News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by Mordor on Friday July 12, 2013 @05:33AM (#6031748)
I've stopped using Facebook and behold - all my best friends are still here. If a friendship can't exist without Facebook, then they probably aren't your friend at all...
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by mathrawka on Friday July 12, 2013 @06:03AM (#6031824)
It's a bit different when friends are spread out all over the globe. If I want to message someone 13 hours away it is either Facebook or email, and facebook has been replacing those short messages that email or IM used to be used for.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by tripzilch on Friday July 12, 2013 @07:53AM (#6032104)
You can't email someone 13 hours away? [0] What difference does it make if they're spread out all over the globe or not, whether you can email or FB them?

I do get the idea, sometimes I feel a little bit excluded without an FB account, but I have never had the problem that somebody didn't have an email address. Not even kids.

People seem to make up all sorts of excuses, but in the end it always boils down to 1) suffering minor inconveniences and 2) the (often[1] irrational) fear of social exile.

As other people have pointed out, changing networks is not that hard. It's a false belief that it is. Years ago my local friends were mostly on MSN[2], East European/Middle East folks were on ICQ and Y!C, US people were using AIM. So I used Trillian and later Pidgin. What you saw was this, people are moving around all the time, and many of the persons were 2 or 3x in my contact list because they too were on multiple networks. Google chat just sort of edged itself in there as well.

Think of it like this, remember how easy it was to find all your friends on FB because of that network? And didn't the same happen with email, and with AIM/MSN/iCQ/etc? I see friends and acquaintances trickle in on G+ without any effort for that reason (except I don't want to use G+ either). Now FB pushes its "help" quite aggressively, but even without that, people connect in networks, point eachother to their friends, it's very peer-to-peer :)

[0] I mean, it happens ... http://www.ibiblio.org/harris/500milemail.html

[1] note I'm not saying "always", I can imagine certain high school scenarios where this fear might be somewhat real, although one has to wonder ...

[2] unfortunately I lost my MSN acct because the not-hotmail domain I registered it to expired a long long time ago and it stopped working--if anyone knows a solution to that I'd love to hear it because I would love to see that old contact list back :) (however I could also reg a new account and repopulate my contacts via-via just as easy)

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by freehunter on Friday July 12, 2013 @08:28AM (#6032199)
>You can't email someone 13 hours away?

>facebook has been replacing those short messages that email or IM used to be used for.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by TsiCClawOfLight on Friday July 12, 2013 @06:20AM (#6031858)
But why? Why can't people use email anymore? This is a genuine question! I rarely feel like I would need something other than email for anything, so I don't understand how facebook replaced that?
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by amirmc on Friday July 12, 2013 @06:42AM (#6031904)
FB gives you a great way to stay peripherally involved in people's lives. It allows you to have numerous but low-cost touch points such that when you next have a chance to properly catch-up you already know what the major events have been.

It's the complete opposite of email where I think "I'll wait until I have something proper to say" and then never send anything. On FB, it's totally normal to leave one-line comments. Having said this, I barely use FB anymore (due to privacy concerns).

Edit: I should also add that I've never used email in the social way that people seem to refer to. I really don't understand how that would be possible. FB allowed new types of social exchanges that didn't exist before (for me, at least).

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by TsiCClawOfLight on Friday July 12, 2013 @08:54AM (#6032300)
I think I start to get it, thank you. So facebook basically replaces blogs/microblogging and photo sharing websites? i.e. blogs for the passive or peripheral involvement. Regarding your second point, mailing lists and group emails combined with personal emails are a good medium of social interaction IMO.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by rahoulb on Friday July 12, 2013 @10:09AM (#6032631)
It's more like having RSS feeds in your reader for blogs that are rarely updated and you may have forgotten about (although not quite as you have to actively mark feeds as read).

An email (whether direct or via a mailing list) is an interruption (at least to me), whereas a Facebook post just drops off the bottom of the page if I ignore it.

EDIT: Sorry, that was poorly worded.

The discovery side of it is more like an RSS reader (or maybe a group email). But the key distinction (for me at least) is that I can be totally passive - I don't even need to mark things as read - or I can engage.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by amirmc on Sunday July 14, 2013 @12:06PM (#6041222)
Moreoever, it's socially acceptable to be passive whereas ignoring an email (even a group email) is considered more like wilfully ignoring them (e.g cold-shoulder, blanking, etc)
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by jtolle on Friday July 12, 2013 @09:05PM (#6036281)
Isn't there an old saw about every big "Web 2.0" business being something that took what people were already doing but made it "social"? So Facebook made blogging social, Twitter made texting social, etc.

10+ years ago I knew a bunch of people who had personal blogs, but of course most of them were filled with "sorry for the lack of posts recently" type posts.

I'm not on Facebook, but I understand why it's popular. The more people who might be reading, the more reason there is to post stuff. So it makes sense that everyone winds up in the same network.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by rahoulb on Friday July 12, 2013 @06:44AM (#6031911)
For me, it's not about the direct messaging - it's the feed.

Someone on the other side of the world posts a photo of something they've been doing, I comment on it and we have a conversation.

For this to happen without the likes of Facebook, they would have to explicitly share that photo with me, something that may or may not be likely depending upon what the photo is about, what their perception of my interests are and whether they think I want to be bothered with it.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by Volpe on Friday July 12, 2013 @06:39AM (#6031895)
Depending on your friends, facebook offers various advantages. You can see what they've been doing", see if they are online, send a simple 'hey' that wouldn't really be written if you were to use email.

People do use email still... But pretending facebook doesn't offer any value is an exercise in reality distortion.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by megablast on Friday July 12, 2013 @07:27AM (#6032024)
They can, but they do not. Why send an email to each person, when you can just post baby pictures or what you are doing to everyone on your feed? Then you don't have to worry about missing someone.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by fauigerzigerk on Friday July 12, 2013 @08:04AM (#6032133)
You could just as well use an address book group to send email to everyone or to a specific group. But I worry much more about spamming people with stuff they're not interested in than missing someone.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by freehunter on Friday July 12, 2013 @08:32AM (#6032211)
Sharing on Facebook is a passive thing. You put a picture on your profile and your friends decide if it's worth their time to look at further. You never explicitly told them to look at it, you merely gave them the opportunity. It's like hanging a picture on the wall of your home.

Email is a very explicit share. You are telling someone to look at this, because you sent it to them. This is much more personal. There's a social stigma in over-emailing, as much as there is a social stigma in not reading the emails a friend sends you. Emailing pictures is more like calling a friend. Yeah it's nice to hear their voice directly, but what if they don't want to hear what you have to say at this moment?

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by fauigerzigerk on Friday July 12, 2013 @08:48AM (#6032283)
Email has changed. I don't reply to every link or picture people send me, nor do I expect a reply on each and every email I send.

There are certainly different social assumptions between email and Facebook, but the differences have long started to blur, depending on what context we're talking about (e.g work vs friends, etc.)

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by TsiCClawOfLight on Friday July 12, 2013 @08:57AM (#6032309)
I agree with fauigerzigerk. I would say that email can, at this point, be used to "bump" stuff, to inform people, etc. without commitment or expectancy of an answer. At least, that's the way I use it.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by DamnYuppie on Friday July 12, 2013 @10:27AM (#6032742)
I don't agree with this. I have had friends spread all over the globe and we still managed to have a call once a week and text regularly. Facebook does nothing to promote or enhance true friendships, it is social lip gloss at best. Yet too many people are to unfilled and shallow to truly see it.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by betterunix on Friday July 12, 2013 @10:31AM (#6032763)
Not really. My friends are spread out all over the globe. I do not use Facebook. I still manage to email and IM them without any headaches or complaints.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by aw3c2 on Friday July 12, 2013 @10:55AM (#6032912)
That's lucky. What IM do you use? Skype? ;)
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by betterunix on Friday July 12, 2013 @01:49PM (#6033941)
It is not "lucky," it is a result of the fact that my friends are actually my friends. For what it's worth, I use jabber.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by antimagic on Friday July 12, 2013 @07:33AM (#6032038)
Here's the thing. My friends and I use Facebook to organise evenings out and other outings. We have one friend that refuses to use Facebook, so now we post an event in Facebook, and then someone has to go to the effort of keeping the outcast informed. It's actually quite a pain for your friends if you refuse to use the tool that they are using to organise themselves. It makes your friends do extra work to accomodate you...
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by muyuu on Friday July 12, 2013 @10:27AM (#6032740)
It's you and your friends who decided to make him an outcast by forcing him to choose to stay in a particular closed site when there are so many open options to organise meet-ups, including simply firing an email with CC/BCC to all parties.

Even now there are still simpletons who don't understand the reasoning of those deciding to stay away of these sites. I'm saying just understanding it, not necessarily agreeing to it.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by jakobe on Friday July 12, 2013 @09:03AM (#6032341)
All my other tools don't track everything I do with them, don't sell the information to advertisers, and don't spam me with dozens of emails.

I don't get why it's necessary to justify not using such a "tool".

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by wutbrodo on Friday July 12, 2013 @09:40PM (#6036356)
I know this not the crux of your post, but have you tried turning off email notifications from Facebook? I did sometime ago and I haven't gotten an email from them in years. Moving Facebook notifications out of my inbox and into a space that I had to explicitly poll went a long way towards reducing how annoying FB could be.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by disgruntledphd2 on Saturday July 13, 2013 @07:00AM (#6037249)
1) Facebook do not sell your information to advertisers. 2) The emails are pretty easy to remove - case in point, I stopped them sending me emails in 2009, and have not received one since. Linkedin on the other hand, go straight into spam because they just won't stop sending me mails...
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by jakobe on Saturday July 13, 2013 @07:58AM (#6037354)
First thing I did was disable all email notifications. Not a trivial task: I had to turn off like 30 different types of notifications one by one. However, these sly bastards just kept coming up with new notifications, that were turned on by default. So I kept getting emails from facebook, even though I thought I had disabled all of them.

That was my experience a year or two ago. At some point I deleted my facebook account, because the value I got out of it wasn't sufficient to tolerate all those annoyances: changing email notifications, constantly changing privacy settings and policies, annoying ads, annoying messages from people I barely know...

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by disgruntledphd2 on Saturday July 13, 2013 @10:20AM (#6037578)
I got rid of everything a few years back. The only thing they introduced was the mentions, and i disabled that a few weeks ago (after my friends learned about it). I didn't have the same experience, to be honest. I found Linkedin much more difficult.

Mind you, the constantly shifting privacy settings are weird, its easy to be really granular (go to your Activity Log) but it is effort. You can also change privacy on a post by post basis, but its sticky, so you need to be careful. The ads never really bothered me (except for the dating ones just after i came out of a long term relationship). In fact, I never ad-blocked facebook because I could x out of ads I didn't want to see. The annoying messages from people is not really Facebook's fault, though I feel your pain....

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by betterunix on Friday July 12, 2013 @02:00PM (#6033994)
You make it sound like this is the fault of the person who is not on Facebook, as opposed to the fault of the people who chose to use a system that has zero interoperability with other systems. From where I sit, the problem is you for choosing to use a closed system to organize social events. The problem is you for allowing Facebook to control your social life in this fashion.

Making someone into an outcast because they do not use your favorite social networking system is the problem here.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by antitrust on Friday July 12, 2013 @11:48AM (#6033203)
I really like email lists. Everyone has email. Most get it on their phone. I feel your pain... and this is my suggestion for a work-around.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by lttlrck on Saturday July 13, 2013 @08:25AM (#6037394)
If you were truly his friend you wouldn't be moaning about him in public...
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by eyeareque on Friday July 12, 2013 @01:22PM (#6033788)
After quitting facebook I realized that my true friends would still be my friends. Two months have passed and (in my case anyway) I feel like I am building better friendships with my friends because of using email/sms/voice calls more often instead of facebook.