It's a huuuuuuge backpedal to go all the way from "reddit thought this guy was the bomber" to "one person on HN saw a reddit comment and it made him think that the guy was one possible suspect".
> no amount of nuance is worth anything when stuff leaks out of Reddit
Sure, but then the blame needs to be placed at the feet of the person who misrepresents the reddit post -- not on reddit itself.
Speaking of which, misrepresenting reddit is exactly what your comment at the top of this thread is doing. You should edit it.
I've (reluctantly) edited the comment.
You're absolutely right about vigilante justice, but there's a big difference between that (i.e., playing judge, jury, and executioner) and public evidence-review assistance (i.e., playing forensic investigator).
I guess I am proof. And so is 'jaredsohn (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5562975 -- "Closer up view of person in OP (includes shot of face): http://i.imgur.com/BBxplgk.jpg " -- it was his interpretation from Reddit comments that Salah was one possible suspect).
There's a lot of truth to 'untog's comment up above that no matter the nuance and diligence being practiced, Reddit is still an open and public forum and no amount of nuance is worth anything when stuff leaks out of Reddit.