News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anonymous Person Posts $500,000 Bond To Free Texas Teen by TeMPOraL on Saturday July 13, 2013 @10:24AM (#6037589)
> Perhaps not, but it absolutely does deserve a visit from police (many school shooters have made the same sort of at-the-time humorous comments beforehand)

It's not how reality works.

Just write it like this:

P(shooter|makes-a-joke) = P(makes-a-joke|shooter) * P(shooter) / P(makes-a-joke).

And try to look at it, even qualitatively.

Even if every shooter was known to have made those kinds of jokes ( P(makes-a-joke|shooter) = 1 ), there are many, many more kids making those jokes who don't end up shooting anybody ( P(shooter)/P(makes-a-joke) ~ 0 because P(shooter) will be around 1/10^6 (several hundreds shootings so far over hundreds of millions of children being alive at those times) ).

Therefore a visit from police is absolutely undeserved because this test has mind-bogglingly huge potential for false positives. You'd probably had to interrogate thousands of kids per a school shooter to be found.

It's the same reason when you get "positive" on cancer test that has 99% chance of being right if you have cancer, that doesn't mean you have 99% chance of having cancer. It probably bumped up from 0.001% to 2% or something.

> and I doubt many who claim otherwise would stick to their positions had he actually then moved to violence.

Those who wouldn't shall be considered unwise and taught how the world works until they understand causality.

There are no comments on this comment yet.