The guy was right about basically everything. The anti-tivoization provisions that the FSF was talking about more than a decade ago, and that appeared in a usable license almost 6 tears ago, would absolutely have had a place in preventing this nonsense. Yet no one uses it, because RMS is a dirty f'ing hippie.
(And yes, I know the real world is complicated, and that corporate sponsors of copyleft development "refuse" to use the GPLv3 and cannot be convinced. The same thing was said about copyleft itself 15 years ago. The commercial world adapted. They'll figure this out too if we demand it.)
For the longest time, I used to think that rms was insane. Everybody did. It was just, "Oh, did you hear about Stallman's interview on [insert website/news/channel here]?" "No, what crap did he say now??"
I think now people are realizing how he was right. I don't agree with everything that comes out of his mouth, like the whole GNU/Linux thing, or how he uses an inferior computer because it doesn't have a proprietary BIOS. But, now we see the government in bed with Hollywood, we see them in bed with Big Business, and we see them in bed with the big tech companies.
Our government is a slut. The only way we can get it to do what we want and not what it wants is by expressing our opinions about it. rms may be quite vocal about his opinions, but without any sort of noise, the flame will die out. He knows this, and that's why we think he's crazy.
Too bad ~99% of the general masses and public have been irreversibly deceived by the bipartisan system to even think about a possible alternative (The Green Party, Libertarian movement, etc.).
It's really sad, to be honest.
Of course that is a bit of historic revisionism through selection bias, the people with a similar appearance who aren't onto something are soon forgotten, but I think it is becoming clear that RMS will not be playing that role.
Except that most people these days are renting/leasing/amortizing a phone from a carrier and for that carrier, not buying it.
Cell phone subsidies are not loans and they are not partial transfers of property. I buy a phone outright, and I get a cheap price on it because I simultaneously sign up for a service contract. That service contract doesn't change the fact that I now own my phone outright.
To be fair, when someone buys a locked phone, they are really buying it with a combination of their own money and the carrier's money.
This situation is not unlike a credit card issuer requiring that you don't lend out the books you bought with their credit card.
If you buy a car, the seller of said car only has a very limited liability in case of faults. If the car breaks down, its up to the owner to fix it. However, if you rented a car, safety and repairs are on the company that rents the car out. This is how things worked until the 21th century
Selling or renting a product was supposed to be a trade off between liability and ownership. Companies made a choice, depending on risks/reward and if they wanted to effectively become a service company. With DRM however, liability is gone because the company do not claim property ownership, thus any product can now become a effectively rented product and never leave the control of the company.
I have no problem with a company that rents out products. I do however have a problem with companies that is exempted from liability while effectively renting out products under the pretense of selling products.
What's wrong with letting some (most) companies compete with their closed products while others compete with their open products? If you don't want a non-modifiable cell phone you have the option not to buy it.
It would seem to me that the anti-circumvention provisions are facially unconstitutional. The provisions do not criminalize the distribution of copyrighted material, but instead of material which can help others bypass DRM. This is inconsistent with the standard of speech protection in the U.S. (that merely helping or encouraging others cannot be criminalized unless it is imminent lawless action). Of course, anti-circumvention tools can be as simple as a 64 bit key, or as complicated as an exploit payload.
The provisions are overly broad, especially in that they are permanent. If I released something not protected by copyright, but protected by DRM, any circumvention tools would remain criminal forever, unlike copyright which lasts "forever less one day". (MPAA joke)
I can think of so many reasons why these tools should not be criminalized. A circumvention tool in one context could be research or perfectly legitimate in another context. If I released software that could be circumvented with a key and it is illegal to distribute the key, what if the key was already used by some other software in a different way?
I believe one federal court ruled a key might not be criminal under the DMCA, but a different federal court ruled a large program could, so there's some conflicting precedent and we have a long way to go before the DMCA is shot down for any reason.
Here's a well-cited document that might be worth a look: http://techlawadvisor.com/dmca/research.html
To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_law_of_the_United_St...
Using copyright for control and domination has nothing to do with what it was granted for to begin with.
And in any case a very reasonable interpretation is that the DMCA is simply providing legal teeth to the "securing ... the exclusive Right" part of that sentence, which would otherwise be impossible to secure (in both the old and new sense of the word) in the digital age.
I'm not saying you can't make a constitutional argument here, but that it's hardly cut and dry. If you really want to hang your hat on the "unconstitutional" bit, I think you're going to need some actual judges to back you up before anyone takes you seriously.
He, and I, don't support this law. Further, we don't support those who passed this law either knowing its abuses, or not caring to investigate. None of the "too busy, had to do something" excuses count because we, the people, supposedly to root of power in this country, were systematically ignored and silenced by government action when we spoke out against this type of law. A government that passes these laws is a government directly acting outside the powers granted by the people.
When we say unconstitutional we mean against the founding spirit of this country, that government is limited and responsible to the people.
If you have a better term than unconstitutional, suggest it, but we aren't discussing some technical quirk of this system as if we cared about the justifications others have made - we're discussing that it's poisoned and not serving those who feed it.
Fine. Just recognize that the rest of us use the same term to mean "incompatible with the constitution" and are going to get confused when you start changing the langauge without telling us.
Look, I think the DMCA is dumb too. But if I'm reading between the lines, what's really happening is that you actually want the DMCA to be "technically invalid" in the way that an unconstitutional law is. That is, you want the technical definition of "constitutional" for its impact but you want your looser "principles" definition for categorizing the DMCA. Sorry, but that's just bad logic. Stop it.
The law sucks, and there are few plausible ways to correct that. But stop with the constitutionality argument; it's not a get-out-of-jail-free card here.
I don't disagree with the sentiments about the badness of the DMCA, but it doesn't help anyone to trivialize the practical difficulties in establishing a well-functioning government.
I don't mean to trivialize anything. But government starts with the consent of the governed. It's cool, sort of, that you feel you consent to this. But I don't. It's not that it isn't good enough soon enough, it's that we reward treacherous behavior so the system is never going to work for the people.
This is the problem with copyright and patent law at all. We're not actually helping the creators, we're giving some of them (those who jump through certain hoops, and meet arbitrary requirements) a letter of marque with which to enforce the law on their own and presumably make enough justify the process. While intended to let a little guy claim his own these invariably wreak havoc in the wrong hands.
If we did what RMS suggested years ago we could be straight-up paying creators of popular works based on self-reported usage. And it would totally rid us of the need for DRM, and thus the need to legally support DRM, etc, by being based on a copying is encouraged because it helps the people model.
Of course we'd need administration to track the creator of certain things, like lolcats and other casual works, and pay them, and arbitrate ownership disputes when two people claim a work, etc, but that's just a fraction of the bureaucracy we already have in place.
The entire system of monopoly grants, and the bureaucrats (janitors, clerks, judges, and lawyers), the lawmakers, and the companies who exploit the cracks, can all just dry up and blow away if we decide to truly promote progress.
Worse, even if you find a fault in your device that threatens your personal safety, your are still not allowed to fix that fault. On top of that and thus even worse, if that fault actually causes a problem, the entity that is active preventing your from fixing the problem is still not liable for any damages caused by that fault. All risk is on the consumer who owns the device, while all rights belonging to the company. The owner of the device is left with no rights, and has no effective power over the device.
Its absurd.