This is an example of mechanically quoting arguments we're told to believe.
If you'd like to learn more about post-WWII US planning, simply look up the Marshall Plan and George Kennan. If you're able to deal with dissident lit, this may inform you: (http://books.zcommunications.org/chomsky/dd/dd-c11-s03.html).
And that is an example of when people who know they have no argument dismiss reality because it gets in the way of what they want to believe.
That's a rather startling claim, especially since the original argument is with respect to economic rather than military power.
Care to back this up?
I think the common-sense notion is that forms of power are interlinked. (Economics means ability to produce; military means capacity to inflict violence.)
Cambridge economist Ha-Joon Chang discusses the problems when we try to draw artificial, ideological boundaries between politics and economics; the analysis also applies to military. (http://ineteconomics.org/blog/institute/ha-joon-chang-and-ma...)
And when the economic sanctions in Iraq caused a US journalist to ask Madeline Albright, "We have heard that half a million children have died. I mean, that's more children than died in Hiroshima. And, you know, is the price worth it?" we see that economics can accomplish military objectives. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sanctions_against_Iraq#Albright...)
Suppose we immediately moved all of our military bases out of Japan. Are you predicting that the country would collapse, economically or otherwise?
Is Japan otherwise dependent on us, except insofar as we are a large market for Japanese-made goods?
b) Japan has significant weaknesses, like historic lack of natural resources. I imagine it has enormous dependences, and not just on the US. (Dunno how the recent finds of rare earth metals changes this.)
And yes, Japan has the most powerful navy in the Far East (aside from the US navy, of course) regardless of what they call it. But that's temporary - they'll be eclipsed by China over the next decade.
Now who's being a bit silly? :) If anyone could cite sources supporting such a strange position, presumably they would have by now.
Let's take another example: "The current government of Cuba regards the U.S. presence in Guantánamo Bay as illegal and insists the Cuban-American Treaty was obtained by threat of force in violation of international law." (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guant%C3%A1namo_Bay) Of course the US does what it wants, because it's the military superpower. We don't ask people nicely if we could invade them, nor would we respect their votes on the matter.
As for Japan, Okinawans want the US military off their land. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Okinawa_Prefecture#U.S._militar...) Does the US hold votes, asking them if they wish to be occupied? Do we ask which other prefecture would prefer us to occupy them?
In any case, that's all besides the point. Even if your claims were 100% correct (and there's areas I agree with), the point still stands: "It's doing reasonably ok because we let it". (When you consider social dynamics, people often choose subordination to gain protection.) You're arguing a point I haven't made.
There's nothing strange about that position. The Japanese derive enormous benefit from the US presence. We left the Philippines when the Philippine government asked us to do so, and we'd leave Japan under the same circumstances. Do you really think we'd go to war with Japan to maintain bases there? That's preposterous.
>As for the US, Okinawans want the US military off their land.
So what? Okinawa isn't an independent country.
>In any case, that's all besides the point. Even if your claims were 100% correct (and there's areas I agree with), the point still stands: "It's doing reasonably ok because we let it". You're arguing a point I haven't made.
We "let" Japan do things to the same extent we "let" other countries do things. The only real stick we have with the Japanese is the threat to leave and take our money and protection with us.
Dick Cheney said, "We have made a decision ... that we simply do not want to go back in and try to reuse Clark Air Force Base. The cost of doing so would be several hundred million dollars. It's in an area that is still threatened by continuing eruptions by the volcano."
> So what?
Indeed, "so what?" is our common reply to people's wishes to get our military off their land, as with Cuba's Guantanamo Bay and the Middle East in general.
I already mentioned one obvious alternative to occupying Okinawa against its residents' wishes. But as usual, "so what?" is the response.
> We "let" Japan do things to the same extent we "let" other countries do things.
Yep, ask people in the Middle East, Cuba, etc. (That's it from me, given that I cite evidence rather than merely repeat vague snatches of politics we can get from propaganda sources. I wish others would show us the same respect.)
No it isn't. We would not have left Subic Bay unless they asked us to.
>Indeed, "so what?" is our common reply to people's wishes to get our military off their land
It's not "their land". It's Japanese land, and people in Okinawa don't get to make that decision for the entire country. The country of Japan wants us to be there, and we'd leave if they didn't.
Places in Japan have NIMBY sentiment. Go figure.
>Yep, ask people in the Middle East, Cuba, etc...
The Cubans made a deal with us for a long lease in Guantanamo. When the lease is up we'll leave.
We never had any intention of staying in Iraq or Afghanistan, and we wouldn't have been in either country if the locals had kept to themselves. We were invited into Qutar and KSA.
I don't see the problem.
On the dissident end, it's common knowledge that Japan's weakness has been overstated. Left Business Observer interviewed Fingleton (http://www.leftbusinessobserver.com/Radio.html#S130530), and Chomsky often mentions it.
(Never dug into the motivation though.)