News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by edw519 on Monday April 08, 2013 @07:34AM (#5511080)
"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances."
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by SeanDav on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:12PM (#5512585)
As an outsider, it appears to me that almost the entire US legal and political system is driven by, and for the benefit of, corporate and big business interests. The only other major factor at work seems to be fear - witness the ever increasing power of the TSA

Probably appears worse than it is, but it does appear to be in a pretty sad state now.

The Founding Fathers are probably turning in their graves.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by GHFigs on Monday April 08, 2013 @02:03PM (#5513383)
Probably appears worse than it is

I don't mean to diminish the significance of any particular issue, but this is definitely true for much of what you hear about the US. Our media, both mainstream and alternative, tends to revolve around scandal and outrage, and there's an apocalyptic undertone that we love to hear in everything. Imagining events as fragments of gigantic intractable problems that may soon crush us all infuses our opposition to them with a sense of heroism so American that we feel naked without it.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by rthomas6 on Monday April 08, 2013 @04:20PM (#5514282)
>Imagining events as fragments of gigantic intractable problems that may soon crush us all infuses our opposition to them with a sense of heroism so American that we feel naked without it.

This rings so true. I think you just hit upon one of the reasons why American politics is so polarizing. Maybe middle ground and slow progress don't get talked about because there's no bad guy to rally against.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by joe_the_user on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @03:01AM (#5516814)
Imagining events as fragments of gigantic intractable problems that may soon crush us all infuses our opposition to them with a sense of heroism so American that we feel naked without it.

Yes but, what if, this itself really is ... a gigantic intractable problems that may soon crush us all...?

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by kingkawn on Monday April 08, 2013 @05:47PM (#5514858)
Media in general tends to revolve around scandal and outrage, including the scandal and outrage over how the media revolves around scandal and outrage.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by maratd on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:40PM (#5512758)
> As an outsider, it appears to me that the almost the entire US legal and political system is driven by, and for the benefit of, corporate and big business interests.

This is the case in every country. Those at the top will take an inordinate amount of time to make rules that benefit themselves and their friends.

The primary difference between the US and other countries is that the US constitution provides a means for the citizens to fight back against the most outrageous of offenses. Now, that doesn't mean it always works. In fact, it rarely does. But it does, in fact, work occasionally, which is better than nothing.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by gambiting on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:03PM (#5512932)
No, I strongly disagree with that statement that it's the same in every country. US supports and openly agrees with lobbying. Actually, I have read opinions saying it's a good thing - companies can have a direct effect on laws by pouring money into the government,so it kind of is democratic, right?

Well, not every country is like that. In many others lobbying is illegal and people who do it are severely punished. Any connection with a business is strongly frowned upon, and if the laws a politician is voting for turn out to support his/her company or his family's business, the negative press will pretty much destroy their career as it has happened many times in the past. Meanwhile, in the US, politicians are very well known for making money thanks to policies they themselves wrote, and it has been a plague of both senators and presidents of the United States.

The problem is, that the US is calling our approach socialist. The first question we always ask is - how is this going to affect people? Most of the time the people's interest is put before companies interest. Media companies lobbying for making breaking ToS criminal offence? They can piss right off, this does not benefit people in any way. Monsanto wants to grow GMO crops in our country? Sure, but only after they show the documentation that its safe for people and does not affect local businesses. I can't imagine Microsoft ever being given a fine in the US for monopolistic practices - in the US it's probably just how you do business and no one sees anything wrong with it. In the "land of the free" you are also free to exploit your employees, because they being "free" can just change jobs,right? Well, in most of the EU you need to guarantee decent working conditions, health insurance and you can't work more than X number of hours per day. Is that bad/socialist? Maybe, but I know for certain where I would prefer to live and work!

And sure, its very,very far from perfect, but I am pretty sure its nowhere as corrupt as the US government. Mostly because in US it's not corruption, it's legitimate business.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by mynewwork on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:49PM (#5513256)
"I can't imagine Microsoft ever being given a fine in the US for monopolistic practices" See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft

"Well, in most of the EU you need to guarantee decent working conditions" You also do in the US. See OSHA safety standards. Also US has much stricter anti-harassment and anti-discrimination laws and rules than much of the EU. Comments that would be acceptable jokes in the workplace in Denmark could get you fired for creating a hostile work environment in the US.

Maybe instead of just slandering the US, you should learn a bit more about it.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by stefantalpalaru on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @07:06AM (#5517316)
Harassment and discrimination are nothing compared to actually abusing the worker through lack of vacations, imposed overtime, laughable minimum wages (specially for the "mandatory tip" jobs) and no safety nets.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by tripzilch on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @04:36AM (#5523890)
> laughable minimum wages (specially for the "mandatory tip" jobs)

I couldn't believe this when I first heard of it: Some (or most?) states have a "different minimum" (? yeah ..) wage for certain types of service jobs (waiters, etc) that exclude some arbitrary amount they are supposed to get as "tips".

If that's not something that's purely beneficial to the business and puts a burden on the individual person, I don't know what. It makes the whole concept of "minimum wage" laughable by setting an impossibly low one for a certain class of jobs ("tip money" isn't guaranteed so you can't count it as part of the minimum wage, the guarantee is the whole point). And then it turns into a situation where the customers (nicely sidestepping the business) are made to be felt responsible for the servants to make "minimum wage", but they aren't responsible at all, it's charity.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by rayiner on Monday April 08, 2013 @11:19PM (#5516246)
Any country you could be talking about is either shittier than the U.S. in other ways (Continental Europe), exactly like the U.S. (U.K., Australia), or too small and homogenous to be a credible counter example (Scandinavia, etc).
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by sebcat on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @12:08AM (#5516396)
Scandinavia is small, but depending on who you ask it's not homogenous. E.g:

http://www.sweden.se/eng/Home/Work/Life_in_Sweden/A_multicul...

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by 3amOpsGuy on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @12:20AM (#5516427)
Examples or evidence for any of those 3 claims? Appears to be wind and noise.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by mediascreen on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @02:20AM (#5516715)
Over 15% of the Swedish population was born outside of the country. The largest groups are from Irak, Poland, Afghanistan, Somalia, China and Iran. There are also large groups of second generation immigrants with parents from Chile, Greece and Italy. Not everybody is blonde and blue eyed...
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by devdas on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @09:40AM (#5517952)
That's mostly white people then?

You'll get diversity when there isn't a single majority group. Put all of Europe together (including western and eastern), that would be reasonably diverse.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by mediascreen on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @01:20AM (#5523353)
Yes, just like in the USA, the large majority is white (72% for USA, Sweden doesn't measure ethnicity). And Sweden has more foreign born inhabitants than the US (12.4% for US and 15% for Sweden).

So, just dismissing comparisons with the Scandinavian countries based on homogeneity of population might be hasty.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by eru on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @03:24AM (#5516874)
> exactly like the U.S. (U.K., Australia)

They are different. E.g. the UK has `socialistic' health-care.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by arethuza on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @07:34AM (#5517422)
Not to mention that thing about guns.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by derleth on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:39PM (#5513171)
> Well, not every country is like that. In many others lobbying is illegal and people who do it are severely punished.

That's not the only way to buy influence.

> Monsanto wants to grow GMO crops in our country? Sure, but only after they show the documentation that its safe for people and does not affect local businesses.

So this only applies to Monsanto, or do local companies have to do the same things?

> In the "land of the free" you are also free to exploit your employees

Utterly untrue. You have no idea what you're talking about.

> And sure, its very,very far from perfect, but I am pretty sure its nowhere as corrupt as the US government.

How can you possibly know?

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by jussij on Monday April 08, 2013 @06:54PM (#5515253)
> Utterly untrue. You have no idea what you're talking about.

It took ten (1998-2008) years before the US minimum wage went up.

That's 10 years without a pay rise for the unskilled worker of America.

It that's not an example of worker exploitation I don't know what is?

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by arkem on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @12:23AM (#5516435)
Statutory minimum wages not rising are not an example of worker exploitation. Even if there were no minimum wage laws worker exploitation does not necessarily follow.

Additionally, in your example while the federal minimum wage might not have increased many states have their own minimum wage laws that have changed over the period you describe.

The closest statement you could make is that an absence of minimum wage laws may make it legal to employ people at an exploitatively low wage. This is not really the name thing.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by jussij on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @08:32AM (#5517611)
> Even if there were no minimum wage laws worker exploitation does not necessarily follow.

To answer this question you have to go no further than to study history.

When there where no minimum wage laws workers where exploited.

You have to go back no further than the first industrial revolution to see evidence of this.

Now that exploitation brought about the rise of the union movement.

I don't think it is a coincide that as we now witness the decline of the union movement, there is a corresponding rise in the exploitation of workers.

Those who don't study their history are destined to repeat it.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by kpommerenke on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @01:09AM (#5516534)
Germany doesn't have a minimum wage either.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by eru on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @03:22AM (#5516865)
It's becoming more complicated in Germany. See e.g. http://www.economist.com/node/21536648
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by noselasd on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @06:30AM (#5517217)
>So this only applies to Monsanto, or do local companies have to do the same things?

This would naturally apply to any company, local or foreign.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by glogla on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @07:34AM (#5517420)
> Utterly untrue. You have no idea what you're talking about.

Just six words: "right to work", "at will employment".

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by drharris on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @08:11AM (#5517551)
And only four to counter: "Be a hard worker".
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by camus on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:20PM (#5513042)

    > companies can have a direct effect on laws by pouring money into the government,so it kind of is democratic, right?
"corporations are people my friend!" ;)
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by rayiner on Monday April 08, 2013 @11:21PM (#5516251)
I realized the other day that it's a grammatically correct way of saying "corporations are made of people." Consider the famous quote: "Soylent green is people!" It doesn't mean that Soylent Green is a person, it means Soylent Green is made of people.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by herval on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:56PM (#5512884)
> The primary difference between the US and other countries is that the US constitution provides a means for the citizens to fight back against the most outrageous of offenses.

What way does the US constitution provide that other countries don't (besides the firearms shenanigans)?

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by maratd on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @07:47AM (#5517462)
1. A right to practice any religion without the establishment of any official religion.

2. The right to speak freely against the government. This is culturally extended to other targets of speech as well. Includes written, artistic, and some obscene works.

3. The right to not have soldiers commandeer your property, even in times of war.

4. The right to be safe in your possessions against arbitrary search. In the US, a police officer can't just pull you aside and search you. They need to have a clearly defined reason to do so or get a search warrant from a judge.

5. Every citizen above a certain age has the right to vote and be heard in government, regardless of political affiliation or sex.

I'm bored of listing things. Go read the constitutional yourself if you're curious. Two and half centuries later, and it's still a document that puts much of Europe and the rest of the world to shame. As I said, it's implementation isn't perfect, nothing in life is ... but it's certainly much better than the alternatives currently on display elsewhere.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by yardie on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @08:56AM (#5517720)
Look, the constitution is 250 year old parchment and it appears a lot of legislators have probably forgotten what's on it.

1. Applies to most european countries as well. Some, like Scientology, are actually called what they are, scams. Not because of the dogma, but because they put greater emphasis on raising money.

2. And what EU member country doesn't have this?

3. The US has only been invaded by a) the British b) itself. Just like torture, when push comes to shove the government will find a way around this. Do remember the government confiscated property from the southern gentry by classifying them as traitors.

4. Minorities (black, hispanic, asian, arabic) throughout the US would like to have a word with you. Hell, NYC doesn't even try to gus it up. They call it "stop and frisk".

5. You have the right to vote. Not all states have to make it easy or convenient to do so. I'm lucky in that I live abroad so I'm entitled to an absentee ballot. If I lived in my last US address I could not vote by mail on my free time. I would have to go to the polls, on a tuesday, during working hours.

Europe isn't one country so I don't know why you describe it as such. I could equally say the US has a beheading problem since Mexico is right there and they are the same, right?

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by maratd on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @11:35AM (#5518818)
> 1. Applies to most european countries as well.

No.

http://nationalinterest.org/commentary/western-europe-vs-rel...

> 2. And what EU member country doesn't have this?

Germany, Austria, etc.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Irving#Persona_non_grata

Mind you, the man is absolute human garbage, but the entire point of protecting speech is protecting the most despicable kind. It's fairly easy to tolerate the pleasant variety.

> 3. The US has only been invaded by ...

My point still stands. Even if the US throws this one under the bus in the future, my point still stands. It's not about a perfect record, but a good one. The US has a good record on this.

> 4. ... Hell, NYC doesn't even try to gus it up. They call it "stop and frisk".

I live in the NYC area, so I know about this a bit. In each case, the person consents to the search. Yes, it's pretty scary when a cop walks over to you and tells you to empty your pockets. You need to have balls to say "No" and "I do not consent to any searches". But then again, any right given to you is pointless if you don't have the balls to exercise it.

> 5. You have the right to vote. Not all states have to make it easy or convenient to do so.

You don't have a right to a convenient process, merely a process. It's a wonderful thing to reach a point where people have the wherewithal to bitch about how convenient voting is, rather than if their vote is actually counted. Mind you, I'm of the same mind as you, I think we should be able to vote on the Internet. Lately, my home state of New Jersey has made an effort to permit this (albeit, in response to a natural disaster).

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by tripzilch on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:11AM (#5524039)
> http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Irving#Persona_non_grata

Yeap. Moving the goalposts. You said "The right to speak freely against the government".

If you said "free speech" in general, yes, you'd be right.

But you said "speaking out against the government".

Right now, you've only shown that the US is somehow better because you're allowed to freely deny the Holocaust. Let's put your "god hates fags" guy in the same category. Such a free country!

See, my point is not that these anti-holocaust-denying laws are silly, they are and I wish they'd go away.

The point is, how does your "free speech" protect you when you've actually got something to say. So far you've demonstrated American citizens have the right to inane and offensive yelling, that doesn't actually speak out in any effective way against the government.

Let's see some real examples, where someone exercised their right to free speech of something that actually made the government actually really uncomfortable that actually really led to change, as well as a similar example where this was not possible in a EU country because its people didn't have the right.

And there's been enough examples, also in the US, of people gagged (with legal rulings) because of what they would have to say would make the government uncomfortable.

In practice, your right is the Freedom to Scream Dumb Shit. Don't delude yourself it's actually anything more than that. Maybe "Freedom to play court jester" sounds a bit more forgiving. I'm not saying the EU-"no holocaust denying"-countries are any better, but it's not "free speech" if it only protects raging lunatics.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by maratd on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @01:10PM (#5526485)
What goal posts? I was summarizing the constitution. If my summary is too vague for you, here is the actual text:

> Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

Then you spend the entire post ranting about what can really be summarized as:

> In practice, your right is the Freedom to Scream Dumb Shit.

Ok. Are you the arbiter of what is and is not "dumb shit"? Because as long as there is somebody deciding what is and is not dumb, then you don't have the capacity to speak your mind. You merely have the capacity to speak what everybody else is already thinking.

And the point wasn't that much of Europe is some sort of third-world cesspool. It isn't.

The point was that the US Constitution provides protections which are not clearly codified in the EU, beside the right to carry arms. Even though the EU is a modern invention, while the US Constitution is the oldest constitution still in use.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by herval on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @10:03AM (#5518071)
these hold true in all european countries, most south/central american ones and probably most asiab countries as well (although I don't know that side of the world firsthand, unfortunately. So much for a pedantic ufanist reply...
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by maratd on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @11:18AM (#5518667)
> these hold true in all european countries

Last time I checked, Belarus was in Europe.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by alan on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:57PM (#5512885)
> This is the case in every country. Those at the top will take an inordinate amount of time to make rules that benefit themselves and their friends.

It's actually a bit simpler than that. Any set of rules will allow certain segments to rise to the top. Once there, they have great interest in keeping the rules in their favour, but they don't have to take all that much time making the rules favour them in the first place.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by swift on Monday April 08, 2013 @04:00PM (#5514138)
Your categorical statement about rules is an interesting one. I think this is actually a mathematical claim which I'm fairly certain is false.

It'd be interesting to explore whether the space of rules that keep everyone on an even keel include any rule sets that we'd actually want to live under, though. Ever read "The Lottery in Babylon" by Borges?

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by neilk on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:02PM (#5512925)
Oh, absolutely. As a Canadian, I live in hope that the US will invade and replace our system of government.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by rapind on Monday April 08, 2013 @03:14PM (#5513815)
Already happened. It was peaceful, and at least we're allowed to think we're different.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by katbyte on Monday April 08, 2013 @03:17PM (#5513835)
As a canadian I sincerely hope that you are joking.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by maratd on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @07:53AM (#5517489)
Oh please. You would only be so lucky. Then this sort of nonsense wouldn't even come to fruition:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/mar/01/quebec-language-...

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by brightsize on Monday April 08, 2013 @07:49PM (#5515504)
No doubt you're joking, but one thing I've repeatedly noticed in my many visits to Canada is the extent to which Canadians define themselves as being "not American" (meaning not US citizens). Can't blame 'em, more power to them.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by neilk on Monday April 08, 2013 @10:15PM (#5516077)
This is a fair point. I actually can't stand that too.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by ced on Monday April 08, 2013 @03:13PM (#5513814)
Why? Or was that sarcasm?
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by rosser on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:33PM (#5513126)
the US constitution provides a means for the citizens to fight back against the most outrageous of offenses

Did you, by chance, mean "voting"?

How quaint.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by Aloisius on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:59PM (#5513358)
Did you, by chance, mean "voting"?

Suing obviously. Legal action is the American way.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by inopinatus on Monday April 08, 2013 @05:57PM (#5514908)
I think the observation was that this has turned out to be the problem, not the solution.

I.e. that not everything is better as a confrontation.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by coldtea on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:31PM (#5512702)
>As an outsider, it appears to me that the almost the entire US legal and political system is driven by, and for the benefit of, corporate and big business interests. The only other major factor at work seems to be fear - witness the ever increasing power of the TSA

Three factors driving law and politics in the US, IMNSHO:

money: big business, work the system for profit

fear: government works the system for more control

selfism: citizens (neoliberals, Bible Belt, etc) working the system to ensure nothing will be done for the public good

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by wisty on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:43PM (#5512794)
Kind of. Democracies are often driven by entrenched interests. This is especially true in the US, with their non-compulsory voting. If your livelihood depends on producing meat, you have an incentive to learn who supports it, and bother to actually vote. If you just think the meat industry is kind of icky, you won't bother informing yourself, and may not even bother voting. It doesn't help that politicians will go out of their way to communicated to these entrenched interests, but not try to tell regular voters what they are actually up to.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by mcguire on Monday April 08, 2013 @06:29PM (#5515090)
"The Founding Fathers are probably turning in their graves."

Keep in mind that the Founding Fathers were the big business interests of their time.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by pfedor on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @03:00AM (#5516812)
it appears to me that almost the entire US legal and political system is driven by, and for the benefit of, corporate and big business interests

"Corporate and big business interests", i.e., publicly traded companies, are responsible for the majority of wealth creation (source: well it's obvious, but see for example William Bernstein, "The Birth of Plenty".) So what you said can be rephrased as, "The US system works to enable wealth creation", or in other words, "The US system is optimized for providing the best standard of living for its citizens." Which is exactly the case.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by nickpinkston on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @03:10AM (#5516841)
You spelled 'wealth extraction' wrong
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by mmariani on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:49PM (#5512836)
Not only the US. The EU has been following the same shady path.

There's even a good documentary made to throw some light at this subject.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2279313/

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by rayiner on Monday April 08, 2013 @11:52AM (#5512450)
That would be relevant if the state governments were banning display of these videos. But free speech rights have never encompassed regulation of what you can do on private property without the consent of the property owner. It's not any more unconstitutional (note, as usual, the disclaimer that just because its constitutional doesn't mean its a good idea) to make a law that bans video taping on private farms than it is to make a law that bans me video taping your wife in the shower in your house.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by spacemanaki on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:31PM (#5512708)
Actually, I think some of the laws DO ban distributing the videos:

  Many of these bills are explicit about not just targeting the people
  who do the investigation but the people who distributed it, who
  republish it. For instance, there was an investigation a couple of
  years ago that at the same time the group, Mercy for Animals, was
  conducting the investigation ABC news was following along with it,
  aired the same footage, after they verified it, and it drew national
  attention to this and criminal charges. Under these bills, in North
  Carolina, for example, both the investigator and the journalist would
  be wrapped up together.
http://www.onthemedia.org/2013/mar/01/states-consider-so-cal...

I'm looking for more references now.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by spacemanaki on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @12:06AM (#5516391)
The N Carolina law mentioned appears not to have any reference to distribution: http://www.ncleg.net/Sessions/2013/Bills/Senate/PDF/S648v1.p...

However this law in Indiana does, http://www.in.gov/legislative/bills/2013/SB/SB0373.2.html

IANAL but this appears to make distribution of such recordings illegal:

  Makes it unlawful recording of agricultural or industrial
  operations, a Class A infraction, for a person, with intent to harass,
  defame, annoy, or harm, to: (1) enter real property that is owned by
  another person and on which agricultural operations or industrial
  operations are being conducted; (2) take a photograph of or make a
  video recording or motion picture of the real property, structures
  located on the real property, or the agricultural operations or
  industrial operations being conducted on the real property; and (3)
  distribute the photograph or recording; without the written consent of
  the owner of the real property or an authorized representative of the
  owner.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by ensignavenger on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @10:42AM (#5518360)
IANAL, but the above citation says AND, implying that it may be legal to take the photo or recording, if you don't also distribute it, or to distribute it, if you don't also create it- so you would have to do both. I may be completely wrong with this interpretation though, and the wording is too vague.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by spacemanaki on Thursday April 11, 2013 @08:53AM (#5531584)
Good catch! I guess you'd have to take it to a lawyer to be sure... I wish that On The Media bit did a better job with citations.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by trhtrsh on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:08PM (#5512561)
Why do you need a law to ban something that is already illegal, or something that is intentionally protected by law? Trespassing and violating private legal activity is already illegal, and whistleblowing on criminal activity is protected by current law.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by rayiner on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:18PM (#5512627)
The point isn't that video tapers should be prosecuted as anything other than as trespassers. The point is that the constitutionality of the law derives from the same place. It is not an exercise of free speech to go onto private property to do pretty much anything.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by mapster on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:25PM (#5512669)
then we can expect a cascade of similar legislation banning taping in non-profits (Acorn), pseudo-private areas, etc.?
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by cobrausn on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:39PM (#5512756)
Seems to me institutions like Acorn that accept the public as part of their operation can't really prosecute a whistleblower as a trespasser. I'm not sure what a pseudo-private area is.

What raynier is saying (I think) is that if it is illegal to trespass, then it is illegal to trespass for purposes of whistleblowing because that is still trespassing - imagine if they had trespassed, filmed, and found nothing illegal. If one of the farm workers were to film the video, there would have been no trespassing - it would constitute whistleblowing.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by itstriz on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:15PM (#5513015)
It is farm workers filming the videos. It just happens that these farm workers got hired as farm workers with the sole intention of filming the videos and did not disclose this intention to their employer. I'm not sure how it can be construed as trespassing to enter your place of employment, regardless of what your intentions are.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by rayiner on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:24PM (#5513068)
> What raynier is saying (I think) is that if it is illegal to trespass, then it is illegal to trespass for purposes of whistleblowing because that is still trespassing

Not exactly. What I'm saying is:

1) The Constitution only prohibits governments from restricting free speech;

2) What you do on other peoples' private property is rarely if ever considered free speech or free expression.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by mcguire on Monday April 08, 2013 @06:37PM (#5515134)
On the other hand, the consequences of trespassing are typically pretty mild and don't usually include being placed on a "terrorist registry".
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by mapster on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:55PM (#5512867)
Following these heavy handed approaches to whistle-blowers and undercover reporting, then Acorn should be protected from terrorists using some 'intent to harm' argument. You see how insane this all becomes. I hope these legislations are challenged, tossed out, and in the meantime circumnavigated to reveal the barbaric treatment that occurs.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by MaysonL on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:00PM (#5512909)
So is cruelty to animals...
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by strlen on Monday April 08, 2013 @05:46PM (#5514852)
That's not universally true: some states (e.g., California) take a wider view of freedom of speech beyond what first amendment allows and protected freedom of speech in certain kind of privately-owned spaces (e.g., malls open to the public). Supreme Court has upheld this, in a case that happened a few miles from my home:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pruneyard_Shopping_Center_v._Ro...

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by rayiner on Monday April 08, 2013 @11:22PM (#5516255)
Sure, but a mall invites the general public in and acts as "third spaces" for the public (and profits from doing that). Even in the Socialist Republic of California courts aren't going to decide that activists' free speech rights extend to what they do on private farms.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by katbyte on Monday April 08, 2013 @03:21PM (#5513869)
Just because it is not unconstitutional does not make it right. How can anyone argue that it should be illegal to videotape an illegal activity with the goal to expose and stop it, especially cruelty to animals.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by orbitur on Monday April 08, 2013 @08:00AM (#5511160)
Isn't this a privacy issue? Going in to someone's private property and filming/recording them without their knowledge doesn't seem like it would have anything to do with the first amendment.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by Xodarap on Monday April 08, 2013 @08:41AM (#5511315)
If you invite me over to your house and I happen to see a dead body on the floor, the first amendment doesn't prevent me from reporting you to the police.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by pvaldes on Monday April 08, 2013 @09:32AM (#5511536)
weeeeeell...mmmh, even if is a bird corpse? Are we comparing a dead chick with a dead chicken?
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by FireBeyond on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:12PM (#5512998)
If I see direct evidence that you committed animal abuse to kill it, then yes, even then.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by pvaldes on Monday April 08, 2013 @06:10PM (#5514999)
And if I see direct evidence that you commited plant abuse to kill it, can I call the police also? I want also to manipulate the other people with my elastic god-rules, created for the ocassion, like vegans do.

Hey a dead cactus, in a minuscule pot... call the FBI!

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by jlgreco on Monday April 08, 2013 @07:24PM (#5515408)
There are animal abuse laws on the book right now. If there are plant abuse laws, then feel free to report plant abuse that you observe while trespassing.

For that matter, feel free to report plant abuse even if there are not laws against it, just don't expect anyone to care.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by pvaldes on Monday April 08, 2013 @08:09PM (#5515602)
> just don't expect anyone to care.

And this the sad fact that I want to stress.

Most people see only an invented and small part of the reality. Plants are much more important to the humans that animals.

To classify a living organism as good because it has neurons and can emit noises (like a clam?) or bad because it has chloroplasts instead and can not move quickly (like a Mimosa?) is a real nonsense. Inherited stupidity.

Same as to protect common animals with four legs but to crush rare animals with six legs. Same as to call the police because we can not stand that somebody kills a chicken and feeling soo virtuous eating soy that was cultivated killing thousands of animals and plants. Same as to ignore that we, humans, are omnivores, and our gut is neither a moral nor amoral structure.

Plants provide the 99% of the energy that moves the chain food and that permits the human life on this planet. Plants provide water, and we, the people, are made of more than 60% of pure water. We should be grateful to those magnificient creatures... Yes, we can argue that plants can not cry... and what's the big fuss? We don't expect a lattice singing opera. We are just scratching the surface about the complex plant communication (chemical, electrical)... So we chomp, ignore, cut down and poison the plants, and protect the animals that are plant eaters until the exhaustion of the resources... yep, human moral.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by jlgreco on Monday April 08, 2013 @08:50PM (#5515764)
I don't think that the classification being done is "good" or "bad". Rather we classify things as "okay to eat" and "not okay to eat". Vegetarians are not classifying animals as "good" and plants as "bad". Fruititarians are not classifying plants and animals as "good" but things that fall off plants as "bad". Everyone is doing the same classification: "am I okay with eating this, or am I not"; the only trick is that different people come up with different answers to that question.

To be clear, my classification is tuned very far to one extreme. That is to say, I would eat anything given the opportunity (in some cases necessity comes into play).

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by carbocation on Monday April 08, 2013 @08:03AM (#5511173)
By that logic, don't we already have an enormous apparatus of laws that exist to protect the property owner? What would these bills add?
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by orbitur on Monday April 08, 2013 @08:06AM (#5511184)
I'm not advocating for new laws, but I do not believe this is a first amendment issue.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by carbocation on Monday April 08, 2013 @08:13AM (#5511205)
Sure it is. The proposed text of the "Animal Ecological Terrorism Act" provides for criminal penalties including jail time for violators. Why should the First Amendment not protect me from the state in this context?
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by pc86 on Monday April 08, 2013 @08:33AM (#5511290)
Because you broke other pre-existing laws (trespassing, possibly breaking & entering, other violations of private property)?
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by uptown on Monday April 08, 2013 @09:05AM (#5511404)
"And employees who do something beyond the scope of their jobs could be charged with criminal trespass."

So say an employee that's not an animal rights activist sees something deplorable and records it as evidence. Only then are they considered to have trespassed - flying in the face of whistle-blower protections that have been in-place in countless other industries for decades.

If what's happening is a crime - and I believe animal cruelty still qualifies (even if it occurs on a farm) - at what point does someone that chooses to look the other way become a co-conspirator?

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by btipling on Monday April 08, 2013 @09:30AM (#5511520)
Whistleblower laws would protect this individual.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by jellicle on Monday April 08, 2013 @10:01AM (#5511698)
You perhaps think the United States has some sort of generic whistleblower protection laws. This is not the case. What you may be thinking of this:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whistleblower_Protection_Act

which only applies to Federal agency employees.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by pc86 on Monday April 08, 2013 @10:20AM (#5511797)
This is an important distinction.

To the best of my knowledge, individuals who are not Federal employees that engage in whistleblowing do so with the very real possibility that there will be permanent professional retribution.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by tptacek on Monday April 08, 2013 @03:27PM (#5513924)
It's not quite that simple; many US states have a "public policy" exception to at-will employment that allows you to sue if you're terminated or constructively terminated in retaliation for whistleblowing.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by trhtrsh on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:13PM (#5512589)
"Professional" is bad enough. "Criminal" is far worse.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by mweisbrod on Monday April 08, 2013 @10:48AM (#5511983)
in response to pc86:

professional retribution is fine. That is like getting fired.

Going to jail and being labelled a terrorist is not professional retribution.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by tedks on Monday April 08, 2013 @11:00AM (#5512071)
Whistleblower laws protect no one.

For one, there is no such thing as unified "whistleblower laws." There are whistleblower laws in various states covering various domains, forming a legal morass that is near impossible for a human to navigate unaided.

But more importantly, abiding by every one of these laws still results in years of legal limbo under attack from the superhumanly powerful entity that you as a moral person managed to piss off, bankrupting you, ending your marriage, and making you a damaged, nervous wreck. No whistleblower says they'd do it again if they had the choice.

This is the protection your laws provide.

I sadly can't yet link to a source, and am not sure how much I can say about how I know this, but I will say there'll be a great article out in a month or so on this topic in a major print publication.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by uptown on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:05PM (#5512527)
I think you're probably thinking about the NECC case which was profiled on '60 Minutes':

http://www.cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=50142537n

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by Retric on Monday April 08, 2013 @09:54AM (#5511666)
The most recent law takes precedence, so this may remove Whistleblower protection.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by carbocation on Monday April 08, 2013 @08:50AM (#5511354)
> By that logic, don't we already have an enormous apparatus of laws that exist to protect the property owner? What would these bills add?
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by glesica on Monday April 08, 2013 @09:48AM (#5511615)
Then the person should be prosecuted for trespass. Still doesn't make it OK to violate their free speech rights...
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by dbpatterson on Monday April 08, 2013 @10:19AM (#5511793)
and certainly not for "terrorism"
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by nkozyra on Monday April 08, 2013 @08:43AM (#5511326)
Wait, was this necessarily without their knowledge? It seems like the proposed legislation targets people who get jobs under the guise of normal employment but are really there to film.

This takes away the "trespassing" thing that's getting bandied about ... there are certainly whistleblower protections for regular employees, are those out the window?

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by pyre on Monday April 08, 2013 @09:42AM (#5511582)
How is this any different from other investigative journalism? Why is "getting film of what happens behind closed doors" need to be called "terrorism?"
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by goostavos on Monday April 08, 2013 @10:22AM (#5511808)
Perhaps I'm just cynical, but I would assume to make it less pleasurable to vote against. It's not tough to imagine a blurb come election cycle along the lines of "Senator X voted against anti-terrorism bills designed to keep us safe! Senator Y strongly cares about your safety, and the safety of the Nation. Vote Y. Vote America."
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by trhtrsh on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:14PM (#5512597)
Right, and that's why this lawmaking behavior is so wrong.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by jdietrich on Monday April 08, 2013 @11:19AM (#5512215)
No. If you're selling meat to the public, they have a right to know how that meat was produced. Farmers and slaughterhouses have no right to privacy, or their right to privacy is completely over-ridden by the right of their customers to know what they are buying.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by Jun8 on Monday April 08, 2013 @11:23AM (#5512250)
"Farmers and slaughterhouses have no right to privacy"

This position is indefensible, I think. By the same token any institution that produces a product that somehow impacts customers should have no right to privacy. Having corporate privacy and being regulated are related but different things.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by jchrisa on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:52PM (#5512852)
It's not indefensible, it's radical. IMHO almost all productive enterprise should be 100% transparent. Good luck convincing the world of that. But most rational analysis of capitalism will get you to that conclusion.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by mapster on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:33PM (#5512727)
in part yes. at the same time, anyone using this argument for farms/ag is trying to conceal misdeeds, not trade secrets. Farms etc., house animals, which are protected by laws. The operation is not private such as your home is. Equally, a worker at a paper mill should be able to video and report illegal chemical dumping or worker safety issues.

The bottom line is that the prosecution processes aided by whistle-blower testimony is broken, requiring long investigations and, to play devil's advocate, wrongful accusations and financial harm to a business.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by carbocation on Monday April 08, 2013 @07:58AM (#5511149)
To crystallize the point: how is this not, on its face, textbook First Amendment material?
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by brownbat on Monday April 08, 2013 @10:13AM (#5511760)
There is a paper that discusses this issue in more detail, "Principles for Resolving Conflicts Between Trade Secrets and the First Amendment" by P. Samuelson: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=925056

Upholding contracts and preventing trespassing (or other "wrongful conduct") are usually fair game for restrictions on 1A. But "Trade secret law is grounded in unfair competition principles, ... [so] First Amendment defenses to trade secret claims are most likely to succeed as to those who did not participate in misappropriating the information, who acquired the information lawfully, and who seek to make public disclosures as to matters of public concern. In exceptional cases, preliminary injunctions may impinge on First Amendment rights even when defendants are in privity or have wrongfully acquired the information."

This isn't just "what's your secret method for cheaply polishing ball bearings." It's clearly a "matter of public concern," and that does help enormously. But your first amendment claims would improve even more if the person distributing the information neither trespassed nor broke an employment contract.

Also note that the California Supreme Court has made it a jurisdiction least likely to apply first amendment to trump trade secret law, thanks to DVD Copy Control v. Bunner.

It would be advisable for any prospective documentarians to pass off any collected information to a local news station (rather than just youtube). Don't tell the network how you got it or develop any long term relationship with them. Make sure they have media liability insurance. Then maybe lay low while they fight the case, which they'll probably have to appeal all the way up. That'd set up the model case and the money to fund it.

Even short of that, though, as a "matter of public concern," this may be one of those "exceptional cases" alluded to above. It'd be interesting to see it argued.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by pyre on Monday April 08, 2013 @10:17AM (#5511786)
Why does the breaking of an employment contract need to turn into criminal charges, and get labelled as 'terrorism?'
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by brownbat on Monday April 08, 2013 @10:52AM (#5512017)
Note that it's labeled "terrorism" only in some interest group's "model bill."

Random interest groups are allowed to call whatever they like "terrorism," and they're allowed to write poorly thought out bills.

Also note that most of the bills are failing.

Even Missouri, where the article says one passed, you're just required to notify law enforcement if you witness animal abuse, and offer them copies of your video:

http://www.senate.mo.gov/12info/BTS_Web/Bill.aspx?SessionTyp...

It's a strange type of gag order that only compels speech.

I mean, these are definitely still bills worth challenging, but the article seems to be embellishing a bit.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by spizzo on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @09:17PM (#5522626)
>Note that it's labeled "terrorism" only in some interest group's "model bill."

This reminds me of an old web design trick. You get the customer specs, plan out exactly what you think will work, and then add something stupid-looking. Like a giant duck by the login button. The duck acts as a decoy for customer complaints; a lot of business people want to point at something and say "change it!", so you give them that. And when they bring it up you smile and say "say no more, I'll have it removed sir".

Likewise, if complaints about a given bill can be pulled or drawn towards language like "terrorism", then the meat of the bill avoids some scrutiny. Hell, an unscrupulous legislator whose constituency opposes the bill could demand the terrorism language be cut and then end up supporting the bill, pleasing both sides of the aisle as it were.

This is just me thinking out loud, though.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by steveklabnik on Monday April 08, 2013 @02:05PM (#5513398)
If the Green Scare had happened a few years later, the words 'domestic terrorism' would have been thrown around quite a bit more.

The FBI has referred to animal rights activism as domestic terrorism for a while now, it's just that 'terrorism' wasn't a public meme until relatively recently.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by rayiner on Monday April 08, 2013 @11:53AM (#5512459)
That is of course a totally separate issue from whether the law is constitutional or not. There is an infinitude of bad law that is constitutional, especially at the state level where the state police power was historically nearly unlimited.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by antihero on Monday April 08, 2013 @11:48AM (#5512426)
Because this is ALEC.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by jrockway on Monday April 08, 2013 @08:19AM (#5511231)
It's First Amendment material, and I doubt the Supreme Court will uphold any of these laws. The problem is that there will be problems for people in the years between when the laws are passed and when a good case finally makes it to the Supreme Court.

(The bit about making violating your employment contract a criminal act sounds exactly like the law that makes you a criminal for violating a website's ToS. Which has pretty much been struck down. But hey, there's no penalty for passing bad laws, so why not try? It makes your handlers happy!)

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by jrwoodruff on Monday April 08, 2013 @11:12AM (#5512163)
Back in my journalism school days, ABC v. Food Lion was referenced as the precedent for undercover reporting. In this case, Two ABC reporters got jobs working at a Food Lion in North Carolina and taped footage of the store selling spoiled meat.

Food Lion sued for unfair trade practices, fraud, breach of contract, etc. ABC was fined $5.5 million, but that was later reduced to about $300,000, according to a quick Google search.

This was used to illustrate why journalists must disclose that they are journalists and should avoid undercover methods, as written in the journalism code of ethics.

Sources:

http://lawclassolemiss.wordpress.com/2010/04/05/food-lion-in...

http://www.poynter.org/uncategorized/2125/abc-and-food-lion-...

http://www.nytimes.com/1997/03/09/arts/beyond-abc-v-food-lio...

http://www.spj.org/ethicscode.asp

Edit: Also interesting, but not quite as relevant, is the Chiquita/Cincinnati Enquirer scandal that happened around the same time.

http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/newsdesk/2011/07/chiqu...

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by spizzo on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @09:25PM (#5522660)
I don't understand why this is bad, though.

In that case food lion got publicly busted and undoubtedly had to tighten standards. What's the alternative in a system where you can't engage in undercover reporting?

ABC: "Hey food lion. ABC here. Do you guys sell rotten meat?"

Food Lion: "no. no we do not."

ABC: "Mind if we check?"

Food Lion: "Sure, just give me a minute to clean up some things so you're not seeing how we operate day-to-day. I'll schedule your visit."

ABC: "Huh. Everything looks above board"

Food Lion: "Yes, they do look that way today. On your visit. Don't come back without notice."

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by jrockway on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @06:34AM (#5517225)
This is very interesting and I didn't know about it. Isn't $300,000 pocket change, though?
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by jrwoodruff on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @07:58AM (#5517506)
Oh definetly. In the Chiquita case, Gannett was willing to settle out of court for eight figures. IANAL, but my understanding is its more about the precedent set, as other similar cases will reference these judgements.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by mtgx on Monday April 08, 2013 @08:41AM (#5511313)
This is what I like about other countries which have Constitutional Courts that check for the a bill's constitutionality before it's passed into law.

How many years does it have to pass in US before the Patriot Act, NSL's and FISA are verified by the Supreme Court? We're already into the second decade of their existence now.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by DannyBee on Monday April 08, 2013 @11:11AM (#5512157)
The US supreme court doesn't like facial constitutional challenges (IE challenging statutes as unconstitutional on their face with no actual injured person orset of facts) There is actually a mildly good reason for this, which is that facial challenges basically have no fact records, and involve a lot of speculation. One of the principles of judicial restraint is:

  Courts should neither "anticipate a question of   
  constitutional law in advance of the necessity of deciding 
  it" nor " formulate a rule of constitutional law broader 
  than is required by the precise facts to which it is to be 
  applied." 
  Ashwander v. Tennessee Valley Authority, 297 U.S. 288, 347 (1936) (Brandeis, J.)
(I borrowed this cite from wikipedia, so i didn't check it, but it looks rights at a glance).

A good explanation of the list is here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashwander_rules

However, in practice, IMHO, this excuse is used to punt cases more than really viewed as a valid principle

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by trhtrsh on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:11PM (#5512580)
Sure, but we have obvious "chilling effects" when a law is explicitly written to combat a specific recently witnessed fact pattern, and the law is unconstitutional not only in some theoretical future fact pattern, but also in its well-documented primary intent.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by DannyBee on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:43PM (#5512791)
The argument here is that then it should be pretty easy to find a person it is impacting, and then it's no longer a facial challenge, but an as-applied one.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by RyanMcGreal on Monday April 08, 2013 @09:47AM (#5511611)
Americans have this persistent idea that their Constitution is somehow superior to the constitutions of other industrialized liberal democracies, when the reality is that the American system, notwithstanding amendments to fix certain practical failures, remains essentially stuck in 18th century ideas about liberty and governance.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by philwelch on Monday April 08, 2013 @11:39AM (#5512362)
Yes, it's a pity we never did things like make "hate speech" exceptions to freedom of speech, ban firearms, abolish double jeopardy, or revoke this silly notion that you're not required to talk to the police.

The only problem with the American constitution is that the federal government isn't very good at following it. Other than that, it's far more liberal than most liberal democracies even try to get away with.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by RyanMcGreal on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:18PM (#5512620)
This is exactly what I'm talking about. The US has no monopoly on the right to free expression, silence when talking to the police, protection against double jeopardy and so on. It is a peculiar kind of American exceptionalism that imagines other liberal democracies suffer under quasi-tyrannical legal systems by comparison.

The US Constitution's protection of the right to firearms, which actually is an outlier among liberal democracies, is also a case in point of its essentially 18th century conception of rights and governance. The Second Amendment is based on the quaint idea that individual liberties can only be secured through the constant threat of civilian rebellion and violence against the government.

Nearly every other liberal democracy regulates and restricts ownership and use of firearms far more than the US does, and those countries have no more fallen into tyranny than the US has - in fact, those countries tend to have governments that are more responsive and accountable to their citizens than the US, in addition to having rates of gun violence that are orders of magnitude lower.

I would respectfully submit that the common American assumption that the government cannot be trusted to do anything right is self-fulfilling.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by snowwrestler on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:59PM (#5512898)
> I would respectfully submit that the common American assumption that the government cannot be trusted to do anything right is self-fulfilling.

Americans do not actually think this. The highway system, environmental protections, labor laws, the military, Medicare, and Social Security are all extremely popular.

What Americans actually believe is that government actions should not be trusted merely because they are government actions.

The fundamental concept of American governance is that the people are sovereign, not the government. This was a radical notion in the 18th century, and I would argue that is remains so today, given the number of folks who can't seem to wrap their heads around it.

For example, gun ownership is not based on the right to rebel--no such right exists (see: the Civil War). Americans have the right to own guns because Americans want to own guns, and Americans are in charge. We get to decide what we want to do and when we want to do it. The role of government is not to rule the people, but to adjudicate peacefully between the many different opinions that people freely hold.

The 2nd Amendment is still in force today not because it is old, but because the American people, today, want it to remain in force.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by philwelch on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:12PM (#5512996)
I would actually venture the opinion that the South did have the legal right to rebel and secede. The North just reconquered the South and readmitted it to the Union state by state.

In other words, you can try to rebel. You don't have the right to win though ;)

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by rvkennedy on Monday April 08, 2013 @06:11PM (#5515004)
They had the right to self-determination, just as the 13 rebel colonies did in seceding from Britain. But they gave up that right a-priori by enslaving an entire section of their population. The same could be argued about the American Revolution, but Britain had not raised any significant complaint about colonial slave-holding, so had no real standing from that perspective.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by snowwrestler on Monday April 08, 2013 @05:17PM (#5514680)
I see what you're saying, although I'd quibble with the word "legal."

It certainly seems very American to think that people have a right to rebel...that's how we got our country, after all. But I'd say that's more of a natural right than a legal right--one that supercedes the typical concept of legality in its very nature.

What I meant above was more that the U.S. Constitution does not provide a power, right, or mechanism for states or individuals to violently rebel. It's certainly not the reason we have the 2nd Amendment (quite the opposite, actually).

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by philwelch on Monday April 08, 2013 @11:15PM (#5516237)
Sure. It's a logical absurdity to suppose a legal right to rebel, since the act of rebellion is the act of rejecting that legal authority in the first place.

I would actually say, though, that the Second Amendment is likely intended to put governments at explicit risk of rebellion, especially when it comes to day-to-day enforcement. It's not so much about rising up and marching on DC when they decide to oppress people. It's more about not being able to send in the cops to oppress people in the first place, because if they do, they'll end up being shot. Even within this century, the Black Panthers used the Second Amendment to protect blacks from police brutality: http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2011/09/the-secr...

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by ensignavenger on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @10:36AM (#5518318)
And used effectively in the Battle of Athens, too. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Athens_(1946)
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by RyanMcGreal on Monday April 08, 2013 @04:03PM (#5514165)
> What Americans actually believe is that government actions should not be trusted merely because they are government actions.

This is precisely the exceptionalism I'm talking about. Americans do not have a monopoly on the understanding that individuals are sovereign and that the government operates only with the consent of the people.

The citizens of other liberal democracies are not passive subjects - indeed, aside from selective dogmatism around gun ownership, Americans are far more passive and fatalistic toward their government's abuses and intransigences than the citizens of many other countries.

The US political system is as dysfunctional as it is precisely because so few Americans believe it can be made to work. In the absence of a culture in which large groups of people people actively engage in the formal and informal mechanisms of democratic governance, too many Americans instead express contempt and despair and stockpile guns.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by snowwrestler on Monday April 08, 2013 @04:48PM (#5514486)
I didn't say that Americans are the only ones who believe that. You are the one who is singling out the U.S. for some sort of special criticism--based on gross misunderstandings of the state of things here.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by Karunamon on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:15PM (#5513013)
>The 2nd Amendment is still in force today not because it is old, but because the American people, today, want it to remain in force.

How does this apply to the rest of the bill of rights, though? Two major instances I can think of the oft-maligned "legislating from the bench" both apply to civil rights, first desegregation, and more recently marriage equality.

The courts are ruling the existing laws cover marriage equality despite the outcry - and this is a good thing. Some things are right and wrong regardless of how many people want it to be a certain way.

I don't think whether people "want" something especially when it comes to equal rights should have any impact on how the law is interpreted. One of the good arguments against direct democracy, IMHO.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by snowwrestler on Monday April 08, 2013 @05:32PM (#5514777)
If U.S. citizens do not like a Supreme Court ruling, they can pass a Constitutional amendment overturning it. After the Civil War, the 14th Amendment was ratified, overturning the Dred Scott Supreme Court decision and allowing former slaves and their children to become citizens.

That Amendment has since provided the legal power behind most civil rights decisions, including desegregation and (if they win) marriage equality. The "equal protection" clause justifies rulings against needless discrimination, and the "due process" clause makes those rulings apply to state and local laws in addition to federal law.

So here is an example where a huge swatch of what people take for granted today as Constitutional protections, in fact dates only to the 1860s.

If Americans as a whole wanted to get rid of the 2nd Amendment, they could pass a Constitutional amendment revoking it. They did it to Prohibition. The reason that is not happening is that most Americans like guns, or at least they respect the desire of other Americans to own them.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by JohnBooty on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:35PM (#5512739)

  > I would respectfully submit that the common 
  > American assumption that the government cannot 
  > be trusted to do anything right is self-fulfilling
Yes. American here, and I feel the "self-fulfilling" aspect is key and is often overlooked.

With such a significant portion of the country deeply suspicious of government, we steer away from government in the name of "freedom" but actually just place more power in corporations' hands.

I feel as though our country is (perhaps stuck in) our awkward teenage years. You know how teenagers often resist anything teachers and parents tell them? We rail against government just because we can regardless of whether or not it's actually a good idea.

In our defense, the last two presidential elections have shown a willingness of the country (particularly among younger voters) to begin to move away from some of the mistrust in government.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by ams6110 on Monday April 08, 2013 @08:38PM (#5515719)
In our defense, the last two presidential elections have shown a willingness of the country (particularly among younger voters) to begin to move away from some of the mistrust in government.

Sometimes people just have to learn things the hard way.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by saraid216 on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:32PM (#5512720)
> I would respectfully submit that the common American assumption that the government cannot be trusted to do anything right is self-fulfilling.

This, pretty much. It has bottomed out civic participation such that the majority of civic participation comes from businesses whose engagement is about gaming the system.

I admittedly do not have stats to back that sentence up, but I suspect I could find them.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by philwelch on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:08PM (#5512969)
So when we do have more freedoms than other countries, it's "quaint" and dangerous?

The examples I gave are things that aren't omnipresent among liberal democracies. It's not quasi-tyrannical to outlaw "hate speech", just less free. I prefer more freedom to less.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by RyanMcGreal on Monday April 08, 2013 @03:54PM (#5514089)
The US Supreme Court has ruled that the First Amendment is consistent with several arguably reasonable limits on free expression, including:

* Expression that incites criminal action;

* Expression that causes injury;

* Obscenity via the Miller Test;

* Child pornography;

* Regulation of commercial speech;

* Copyright and other 'intellectual property' restrictions;

and so on.

Of course, the various other liberal democracies also enshrine the right to free expression; and they also enforce arguably reasonable limits on that right, some of which are similar to the limits in the US and some of which are slightly different.

Is a country where you can be fined for saying "fuck" on television more or less free than a country where you can be fined for saying a minority should be exterminated, where it can be shown that hateful propaganda has the effect of silencing a whole group of people?

There is nothing special about the US Constitution. It is no better, and in many ways worse, than the constitutions of other liberal democracies. The US Constitution is a legal, historical document that admits of many possible interpretations, and it is nothing if not misleading to pretend to absolutism, however selective, in how it shapes the law.

As for the Second Amendment, the US is perhaps the only liberal democracy that perceives a need to guarantee a citizen's right to own and bear firearms, based on the 18th century idea that governments are inherently tyrannical and the only way to guarantee liberty is with the constant threat of violent rebellion.

As we have seen, this belief has been disproven. The citizens of other countries are able to keep their governments more or less honest through maintaining formal and informal democratic institutions and civic engagement - indeed, the governments of many other countries are more responsive and accountable to their citizens than the US government.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by philwelch on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @12:40AM (#5516473)
> Is a country where you can be fined for saying "fuck" on television more or less free than a country where you can be fined for saying a minority should be exterminated, where it can be shown that hateful propaganda has the effect of silencing a whole group of people?

You can legally say "fuck" on American television all you want, just not using the public airwaves. Since the rise of cable it's the market, not the FCC, that sets those rules.

And there is a very, very important qualitative difference between regulating pornography and advertising and regulating political and religious expression.

> As we have seen, this belief has been disproven. The citizens of other countries are able to keep their governments more or less honest through maintaining formal and informal democratic institutions and civic engagement - indeed, the governments of many other countries are more responsive and accountable to their citizens than the US government.

Well, so far. There are some liberal democracies that are more honest than the US (probably Germany) and some that are less (probably Italy), and they haven't been liberal democracies quite as long as the US.

Frankly, much of the problem is that the US is such a damn big country. Most liberal democracies have the population of a large state, and New York and California both have relatively responsive state governments compared to the US federal government. How responsive is the EU? Less responsive than they can be because Germany and Greece want radically different things. The same is true of California and Mississippi.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by beeffective on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:04PM (#5512936)
Pointing at lack of firearms regulations in the US correlating to higher firearm violence does not imply causation. We had an assault weapons ban for 10 years that did nothing, and given that 98% of murders are from handguns (in 2011) and DC banned handguns for 30 years, you would expect DC to have low handgun violence, but it does not.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by devdas on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @01:53PM (#5519792)
Pointing out places within the US where (some) guns are banned is a bad choice of example, unless you can't get in without being searched.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by makomk on Monday April 08, 2013 @05:00PM (#5514582)
Exactly! Sure, the Supreme Court ruled that it was fine to prohibit a vast swathe of political speech, including pro-communist and anti-draft speech, but the moment - the very moment! - they realised that ruling could also be used to shut down groups like the KKK which actually murdered and terrorised black Americans they promptly reversed their ruling, making sure that hate speech was given the full Constitutional protection it so obviously deserved.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by mindslight on Monday April 08, 2013 @02:58PM (#5513715)
> The only problem with the American constitution is that the federal government isn't very good at following it

In other words, the Constitution has failed at its fundamental purpose - controlling the federal government. Not that there are any political remedies - this would just spread the cancer faster. Pride blinds. The more we insist our well-built ship cannot possibly be sinking, the less inclined we are to look for the lifeboats.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by zanny on Monday April 08, 2013 @10:12AM (#5511755)
I'd argue they are 19th century, since they were the first in a long line of democratic (r)evolutions. But they are still outdated.

<Insert the Thomas Jefferson quote about having a new constitution every generation>

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by solistice on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:21PM (#5512645)
That's not entirely right. The American Revolution and the Founding Fathers borrowed some ideas from the French Revolution, which would make that revolution the first in line. Yes, it was major, but it wasn't the first.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by carbocation on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:25PM (#5512670)
The French Revolution comes a full 13 years after the American Declaration of Independence, 2 years after the adoption of the US Constitution, and several months after the US Constitution was ratified and went into effect.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by Locke1689 on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:08PM (#5512967)
This should be obvious, given that the primary backer to the American Revolutionary War was the French monarchy. grumble grumble kids these days...
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by solistice on Monday April 08, 2013 @03:52PM (#5514069)
Then either my history teacher told me something absurdly wrong or I simply remebered it the wrong way round. I'm really sorry about that.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by carbocation on Monday April 08, 2013 @06:07PM (#5514982)
Either way, it's nothing to worry about. Don't let this hold you back from participating in the future, by the way. Being wrong sometimes is a powerful motivator for learning.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by thisrod on Monday April 08, 2013 @09:00PM (#5515798)
Actually, representative democracy started with the English Revolution, in 1688. It was carried out so competently that no one got shot, and hardly anyone has heard of it.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by arethuza on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @07:38AM (#5517429)
Usually known as the "Glorious Revolution":

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glorious_Revolution

Then there was the earlier Civil War where parliament fought a war to remove (and eventually execute) a king long before the French has a similar idea:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_Civil_War

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by snowwrestler on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:49PM (#5512839)
Ideas don't get old, like fruit left on the counter. They're still with us because they are still good.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by dsfasfasf on Monday April 08, 2013 @11:22AM (#5512241)
For your comment to not come off as xenophobic you need to provide examples and counter-examples. Otherwise your comment is not constructive and is pure vitriol.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by peejaybee on Monday April 08, 2013 @11:43AM (#5512391)
I dunno, it seemed like pretty highly-diluted vitriol to me.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by saurabhnanda on Monday April 08, 2013 @10:34AM (#5511900)
Doesn't US have the equivalent of a Public Interest Litigation (PIL), like in India?
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by Justsignedup on Monday April 08, 2013 @08:21AM (#5511238)
...And of course if the supreme court refuses the case...
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by ecaron on Monday April 08, 2013 @09:48AM (#5511622)
At risk of being down-voted out of existence, this isn't First Amendment material in the same way that defamation (e.g. slander, libel) isn't First Amendment material - or how breaking into a pharmaceutical and publishing their formulas aren't First Amendment material.

Although Minnesota's version of the ag-gag bill was certainly too far reaching and rightfully shut down (https://www.revisor.mn.gov/bin/bldbill.php?bill=S1118.0.html...), I'm behind the core concept that guerrilla-style undercover videos belongs on the farm as much as it does in our offices. The biggest danger is confusing the "taping" discussed in this article with actual journalism - and in-depth analysis of the legislation definitively shows that these ag companies will grudgingly allow legitimate reporting of their facilities, but have a right to persecute unethical practices.

* Don't confuse the Humane Society of the United States with your local humane society. For example, their CEO is against the ownership of pets. More details are at http://www.humanewatch.org/, but take that with the same scepticism you would any documentary or online video:-)

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by pyre on Monday April 08, 2013 @09:52AM (#5511649)

  | breaking into a pharmaceutical and
  | publishing their formulas aren't First
  | Amendment material
Are you really trying to claim that filming the way that animals are treated behind closed doors is a 'trade secret' in the same way that pharmaceutical formulas[1] are?

[1] Not to mention that most of these are published in the form of patents anyways...

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by ecaron on Monday April 08, 2013 @10:01AM (#5511695)
You're right, my formula analogy was poor because of the reasons you mentioned. Breaking in and filming the testing facilities would have been more apt. Certainly those facilities need watch guard groups advocating for the protection of the tested, but pharmaceutical has proper channels for that oversight and we're denying ag that same benefit.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by eltondegeneres on Monday April 08, 2013 @11:06AM (#5512113)
Just a heads up: Humane Watch is run by the Center for Consumer Freedom which is a lobbying group for the agriculture and tobacco industries. I'd be wary of anything i read of their websites.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by pyre on Monday April 08, 2013 @09:50AM (#5511633)
It's obvious. Animal rights activists are terrorists, and terrorists don't have rights because they are "attacking our way of life and they hate our freedom [to eat meat while ignoring how it gets to our tables]."
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by solistice on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:27PM (#5512685)
I'm a semanticist precisely for that reason. Due to ill definition of the term "terrorist", it went from "Violent supporter of an agenda that uses scare tactics to demoralize" to "People filming Animal Abuse" or other more benign individuals that do not deserve that description.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by bjustin on Monday April 08, 2013 @09:54AM (#5511665)
Many states do not allow ordinary citizens to record a phone call without the consent of both parties. This seems like it would have the same kind of justification.
Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by bane on Monday April 08, 2013 @10:00PM (#5516032)
The way that it's determined if these laws are congruent with the U.S. Constitution is for the infringed groups to take the case before SCOTUS.

It's just the sad way it is, the Legislature is under no particular obligation to determine the Constitutionality of the laws it passes.

Sucks, but that's the way it is.

Re:Taping of Farm Cruelty Is Becoming the Crime by lifeisstillgood on Monday April 08, 2013 @04:11PM (#5514211)
What with Thatchers passing, a Home Secretary wanting to abolish our signing up to the european human rights act, I just love the sound of those words tonight.

+1 to Madison and Jefferson