News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Logic Pro X by bsaul on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @11:27AM (#6052497)
The price tag really reflects that the music industry is the poorest of all creative industries (aka video, photo, 3D and web). When i think about all the genius algorithms and technologies that products like Ableton or logic Pro ship it really saddens me.
Re:Logic Pro X by calinet6 on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @11:40AM (#6052584)
As with many of Apple's recent price drops (OSX, iWork, etc. etc.) I think it's a highly strategic and intentional move, not reflective of the greater market, but showing that Apple is enabling the larger success of their brand by enabling more people to purchase and use these pro apps at a lower price point. Plus, it will sell Macs, both laptops and Mac Pros. Smart.
Re:Logic Pro X by ctdonath on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @01:21PM (#6053266)
Plus, it will sell Macs, both laptops and Mac Pros. Smart.

Plus? No, _first_. Apple is a hardware company. They sell computers. Their software, while excellent and profitable, IMO exists only to sell more hardware.

All companies have a core competency & purpose. Everything else must feed that core; a product may be excellent on its own, but must still support the core. Deviate from that core, badness happens. Logic Pro is awesome on its own, but was created to give a niche a reason to buy into the Apple ecosystem, buy hardware, and buy more hardware.

Re:Logic Pro X by gamegod on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @12:58PM (#6053097)
This strategy benefits Apple, but screws over independent software developers/vendors.

Look at the top 10 apps in the Mac App Store. That list is always dominated by Apple's applications like Logic and iWork because of this pricing strategy. Nobody else can afford to sell a DAW for $200 and make money. IMHO it's some kind of anti-competitiveness but I don't know if there's a term for it. Maybe it's just a fact of life when Apple owns and controls the entire software/hardware ecosystem.

Re:Logic Pro X by snom380 on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @01:18PM (#6053239)
Of course others can afford it. Whether they want to is another matter, but other companies like Propellerheads make lots of money selling software in the same price range.

Also, don't forget that most of the Apple Pro Apps came about because pretty much none of the creative market vendors were initially on board with OSX, that only happened later when they saw OSX grow.

Re:Logic Pro X by freyr on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @02:36PM (#6053829)
Are the existing DAWs really hurting since Apple dropped their price? Live, Pro Tools, Reason, etc. seem to be doing well.

Are many independent developers really in the business of creating DAWs anyway? There seem to be far more developing instrument/effect plugins. The more people that use DAWs, the larger the market for plugins becomes. The net effect for independent developers could be positive.

Besides, if independent developers cannot find a way to compete, perhaps they should reconsider their business. It's not like they're competing with Microsoft's monopoly in the 80s and 90s. There are many other platforms (some much more popular than Apple desktop) on which they can develop, and Apple won't compete with them there. That's still a huge potential market share.

Re:Logic Pro X by chucknelson on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @02:25PM (#6053739)
I would argue that having the type of professional software that only companies like Apple can develop, available at an affordable price, is a great win for consumers.

Companies will find ways to compete. Just look at the $30-$50 apps that emulate stripped down versions of Photoshop (Acorn, Pixelmator) - yeah, they aren't near the full feature set of PS, but they get 90% of us what we need and for way less money. I'm sure audio apps already have some of this going on in the market.

Re:Logic Pro X by kolya3 on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @02:10PM (#6053632)
Both Ableton and Reason are over $400 and tons of musicians still choose those over Logic. For many, price is not the only consideration when picking a DAW and there are plenty of developers selling mere VSTs, not even DAWs, at $200/pop.
Re:Logic Pro X by dorkrawk on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @01:24PM (#6053286)
That's not totally true. I've heard from several professional musicians who use Reaper ( http://www.reaper.fm/ ) and it sells for $225.
Re:Logic Pro X by owlmusic on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @01:55PM (#6053497)
Reaper also has the excellent discounted license for $60 which covers a lot of musicians who would otherwise be forced by the singular license of Reason / Logic Pro / Ableton Live.
Re:Logic Pro X by sjwright on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @08:14PM (#6055508)
> That list is always dominated by Apple's applications

I haven't looked, but I bet the Microsoft equivalent is (will be?) dominated by their apps, like the Office suite. It's not unfair, it's just the reality of such markets.

A supermarket's home brand would probably also be the most successful brand in their stores, too.

Re:Logic Pro X by acomjean on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @04:18PM (#6054470)
Requires: OS X v10.8.4 or later

Lots of people will need a new mac for this. I know I can't run it on my Mac Pro 1,1

Re:Logic Pro X by scrumper on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @04:29PM (#6054537)
There is a way to get Mountain Lion on your MP, which is I think the only reason you can't have LPX. It looks a tad tricky (and it's not recommended if your 1,1 is in any way connected to your ability to earn money) but you can do it by mucking about with hard drives and the installer images.

Kicks off here: http://9to5mac.com/2012/07/23/mountain-lion-installed-on-a-m...

Re:Logic Pro X by acomjean on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @04:49PM (#6054642)
Thanks, I'll check that out.
Re:Logic Pro X by joeblau on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @12:04PM (#6052752)
Logic has been $200 for a while. Even though Logic uses Audio Unit plugins, I don't think there is really any substitute for physical hardware. You can get this to run a project on the cheap, but it's still going to cost you $1000+ for a good mic and +600+ hardware like compressors, limiters, equalizers, monitors, and mixing boards. Plus you have to get cabling, power conditioners and cases to hold and connect everything. My last "Home Studio" ran me nearly $10,000; Logic was the cheapest thing I had to buy and that's when it was around $700.
Re:Logic Pro X by coldtea on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @02:07AM (#6056338)
>Logic has been $200 for a while. Even though Logic uses Audio Unit plugins, I don't think there is really any substitute for physical hardware.

You may not, but most of the productions, from the Billboard top-100 to independent stuff, are choke full of plugins. And a lot of "physical hardware" can't be told apart when A/B with quality plugins (Waves, UAD etc).

>You can get this to run a project on the cheap, but it's still going to cost you $1000+ for a good mic and +600+ hardware like compressors, limiters, equalizers, monitors, and mixing boards. Plus you have to get cabling, power conditioners and cases to hold and connect everything. My last "Home Studio" ran me nearly $10,000; Logic was the cheapest thing I had to buy and that's when it was around $700.

If you want to record Led Zeppelin, maybe.

For a 4-piece rock band, Logic, a mixing board, a audio interface, a pair of monitors, a few mikes, stands, rack unit etc, will do it for around $3000-$4000.

And for electronic music (including hip-hop), you can just make do with Logic, an audio interface, headphones, monitors, a MIDI keyboard and one-two mikes, for around $1500 total.

Re:Logic Pro X by knowaveragejoe on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @12:21PM (#6052862)
Unless you plan on making your own vocal or acoustic instrument samples, most of that equipment isn't necessary.
Re:Logic Pro X by klodolph on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @12:38PM (#6052974)
Samples? Some of us record audio tracks, we don't use MIDI for everything.

For example, if you want to record your band at home, you might have six microphones just to get started (vocals, guitar, bass, snare, kick, and drum overhead). Outboard limiters and microphone preamps are not out of the question.

On the other hand, if you do everything with software samplers and synthesizers, then you just need a computer, Logic, and some headphones.

Re:Logic Pro X by VLM on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @01:01PM (#6053114)
You missed how much it costs... perhaps $500 for pro grade audio per channel. So he's talking about $3K so far.

Now you'll argue that a bottom of the barrel high end amateur grade mic might be only $50. But you'll still need cables, probably a preamp, some kind of (expensive) interface box to input 6 audio channels in phase (can't just plug in 3 stereo usb sound adapters... well, usually...). A decent stand or boom is probably $75 for a hunk of metal. Suddenly paying $50 for a cheap mic is false economy if the support infrastructure is setting you back $300... may as well buy a decent $200 class mic... to go with your $200 software.

Unless you're solely a vocal group you'll probably need to mic and input instruments.

My sister used to play the viola (more or less a big violin). A pro grade mic costs $400. Not a viola with a mic installed. Not a package deal of mic and cable and preamp and all that. No, just the custom designed weirdly mounted mic. Before permanent professional installation of course. This is probably an extreme, obviously its hard to mic a stringed instrument without screwing up the resonance sounds while the musicians face is inches away from the mic. I bet you could mic a brass instrument for a quarter the cost.

Re:Logic Pro X by klodolph on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @10:49PM (#6055868)
That was exactly my point. If you pay $500 per channel, and maybe $1k for monitors, $1k for the computer, $1k for a MIDI controller, that's already $6k. Another $4k could easily get eaten up by room treatments, misc hardware like mic stands and cables, control interfaces, patch bays, etc. So $10k is reasonable, and if that's reasonable, then the difference between $200 Logic and $60 is not all that great.

Never mind the fact that if you actually earn a living doing this, the Reaper license is $225 anyway.

P.S. I think the $50 for a cheap mic is too low, and $100 is the lowest you should pay (probably for an SM57).

P.P.S. There are lots of ways to mic a Viola, no need to get a special Viola mic.

Re:Logic Pro X by joeblau on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @12:30PM (#6052912)
Yeah then you need real instruments which aren't cheap either. Along with that you need a way to record your instruments to a digital or analog format. Unless your a street performer that's playing drums on old buckets and trash cans and not recording anything, it's going to cost more than the $200 for a DAW. My point is that making music is not as cheap as people think it is.
Re:Logic Pro X by igorgue on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @12:21PM (#6052867)
I think it's all about demand, that's why prices are lower, these days demand is a lot more than before, and everything is really accessible.

With that being said, it's not cheap if you add other things you have to buy, studio monitors, a fast computer, and good midi keyboard (and that's the minimum for a full in-the-box musician).

Re:Logic Pro X by adw on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @08:40PM (#6055564)
I reckon you're looking at $1000 including software but excluding the laptop, basically; say $100-150 for decent headphones, $200-250 for monitors, $100 for a workable MIDI controller, $150 for an audio interface (something from M-Audio or Focusrite, say). That leaves around $350-400 for software, a cheap mic, stands, cables etc.

(And you'll probably want at least one more controller, whether a Launchpad-style thing, a fader box, or Akai pads.)

Re:Logic Pro X by cageface on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @12:15PM (#6052829)
Apple sells Logic at cut rate prices to help sell their hardware. Other comparable packages cost much more. The music software business is pretty tough, but not as tough as this alone would suggest.
Re:Logic Pro X by Sephiroth87 on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @01:28PM (#6053314)
Apple stuff is expensive = Bad Apple stuff is cheap = Bad

LOGIC!!!

Re:Logic Pro X by ryen on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @01:55PM (#6053495)
Logic is one of the cheapest (if not the cheapest) of the higher end DAWs out there. Combine that with the amount of plugins and sounds it ships with at that price tag and I think its one of the best options out there.
Re:Logic Pro X by Sephiroth87 on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @03:01PM (#6054017)
I'm not disagreeing with that, but with people that complains Apple stuff is expensive, except when it's not and they still complain for the opposite reason...
Re:Logic Pro X by bsaul on Thursday July 18, 2013 @05:40AM (#6062636)
There's a bit of truth in there. But my remark was more general than just apple's product. The audio software industry is extremely poor compared to the difficulty of the algorithmic it has to deal with. It's the only computer tools i know that needs sub 50ms latency all the time, with extremely complex mathematic computations, along with an extremely and intuitive GUI.

A proof of that is that android still doesn't have descent audio performance. Yet it is able to do everything else.

Re:Logic Pro X by bpicolo on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @12:02PM (#6052736)
Well, with Photoshop you don't really have competition. There are a lot of players in the music editing business. Competition = lower prices.
Re:Logic Pro X by wtvanhest on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @12:04PM (#6052751)
As someone that doesn't own any apple products, do you recommend any decent alternatives?

[ADDED]

Thanks for adding those, I was looking at them after I wrote my question. Its kind of hard to know which is a solid option from the reviews and what I'm seeing online.

Re:Logic Pro X by cageface on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @12:16PM (#6052833)
There are plenty of alternatives to Logic. Check out Cubase, Ableton Live, Studio One, Sonar, Reason, Reaper etc.
Re:Logic Pro X by joeblau on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @12:33PM (#6052930)
You just gonna leave out Pro Tools :).
Re:Logic Pro X by diggum on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @01:03PM (#6053133)
And Audition? ::)
Re:Logic Pro X by bwy on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @12:12PM (#6052802)
GIMP isn't bad.
Re:Logic Pro X by nkozyra on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @12:34PM (#6052939)
It isn't bad.

It also isn't Photoshop.

Re:Logic Pro X by deadreturns2 on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @05:47PM (#6054954)
I love FOSS but GIMP is ridiculously bad.
Re:Logic Pro X by ttflee on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @01:53AM (#6056293)
What makes it worse is that I can't find an alternative choice.
Re:Logic Pro X by gideon_b on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @01:17PM (#6053235)
I wouldn't jump to that conclusion, Mac software is priced as bait for Apple hardware. Professional recording equipment is very expensive, and high-end producers have no qualms spending a few grand on Pro Tools plugins. Logic isn't the Photoshop of recording, it's more like Sketch.
Re:Logic Pro X by cmpxchg8 on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @04:23PM (#6054495)
People use Pro Tools because PT has been the industry standard for years. For tracking and mixing PT11 is pretty good. Some people master using PT, others prefer something like Sequoia.

For MIDI work PT is several years behind Cubase, Logic and Ableton. Everybody has their own favorite. I've found Logic to fit my workflow very well and is not any less of a professional tool than the other DAWs I mentioned.

Re:Logic Pro X by debian69 on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @08:42PM (#6055569)
All of these are lightyears behind Mark of the Unicorn Digital Performer for midi work.

Logic btw is horrible for external midi or was at least up till version 9. I've lost count the times it mess's up with my virus ti.

Re:Logic Pro X by jolohaga on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @01:28PM (#6053315)
Photoshop could never inspire me to do anything artistic.