via shortsightedness, bad decisions, cultural taboos, etc.
Ah China, Like religion, a topic about which people who have no idea about are comfortable making grand, utterly wrong statements.
China's GDP is about 50% bigger than japans, its exports are about 2.5 times japans. The idea that china is too big to fail is ludicrous. It might be possible to argue though, that its too big to succeed
On the one hand it's already succeeded - second largest economy in the world and all that.
But from an economic development point of view, that's a very interesting question. Can China solve its development problems, which are numerous - development of the entire country not just the 30% of the population on the coast, governance of that unprecedented mass of people, and rapidly ramping environmental problems?
Careful, that sword has two edges.
I was referring to its potential - population, territory, resources.
One order of magnitude, anyway.
Exports are real costs, imports are real benefits. A trade surplus can help you keep net government spending low, but there's nothing positive about that in and of itself.
This is a good read about the real problems, lack of aggregate demand. Everytime government spending gets high enough to lift GDP, they pull the rug out from under the economy by raising taxes. A process they're looking to continue.
http://www.inginvestment.com/idc/groups/commentary/documents...
> Ordinarily, a decline in working-age population — and, thus, a decline in the supply of workers — would tighten the labor market and cause the unemployment rate to fall; in Japan’s case, however, the gradual rise in the unemployment rate and tepid job growth is occurring in spite of these demographic shifts, reflecting economic stagnation and weakness in aggregate demand.
On the dissident end, it's common knowledge that Japan's weakness has been overstated. Left Business Observer interviewed Fingleton (http://www.leftbusinessobserver.com/Radio.html#S130530), and Chomsky often mentions it.
(Never dug into the motivation though.)
This is an example of mechanically quoting arguments we're told to believe.
If you'd like to learn more about post-WWII US planning, simply look up the Marshall Plan and George Kennan. If you're able to deal with dissident lit, this may inform you: (http://books.zcommunications.org/chomsky/dd/dd-c11-s03.html).
And that is an example of when people who know they have no argument dismiss reality because it gets in the way of what they want to believe.
That's a rather startling claim, especially since the original argument is with respect to economic rather than military power.
Care to back this up?
I think the common-sense notion is that forms of power are interlinked. (Economics means ability to produce; military means capacity to inflict violence.)
Cambridge economist Ha-Joon Chang discusses the problems when we try to draw artificial, ideological boundaries between politics and economics; the analysis also applies to military. (http://ineteconomics.org/blog/institute/ha-joon-chang-and-ma...)
And when the economic sanctions in Iraq caused a US journalist to ask Madeline Albright, "We have heard that half a million children have died. I mean, that's more children than died in Hiroshima. And, you know, is the price worth it?" we see that economics can accomplish military objectives. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sanctions_against_Iraq#Albright...)
Suppose we immediately moved all of our military bases out of Japan. Are you predicting that the country would collapse, economically or otherwise?
Is Japan otherwise dependent on us, except insofar as we are a large market for Japanese-made goods?
b) Japan has significant weaknesses, like historic lack of natural resources. I imagine it has enormous dependences, and not just on the US. (Dunno how the recent finds of rare earth metals changes this.)
And yes, Japan has the most powerful navy in the Far East (aside from the US navy, of course) regardless of what they call it. But that's temporary - they'll be eclipsed by China over the next decade.
Now who's being a bit silly? :) If anyone could cite sources supporting such a strange position, presumably they would have by now.
Let's take another example: "The current government of Cuba regards the U.S. presence in Guantánamo Bay as illegal and insists the Cuban-American Treaty was obtained by threat of force in violation of international law." (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guant%C3%A1namo_Bay) Of course the US does what it wants, because it's the military superpower. We don't ask people nicely if we could invade them, nor would we respect their votes on the matter.
As for Japan, Okinawans want the US military off their land. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Okinawa_Prefecture#U.S._militar...) Does the US hold votes, asking them if they wish to be occupied? Do we ask which other prefecture would prefer us to occupy them?
In any case, that's all besides the point. Even if your claims were 100% correct (and there's areas I agree with), the point still stands: "It's doing reasonably ok because we let it". (When you consider social dynamics, people often choose subordination to gain protection.) You're arguing a point I haven't made.
There's nothing strange about that position. The Japanese derive enormous benefit from the US presence. We left the Philippines when the Philippine government asked us to do so, and we'd leave Japan under the same circumstances. Do you really think we'd go to war with Japan to maintain bases there? That's preposterous.
>As for the US, Okinawans want the US military off their land.
So what? Okinawa isn't an independent country.
>In any case, that's all besides the point. Even if your claims were 100% correct (and there's areas I agree with), the point still stands: "It's doing reasonably ok because we let it". You're arguing a point I haven't made.
We "let" Japan do things to the same extent we "let" other countries do things. The only real stick we have with the Japanese is the threat to leave and take our money and protection with us.
Dick Cheney said, "We have made a decision ... that we simply do not want to go back in and try to reuse Clark Air Force Base. The cost of doing so would be several hundred million dollars. It's in an area that is still threatened by continuing eruptions by the volcano."
> So what?
Indeed, "so what?" is our common reply to people's wishes to get our military off their land, as with Cuba's Guantanamo Bay and the Middle East in general.
I already mentioned one obvious alternative to occupying Okinawa against its residents' wishes. But as usual, "so what?" is the response.
> We "let" Japan do things to the same extent we "let" other countries do things.
Yep, ask people in the Middle East, Cuba, etc. (That's it from me, given that I cite evidence rather than merely repeat vague snatches of politics we can get from propaganda sources. I wish others would show us the same respect.)
No it isn't. We would not have left Subic Bay unless they asked us to.
>Indeed, "so what?" is our common reply to people's wishes to get our military off their land
It's not "their land". It's Japanese land, and people in Okinawa don't get to make that decision for the entire country. The country of Japan wants us to be there, and we'd leave if they didn't.
Places in Japan have NIMBY sentiment. Go figure.
>Yep, ask people in the Middle East, Cuba, etc...
The Cubans made a deal with us for a long lease in Guantanamo. When the lease is up we'll leave.
We never had any intention of staying in Iraq or Afghanistan, and we wouldn't have been in either country if the locals had kept to themselves. We were invited into Qutar and KSA.
I don't see the problem.
http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_sb_noss_1?url=search-alias%3D...
I read Blindside back in 1996 and I thought his argument was interesting for that time. However, when you read him, it is important to remember that he has not changed his opinion in 20 years, and there are new facts to be accounted for. At that time he seemed certain that Japan would be the worlds #1 economy by the year 2000. His prediction was wrong, but he has not much changed his opinion: he still believes Japan is an important success story.
Japan suffered a long depression in the 1990s. That is not fiction. That is a fact. However, it is also true that some of the stagnation of the period 1990-2013 should be attributed to demographic change.
Paul Krugman offered a partial counter-argument to Eamonn Fingleton here:
http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/01/09/japan-reconsider...
Also, it is worth noting that for the last 20 years Fingleton has constantly harped on the fact that Japan has a trade surplus, sometimes a very large trade surplus, and he thinks this represents economic strength. Numerous economists have made the point that a large trade surplus can be a sign of economic weakness: perpetual insufficient demand at home in the domestic market. Fingleton has rarely taken this view into account.