News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by brownbat on Thursday April 18, 2013 @04:52PM (#5573009)
> And this is why vigilante justice sucks.

a) I can't speak for 4chan, but the Reddit thread has been full of counterarguments, doubts, discussions of likely innocence as well as guilt. Some of the most upvoted threads are all about Devil's Advocacy and finding evidence of innocence: http://www.reddit.com/r/findbostonbombers/comments/1cjc30/de... With that, similar threads, the rules imposed, it's following exactly the textbook approach to avoid groupthink.

b) Meanwhile, we have the case studies of Richard Jewell, Steven Hatfill, the Central Park Five, among others. Those were not cases of "vigilante justice." Those happened because no one bothered to check the math of the authorities.

The internet can be an unruly mob, sure, but it's simply inaccurate to claim the internet can ONLY be an unruly mob. Or why are any of us even here?

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by untog on Thursday April 18, 2013 @04:54PM (#5573028)
the Reddit thread has been full of counterarguments, doubts, discussions of likely innocence as well as guilt.

And all that nuance is immediately lost once someone posts the photo on Facebook or Twitter. Unfortunately, that's the issue at hand.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by brownbat on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:36PM (#5573267)
If the cautious stay silent for fear of the careless, then they cede a monopoly on speech to the careless. Aka, the remedy for bad discussion is more discussion, not less.

Some may argue against this. Some may use the internet to claim that internet discussions are harmful, but not without a certain degree of inconsistency between their words and their actions.

A natural response might be, "Yes, but I'm RIGHT, of course I should speak..." but the trouble is, no one knows whether they're right or not without submitting their ideas to the crowd for a full and proper vetting.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by yew on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:45PM (#5573326)
No one knows whether they're right or not after submitting their ideas to the crowd for a full and proper vetting, either. 'The crowd' is not a substitute for experimentation and investigation.

Noticing that someone looks suspicious in a picture and reporting it to the proper authorities (preferably a division thereof known for evenhandedness) so that they can look at all sides of the issue is reasonable. Someone has to handle crimes, and whoever that someone is will always be human. Noticing that someone looks suspicious and posting their picture on Facebook with an accusatory tagline is entirely indefensible.

It's bad enough when their are no proper authorities.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by brown9-2 on Thursday April 18, 2013 @04:57PM (#5573043)
Even with those counterarguments and discussion, there is something to be said for the unfairness of publicly discussing whether or not this kid has anything to do with the case. For a long time now this event will be associated with his name.

Even if 99 comments out of 100 on Reddit or whatever other forum are doubtful, there is still the fact that his name has been publicized incorrectly - which would not have happened in the absence of a public witch hunt.

Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by hkmurakami on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:00PM (#5573064)
I really hope this doesn't affect him 5 years from now when employers are googling his name :(
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by alan_cx on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:24PM (#5573193)
Unruly mobs tend to be made up of perfectly normal people, who never intended to be an unruly mob in the first place. It is remarkable hoe a group of people can suddenly act as one coherent unit. Not just in thought, if you observe a mob form the air they make patterns like migrating birds to.
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by Macsenour on Thursday April 18, 2013 @06:18PM (#5573517)
I'm pretty sure there's an OLD Twilight Zone episode about this very topic.
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by krapp on Friday April 19, 2013 @10:22AM (#5576770)
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by lostlogin on Friday April 19, 2013 @02:34AM (#5575219)
Nazi Germany.
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by alan_cx on Friday April 19, 2013 @10:19AM (#5576751)
I was thinking of Northern Ireland, but yeah, Nazi German will do.
Re:Teen: I Am Not the Boston Marathon Bomber by ars on Thursday April 18, 2013 @05:53PM (#5573383)
> Meanwhile, we have the case studies of....

The umbrella man is my favorite falsely accused bystander - I mean he looked SO GUILTY!