He, and I, don't support this law. Further, we don't support those who passed this law either knowing its abuses, or not caring to investigate. None of the "too busy, had to do something" excuses count because we, the people, supposedly to root of power in this country, were systematically ignored and silenced by government action when we spoke out against this type of law. A government that passes these laws is a government directly acting outside the powers granted by the people.
When we say unconstitutional we mean against the founding spirit of this country, that government is limited and responsible to the people.
If you have a better term than unconstitutional, suggest it, but we aren't discussing some technical quirk of this system as if we cared about the justifications others have made - we're discussing that it's poisoned and not serving those who feed it.
Fine. Just recognize that the rest of us use the same term to mean "incompatible with the constitution" and are going to get confused when you start changing the langauge without telling us.
Look, I think the DMCA is dumb too. But if I'm reading between the lines, what's really happening is that you actually want the DMCA to be "technically invalid" in the way that an unconstitutional law is. That is, you want the technical definition of "constitutional" for its impact but you want your looser "principles" definition for categorizing the DMCA. Sorry, but that's just bad logic. Stop it.
The law sucks, and there are few plausible ways to correct that. But stop with the constitutionality argument; it's not a get-out-of-jail-free card here.
I don't disagree with the sentiments about the badness of the DMCA, but it doesn't help anyone to trivialize the practical difficulties in establishing a well-functioning government.
I don't mean to trivialize anything. But government starts with the consent of the governed. It's cool, sort of, that you feel you consent to this. But I don't. It's not that it isn't good enough soon enough, it's that we reward treacherous behavior so the system is never going to work for the people.
And in any case a very reasonable interpretation is that the DMCA is simply providing legal teeth to the "securing ... the exclusive Right" part of that sentence, which would otherwise be impossible to secure (in both the old and new sense of the word) in the digital age.
I'm not saying you can't make a constitutional argument here, but that it's hardly cut and dry. If you really want to hang your hat on the "unconstitutional" bit, I think you're going to need some actual judges to back you up before anyone takes you seriously.