> But, instead of slamming your parent post for wanting something that makes no sense
I'm not slamming the parent, just T-mobile rephrasing a still predatory model.
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by thaumasiotes on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:36AM
(#5510130)
What do you mean? T-mobile's model is exactly the model you said they should have. Texting is free. There is no way to pay them to carry your texts (if you're on a plan with unlimited data). Do you want them to offer $50 / month calling and data with 50 texts alongside $50 / month calling and data with unlimited texts? How would that be an improvement?
Straight Talk, for example, offers an unlimited 1 year plan for what works out to be $41 a month. I can use an unlocked phone and change out sim cards for international travel. It's $45/mo if you pay monthly.
T-Mobile is rather unattractive at $70/month on a BYOP plan.
edit: Tmo's plan has a data cap on the $50/mo setup. Straight Talk does not.
Re:Wireless is broken. And we're fixing it
by JoshTriplett on Monday April 08, 2013 @06:58PM
(#5515283)
Straight Talk definitely does, they just don't tell you very clearly what it is. Do some searching, and you'll find quite a few reports of people who get cut off for downloading more data than Straight Talk expects. They also very specifically prohibit video and audio streaming, and several other high-bandwidth activities.
What exactly is the difference between "cut[ting] out the SMS charge" and including unlimited texting in every plan?
EDIT: let's see if I can wrap some more words around my point.
Your parent post is complaining that t-mobile doesn't want to offer a plan which is differentiated from some current plan of theirs by (a) offering lower texting allowances, and (b) being cheaper.
You think that, since the cost of transmitting texts is nil, t-mobile shouldn't charge for transmitting them.
And by looking at the plans t-mobile wants to offer, we can see that they agree with you; they don't think it makes sense to charge more for a plan with higher texting allowances vs one with lower allowances. No matter how much texting you do, they're going to charge you exactly the same. (Your argument is phrased in moral terms, while I suspect t-mobile's position is driven more by the fact that an unlimited data plan is a perfect substitute for texting.)
But, instead of slamming your parent post for wanting something that makes no sense (plans that charge extra for more texting), you're slamming t-mobile for "dishonest pricing" that reflects exactly what you believe should be happening. I don't get it.