Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by friendly_chap on Monday April 08, 2013 @02:14AM
(#5510224)
I am glad they are such a cool company today, yesterday (yes, I worked my ass off on Sunday) I had to work with one of their products - a company I do freelance work for bought a domain and some hosting from them.
Instead of cPanel or Plesk they had some home made solution, basically 80% of the links were dead,
and the whole application only consisted of approx. 10 pages. Bravo!
I called the tech support, I've talked with 10-12 people, 9-10 of them were supposed experts at the technical department. Only one of them said he knew what an A record is, but he had to redirect me to yet another "expert", but he informed me it will take a "lot of time to access this man". A lot of compared to what? I was on the phone for like 1.5 hours already! I suspect this guy was eating his lunch at home but he was a resrouceful chap so they had to phone him with "tough" questions. I feel sorry for that guy working with idiots! And if he is unlucky enough he doesn't even get paid more.
The tech support story is not necessarily related to this article but I had to shout it out. I will probably write a blog post too. On the other hand, the fact they undertook developing a software which has perfect open source alternatives, and they let the end product become an epic fail, seeing these "we are so cool and competent" ads makes me puke.
Please, PAY YOUR TECHNICAL EMPLOYEES TOO, not just the marketing guys and DON'T BE DUMB, if you want to develop software give me a call because I can cut your costs by 90%, your managers are dumb.
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by Samuel_Michon on Monday April 08, 2013 @02:45AM
(#5510302)
The page was about T-Mobile USA, formerly known as VoiceStream. Nowadays, it is owned by Deutsche Telekom, but it has little to do with the T-Mobile brand in other countries. T-Mobile USA doesn't offer domain or web hosting services. T-Mobile USA mostly just sells budget cellphone plans. They're a small player trying to gain more marketshare.
I suspect you're talking about T-Mobile Hungary which, like T-Mobile in other European countries, is the largest carrier in the country and really couldn't care less about its customers. (I'm a subscriber with T-Mobile in The Netherlands, where the company isn't dominant. The situation is better here.)
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by yareally on Monday April 08, 2013 @03:06AM
(#5510352)
All of what you said is 100% true about T-Mobile USA. Just to amend, their tech support and customer service is similar. From friends I know that deal with them, they outsource all their tech support to firms with employees that can barely speak English and are inadequately trained. I don't like dealing with Verizon (Vodaphone for those outside the US) customer service either, but their service is still leap years ahead.
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by Samuel_Michon on Monday April 08, 2013 @03:31AM
(#5510410)
“Verizon (Vodaphone for those outside the US)”
Verizon and Vodafone are separate publicly traded companies. Verizon Wireless is a joint venture between Verizon and Vodafone. Vodafone owns 45% of Verizon Wireless. However, Verizon has a 23% stake in Vodafone Italy.
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by EliRivers on Monday April 08, 2013 @08:37AM
(#5511303)
Now that's interesting; a brand in one country that's doing well (if I take your word for it, which I will - no reason not to :) ) is (presumably) being actively damaged by the incompetence of companies operating under that brand in other countries.
What happens in this sort of case? Can we expect to see T-Mobile US try to rebrand or rename itself?
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by Samuel_Michon on Monday April 08, 2013 @03:22PM
(#5513887)
T-Mobile has a better reputation in the US than it has in most European countries.
It’s not so much about the T-Mobile brand, but about the companies it acquired. In the US, T-Mobile doesn’t have a large network, which makes it uninteresting to customers who travel, but at least it’s relatively cheap. In Europe, the problem is that the T-Mobile networks are the incumbents. As we know from AT&T before the Baby Bell division, dominant parties tend to get lazy and lose interest in their customers’ wishes.
Like the cable companies in the US, T-Mobile doesn’t have a lot of customers because it’s such a great company, it has lots of customers because of mergers & acquisitions, false advertising, and lack of choice.
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by friendly_chap on Monday April 08, 2013 @03:01AM
(#5510336)
Yeah I suspected they may differ but how come they don't control the quality at the top?
Developing shitty ad hoc in house software? Which company allows that?
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by fab13n on Monday April 08, 2013 @04:12AM
(#5510505)
BS: wireless will be fixed when operators will accept to be dumb pipes, with flat prices, and without almost mandatory bandwidth+device bundles. That's exactly what they don't want, and doesn't seem to be what T-Mobile offers.
In France, free.fr wreaked the whole market by offering illimited phone calls + SMS + data (bandwidth capped beyond 3GB/month) for €16 to €20, depending on whether you already get ADSL from them. No device (rather, unlocked devices can be bought with a 12 or 24 months credit, in a contract independent from the network subscription), network subscriptions can be cancelled in 1 month. Simple, cheap, readable. All other operators had to follow suit.
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by gergles on Monday April 08, 2013 @11:27AM
(#5512274)
That is exactly what T-Mobile offers; all of these prices do not include a device (you can purchase one on installments.)
The pricing is higher, but other than that, it's basically the same shebang and T-Mobile doesn't have a profit-margin wetdream of a landline network to subsidize their pricing.
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by dangrossman on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:31AM
(#5509984)
Conspicuously missing is the $30/mo plan with unlimited data (first 5GB at 4G speed) and 100 minutes of talk. Now I wonder what will happen to my service next month. [Edit: 5GB, not 2GB]
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by cheald on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:13AM
(#5510084)
You should go into a TMo store or call them - I've generally found that to be more productive. I recently went in to get a new SIM for my Nexus 4 and ended up switching to a $40/mo plan (100 minutes/unlimited text+web) right then, and wasn't charged any activation fee.
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by thaumasiotes on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:39AM
(#5510138)
Interesting viewpoint; I ordered a new sim card so I could get the cheaper rates. The goal to not cannibalize existing lines doesn't seem to have worked out (and the sim card was all of $1); further, given the immense pricing discrepancy, it's hard for me to see this deterring many people at all (the new-activations-only plan costs 60% of the price of the next cheapest plan with unlimited data, $30 / mo instead of $50).
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by Kerrick on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:55AM
(#5510034)
Actually, the first 5GB are at 4G speeds. I've got that plan. I got an email from T-Mobile inviting me to change to a new plan and explaining why they think I should, but it wasn't a notification of forced change.
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by dangrossman on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:55AM
(#5510173)
That plan was offered by both Wal-Mart and T-Mobile through their website. No difference. I was mistaken in saying it was only 2GB at 4G speed. From your link:
> The plan will be sold exclusively in-store at more than 2,200 Walmart stores and online at www.walmart.com and www.T-Mobile.com and is expected to launch Oct. 16.
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by hkmurakami on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:10AM
(#5510072)
:( I'm afraid that it's going to go away in the future so I'm signing up for the plan as we speak (I had been putting it off for quite some time after getting a Nexus 4, continuing to use my old phone), but now their website won'tc complete my order. Perhaps this article is driving traffic to the site and people really are signing up?
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by gergles on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:15AM
(#5510089)
I'm a little annoyed they won't offer official tethering on the 4.5 GB plan, even for an extra charge. This is especially annoying because T-Mobile is historically one of the most aggressive anti-tethering carriers (through use of packet inspection and other techniques to try to guess if the use is 'genuine' or not) if you are not paying for the "service" of using your bytes as you see fit.
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by saool on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:30AM
(#5510117)
I tether every now and then with the 2GB plan and it works fine. Sometimes they will "catch" me and tell me to pay up. When that happens I just use an agent switcher and spoof as Opera 12, works every time...
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by lucb1e on Monday April 08, 2013 @04:19AM
(#5510530)
How can they know if you do tethering without deep packet inspection? I think that's actually illegal by law in the Netherlands (net neutrality law), but not sure about that. It's very much frowned upon though.
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by anigbrowl on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:08AM
(#5509938)
I'm glad to see T-Mobile grasping this nettle, but they're buing a bit disingenuous. Look at the plans here: http://how-to.t-mobile.com/newplans/ The $50/mo plan had unlimited everything plus no hotpsot restrictions until a few months ago, when they took that away. Now they're giving it back after consumer backlash. not advertised is a $30/mo plan with limited talk and text but only 100mb/mo of data (which will be eaten by T-mobile status updates and app checkins even if you have sync turned off). Don't want text because you never use it? Too bad, you have to pay for unlimited text anyway. They don't even mention this alternative here because they want to position $50 as the mobile price floor going forward.
They're going in the right direction, but kicking and screaming a bit.
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by fein on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:29AM
(#5509978)
> Too bad, you have to pay for unlimited text anyway.
Which is a massive lie right there (from t-mobile). SMS is effectively piggybacking on the signals your phone sends out to find which towers are available, so were t-mobile being totally honest, they'd just cut out the SMS charge period. It's such a low cost (borderline free) to process and send SMS's that there is really no honest way to charge for it.
But we live in America, where tech literacy is abysmal for 75% of the inhabitants, and Telco's capitalize on this. Either that or we don't have a single honest Telco CEO.
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by thaumasiotes on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:44AM
(#5510009)
> SMS is effectively piggybacking on the signals your phone sends out to find which towers are available, so were t-mobile being totally honest, they'd just cut out the SMS charge period.
What exactly is the difference between "cut[ting] out the SMS charge" and including unlimited texting in every plan?
EDIT: let's see if I can wrap some more words around my point.
Your parent post is complaining that t-mobile doesn't want to offer a plan which is differentiated from some current plan of theirs by (a) offering lower texting allowances, and (b) being cheaper.
You think that, since the cost of transmitting texts is nil, t-mobile shouldn't charge for transmitting them.
And by looking at the plans t-mobile wants to offer, we can see that they agree with you; they don't think it makes sense to charge more for a plan with higher texting allowances vs one with lower allowances. No matter how much texting you do, they're going to charge you exactly the same. (Your argument is phrased in moral terms, while I suspect t-mobile's position is driven more by the fact that an unlimited data plan is a perfect substitute for texting.)
But, instead of slamming your parent post for wanting something that makes no sense (plans that charge extra for more texting), you're slamming t-mobile for "dishonest pricing" that reflects exactly what you believe should be happening. I don't get it.
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by thaumasiotes on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:36AM
(#5510130)
What do you mean? T-mobile's model is exactly the model you said they should have. Texting is free. There is no way to pay them to carry your texts (if you're on a plan with unlimited data). Do you want them to offer $50 / month calling and data with 50 texts alongside $50 / month calling and data with unlimited texts? How would that be an improvement?
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by fein on Monday April 08, 2013 @11:20AM
(#5512220)
Straight Talk, for example, offers an unlimited 1 year plan for what works out to be $41 a month. I can use an unlocked phone and change out sim cards for international travel. It's $45/mo if you pay monthly.
T-Mobile is rather unattractive at $70/month on a BYOP plan.
edit: Tmo's plan has a data cap on the $50/mo setup. Straight Talk does not.
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by JoshTriplett on Monday April 08, 2013 @06:58PM
(#5515283)
Straight Talk definitely does, they just don't tell you very clearly what it is. Do some searching, and you'll find quite a few reports of people who get cut off for downloading more data than Straight Talk expects. They also very specifically prohibit video and audio streaming, and several other high-bandwidth activities.
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by mcpherrinm on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:45AM
(#5510012)
> SMS is effectively piggybacking on the signals your phone sends out to find which towers are available
This argument bugs me. The phone-to-tower is only a portion of the infrastructure: You have to get those messages somewhere after that. But the rest of that infrastructure isn't any more interesting than email.
So I'm not disagreeing with the point that SMS is overpriced (especially without a plan). I doubt you could convince anybody to spend $10/month on "unlimited email".
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by rurounijones on Monday April 08, 2013 @04:46AM
(#5510632)
When SMS first exploded in popularity back in the day a friend of mine worked at BT (British Telecom) and pointed out that the entire network's SMS traffic was handled by 3 mid-range sun sparc servers.
Since SMS was originally designed to use management channels it was already built into the general infrastructure, they just needed to up the server count to 3.
SMS was (and maybe still is?) almost pure profit for at least BT and I imagine other carriers.
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by smutticus on Monday April 08, 2013 @03:18AM
(#5510384)
>SMS is effectively piggybacking on the signals your phone sends out to find which towers are available, so were t-mobile being totally honest, they'd just cut out the SMS charge period.
It's still data and they still need to provision timeslots for it and transfer it. There is no free lunch. SMS goes over the signalling timeslot, in ISDN terms this is called the D-channel. D-channels cannot carry voice traffic. So provisioning more timeslots for D-channels, and consequently SMS, means that at a given tower and frequency you will have fewer timeslots for voice. So SMS has a cost.
This analysis is not taking into account the cost of transferring SMS over the wired infrastructure as well.
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by asynchronous13 on Monday April 08, 2013 @04:19AM
(#5510534)
In this case it is a free lunch. SMS was specifically designed to make use of an unused portion of communication between handset and tower. Thus, the limit of 1,120 bits (140 8-bit chars, or the now standard 160 7-bit chars). No extra time slots are needed to accomodate SMS, because it's bandwidth usage is dramatically lower than that of voice data.
As you said, it's still data. If one has a plan that includes unlimited internet data, where is the justification to charge even more for SMS?
But none of that really matters, because it's not the cost of the product that determines pricing. It's the delivered value that determines pricing.
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by bdcravens on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:54AM
(#5510171)
Is wireless broken, or is there competitive position? It's great that they're doing something totally different, but pretty sure they wouldn't be were they #1 or #2.
Also, that's a horrible address, with the combo of dashes and dot.
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by rurounijones on Monday April 08, 2013 @04:38AM
(#5510595)
Despite how good this may be as soon as I see massive amounts of small grey text at the bottom of the page I immediately dismiss any of the main points on the page and lose interest in the product since I cannot be bothered to unscramble the important stuff they are trying to hide.
(seriously, on my computer it is a 600px by 250px wall of small grey legalese)
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by oakesm9 on Monday April 08, 2013 @05:40AM
(#5510788)
GiffGaff in the UK is a bit more radical with "fixing wireless". £12 for unlimited texts and data and 250 minutes. But any calls to other GiffGaff customers don't count towards your limit. There's other plans as well, including data only ones http://giffgaff.com/index/offer
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by Samuel_Michon on Monday April 08, 2013 @03:10AM
(#5510367)
He went to MIT, but he doesn't have a New England accent. However, the 'Legere' family name is most common in Maine and Massachusetts. I can't find any mention of his birthplace but he likes to curse[1], so he could be from anywhere in the Northeast ;)
Instead of cPanel or Plesk they had some home made solution, basically 80% of the links were dead, and the whole application only consisted of approx. 10 pages. Bravo!
I called the tech support, I've talked with 10-12 people, 9-10 of them were supposed experts at the technical department. Only one of them said he knew what an A record is, but he had to redirect me to yet another "expert", but he informed me it will take a "lot of time to access this man". A lot of compared to what? I was on the phone for like 1.5 hours already! I suspect this guy was eating his lunch at home but he was a resrouceful chap so they had to phone him with "tough" questions. I feel sorry for that guy working with idiots! And if he is unlucky enough he doesn't even get paid more.
The tech support story is not necessarily related to this article but I had to shout it out. I will probably write a blog post too. On the other hand, the fact they undertook developing a software which has perfect open source alternatives, and they let the end product become an epic fail, seeing these "we are so cool and competent" ads makes me puke.
Please, PAY YOUR TECHNICAL EMPLOYEES TOO, not just the marketing guys and DON'T BE DUMB, if you want to develop software give me a call because I can cut your costs by 90%, your managers are dumb.
Ohh, thank God I feel so much better now.
I suspect you're talking about T-Mobile Hungary which, like T-Mobile in other European countries, is the largest carrier in the country and really couldn't care less about its customers. (I'm a subscriber with T-Mobile in The Netherlands, where the company isn't dominant. The situation is better here.)
Verizon and Vodafone are separate publicly traded companies. Verizon Wireless is a joint venture between Verizon and Vodafone. Vodafone owns 45% of Verizon Wireless. However, Verizon has a 23% stake in Vodafone Italy.
Complicated, but not the same company.
What happens in this sort of case? Can we expect to see T-Mobile US try to rebrand or rename itself?
It’s not so much about the T-Mobile brand, but about the companies it acquired. In the US, T-Mobile doesn’t have a large network, which makes it uninteresting to customers who travel, but at least it’s relatively cheap. In Europe, the problem is that the T-Mobile networks are the incumbents. As we know from AT&T before the Baby Bell division, dominant parties tend to get lazy and lose interest in their customers’ wishes.
Like the cable companies in the US, T-Mobile doesn’t have a lot of customers because it’s such a great company, it has lots of customers because of mergers & acquisitions, false advertising, and lack of choice.
In France, free.fr wreaked the whole market by offering illimited phone calls + SMS + data (bandwidth capped beyond 3GB/month) for €16 to €20, depending on whether you already get ADSL from them. No device (rather, unlocked devices can be bought with a 12 or 24 months credit, in a contract independent from the network subscription), network subscriptions can be cancelled in 1 month. Simple, cheap, readable. All other operators had to follow suit.
The pricing is higher, but other than that, it's basically the same shebang and T-Mobile doesn't have a profit-margin wetdream of a landline network to subsidize their pricing.
http://prepaid-phones.t-mobile.com/prepaid-plans
http://newsroom.t-mobile.com/articles/walmart-and-t-mobile-i...
From what I understand you CANNOT switch over an existing gsm sim and balance to the special walmart plan, it has to be started with them.
> The plan will be sold exclusively in-store at more than 2,200 Walmart stores and online at www.walmart.com and www.T-Mobile.com and is expected to launch Oct. 16.
edit: got it to go through after about 5 tries
They're going in the right direction, but kicking and screaming a bit.
Which is a massive lie right there (from t-mobile). SMS is effectively piggybacking on the signals your phone sends out to find which towers are available, so were t-mobile being totally honest, they'd just cut out the SMS charge period. It's such a low cost (borderline free) to process and send SMS's that there is really no honest way to charge for it.
But we live in America, where tech literacy is abysmal for 75% of the inhabitants, and Telco's capitalize on this. Either that or we don't have a single honest Telco CEO.
What exactly is the difference between "cut[ting] out the SMS charge" and including unlimited texting in every plan?
EDIT: let's see if I can wrap some more words around my point.
Your parent post is complaining that t-mobile doesn't want to offer a plan which is differentiated from some current plan of theirs by (a) offering lower texting allowances, and (b) being cheaper.
You think that, since the cost of transmitting texts is nil, t-mobile shouldn't charge for transmitting them.
And by looking at the plans t-mobile wants to offer, we can see that they agree with you; they don't think it makes sense to charge more for a plan with higher texting allowances vs one with lower allowances. No matter how much texting you do, they're going to charge you exactly the same. (Your argument is phrased in moral terms, while I suspect t-mobile's position is driven more by the fact that an unlimited data plan is a perfect substitute for texting.)
But, instead of slamming your parent post for wanting something that makes no sense (plans that charge extra for more texting), you're slamming t-mobile for "dishonest pricing" that reflects exactly what you believe should be happening. I don't get it.
I'm not slamming the parent, just T-mobile rephrasing a still predatory model.
T-Mobile is rather unattractive at $70/month on a BYOP plan.
edit: Tmo's plan has a data cap on the $50/mo setup. Straight Talk does not.
Don't downvote until you know what you're speaking on.
This argument bugs me. The phone-to-tower is only a portion of the infrastructure: You have to get those messages somewhere after that. But the rest of that infrastructure isn't any more interesting than email.
So I'm not disagreeing with the point that SMS is overpriced (especially without a plan). I doubt you could convince anybody to spend $10/month on "unlimited email".
Since SMS was originally designed to use management channels it was already built into the general infrastructure, they just needed to up the server count to 3.
SMS was (and maybe still is?) almost pure profit for at least BT and I imagine other carriers.
It's still data and they still need to provision timeslots for it and transfer it. There is no free lunch. SMS goes over the signalling timeslot, in ISDN terms this is called the D-channel. D-channels cannot carry voice traffic. So provisioning more timeslots for D-channels, and consequently SMS, means that at a given tower and frequency you will have fewer timeslots for voice. So SMS has a cost.
This analysis is not taking into account the cost of transferring SMS over the wired infrastructure as well.
As you said, it's still data. If one has a plan that includes unlimited internet data, where is the justification to charge even more for SMS?
But none of that really matters, because it's not the cost of the product that determines pricing. It's the delivered value that determines pricing.
Also, that's a horrible address, with the combo of dashes and dot.
(seriously, on my computer it is a 600px by 250px wall of small grey legalese)
Is that all iPhones? Bummer if so
[1] http://www.bizjournals.com/seattle/blog/techflash/2013/03/t-...