News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Michael Hastings Sent Panicked Email Hours Before Car Crash by skwirl on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @08:52PM (#5981711)
It is a huge leap from the revelations of late and a world where the government goes around killing journalists. When your parents confided to you that Santa Claus wasn't real, you didn't suddenly become adopted too. Chill out and reacquaint with reality.
Re:Michael Hastings Sent Panicked Email Hours Before Car Crash by jychang on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @09:11PM (#5981785)
You completely misread the point. We don't know the truth, if it was foul play or not. Probably not. BUT, it doesn't matter about the size of the jump, yet the fact that it's even a POSSIBILITY THAT WE HAVE TO CONSIDER ... is scary.

Plus, it's not as large of a leap as you think, it goes hand in hand. Everyone is familiar with journalists disappearing in countries like Turkey.

Re:Michael Hastings Sent Panicked Email Hours Before Car Crash by glhaynes on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @10:08PM (#5982024)
No, you don't get to do that. You can't say "I'm speculating that this person might have been murdered. Wow, look at what the world is coming to, that people are even considering the possibility that this person was murdered. (Besides, sometimes people do get murdered...)" This is begging the question in its most basic form.
Re:Michael Hastings Sent Panicked Email Hours Before Car Crash by dllthomas on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @10:29PM (#5982078)
Well, not quite begging the question, in that it's not something you're assuming to be true but rather something you're causing to be trivially true, but it's still an odd and presumably invalid construction to be sure.
Re:Michael Hastings Sent Panicked Email Hours Before Car Crash by pessimizer on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @06:37AM (#5983586)
If you are using your suspicion as an argument to prove that Hastings was murdered. If you are saying that you are sad or afraid that you are suspicious when once you wouldn't have been, that's just a simple statement of fact.

I don't think you can ever legitimately accuse someone of a logical fallacy who isn't making an argument.

Re:Michael Hastings Sent Panicked Email Hours Before Car Crash by saalweachter on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @09:54PM (#5981980)
Yeah, but the thing is, governments -- and individuals within governments -- don't have to be super secret ninjas. They can be heavy handed and get away with it because they've got power and you don't.

The US sent helicopters full of Navy Seals into a foreign country, supposedly an ally, without their permission to kill someone, and then went on TV the next day to brag about it. George W Bush threw hundreds of people into a not-very-secret off-shore prison and then tortured them for a few years and no one did a damn thing about it. When Bradley Manning leaked diplomatic cables, we threw him in a prison and tortured him for a year or three, depending on how you count.

Governments don't have to come in the night and fake your accidental death. They can come for you in broad daylight and beat you to death in the street and no one will stop them.

Re:Michael Hastings Sent Panicked Email Hours Before Car Crash by ekianjo on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @10:09PM (#5982028)
Are you saying governments don't do anything secret, because they don't have to ? Well, you are surely misguided. Tons of governmental operations are clearly not happening in the open. And it wouldn't be the first time they make an assassination pass for an accident (or suicide, or whatever other "natural" event). Even "democracies" do that all the time.
Re:Michael Hastings Sent Panicked Email Hours Before Car Crash by dllthomas on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @09:28PM (#5981863)
Because law enforcement abusing power and doing crazy shit flat out never happens.

I agree that foul play doesn't seem like the most likely cause, and I don't expect it is systemic if so, but seeing "he was on to a pocket of more explicit corruption and they offed him" as outside the realm of possibility seems odd.

Re:Michael Hastings Sent Panicked Email Hours Before Car Crash by unclebucknasty on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @09:19PM (#5981815)
Reality? To which reality are you referring? How are you so certain what the reality here is or is not? How is your version of reality any more or less likely to be the truth?

So, no one has proven what happened. That cuts both ways. And that's the point: there are unanswered questions. No one is stating for a fact that foul play was involved. People are merely asking questions. And, given the plausibility of foul play and the incredibly mind-blowing implications if there was foul play, it is much more rational to ask questions than to summarily dismiss out of hand that it is worth asking questions, or to ridicule those who do.

Your post doesn't come off as clever. It just seems thoughtless and unserious.

Re:Michael Hastings Sent Panicked Email Hours Before Car Crash by dllthomas on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @09:32PM (#5981885)
"Neither has been proved, therefore either is equally likely" is false, and if you believed that to be the case you would be horribly calibrated in your judgements, and parent would be right to criticize it. Plausibility is of course a much lower standard, but there is still some correct level of belief; I disagree with the parent in asserting that it is clearly below "plausible" but it's a legitimate discussion.
Re:Michael Hastings Sent Panicked Email Hours Before Car Crash by unclebucknasty on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @10:50PM (#5982146)
>Neither has been proved, therefore either is equally likely" is false

I didn't say that. Go back and read my post.

In fact, it's the opposite. We have many trying to claim the illegitimacy of asking questions, because there is no direct evidence. The parent went so far as to ridicule those asking questions.

So, it is they who are making claims about which is more likely, given a lack of evidence in either direction. That is exactly what my post was about.

Re:Michael Hastings Sent Panicked Email Hours Before Car Crash by dllthomas on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @11:22PM (#5982269)
I know you didn't say that. Read my post more carefully.

Though actually, you're close to saying it here:

"[I]t is they who are making claims about which is more likely, given a lack of evidence in either direction."

If you lack evidence in either direction, your estimate of likelihood should be at your priors. If your mental model assigns the same prior probability to assassination as to car accidents, it's likely broken.

I recommend reading through http://lesswrong.com/lw/19m/privileging_the_hypothesis

Re:Michael Hastings Sent Panicked Email Hours Before Car Crash by unclebucknasty on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @09:46AM (#5984418)
I re-read your post. You are correct. It is possible to read it in a manner wherein you are not making the claim about my post. Seems a little odd as a response. Perhaps your intent would be clearer if your replies didn't hypothesize quite so much about what the parent might be thinking. I noticed a lot of "ifs" in your most recent post as well, as in "if you believe this or that". Comes off rather straw-mannish. Why not just stick to what the person actually said?

But granted, I stand corrected.

I'm aware of the general mode of privileging the hypothesis, though I've never heard that term. I'm not sure that there's anything new or groundbreaking in that post, however. For instance, criminal law is set up to avoid railroading suspects and it's a pretty easily identifiable fallacy, in general.

In any event, your conclusion that I come close to claiming them equally likely rests on its own fallacy. That is, this statement is so general as to be misleading:

"If your mental model assigns the same prior probability to assassination as to car accidents, it's likely broken"

First, I didn't assign a probability. I said we should be asking questions.

But what makes your argument fallacious is that details matter. It is not just any car accident. It is a fiery, one car, high speed accident, under unexplained circumstances. And, he is not just a random person, but a prominent reporter who brought down a powerful person and was working on a "big" story involving, presumably, other powerful people. Ignoring this information, and simply relying on the percentage of the general population who are in car accidents vs assassinated (i.e. relying on the priors) is misguided to say the least.

And while there is a lack of concrete evidence in either direction at this point, the circumstances and information we do have point to the fact that we should be asking questions, not drawing conclusions on any side. Again, that is what my posts are about. Questions.

OTOH, I'm not sure what you are actually trying to say, short of providing an off-topic and somewhat faulty explanation of how we should estimate likliehoods.

Re:Michael Hastings Sent Panicked Email Hours Before Car Crash by dllthomas on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @10:17AM (#5984619)
I think you are assuming I hold positions that I do not. I agree with you that foul play is sufficiently likely to warrant some consideration. I said as much in my own reply to skwirl's comment.

"First, I didn't assign a probability. I said we should be asking questions."

"We should be asking questions about X" is a claim that probabilities are sufficiently high that it's not a complete waste of time to be asking questions about X. You also said it was plausible, which is assigning some bounds on probability. Neither of those were what I was objecting to, however.

I was objecting to what I saw as your rejection of the sort of argument skwirl was making ("This is sufficiently unlikely that it doesn't make sense to be talking about it") in the face of lack of evidence, rather than simple rejection of the particular claim skwirl made (which I reject as well).

Re:Michael Hastings Sent Panicked Email Hours Before Car Crash by unclebucknasty on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @10:59AM (#5984933)
>I think you are assuming I hold positions that I do not.

Very possible. I think those "ifs" got me again.

>You also said it was plausible, which is assigning some bounds on probability.

A fair enough interpretation, but I was thinking of it in the more subjective sense vs. mathematical.

>I was objecting to what I saw as your rejection of the sort of argument skwirl was making

OK! Understood. LOL! I wasn't objecting to or even addressing whether the sort of argument skwirl was making could ever be valid in any scenario. My point was with regard to this particular discussion. That is, in this context it is not valid to dismiss the need for questions out-of-hand. I tried to be specific and narrow in my explanation.

I think the confusion came in because you broadened what was a very concrete discussion, then began introducing hypotheticals: "well, if you believe this or that, then the other".

I didn't make that turn. Wasn't sure what your position was or what you were attributing to me.

All of this to say, that we appear to be in agreement on the substance. That is, the circumstances merit questions.

Re:Michael Hastings Sent Panicked Email Hours Before Car Crash by smky80 on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @09:36PM (#5981911)
I can't help but notice the vast majority of your comments over the time you've been here are basically NSA spying apologism.
Re:Michael Hastings Sent Panicked Email Hours Before Car Crash by JackFr on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @09:31PM (#5981880)
Reality -- is that the place where our President has an American citizen, without trial or court order, killed by a drone? Yeah, it is. So while not proven, certainly not beyond the pale from what we do know is true.
Re:Michael Hastings Sent Panicked Email Hours Before Car Crash by latj on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @09:31PM (#5981882)
When you tell your kid Santa Claus isnt real, they already know. But when you admit it its often the first time they realize that their parents lie. If Santa Claus is fake, the Easter Bunny is probably fake too. Then one day they are sitting in church and a picture of Jesus Christ falls out of someone's bag and onto the floor. Your kid sits there, starring at upside down Jesus, and cant help but notice how much he looks like his school bus driver. After that, all the lies of the adult world unravel.
Re:Michael Hastings Sent Panicked Email Hours Before Car Crash by PavlovsCat on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @05:04AM (#5983290)
It is a huge leap from the revelations of late and a world where the government goes around killing journalists.

Well, there was Putin being all concerned about Snowden hurting his American friends, so there's that :P

Seriously though, the US government killed plenty more people for minding them a lot less. So where exactly does this huge leap come into play? That it would be hard to do? Why, just look at what random comment is floating atop this discussion, completely unfounded speculation about drug abuse or nervous breakdowns, with zero argument for them given, except that it's technically possible, however unlikely.

Are you denying that it's "technically possible" that the US government "goes around killing journalists" (which is NOT what the comment you replied to said by the way, that's all yours), however unlikely? If not, why not react with the same rigour to the original comment?

This is all kinda disgusting. Yes, we don't know either way, and maybe it's pointless to speculate. But if it's okay to speculate some utter bullshit like the top comment, then it's allowed to point something out in response without that being utterly twisted into something childish, and then being patronizing about your own fucking strawman.

Re:Michael Hastings Sent Panicked Email Hours Before Car Crash by coldtea on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @05:30AM (#5983372)
>It is a huge leap from the revelations of late and a world where the government goes around killing journalists.

Really how? How is it out of order for a government that goes around jailing foreign citizens without trial abroad to avoid local laws?