News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by veridies on Friday July 12, 2013 @03:49AM (#6031415)
It's bizarre to see the number of comments on places with normally great discussion (Ars Technica being a prime example) who talk about how this kid should "only" get community service or a small fine.

He made a joke. An obvious joke, seemingly devoid of any real malice. The idea that he should invoke any punishment for this is insane. His speech is protected by the First Amendment, and morally he did absolutely nothing wrong.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by SagelyGuru on Friday July 12, 2013 @03:59AM (#6031456)
I remember the days, my friend, when people got charged with what they did rather than with what they said. I am feeling very old suddenly. The combination of introducing new thought and speech crimes, while recording everything everybody says and writes, brings us squarely into an unchartered new era of despotism. No doubt this case figures prominently in the handful of statistics of "prevented terrorism attacks", used to justify the NSA activities. There is a danger here of a vicious downward spiral, whereby such cases are energetically pursued because they are interpreted as successes of the surveillance, used to boost the surveillance and thus to create even more such cases.
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by rayiner on Friday July 12, 2013 @08:21AM (#6032181)
Those days never existed, people just got worked up about different stupid shit.

Also: what's the point of bringing the NSA into this? Some Canadian lady saw his Facebook post and called the police.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by cloverich on Friday July 12, 2013 @09:40AM (#6032494)
> Also: what's the point of bringing the NSA into this? Some Canadian lady saw his Facebook post and called the police

Because its easy to draw a line between: 1. Some lady see's stupid thing you posted, you go to jail. 2. NSA Analyst finds some stupid thing you posted (at any point in the past?), you go to jail.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by acuozzo on Friday July 12, 2013 @10:04AM (#6032603)
> Some Canadian lady saw his Facebook post and called the police.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian,_Texas

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by droidist2 on Friday July 12, 2013 @01:30PM (#6033832)
Wow, that's quite a setup for confusion. Who named that town, Abbott and Costello?
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by criley2 on Friday July 12, 2013 @02:04PM (#6034018)
History bias. If you're a boomer, then you were alive during the Cold War and the red scare, periods where surveillance and crimes of "words" were arguably as bad or worse.

If not before that, then you're greatest generation, and you're obviously not Japanese because you would be singing a very different tune about American civil liberties and being charged for "crimes" had you lived through internment.

These examples go back as long as there is civilization...

I don't buy your "things used to be better" nostalgia. Everything looks better decades later, but it doesn't make it true...

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by SagelyGuru on Saturday July 13, 2013 @06:12AM (#6037196)
>I don't buy your "things used to be better" nostalgia. Everything looks better decades later, but it doesn't make it true...

Of course things were better. The "laws" under which this boy is being hounded did not exist. Plus many other similar new laws.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by criley2 on Monday July 15, 2013 @08:55AM (#6045190)
Again, your mypoia to history does not make today worse.

Widespread, blatant, unmonitored wiretapping has occurred in our history many times. Whether during the Cold War, or before, in the earlier days of telephony when checks and balances were quite literally impossible, the government has absolutely taken full advantage of the prevailing technology without respect to Constitutional rights.

You can argue that the technology makes the scale worse, but the same people are making the same decisions they always have.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by rayiner on Friday July 12, 2013 @08:18AM (#6032172)
Its bizarre to see the number of comments turning this into some dire constitutional issue. No court has said he isn't protected by the first amendment. He said something online, some uptight woman saw it and told the police, now the police are charging him to cover their asses in case he becomes the next Dylan klebold. The constitution doesn't protect you from having to endure stupid shit like this and you're looking at history through rose colored glasses if you think small town Texas sheriffs ever stopped and said "gee, this is a violation of this kid's first amendment rights."

Its an awful injustice and the guy posting the bond is a hero. But people have been prosecuted for stupid shit like this since time immemorial. Heck, at least the kid is white. It would make your skin crawl to read the kind of prosecutions small towns have engaged in against black people.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by CapitalistCartr on Friday July 12, 2013 @08:58AM (#6032313)
"now the police are charging him to cover their asses in case he becomes the next Dylan klebold. The constitution doesn't protect you from having to endure stupid shit like this and you're looking at history through rose colored glasses if you think small town Texas sheriffs ever stopped and said 'gee, this is a violation of this kid's first amendment rights.' "

Yes, the point of the Bill of Rights is to protect against exactly this sort of thing, to prevent the government from shutting people up. That it has happened before, especially based on race, doesn't at all make it right, ethical, or legal. The whole point here is that freedom of speech isn't fought at Michelangelo's David, its fought at Larry Flynt's Hustler.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by adventured on Friday July 12, 2013 @08:59AM (#6032318)
There are numerous cases just like this one going on around the country at the same time. This is not an isolated case, as such it is in fact a dire constitutional issue. Failure to properly defend against these trial balloons will see the definition of freedom of speech radically altered in the span of a single decade. Governments rarely give back ground that they take.
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by Vivtek on Friday July 12, 2013 @12:22PM (#6033449)
Well, but you make it sound as though the Government is some monolithic Man. It isn't.

What's different now is that when the sheriff in some podunk town in Texas throws a mouthy kid into jail unjustly, the entire country hears about it on the Internet. That's a game-changer.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by lkozma on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:59AM (#6031660)
I wonder what would happen if thousands would coordinate to post similar jokes, thereby swamping the legal system and pointing out the absurdity - similarly to the http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AACS_encryption_key_controversy
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by kps on Friday July 12, 2013 @09:53AM (#6032560)
A blogger has proposed a “Quote Justin Carter” day for August 1.

http://ethicsalarms.com/2013/07/08/i-propose-a-quote-justin-...

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by DanBC on Friday July 12, 2013 @06:52AM (#6031932)
Or what would happen if people reported every similar "threat" they heard on Xbox live and similar?
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by tripzilch on Friday July 12, 2013 @08:24AM (#6032183)
The difference between the GP's and your suggestion is who takes the risk. Both protests would risk getting a few people in nasty situations with the authorities.

In the GP's plan that risk lies with the protestors themselves, in your plan it's the random xbox playing kids you are suggesting to report on. Making the problem worse before it gets better and possibly introducing a chilling effect causing the opposite of what you intend to accomplish.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by cinquemb on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:18AM (#6031526)
People who choose to live their lives by fear will be engulfed by their own flames. If the mere utterance of words can drive people to punish fellow beings to any extent, then it is only a matter time before they are stricken with their own gavel…
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by corresation on Friday July 12, 2013 @10:13AM (#6032652)
The comments (and moderation) on here overwhelmingly lean towards the "it was all a joke...freedom!" angle, so I'm not sure which HN you're reading. The very few counterpoints are in light gray.

The police dispute whether the "jk lol" part happened. The only person who vouches for that is his father.

Is his initial threat credible? Perhaps not, but it absolutely does deserve a visit from police (many school shooters have made the same sort of at-the-time humorous comments beforehand), and I doubt many who claim otherwise would stick to their positions had he actually then moved to violence. What the police actually discovered we don't know, but apparently it was enough to make the police, the prosecutor, and a judge escalate the situation.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by Simple1234 on Friday July 12, 2013 @11:10AM (#6032977)
I would stick to my position if it escalated to violence. The best strategy to counter terrorism is not to give up freedom. Giving up freedom is society acting as if it is terrorized. Acting terrorized is exactly what terrorist want.

Whether he wrote a song, a poem, a joke, a virus infected his computer and posted it, a friend wrote it while he wasn't looking, a hacker got in and wrote it, or any one of a million ways it could have come into existence or be interpreted, the government does not have to right to suppress his speech, set excessive bail, and seize his person. That is why we have the 1st, 4th, and 8th amendments. If all speech was happy-go-lucky speech, it wouldn't need to be protected.

I would rather die in a terrorist attack, then live without liberty. Look up the number of deaths caused by smoking, cars, alcohol, and obesity and then compare them to the deaths from terrorist. Then explain to my why we can't risk having a kid express himself. When did we become the land of the oppressed and the home of those scared by words?

"Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." Really think about that. Think about what it means, why it was said, what the logic is behind it, what the philosophy is behind it. Say it over and over to yourself. Say it to friends and family. Memorize it. Live by it. It is the quintessential wisdom for our time, and for all time.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by corresation on Friday July 12, 2013 @12:08PM (#6033320)
There have always been restrictions on speech -- specifically as it relates to threatening others -- for time eternal, having nothing whatsoever to do with terrorism. I'm actually Canadian, and here we have limits on hate speech, and I'm entirely for that.

We all need to live together, and rote recitations of absolute rights -- cast as if it's stark choices of blacks and whites -- doesn't match a reality that the world is a series of grays, and that your rights are perpetually in conflict with the rights of others (the rights of someone to make ill-conceived threats, versus the right to live peacefully and safely).

I also find it remarkable how many people cast this individual as a "kid". He is 19. At 19 many of us were living on our own, attending university, and there was no absurd notion that threats to schoolchildren would be treated as a joke, lol jk rofl.

Neither of us know why the police, judge and prosecutor decided to treat this so seriously, and it may absolutely be a gross overreach of the law, but at the same time the reflexively opposite reaction that holds his as an innocent joke of constitutional protected threats seem ill considered.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by veridies on Friday July 12, 2013 @06:13PM (#6035586)
I specified Ars Technica as an example because I don't think Hacker News is bad here. In fact, I think HN's discussion about this issue has been great.

Whether or not the "LOL" "J/K" happened, the joke is obvious comedic hyperbole. I've had friends make really similar jokes. I'm sure you have too. My housemate shouts things like that over Skype while playing League of Legends. School shooters may write things like that, but so do plenty of perfectly well-adjusted teenagers.

I don't really have a problem with police making a visit, either. I don't think it's necessary, but if the police wanted to stop by and ask if everything's alright, no harm done. Still, there's a big jump from a police visit to searching his house and arresting him, and they seem to have done all three on the basis of a Facebook comment.

And if they found something really worrying, then they should be charging the kid with that. The fact that this is all they have implies that they haven't found that he's anything illegal. And if he hasn't, he obviously shouldn't be charged.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by TeMPOraL on Saturday July 13, 2013 @10:24AM (#6037589)
> Perhaps not, but it absolutely does deserve a visit from police (many school shooters have made the same sort of at-the-time humorous comments beforehand)

It's not how reality works.

Just write it like this:

P(shooter|makes-a-joke) = P(makes-a-joke|shooter) * P(shooter) / P(makes-a-joke).

And try to look at it, even qualitatively.

Even if every shooter was known to have made those kinds of jokes ( P(makes-a-joke|shooter) = 1 ), there are many, many more kids making those jokes who don't end up shooting anybody ( P(shooter)/P(makes-a-joke) ~ 0 because P(shooter) will be around 1/10^6 (several hundreds shootings so far over hundreds of millions of children being alive at those times) ).

Therefore a visit from police is absolutely undeserved because this test has mind-bogglingly huge potential for false positives. You'd probably had to interrogate thousands of kids per a school shooter to be found.

It's the same reason when you get "positive" on cancer test that has 99% chance of being right if you have cancer, that doesn't mean you have 99% chance of having cancer. It probably bumped up from 0.001% to 2% or something.

> and I doubt many who claim otherwise would stick to their positions had he actually then moved to violence.

Those who wouldn't shall be considered unwise and taught how the world works until they understand causality.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by k-mcgrady on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:06AM (#6031483)
>> "An obvious joke"

Not that obvious. The only thing that makes it clear this was a joke was the addition of 'jk'. A lot of people won't know when that means and even though I know what it means I'd still be worried after reading the post and probably have it looked into. There are some things normal people don't even joke about - this is one of them.

Edit: I might be wrong on the last point. There will be some people who joke about these types of things. But his post wasn't funny. It was just a sick statement.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by peferron on Friday July 12, 2013 @05:06AM (#6031676)
I feel very unsafe knowing that people like you, who are able to consider seriously a scenario as inhuman as eating the still-beating hearts of children, are still out there and free to go. A normal person wouldn't ever be able to think about it as anything else than a joke. The fact that you consider it realistically possible is very disturbing. Who knows what you could do if your life hits a low point and you suddenly flip your crazy switch? If you were living next door to me, I would report you to the authorities, and hope you get jailed with $1M bail until it's made clear that you aren't a ticking bomb endangering our children.
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by greedo on Friday July 12, 2013 @10:23AM (#6032714)
The sarcasm is strong with this one, young padawan.
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by sillysaurus on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:29AM (#6031575)
For the record, here's exactly what the teen said:

"Oh yeah, I’m real messed up in the head, I’m going to go shoot up a school full of kids and eat their still-beating hearts. Lol jk"

That's an obvious joke. The "lol jk" wasn't even necessary to flag it as such.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by jlgreco on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:39AM (#6031608)
Seriously, eating peoples still beating hearts? I don't care about Poe's Law or how much sarcasm doesn't translate to ascii... if that is not plainly a joke to you then you have some serious issues with the english language that you need to resolve.
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by dkersten on Friday July 12, 2013 @05:11AM (#6031694)
I make worse jokes than this on a weekly basis. That something like this could lead to any kind of punishment beyond "stop making tasteless jokes" is insane.
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by jlgreco on Friday July 12, 2013 @05:21AM (#6031727)
Same. I am stunned that this apparently warrants any sort of official response, and I am doubly stunned that so many people seem to support a response of some sort.
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by droithomme on Friday July 12, 2013 @11:07AM (#6032962)
Well, it's not exactly a joke, it's a comment ridiculing the other person by responding with obvious dripping sarcasm. People who really take "eat their still-beating hearts" seriously from a teenager playing a video game have serious difficulty parsing reality.

However, I am skeptical that there is anyone that actually took it seriously and didn't understand that this was a sarcastic comment. Those advocating this teen's continued imprisonment while making claims he is a potential mass murderer or terrorist are not sincere, they are interested in promoting the exercise of state power for its own sake.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by Myrmornis on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:11AM (#6031496)
Rubbish. It's perfectly normal to joke about killing kindergarten kids; it's perfectly normal to joke about all sorts of unpleasant things. Young peoples' culture and the culture of people who don't lead very sheltered lives does push the boundaries of good taste quite a bit, and that is normal.
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by visarga on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:54AM (#6031650)
I can attest that while I was a kid, in my country (Romania), "I'm gonna kill you!" was just an emphatic variant of "I'm gonna beat you!" (which itself was not meant, just a verbal threat) and it came up quite frequently between boys under 15.

They also say "Shall my mom die if what I say is not true!" just to put emphasis, short version is "My mom die, I just found something interesting!" Weird? Everyone knows not to take that literally. A variant is "I should die, look here what I found!"

In the countryside there is a threat that sounds like "I'ma kill you and then do something else" (implying a beating) just as a funny way to scold a child.

Almost no usage of the word "kill" in conversation is literal. It's just a way to project aggression, get attention or just joke around.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by venomsnake on Friday July 12, 2013 @06:08AM (#6031836)
A little south of the border - Bulgaria. In the north parts of the country the Christmas slaughtering of a pig is called killing (without specifying the species).

So a Bulgarian invites Romanian relative to come visit for the killing (mostly brutal overeating on various pig parts with few gallons of wine for drink). Some cops intercept that and mount a full force investigation, wasting money and man hours, arrest the guys etc ... then release them of course, but this would have been avoided if just the cops has asked someone from that part of the country about the jargon used.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by tripzilch on Friday July 12, 2013 @08:27AM (#6032198)
Maybe they were pig cops?
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by freehunter on Friday July 12, 2013 @08:38AM (#6032242)
In the US we have a similar statement: "I swear on my mother's life that this is true".

Kids even have a rhyme they sing while skipping down a sidewalk. The rules of the game are, you can't step on a crack between the stones. "Step on a crack and break your mother's back".

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by Vivtek on Friday July 12, 2013 @12:32PM (#6033500)
Pfft. I do that with my kids. "I'll keel you! I'll keel you until you are dead!" They giggle and run away. This is how normal people talk to their kids.
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by Cakez0r on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:49AM (#6031635)
So he should be punished because firstly people couldn't infer that he was joking and secondly still couldn't infer that he was joking after he clarified that he was joking? 'jk' is really not that hard to figure out given the context.

Regardless of whether people know what he means, his intent is very clear. He shouldn't be punished because some people are too stupid to interpret what he's saying or deliberately misinterpret what he's saying to get him in to trouble.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by megablast on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:18AM (#6031528)
> There are some things normal people don't even joke about - this is one of them.

Is this how we should be judged by society, by what normal people joke about? Are you seriously holding that up as a point?

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by tripzilch on Friday July 12, 2013 @08:38AM (#6032236)
> Is this how we should be judged by society, by what normal people joke about?

Yes, but in the opposite way: by what normal people are free to joke about.

(slightly off-topic: IMO the only way to really judge a society, is by the way it treats the very lowest/poorest/worst-off. everything comes after that. close your eyes to only a tiny fraction of the very long long tail of the very worst, and your perception gets very much skewed)

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by cnwejfnwek on Friday July 12, 2013 @08:31AM (#6032210)
No, the 'jk' isn't the only thing that makes it clear it was a joke. The phrase "still beating hearts" is an example of ridiculous over-the-top language used for the effect of humour. That's sometimes how humour works, you say something and people know it's not serious, because of how ridiculous it is. For example, if someone threatened to stab you, you might think it was a credible threat. If they threatened to sacrifice you to Kali while sodomising your pet gerbil, it's probably a joke.

It's more than just "some people" who joke about dark things. I would say most people make dark or sick jokes with their friends. It's normal behaviour. I find it hard to understand why you don't already know everything I'm saying. In fact it's slightly worrying that you have such a narrow (naive even) view on how "normal" people behave, and yet you feel qualified to have an opinion on the credibility of online threats.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by antihero on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:42AM (#6031620)
We don't punish people on being funny, we punish people based on whether it's a serious, credible threat, which this clearly was not. No motive, no means, etc.
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by nitrogen on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:12AM (#6031498)
There's no such thing as normal, especially when it comes to humor.
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by mseebach on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:19AM (#6031529)
Obvious or not, a reasonable responses would be to send a cop around for a "friendly" chat with the kids and his parents about certain jokes not being appropriate because they'll freak too many people out. Maybe a shrink interview for CYA.
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by InclinedPlane on Friday July 12, 2013 @05:58AM (#6031811)
What? A reasonable response would be to do nothing.
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by k-mcgrady on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:26AM (#6031558)
I would agree with this but he's 19. At 19 you are not a kid and shouldn't need the repercussions of such a statement explained. I think this should be tried in court as a threat to kill, proved he was 'joking' and he should end up with a very, very minor punishment or some time with a psychiatrist.

Edit: No reply link for me to respond the below comments so updating here.

Re: psychiatrist. >> "There's no suggestion that the comments were caused by mental illness"

If someone makes a statement like that and you decide it's a joke and not to punish them having a psychiatrist investigate seems sensible to me. You aren't punishing him so at least make sure he wasn't serious.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by polymatter on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:50AM (#6031640)
I am not sure if you are serious, but this is a teen playing a computer game with his friends. He was responding to a comment that he was "insane". He was showing he was 'insane' by making an outrageously insane comment. And then labelled it as such with "jk lol". I am not sure how it could possibly be more obvious that this was not a serious terrorist plot to eat children.

Perhaps if he had stated he was a unicorn from jupiter you would believe we should do a forced live autopsy on him to verify his extraordinary claims. The previous statement was a joke. The previous statement was not.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by jlgreco on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:36AM (#6031599)
> proved he was 'joking'

So now he has to prove his own innocence as well? What fucking country is this? The prosecution has to prove guilt in America, not the defence innocence.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by k-mcgrady on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:46AM (#6031627)
I didn't mean it he has to prove it (although I worded that badly). I meant the outcome of the trial should be he was joking.
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by DanBC on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:31AM (#6031582)
Important brain stuff hasn't finished developing by 19. He's not allowed to drink alcohol because he's not adult enough. He's not a child, but he's not an adult.

> or some time with a psychiatrist.

Why? There's no suggestion that the comments were caused by mental illness, just by immaturity and disinhibited environment.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by gadders on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:50AM (#6031641)
You can drink alcohol at 18 in the UK. Even earlier in Europe, I believe. Does that mean our brains develop faster?
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by jlgreco on Friday July 12, 2013 @05:02AM (#6031666)
Eh, liquor age laws in the US are actually very varied. 29 states allow minors to drink on private property with parent permission (for example, parents giving their child a glass of wine with dinner.) and 11 states allow parents to order their children alcoholic beverages at restaurants. 6 states allow children to drink on private property without parent permission (for example, I get home from highschool and crack open a cold one before 'the rents' get home).

To my knowledge you have to be 21 to buy alcohol yourself in all 50 states though.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by venomsnake on Friday July 12, 2013 @06:18AM (#6031853)
Always wondered - why not just distill the stuff yourself in the US? It is extremely easy - you just need fruits, heat source, sugar and basic 6th grade chemistry knowledge to separate methanol and ethanol.

Even better solution is to just buy ultra pure for analysis ethanol from local chemistry store (or Merck), dilute with distilled water 3/2, add some drops (very little - a drop or two per liter) of glycerin to smooth the taste, some citric acid or lemon juice.

It is better than top shelf vodka.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by jlgreco on Friday July 12, 2013 @06:41AM (#6031901)
Distilling in America requires paperwork and some taxes, and special construction, even just for personal use. It is pretty much a royal pain in the ass to do legally (http://www.ttb.gov/spirits/faq.shtml#s7), though of course some people do make illegal moonshine.

Homebrewing beer legally is trivial though, and a fairly popular hobby. Homebrewing beer legally for personal use was trickier until 1979 iirc, so there isn't a long tradition of it yet, but it is becoming increasingly popular as time goes on.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by droithomme on Friday July 12, 2013 @11:30AM (#6033098)
I agree with you it is fun and educational.

However, unauthorized distillation in the US is considered a serious federal crime which is investigated by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms, which tends to do everything with full force military raids that kill their targets and/or result in long prison terms.

A license to distill for fuel use only costs $3000 a year.

Home distillation is permitted in many countries. In the US it is unlikely as much of the country still believes that alcohol comes from the devil and anyone who drinks is not going to get to heaven. There are still dry counties in which sales of alcohol are not permitted at all, and there are still Sunday laws in place in many areas.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by gadders on Friday July 12, 2013 @06:43AM (#6031905)
I think most UK people can find an off licence or pub that serves them at 15. We certainly did at my school.
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by jlgreco on Friday July 12, 2013 @06:44AM (#6031912)
Oh yes, the situation there is certainly better. I'm just pointing out that the drinking age is not strictly 21 across the US.
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by DanBC on Friday July 12, 2013 @06:48AM (#6031921)
I did mean to say "buy", not "drink". And in the UK you're legally allowed to drink alcohol from the age of 5.

My point was that the state imposes restrictions on him because the state thinks he's not adult enough to handle the consequences. The state doesn't allow him to buy alcohol because the state thinks he's too immature to do so. Thus, it seems unfair for the state to suddenly claim that he's fully adult and fully capable of behaving like an adult and fully responsible for his actions.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by sillysaurus on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:30AM (#6031579)
I think this should be tried in court as a threat to kill

You can't be serious?

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by k-mcgrady on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:37AM (#6031602)
That's what he did - he threatened to kill. I'm not familiar with US law so maybe there is something more appropriate he could be charged with.

Edit: Based on the US freedom of speech I'm guessing written and oral threats to kill aren't an offence.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by dalke on Friday July 12, 2013 @05:48AM (#6031787)
Some are, some aren't. At a sports game, when disgruntled fans yell out "kill the ref", they are not charged with a crime, much less required to pay $500,000 in bail, sent into solitary confinement, and occasionally stripped naked while waiting for trial.

I believe that it is your viewpoint that any sports player or fan who says anything which can be construed as threatening to kill should be charged with a crime.

Here's a specific oral threat from Shannon Sharpe of the Broncos: "we are killing the Patriots". Of course, the larger context is: "Mr. President! Call in the National Guard! Send as many men as you can spare! Because we are killing the Patriots! They need emergency help!"

Should he be charged? If so, you have an extremely low threshold for free speech. If not, what makes this not a threat, while the teenager's statement is a threat?

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by k-mcgrady on Friday July 12, 2013 @05:53AM (#6031801)
In those instances it's very clear that it's not a real threat, I doubt anybody reported it. In this case it was unclear whether it was a serious threat and somebody reported it. The work kill is used in the contexts you presented all the time and people understand that it isn't serious. It's not everyday you hear it people threaten to kill/shoot children as a joke and some people rightly take that seriously.
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by dalke on Friday July 12, 2013 @07:49AM (#6032091)
What makes it clear that something is a real threat?

If there's lack of motive, lack of planning, and lack of weapons, then is it a threat? Everything about this case says that there was no evidence that it was real, and that all exculpatory evidence (eg, the context this was smack talk, and the "j/k" and "lol" disclaimer) were removed from the evidence presented to the judge.

You say that unusual expressions are more deserving of investigation, and should have a lower threshold than 'normal' phrases like "I'm so angry with you that I could to kill you." However, in the context, the person accused had just been insulted by being called "crazy", and the response seems to have a riff on what "crazy" might really mean, quickly followed by the disclaimers.

Where is the actual threat? I don't see how this teenager is a real threat, just like you don't see how those other cases are real threats.

For that matter, and from what I understand, the person who reported the message is from Canada. Canada has a different cultural expectation of what free speech means than the US. If it takes a single report to make the sort of complaint about "unusual speech", do we need to accept anyone's standard threshold anywhere in the world?

If a DC police officer, who sometimes works as a motorcycle escort for the First Lady, can jokingly say that he want to kill her, and purportedly shows another officer a picture of the weapon he will use to do so, then surely that's a much more serious threat, with specific access and ability. Yet, that officer wasn't charged with a crime, nor sent to prison with a high bond. As I understand, he had desk duty while the investigation occurred.

Why is this case with the teenager so deserving of a disproportionately high bond, compared to other threats which are seemingly more credible?

Recently in Oklahoma, "A Norman man threatened via email to kill Gov. Mary Fallin's “child” and McClain County Sheriff Don Hewitt, apparently because he is upset about the death of his own child." "Helling, who told investigators he sent the emails from the Norman Public Library, was arrested June 7 on “unrelated warrants” and booked into the Cleveland County jail. His bail has been set at $20,000, records show."

Last year in Utah, "A Utah man who police say threatened to assassinate Gov. Gary Herbert is now facing multiple felony charges." "The 52-year-old Baker is being held in the Salt Lake County jail. Bail is set at $25,007."

So we have people who have specifically threatened to kill a governor (and in one case the governor's (grown) child), and had a bail of only $25,000 or so.

Why is this teenager's case so extreme so as to require a bail of $500,000?

I've searched, but couldn't find a similar case with a bail that was this high. The closest I found was from a few years ago: "A Philadelphia man was charged with telephoning death threats into 911 against Mayor Bloomberg and Police Commissioner Kelly, authorities said Monday." "Fisher is being held on $100,000 bail after his arraignment Saturday in Manhattan Criminal Court on 10 counts of making a terroristic threat, authorities said."

I've instead found things like earlier this week, where "An Owatonna man faces felony charges after he allegedly threatened to kill a man while waving a baseball bat. Andrew John Kramer, 24, was charged with second-degree assault with a dangerous weapon and making a terroristic threat in Steele County District Court on Monday morning. ... Because of his criminal history and the possible public safety risk, Judge Joseph Bueltel set Kramer’s outright bail at $30,000 and his conditional bail at $15,000."

Do you seriously believe that these cases of direct threats against specific people, including threatening to use a baseball bat, is less serious, and less deserving of high bail, than what the teenager did?

Why?

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by DanBC on Friday July 12, 2013 @05:57AM (#6031807)
(http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20130709/18282723752/teens-...)

> D.C. Police Officer Christopher Picciano, "a 17-year veteran who was a member of the elite presidential motorcade detail," will be suspended without pay for a little over a month after joking about killing the first lady, threatening to go on a shooting spree, and calling Pres. Obama a communist.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by tripzilch on Friday July 12, 2013 @08:44AM (#6032264)
> There are some things normal people don't even joke about - this is one of them.

Those aren't normal people. At least not "normal" in the sense that you shouldn't keep a very close eye on whether you should worry about what they will do one day.

I mean sure, not joking about something is everybody's choice free to make.

> It was just a sick statement.

It's the ones making baseless assumptions and judgements like this that I am most nervous about.

Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by GotAnyMegadeth on Friday July 12, 2013 @08:07AM (#6032148)
> There are some things normal people don't even joke about

Have you never been on the internet before?