News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by clicks on Thursday April 18, 2013 @04:28PM (#5572874)
So, to be clear, the teen Salah Barhoun was the guy in the blue tracksuit who some 4chan'ers thought was the bomber. Also called out here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5562975

Here's the NYPost cover where he was featured: http://s3.amazonaws.com/dk-production/images/28618/large/o-N...

And this is why vigilante justice sucks. I'm just glad that some nutcase in real life didn't go off on him and he went to the police himself to clear his name before anything bad happened to him.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by brownbat on Thursday April 18, 2013 @04:52PM (#5573009)
> And this is why vigilante justice sucks.

a) I can't speak for 4chan, but the Reddit thread has been full of counterarguments, doubts, discussions of likely innocence as well as guilt. Some of the most upvoted threads are all about Devil's Advocacy and finding evidence of innocence: http://www.reddit.com/r/findbostonbombers/comments/1cjc30/de... With that, similar threads, the rules imposed, it's following exactly the textbook approach to avoid groupthink.

b) Meanwhile, we have the case studies of Richard Jewell, Steven Hatfill, the Central Park Five, among others. Those were not cases of "vigilante justice." Those happened because no one bothered to check the math of the authorities.

The internet can be an unruly mob, sure, but it's simply inaccurate to claim the internet can ONLY be an unruly mob. Or why are any of us even here?

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by untog on Thursday April 18, 2013 @04:54PM (#5573028)
the Reddit thread has been full of counterarguments, doubts, discussions of likely innocence as well as guilt.

And all that nuance is immediately lost once someone posts the photo on Facebook or Twitter. Unfortunately, that's the issue at hand.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by brownbat on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:36PM (#5573267)
If the cautious stay silent for fear of the careless, then they cede a monopoly on speech to the careless. Aka, the remedy for bad discussion is more discussion, not less.

Some may argue against this. Some may use the internet to claim that internet discussions are harmful, but not without a certain degree of inconsistency between their words and their actions.

A natural response might be, "Yes, but I'm RIGHT, of course I should speak..." but the trouble is, no one knows whether they're right or not without submitting their ideas to the crowd for a full and proper vetting.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by yew on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:45PM (#5573326)
No one knows whether they're right or not after submitting their ideas to the crowd for a full and proper vetting, either. 'The crowd' is not a substitute for experimentation and investigation.

Noticing that someone looks suspicious in a picture and reporting it to the proper authorities (preferably a division thereof known for evenhandedness) so that they can look at all sides of the issue is reasonable. Someone has to handle crimes, and whoever that someone is will always be human. Noticing that someone looks suspicious and posting their picture on Facebook with an accusatory tagline is entirely indefensible.

It's bad enough when their are no proper authorities.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by brown9-2 on Thursday April 18, 2013 @04:57PM (#5573043)
Even with those counterarguments and discussion, there is something to be said for the unfairness of publicly discussing whether or not this kid has anything to do with the case. For a long time now this event will be associated with his name.

Even if 99 comments out of 100 on Reddit or whatever other forum are doubtful, there is still the fact that his name has been publicized incorrectly - which would not have happened in the absence of a public witch hunt.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by hkmurakami on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:00PM (#5573064)
I really hope this doesn't affect him 5 years from now when employers are googling his name :(
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by alan_cx on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:24PM (#5573193)
Unruly mobs tend to be made up of perfectly normal people, who never intended to be an unruly mob in the first place. It is remarkable hoe a group of people can suddenly act as one coherent unit. Not just in thought, if you observe a mob form the air they make patterns like migrating birds to.
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by Macsenour on Thursday April 18, 2013 @06:18PM (#5573517)
I'm pretty sure there's an OLD Twilight Zone episode about this very topic.
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by krapp on Friday April 19, 2013 @10:22AM (#5576770)
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by lostlogin on Friday April 19, 2013 @02:34AM (#5575219)
Nazi Germany.
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by alan_cx on Friday April 19, 2013 @10:19AM (#5576751)
I was thinking of Northern Ireland, but yeah, Nazi German will do.
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by ars on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:53PM (#5573383)
> Meanwhile, we have the case studies of....

The umbrella man is my favorite falsely accused bystander - I mean he looked SO GUILTY!

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by potatolicious on Thursday April 18, 2013 @04:42PM (#5572936)
Unfortunately being doxxed by Reddit (funny how Reddit is known for that these days) isn't a requirement for having some nutcases go off on you:

http://www.nypost.com/p/news/local/bronx/bx_idiots_beat_up_a...

Ironically NY Post was one of the "news" sources driving up the hysteria and publishing these photos.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by ep103 on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:03PM (#5573078)
Not ironically, the NY Post is just as bad as the Daily Mail.

On the day of the bombing, they were reporting that the bomber had already been arrested. The day after the bombing, they had a picture on their cover of a backpack that was supposedly the bomb... except it wasn't. Today, they had a picture of two middle eastern looking people, who had nothing to do with the bombing. This is par the course for the NY Post.

My favorite though, is when I used to do political work, the NY Post would show up to large events, set up a quick photoshoot with paid actors, then leave, and whatever they staged a picture of would be the next day's front page.

Fuck the post.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by pkfrank on Thursday April 18, 2013 @09:09PM (#5574181)
Is there no penalty available for flagrantly inaccurate and damaging reporting?
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by rahoulb on Friday April 19, 2013 @02:19AM (#5575176)
Well, in the UK you can complain to the Press Complaints Commission. Headed by the editor of the Daily Mail
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by lostlogin on Friday April 19, 2013 @02:30AM (#5575207)
Steep profits which encourage further moral decline?
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by beedogs on Thursday April 18, 2013 @10:11PM (#5574366)
I honestly think all of Rupert Murdoch's newspapers and TV outlets should be taken away from him and destroyed.
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by jpdoctor on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:27PM (#5573211)
> Ironically NY Post was one of the "news" sources

Just as the WSJ published about people in custody, the lesson is clear: Do not bother listening to any Rupert Murdock publication for news.

The WSJ should just stick to finance, and the NYP should stick to whatever it is that it does well. (Remind me: What was it that the NYP does well?)

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by e40 on Thursday April 18, 2013 @06:48PM (#5573667)
the lesson is clear: Do not bother listening to any Rupert Murdock publication for news.

Amen. Everyone, just refuse to follow a link to a Murdock website. Daily Mail. NY Post. WSJ. Are there others?

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by brewdad on Thursday April 18, 2013 @08:30PM (#5574046)
Murdoch Block extension for Chrome works well.

https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/murdoch-block/moep...

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by cypherpunks01 on Thursday April 18, 2013 @06:52PM (#5573686)
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by desas on Friday April 19, 2013 @04:16AM (#5575486)
The daily mail is worth ignoring, it is nothing to do with Rupert Murdoch though - it is mainly owned by Viscount Rothermere
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by lucisferre on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:27PM (#5573210)
I'd argue being doxxed means some nutcases already did go off on you.
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by silverbax88 on Thursday April 18, 2013 @10:35PM (#5574428)
In cases such as this, I can't help but wonder if the person in the picture has a strong legal case of libel and defamation against the publisher. Maybe it's just wishful thinking, and maybe it's just my personality but if a newspaper tried to ruin my life just to sell newspapers, I'd 'lawyer up' with the intent of owning that newspaper when it was all said and done.
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by rbanffy on Thursday April 18, 2013 @07:47PM (#5573888)
> Ironically NY Post was one of the "news" sources driving up the hysteria

They optimize for units sold, not precise reporting.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by rhizome on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:20PM (#5573164)
Where are you getting irony out of the Post's editorial policy?
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by denzil_correa on Thursday April 18, 2013 @04:45PM (#5572960)
This guy was drawn out by the folks at Reddit - r/findbostonbombers. They are only drawing a list of suspects based on visual evidence from the photographs at the event. They are also passing along these tips to the FBI etc. Just in case, these men (called as the Backpack Bros) were cleared by the subreddit way before this name had come out. You can view their analysis here - https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/lv?key=0AgtCl8YvqiBodEl0...

In addition, the subreddit have clearly outlined their motivation here in this post - http://www.reddit.com/r/findbostonbombers/comments/1ck5hl/me...

In this case, it is more a case of lazy and irresponsible journalism than kangaroo justice.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by anigbrowl on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:37PM (#5573281)
These reports of what went on are almost as confused as speculation about what happened in the bombing.

I watched this going on all day yesterday. Certainly, there were many counterarguments and so on, but frankly the Reddit thread was a confused mess, with the same stuff getting posted over and over again, no coherent plan on organizing files by resolution or time, and no schema for IDing people, leading to multiple subthreads like 'I think this guy looks super-fishy' 'Which guy there's 100 people in that photo, who do you mean?' 'In the middle, on the left, once you've seen him you can't un-see him.' I don't think the Reddit community or subreddit moderators were at fault, but their search were nowhere near as well organized as you suggest.

What happened in the case of the runner kids is that another forum, AR15.com (dedicated to gun enthusiasts, as you might guess) pretty much decided that these two guys were guilty (based largely on the early photo speculations showing backpacks looking large enough to hold a pressure cooker). then one of the members decided to post on the Facebook page of the teenager in the blue tracksuit, which was then noticed by a Reddit user who was also watching the AR15.com thread (not me).

The teen saw the post on his Facebook page, stated that he had nothing to do with it and immediately contacted law enforcement; At this point the subReddit moderator went through and cleaned up the old threads and so forth. IIRC the 'non-suspect' went to a court building or a police station (wherever the investigation HQ is) straight away, and later returned to post an update on his FB page. The ar15.com folks meanwhile ostracized the person who had posted the link on the FB page and convinced themselves that they're all targets now (that community is heavily invested in the idea that it should be Muslim terrorists, presumably because they're feeling sensitive over the gun control issue).

I don't mean this as a criticism of the Reddit folks, who were doing their best. I'm posting this more to observe that social media in general does not do that great of job at this kind of thing. EDIT: I think social media and crowds can do a great job of that, but it needs pretty strict.active moderation and a gameplan at the outset. That proceduralism slows down people who want to dive right in and help straight away, but it also helps to eliminate false positives.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by devcpp on Friday April 19, 2013 @07:07AM (#5575938)
Hey Reddit isn't going to sort everything for the FBI and give them names of suspects to arrest. That's the job of the FBI.

All we are saying is that Reddit, 4chan and others may help the FBI if they care to watch these threads. That might or might not be helpful but it can't hurt as long as the FBI isn't willingly looking away, which might then trigger the vigilante action.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by eertami on Thursday April 18, 2013 @06:16PM (#5573507)
The subreddit is just a gathering for keyboard detectives to jack each other off and should not be used as a source for anything by anyone.
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by bherms on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:51PM (#5573368)
google doc is private
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by wtvanhest on Thursday April 18, 2013 @04:58PM (#5573050)
It might be why it sucks, but if vigilante justice, or in this case looking at photos and pointing out who had backpacks resulted in the capture of the true bomber more quickly, than the unfortunate consequences for the people temporarily named by a subreddit who's existence would be hard to locate without media attention is just not significant enough to outweigh the possibility of them figuring it out before they got on a flight etc.

If we have a terrorist group claiming responsibility and showing new photos with the terrorists in another country in the next 24-48 hours, the FBI failed. It doesn't matter if we eventually drone strike them, they failed and should look in to crowd sourcing the photo investigation in the future.

The fact that highly irresponsible news agencies printed those photos is completely separate from reddit and 4Chan talking about it.

Ideally there should be an FBI sanctioned system which allows this type of work.

For those that point out the man the FBI accused in Atlanta, keep in mind, that was way, way, way more drawn out than a 24 hour period.

Now, I'll also admit, I could be wrong, maybe they don't find them, maybe they don't post photos of who they think it is and these guys aren't cleared by the FBI, maybe it turns out that they are harassed etc.

The internet is new, and I feel like we can figure out a way to do this the right way.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by illuminate on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:16PM (#5573143)
"It might be why it sucks, but if vigilante justice, or in this case looking at photos and pointing out who had backpacks resulted in the capture of the true bomber more quickly, than the unfortunate consequences for the people temporarily named by a subreddit who's existence would be hard to locate without media attention is just not significant enough to outweigh the possibility of them figuring it out before they got on a flight etc.

Sounds vaguely like how the US justifies torture.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by alan_cx on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:30PM (#5573236)
Exactly.

Worse still, it justifies terrorism too.

A terrorist will argue that sacrifice is worth it to achieve their goals, which they see as justice in their terms.

We have to be better than that, or there is literally no point bothering. We just do their work for them. People say Islamic terrorists hate American freedoms. So how come Americans give them up so easily citing the likes of Islamic terrorism? It just goes round and round, bomb, less freedom, bomb, less freedom, until you have less freedom than they have.

Madness. Some one had to stop the spiral.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by wtvanhest on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:20PM (#5573167)
The logic you refer to is "the ends justify the means"... but I assure you that I considered both in my statement. There are definitely arguments to be made that say I am wrong.
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by bgdfgfsgsdsf on Friday April 19, 2013 @06:44AM (#5575866)
The right way to do it would be for the FBI to have a secure crowdsourcing platform that volunteers can work on after major criminal or terrorist incidents. Volunteers should be required (as a condition of volunteering) not to discuss their results with other people.

Only the raw classification and identification data is valuable here. The feedback cycles created by public discourse and news media are terribly flawed and often very harmful. It would be much better to use an automated back end to process the data, seek further verification and then ultimately bring it to the attention of human investigators.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by lostlogin on Friday April 19, 2013 @02:41AM (#5575231)
It does matter if the bomber is found and targeted by drone strikes. That is terrorism in itself and I see it as worse than being killed or injured by a random bombing. There is no recourse and nothing a victim or their family can do. The drone strike happens and no one who sympathises can do anything to help you.
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by ahoyhere on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:38AM (#5577192)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstones_formulation

"It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer",

...as expressed by the English jurist William Blackstone in his seminal work, Commentaries on the Laws of England, published in the 1760s. It is worth note that the actual numbers are not generally seen as important, so much as the idea that the State should not cause undue or mistaken harm "just in case". Historically, the details of the ratio change, but the message that government and the courts must err on the side of innocence is constant.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by raldi on Thursday April 18, 2013 @04:58PM (#5573046)
> Salah Barhoun was the guy [who] Redditors thought was the bomber

Citation needed. I saw no such declaration on reddit -- just that he seemed to be one of the dozens of somewhat interesting people worth looking at a little more closely.

It was the mass media that took this and turned it into "OMG REDDIT SAYS THEY FOUND THE BOMBER!"

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by incision on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:31PM (#5573238)
Comments like this one [1] in this thread [2] didn't just appear out of nowhere. There was plenty of wild speculation (the worst of which has since been edited or deleted) in that thread in the hours following the event.

This widely circulated spreadsheet [3] contains a "suspect summary", not a list of "somewhat interesting people".

1: http://www.reddit.com/r/boston/comments/1cf5wp/2013_boston_m...

2: http://www.reddit.com/r/boston/comments/1cf5wp/2013_boston_m...

3: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/lv?key=0AgtCl8YvqiBodEl0...

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by raldi on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:37PM (#5573279)
I've been closely watching this subreddit from the beginning, and have not seen anything of non-negligible prominence (including the comments you link to) accusing anyone of anything other than being worthy of a closer look.

The spreadsheet has 10+ people on it. You'd have to be willfully misinterpreting it to an absurd degree to conclude that reddit thought they all were simultaneously guilty.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by incision on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:55PM (#5573397)
>I've been closely watching this subreddit from the beginning, and have not seen anything of non-negligible prominence (including the comments you link to) accusing anyone of anything other than being worthy of a closer look.

Either you got there late or weren't paying attention. There are no shortage of people in this thread and the one I linked who witnessed that thread getting out of hand.

>The spreadsheet has 10+ people on it. You'd have to be willfully misinterpreting it to an absurd degree to conclude that reddit thought they all were simultaneously guilty.

I have no idea what kind of point you're trying to make here.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by clicks on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:09PM (#5573106)
> Citation needed.

I guess I am proof. And so is 'jaredsohn (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5562975 -- "Closer up view of person in OP (includes shot of face): http://i.imgur.com/BBxplgk.jpg " -- it was his interpretation from Reddit comments that Salah was one possible suspect).

There's a lot of truth to 'untog's comment up above that no matter the nuance and diligence being practiced, Reddit is still an open and public forum and no amount of nuance is worth anything when stuff leaks out of Reddit.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by raldi on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:25PM (#5573202)
> it was his interpretation from Reddit comments that Salah was one possible suspect

It's a huuuuuuge backpedal to go all the way from "reddit thought this guy was the bomber" to "one person on HN saw a reddit comment and it made him think that the guy was one possible suspect".

> no amount of nuance is worth anything when stuff leaks out of Reddit

Sure, but then the blame needs to be placed at the feet of the person who misrepresents the reddit post -- not on reddit itself.

Speaking of which, misrepresenting reddit is exactly what your comment at the top of this thread is doing. You should edit it.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by anigbrowl on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:39PM (#5573291)
Lots of people on Reddit were casually referring to people as suspects, notwithstanding the subreddit guidelines.
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by clicks on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:34PM (#5573257)
Salah was wearing a bright tracksuit that stuck out, and I think he's got a pretty memorable face -- I would bet a good amount that when a day or two passes by, what people will remember would be that he was one of the suspects. The association in their minds has already been made. And, there's a non-zero chance at that point that someone will misread the post, or recall it inaccurately, there's a chance that someone might attack him in an attempt to catch him or something. Public, vigilante justice is bad, full stop.

I've (reluctantly) edited the comment.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by raldi on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:40PM (#5573300)
Perhaps reddit needs a NSFW-like roadblock for special cases like this: Before you can enter the subreddit, you need to acknowledge that everyone is presumed innocent, that reposting things elsewhere can severely harm innocent people, that vigilante justice is bad, etc. Click each checkbox, hit submit, and only then do you get to start reading and participating.

You're absolutely right about vigilante justice, but there's a big difference between that (i.e., playing judge, jury, and executioner) and public evidence-review assistance (i.e., playing forensic investigator).

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by mcantelon on Thursday April 18, 2013 @04:58PM (#5573047)
>And this is why vigilante justice sucks.

Where's the "vigilante justice" you speak of? I see crowdsourced investigation and a newspaper that, more or less, made something up (that the feds seek the two men).

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by hristov on Thursday April 18, 2013 @06:41PM (#5573637)
Also, this is why the New York Post sucks. I understand a bunch of internet teenagers with too much time on their hands spreading this story, but an actual newspaper with professional journalists? And on the front page too.

The New York Post is only useful for insulation for the homeless. Luckily, this is also its primary use.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by runjake on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:53PM (#5573385)
What vigilante justice? There was a bunch of speculation on some websites the vast majority of the people don't read. The blame solely falls on unethical media organizations like the NY Post. They're the ones that decided to run with their "story".
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by locusm on Thursday April 18, 2013 @09:15PM (#5574204)
Any idea what legal options this kid would have now? I mean is this not the worst kind of defamation? I would think the stigma will take years to shake.