News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Speaking up by h2s on Monday February 04, 2013 @06:03AM (#5163481)
Are there any high profile women in this industry who haven't been treated like shit in some way such as this? What a nasty bunch of people we are. Are we (developers) the douchey 80s guy of the 21st century?
Re:Speaking up by mwetzler on Monday February 04, 2013 @01:25PM (#5165954)
On Friday I pitched my company to a room of 150 developers, since my company was a hackathon sponsor. I was the only female speaker out of about 15.

Afterwards, a well-known, elite developer asked me if I programmed. When I said yes, he said that made me 50% less attractive. Then he asked me if I cooked and cleaned. To my face.

You don't have to be high profile to deal with this stuff. Just being in a room where you're 1 female out of 15 males is enough to get this kind of attention.

Re:Speaking up by gfodor on Monday February 04, 2013 @05:12PM (#5167533)
What the fuck, I really can't wrap my mind around the fact that stuff like this happens. Who are these idiots? It would be pretty useful if there were a way to get these types of things anonymously reported so the accusers could have some way to publicize it, the accuser have their chance to voice their side of the story, and failing to clear the issue up (in your case, there is no excuse for that kind of response) the rest of the entire industry could never, ever hire that person. It's embarrassing that interactions like this happen in a professional setting and there are no good measures in place to report and prevent them.
Re:Speaking up by jellicle on Monday February 04, 2013 @01:46PM (#5166103)
You know, naming names is probably one of the best ways to combat this. Silence helps the asshole keep doing it.

I understand the reasons why you might not want to. It's tragedy of the commons problem; you get no benefit and possible detriment from naming names - only society as a whole benefits.

Nevertheless you should. It's the right thing to do.

Re:Speaking up by mwetzler on Monday February 04, 2013 @01:52PM (#5166151)
It is indeed tricky. I want to give developers a positive association with our company and with me as an individual. Being confrontational does the opposite.
Re:Speaking up by rjknight on Monday February 04, 2013 @05:08PM (#5167503)
I think, in this case, being confrontational is the right thing to do (though I don't think you should have to engage in a confrontation if you don't want to).

Most people (despite the arguments here, which are mostly about either semantics or arcane ethical points) think that the way the guy you described behaved is unacceptable. You're one of us, a hacker, and you don't deserve to be treated like that. I can't imagine you'd get anything other than a positive association from standing up for the rights of hackers to get on and live their lives free of that kind of harassment and bullying.

I don't really understand why people don't mention this more often: the kind of bullying that women in tech receive now is pretty much the kind of bullying that male geeks got from non-geeks twenty years ago. It's not really anti-women so much as it's anti-people-being-geeks; society at large may have (grudgingly!) accepted male geeks, but female geeks are still getting abuse for being more interested in computers or science or whatever than in what society thinks they 'should' be doing. As such, this affects all of us and we all need to be pretty damn clear that we won't stand for it.

Re:Speaking up by saraid216 on Monday February 04, 2013 @08:08PM (#5168389)
> I think, in this case, being confrontational is the right thing to do (though I don't think you should have to engage in a confrontation if you don't want to).

I can't agree with that. The situation she describes is where she's acting as a representative of her company, and anything she does is as the face of the company, rather than as a person.

The decision to be confrontational about it is her company's decision, not hers.

Re:Speaking up by mwetzler on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @02:18AM (#5169596)
I am absolutely empowered, as an individual or on behalf of my company, to tell this guy he is an ass. Or to ask the conference organizers to boot him. But I didn't feel like doing either. I didn't even cross my mind at the time.

It's kind of like when a crazy person yells at you on the street. Yeah, you could tell them to stop, because it makes you uncomfortable, but that would require even more interaction, and they'd probably do something to make you even more uncomfortable. Easier to walk away.

At least by sharing it here some people can learn from the example of what not to do :)

Re:Speaking up by Firehed on Monday February 04, 2013 @03:52PM (#5167036)
Being confrontational also brings the issue to light and may take us one step closer to solving the problem. Simply ignoring the matter (as uncomfortable as it would be to deal with both as a victim and as someone who doesn't want to put their company in a bad light; I can only imagine) quietly indicates that we're ok with this kind of behavior.

I suppose this is one of those "there's a time and place" issues. I wouldn't likely call out such an asshole while I'm on stage (unless this person tried to humiliate me while I was presenting, in which case I'd simply state that's not an appropriate comment for the conference and move on to the next person), but I'd certainly escalate[1] the issue privately.

We need to look into some sort of zero-tolerance[2] policies for this kind of thing until the message that this isn't okay is clearly understood. Certainly if I'm hosting or attending a conference and witness this kind of behavior, I'll be going out of my way to get this person removed from the conference and will also bring it up with their employer.

[1] In the "I'd like to speak with a manager" sense, not throwing a loud tantrum. [2] Not that I generally support zero-tolerance policies, or find them effective. But I think the concept is directionally correct; any attendee making another attendee (including speakers) feel uncomfortable or unsafe should be removed form the event. Maybe they get one strict warning; it depends how obviously offensive they were being.

Re:Speaking up by dhimes on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @09:01AM (#5170645)
You are wise. You may have more of an impact with a discreet riposte to the person at the time the incident happens. Not to embarrass him (the first time), but a simple "this sucks and here's why" kind of non-emotional response. It's the kind of thing you have to be prepared to deliver- maybe even rehearsed (we all have those situations in our lives that take us by such surprise that we're stunned for a while).

It's entirely possible that the guy thought he was being funny, has no idea he wasn't and genuinely finds women painful because he's so ignorant. By adopting the role of teacher, you may win a valuable ally.

But there is a more subtle effect here (if you're still reading and haven't thrown something at the monitor yet). This response from you, if you do it the way I have in mind (even if I'm not articulating it properly), will be entirely patronizing, in fact it will be patronizing in exactly the way men like this patronize you (and I know you know what I'm talking about-- see below). It is delivered from a position of strength, not weakness, in the sense that you are giving sage advice: is he smart enough to see it? Some will be, some won't.

Beyond this, remember to trust your gut. Sometimes the guy is just an asshole (a big clue is if other guys think he's an asshole) and words like I've written above are totally off-the-mark for the situation.

My wife is in a male-dominated (at her level) role, and I hear these stories all the time. Sometimes my advice is helpful- often she tells me to just STFU and listen. YMMV.

Re:Speaking up by mwetzler on Wednesday February 06, 2013 @03:01PM (#5178457)
I think you are right. This guy needs some advice. My best guess is that he thought he was flirting with me. It's called negging.

http://www.seductionscience.com/2010/negging-women/

Just threw up in my mouth a little.

Re:Speaking up by dhimes on Wednesday February 06, 2013 @04:49PM (#5179055)
Ha! Some of that page is pretty stupid, but in general it sounds like it's kind of put-down teasing (done with both sexes, actually). Only works as flirting if there's NO WAY it could actually be true, and both people know it. Almost always has to be someone who knows you well enough to tease in a way that they recognize.

Yeah, maybe someday he'll meet someone who cares enough to set him straight.

Re:Speaking up by kstrauser on Monday February 04, 2013 @04:24PM (#5167240)
I just don't get this. Do these guys not have moms? Sisters? Wives or girlfriends? Daughters? Women friends? I would be incredibly pissed if anyone said those things to my family members; ergo, I can't imagine saying them to someone else.

For me, it really is as simple as that. I want my daughters to feel as welcome in their careers as I hope my sons will be. Anything less than that is utterly unacceptable.

I'm sorry this happened to you and I hope you believe me that not all guys think this way.

Re:Speaking up by enraged_camel on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @01:48AM (#5169524)
They have moms for sure, and sisters maybe. But that's irrelevant. They are behaving this way because that's how they see their dads treating their moms and sisters growing up. If they see their dad treat the mom with a sexist attitude (such as by expecting her to do the house chores or slapping her ass in front of the kids) then that's how they treat women later in life.
Re:Speaking up by tlrobinson on Monday February 04, 2013 @11:20PM (#5169033)
They most likely have a mom, possibly sisters, the rest are unlikely.
Re:Speaking up by rdl on Monday February 04, 2013 @02:34PM (#5166484)
I obviously never get comments like this (being a man in a male-dominated field), but I hear about some women in the industry getting it more often than others. I'm sure there's reporting bias, but at least some of the women I've talked to seem to think it's not a common problem for them at least (but happens to others).

I wonder if there are specific things which make it more likely for some women to be harassed like this. And, is relatively mild stupidity like this correlated in any way with more serious issues (either assault or serious job discrimination)?

Re:Speaking up by mwetzler on Monday February 04, 2013 @02:51PM (#5166618)
I think two things make it more likely for me to encounter incidents of sexism:

1) I do some programming for my job, but a majority of it involves going out and meeting other developers, learning about their work, and seeing how we can make our API better for them. I live in SF so I can't get a coffee without bumping into another developer. I bet I have many more interactions than someone who is developing full time in their home or office. More interactions increases chances for good and bad types of interactions.

2) Since I have been researching sexism in the industry, I have started to notice small slights and snubs more. I went for years brushing off countless minor incidents. I still don't get offended easily, but I do notice things more. For example, checkout the gun.io landing page right now (Beards of Experience). I like gun.io, but their homepage is definitely not female-friendly, and I noticed it immediately.

I'd wager that people who have had some kind of experience that really bothered them, or ones who have recently started learning more about gender bias, will suddenly start to notice all the little "micro agressions" more. Even my male colleagues have started noticing them more since we have been discussing it recently.

One of them even said "it's like when you get a new car, you suddenly start to notice how many people drive the same car as you do".

Re:Speaking up by rdl on Monday February 04, 2013 @03:00PM (#5166679)
Also I guess people are more likely to either be "careful" or to adapt their behavior successfully if there's one woman on a 5 person team and one or more of the guys are in some way sexist or inappropriate, than if it's a casual interaction with someone at a coffeeshop or conference.

I don't know how I feel about the "Beards of Experience" thing. I guess I'd be annoyed if it were a permanent branding of the site, but as a one-off short campaign, I'm I think I'm fine with it. It does only focus on a specific group (I assume it is "unix neckbeards vs. hipster/corporate/suave designer developers", ignoring women entirely), but for a short marketing message, it's probably better to strongly appeal to a subset vs. be "meh" for everyone. It's not on its face offensive, which would be bad even if 5-10% of people were seriously offended and 50% were approving, just narrowly scoped. But it's obviously bad if that kind of exclusion is the default across the whole industry all the time.

Re:Speaking up by gfodor on Monday February 04, 2013 @05:19PM (#5167571)
It's stupid crap like "Beards of Experience" though that fall out of the ephemeral "boys club" in our industry which in turn re-enforce it. This ultimately allows morons like that mentioned by the OP to have the balls to stay something overtly sexist. It's all part of the same problem. It's a giant embarrassment and it wasn't always like this. And it's not a "technology" thing or a "software" thing, it's a "startuppy web/mobile application development" thing so it has nothing to do with the actual discipline but more to do with a rotten aspect of the culture that's grown out of control.

The solution, in my view, has less to do with going out of our way to bring women into the fold and more to do with not putting stupid shit like "Beards of Experience" on your homepage.

Re:Speaking up by halostatue on Monday February 04, 2013 @04:04PM (#5167119)
Concur about "Beards of Experience"; maybe if there were a tastefully done "Braids of Experience" that corresponds to it on a timed slider it may not be as lopsided as just having "Beards of Experience".

It's not offensive, but it is mildly sexist (implying that only those who have beards can be that experienced, and as women cannot generally grow beards…)

Re:Speaking up by nollidge on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @09:51AM (#5170861)
I think you're making the mistake of critiquing the beards thing in isolation. The point is that it's a drop in a bucket. You can look at any individual marketing campaign and come up with perfectly valid reasons it's not really sexist, but in aggregate it's problematic.

The key word in mwetzler's comment is "microaggressions". It's the small things which are probably defensible in isolation but when viewed together exhibit some pretty obvious patterns.

Re:Speaking up by mwetzler on Wednesday February 06, 2013 @03:12PM (#5178516)
Exactly. That's why people are seen as being too sensitive when they complain about any one specific thing.
Re:Speaking up by geoka9 on Monday February 04, 2013 @07:29PM (#5168243)
Come on, guys (and gals).

If we accepted that "Beards of Experience" is sexist, we would have to accept that it's also racist (many Asian men can't grow beards like the guy on gun.io) and maybe homophobic. Don't you think it would get ridiculous at that point?

What about parenting sites where the design and images are clearly targeted at mothers (and not fathers)? Are they evil? Sexist?

Re:Speaking up by saraid216 on Monday February 04, 2013 @08:14PM (#5168405)
I don't see anything that makes me think it's homophobic? Are you implying that gay men tend to be beardless?

And yes. Parenting sites that assume that fathers can't be parents are sexist. Parenting sites that assume that fathers won't be primary caretakers because their target demographic's culture is sexist and doesn't understand that male parents are important are fence-sitting and sexist by omission.

Re:Speaking up by geoka9 on Monday February 04, 2013 @08:54PM (#5168563)
I don't see anything that makes me think it's homophobic?

Me neither. But then again, I don't see anything that makes me think it's sexist. Or racist, for that matter.

And yes. Parenting sites that assume that fathers can't be parents are sexist.

Well, that's the problem I'm trying to highlight. They probably assume no such thing. But we must brand them as sexist by the same token that we are not supposed to tolerate a guy with a beard on an IT recruitment site.

Here's another example: when Nike uses a photograph of a tall black guy to advertise their basketball shoes - are they being racist, sexist and disrespectful to short people?

Re:Speaking up by saraid216 on Monday February 04, 2013 @10:48PM (#5168906)
> Well, that's the problem I'm trying to highlight. They probably assume no such thing.

That's true. It's a good thing someone points it out, then.

> Here's another example: when Nike uses a photograph of a tall black guy to advertise their basketball shoes - are they being racist, sexist and disrespectful to short people?

Yes.

Re:Speaking up by rdl on Monday February 04, 2013 @10:46PM (#5168896)
There's nothing evil or even sexist, IMO, about reinforcing stereotypes. However, given that there is a shortage of tech workers, and there are fewer women in tech than would be predicted based on accomplishment in other fields (bio/chem/pharma/med, specifically), I think it's reasonable to make an effort to be inclusive and try to reach out to women when recruiting or conducting other professional activities.

It's even more wrong to criticize someone aggressively for sexism in this case, but overall I think there would be net gains to everyone by attracting and retaining more women in technology. So, while it's not evil or sexist, "beards in technology" is counter to one's own interests even as a male in technology.

Re:Speaking up by mwetzler on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @02:33AM (#5169625)
It's not evil. It's not mean-spirited. It is a tad sexist, but not in a super offensive way. Probably the worst thing about it is that it's turning away some women and some feminist men. I doubt Gun.io intended that.

I think it's a good example of an easy thing to change for the tech community to be more inviting to women. If we want to break down stereotypes and gender ratios in tech, one thing we can do is make it more inviting for women to work here.

Re:Speaking up by rachelbythebay on Monday February 04, 2013 @01:43PM (#5166084)
I wonder what would happen if someone found out who this "elite developer" was.
Re:Speaking up by tedks on Monday February 04, 2013 @02:22PM (#5166388)
Probably nothing. There would maybe be a few blog posts about it. Their comments would be filled with men defending his actions and suggesting that anyone calling him out was lying, that the real problem is "women that get offended too easily" or "women that don't get jokes," and straight-up male superiority.
Re:Speaking up by Geekette on Monday February 04, 2013 @04:29PM (#5167267)
Pretty much. I for one have had it up to here though. The next incidence I encounter will be called out at the very least to the person's face on the spot, if not also online.
Re:Speaking up by DanBC on Monday February 04, 2013 @05:37PM (#5167676)
I don't know how it works in the US, but it's her face and her name, so can't she just get a lawyer to get a court to order the website to hand over some details? And then get another court to get the ISP to hand over some more details? And then give those to the police?
Re:Speaking up by whiterabbit2 on Monday February 04, 2013 @02:19PM (#5166363)
Oh, I would say "none of his f*cking business". As a woman, you don't need to even be a developer to get this kind of "attention" on a regular basis.
Re:Speaking up by chaostheory on Monday February 04, 2013 @10:32PM (#5168862)
Where did this happen? I'm reading this and I'm a little shocked. I don't understand why people can be such jerks.
Re:Speaking up by mwetzler on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @02:38AM (#5169640)
Here is SF. I think the guy thought he was flirting with me. It was not effective :)
Re:Speaking up by chaostheory on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @10:04AM (#5170935)
When I think about it, people in SF should know better; but based on personal experience bad offensive remarks happen a lot more often than most people would think for such a progressive city. It's one reason I hate the thought of working in the city again.

The last part better explains it. It doesn't change the fact that it was sexism, but I categorize this one as stupidity and awkwardness instead of malice.

Re:Speaking up by enraged_camel on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @01:36AM (#5169504)
>>Afterwards, a well-known, elite developer asked me if I programmed. When I said yes, he said that made me 50% less attractive. Then he asked me if I cooked and cleaned. To my face.

You should have smiled and told him no, because you programmed a robot to do all that stuff for you. Then punched him in the face.

Re:Speaking up by lizzard on Monday February 04, 2013 @07:55PM (#5168353)
Wish I could even be surprised at this.

Join us on #geekfeminism sometime on freenode (if you're not already there) :)

Re:Speaking up by pja on Monday February 04, 2013 @06:24AM (#5163546)
And this is why you need moderated communities, because otherwise the assholes will dominate the discourse in your chosen milieu and drive out anyone they deem unacceptable.

Very often it's women. I don't know why but either there's a class of developers who feel personally threatened by women in their chosen profession, or it's personal: some individual has believed themselves to be entitled to that woman's attention & when it was not forthcoming begin a cruel campaign of punishment to make up for the perceived insult. Maybe even both?

It's been said that sunlight is the best disinfectant: I know that I'd be completely unaware of this behaviour if some of the women involved weren't brave enough to speak out about it. I don't have any good solutions though: the best I can do is to refuse to tolerate any sexism in my own circles, on the grounds that the people who do this kind of thing take other people's silence (not wanting to be "that guy") as implicit affirmation of their actions.

Re:Speaking up by thaumaturgy on Monday February 04, 2013 @06:44AM (#5163603)
Regarding your second paragraph, I think it's primarily a clash of two situations: software development by its nature attracts men who are socially awkward, and the women that are attracted to software development tend not to be there for the attention.

Software development has a broader appeal now than it did twenty years ago, and in spite of the numerous cases like this one, there seems to still be a growing population of women in the community. (I hope that continues, we need all the talent available.) So, hopefully this will sort itself out in time.

In the meantime, I'm more intrigued by the idea of gated communities than I am of moderated communities. Moderation seems to require a lot of resources and lead to conflict. Gated (online) communities don't seem to have been tried as much, and I'm curious about whether or not a lot of social problems would simply solve themselves if not everyone were invited to participate.

Re:Speaking up by NoahSussman on Monday February 04, 2013 @10:00AM (#5164370)
> there seems to still be a growing population of women in the community.

Just keep in mind that, whatever growth you've observed, the number of women in programming now is much lower than it was in the 1980s.

For some historical statistics see http://articles.washingtonpost.com/2011-08-26/opinions/35268...

Re:Speaking up by roguecoder on Monday February 04, 2013 @10:36AM (#5164595)
The percentage of women is lower, but the total number is higher.
Re:Speaking up by sophacles on Monday February 04, 2013 @01:03PM (#5165799)
So what? Percentage is the statistic that matters in discussions like this. Unless you are suggesting that there is some upper limit on the number of women that can ever be involved in programming at one time.

How does notion work to you - is there some sort of cosmic female hive-mind that determines the quotas of them that can be part of any given activity? Is it some sort of feedback loop so that we as a species are approaching the limit of $MAX_FEMALE_DEVS?

Re:Speaking up by pjscott on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @12:50AM (#5169380)
I think you've mistaken a factual nitpick for a bigger argument.
Re:Speaking up by revelation on Monday February 04, 2013 @12:14PM (#5165383)
Society was very different in 1980. Maybe we should be very careful to reach these conclusions.
Re:Speaking up by overgryphon on Monday February 04, 2013 @01:46PM (#5166102)
The software development community attracts socially awkward people by accepting them- and consequently accepting behaviors that are not seen as acceptable in most parts of society.

For example, most of the software development community would see a 22yo guy persistently pursuing a girl who clearly isn't interested as innocent, awkward, and empathize with the guy's rejection (or lack there of, since he probably doesn't have the courage to directly ask her out). They wouldn't consider how it feels to the girl have someone watching you, following you, looking up private information online, and invading her space.

Re:Speaking up by thaumaturgy on Monday February 04, 2013 @04:49PM (#5167386)
I don't think "we" as a community can or should outright reject people who behave badly. We can only reject (or try to change) their behavior. Let's not forget that 8+ hours a day in front of a little glowing box nearly requires a specific personality type. If people who are bad at dealing with other people are blocked from software development, the field would suffer (a lot).

> ...a 22yo guy persistently pursuing a girl who clearly isn't interested...

To be fair, you came >this< close to describing the plot of the average romcom here. The only difference between "sweet" and "creepy" is in judging whether or not the person is interested, or might become interested. A lot of nerds (I use the term with love here) aren't even good at mingling at social events, let alone reading whether or not their advances towards someone are going to turn out well. (This isn't limited to man-woman relationships either, as a recent case shows.)

...I wonder if maybe a huge root cause of this problem is simply that there are few enough women in our field that any attention from men feels like it's too much? I have to imagine that if you got regular, "Hey, are you busy Saturday night?" inquiries from different guys, you'd start to feel a little like chum in shark-infested waters.

Re:Speaking up by overgryphon on Monday February 04, 2013 @05:42PM (#5167707)
The excuse that this person's stalking behavior would be sweet if she were interested is blaming her discomfort/fear on her because she isn't interested, when in reality no "sweet" guy would act in such a way without clear signs of interest.

The online hacker/development community's continuous excuses and empathy for members of their own community who behave inappropriately towards women makes this a field where prominent women are expected to be harassed on a regular basis.

It isn't even a matter of rejecting the person for bad behavior. You didn't even reject the behavior, you justified it.

Re:Speaking up by thaumaturgy on Monday February 04, 2013 @06:38PM (#5168018)
> ...is blaming her discomfort/fear on her because she isn't interested...

No, it's not. You misread my comment.

> You didn't even reject the behavior, you justified it.

HN is large enough now that I can't expect you to know that I've never done any such thing, and in fact have said exactly the opposite pretty frequently.

Re:Speaking up by itsybitsycoder on Monday February 04, 2013 @05:25PM (#5167594)
Romcoms are fiction. There are loads of "romantic" movies where, if acted out IRL, the hero would be rightly arrested on felony charges. They're not meant to be taken as instructional.
Re:Speaking up by thaumaturgy on Monday February 04, 2013 @05:38PM (#5167684)
Yeah, I know that. And yet, people love them anyway. Again: "sweet" vs. "creepy" is all down to reading the situation.
Re:Speaking up by itsybitsycoder on Monday February 04, 2013 @08:20PM (#5168423)
If you're suggesting that nerds are incapable of "reading" the difference between fantasy and reality, I'm not really sure what to say. Certainly most nerds I know are capable of doing so. That's such a basic thing that I don't even think that falls into the category of social skills anymore. If nerds think that seeing something in fiction is a good reason to try it IRL then the anti-videogame-violence crowd has a lot more going for it than I thought.
Re:Speaking up by thaumaturgy on Monday February 04, 2013 @09:36PM (#5168688)
I think at this point there's a fairly well-accepted connection between autism spectrum disorders and the software development community. (If you really need citations for this, I'll provide some.) One of the common side-effects of autism spectrum disorders is an impairment in interpreting other people's facial expressions, body language, and vocal tones.

When I mentioned the romcom stuff, it wasn't because I was arguing that it was a how-to or that nerds couldn't distinguish fiction from reality. It was only there to illustrate that the line between "creepy" behavior and behavior that in the ideal sense might be considered "sweet" is really blurry, and that it's dependent largely on receptivity of the people involved, and that as a trend, people in software development have a more difficult time correctly interpreting these situations.

I could go a lot more in-depth on this. I think there's a lot of very interesting cultural stuff happening in the U.S. (and to a larger extent, Japan) in male-female relations, I think there's a lot of uncertainty now about what constitutes "attractive" behavior and what doesn't, and I think that the ability to correctly interpret body language and other subtle cues is the only substantial edge anyone has over other people in this environment.

However, none of that should be read as a defense of behavior like posting fake nudge images of someone or outright harassment or any of the other things that women have recently been rightly complaining about. I was only wondering aloud earlier whether the combination of the ratio of men to women in software, combined with social impairment by a significant number of people in the industry, might be contributing to the problem.

I'm not really sure what else to say to defend my earlier comment; I honestly wasn't expecting it to be controversial. At this point though, if you'd like to continue to disagree, and you expect me to respond, I'd like for you to at least argue against what I actually write (e.g., I did not say, "nerds are incapable of 'reading' the difference between fantasy and reality"), and I'd love it if you bundled some kind of insight or evidence with your argument.

Re:Speaking up by Firehed on Monday February 04, 2013 @03:56PM (#5167061)
I imagine most developers can tell the difference between 'pursuing' and 'stalking'.
Re:Speaking up by pja on Monday February 04, 2013 @07:02AM (#5163654)
I doubt women are generally in professional jobs "for the attention" & I don't think this kind of behaviour is limited to men who are socially awkward unfortunately.

Gated communities still need moderation: someone has to decide whether or not to kick people out if they behave badly!

Re:Speaking up by lsc on Monday February 04, 2013 @11:53PM (#5169198)
It has been brought to my attention that I missed a 'not' in your sentence, rendering my previous reply... nonsense.

[deleted]

Re:Speaking up by saraid216 on Monday February 04, 2013 @08:22PM (#5168436)
Keep in mind that sexism exists outside the tech industry as well: correlation doesn't imply causation.

We certainly need to address the problems of sexism within our community, but I think it's a mistake to assume that it's part of the community's particular quirks that produce said sexism. Especially when there are some far more obvious indicators of where the sexism comes from: the larger cultural discourse and ambience, for instance.

Re:Speaking up by mootothemax on Monday February 04, 2013 @06:40AM (#5163595)
Are we (developers) the douchey 80s guy of the 21st century?

To paraphrase Neal Stephenson's Snow Crash, one problem is guys believing that they're too smart to be sexist.

I also believe that a lot of people involved can't handle the idea that they're being bullies, and so further attempt to rationalise their actions with terrible analogies and arguments that boil down to "I'm a geek - I'm incapable of oppressing someone!"

Re:Speaking up by mtrimpe on Monday February 04, 2013 @07:00AM (#5163648)
I think to a large degree it's also about not understanding group dynamics. Let's say that:

35% or so of geeks are closet sexists in reform: aware that their belief systems are wrong / socially unacceptable and trying to change.

5% or so aren't sexists but misogynists: men who truly feel wronged by women and wish to retaliate.

60% are perfectly stand-up men who wouldn't do a bit of harm

Now the trick is that whenever the sexist and misogynists form a group where they have a significant majority, the closet sexists will give the misogynists a platform to damage women.

Meanwhile the other 60% sees nothing but 95% of perfectly respectful men who would do no harm against women and can't even imagine something like that happening in their company.

Re:Speaking up by vickytnz on Monday February 04, 2013 @08:45AM (#5164016)
This sort of stuff also ties into the whole 'fake geek girl'thing as well: http://www.theatlantic.com/sexes/archive/2013/01/fake-geek-g... Or, the pink ghetto: http://tarahunt.com/2011/09/14/a-pink-collar-tech-ghetto/
Re:Speaking up by hmason on Monday February 04, 2013 @10:14AM (#5164470)
This isn't a problem with guys or with developers in general.

The vast majority of people who participate in conference are good people. However, it only takes one person (out of thousands!) who has this kind of personality dysfunction to lead an attack, and women are much much more likely to be the target of their dysfunction.

Re:Speaking up by ddellacosta on Monday February 04, 2013 @09:55AM (#5164339)
I'm a man. We (male) developers don't have to be like this, and many of us aren't.

But, I've said it before and I'll say it again: men have even more of a responsibility than women to speak up and combat this kind of sexism. We (men) have the utmost responsibility to make sure that we are fighting to allow women a place in our industry, a place where they feel safe enough so that they can be equal participants without worrying about being looked down upon, harassed or concerned for their safety.

The sad reality is, more than having courageous women speaking up about sexism, men speaking up about sexism convinces other men to treat women respectfully.

Re:Speaking up by saraid216 on Monday February 04, 2013 @08:30PM (#5168467)
> But, I've said it before and I'll say it again: men have even more of a responsibility than women to speak up and combat this kind of sexism.

Some advice on how to do this, for anyone looking: http://www.anamardoll.com/2012/11/deconstruction-how-to-be-m...

Re:Speaking up by mattdeboard on Monday February 04, 2013 @06:17AM (#5163520)
Seriously. I roll my eyes at some of the white-knighting that goes when a woman is slighted on the Internet but holy crap I get nervous for my girlfriend who's a talented programmer and about to graduate with a CS degree. Is this kind of bullshit in store for her? Sheesh.
Re:Speaking up by afarrell on Monday February 04, 2013 @07:11AM (#5163689)
Are you sure you aren't confusing "white knight" for "person who doesn't appreciate seeing other people treated like shit"? I originally thought that phrase meant something like "Claiming to represent someone's position or speak for them when they can very well speak for themselves." But assuming that http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/white-knight is a credible source, that phrase actually refers to dudes who argue against misogyny because they want to get laid. I hope that isn't the sense in which you're using it because there are some gaping flaws in that concept:

- Unless you're all using your real names and on the same campus or convention floor, how does that even work, logistically?

- Treating people with basic levels of respect does not magically make them attracted to you, though it will make them more comfortable hanging around you.

- If the only (or even the most notable) reason someone can think of for trying to argue against misogyny or other flavors of assholiery is to get laid, that person needs to go home and rethink their fundamental values in life. Implying this is true of men generally is pretty misadrist.

I suspect you aren't actually using knowyourmeme's definition, so could you clarify the behavior you're referring to when you say "white-knighting"?

Re:Speaking up by brazzy on Monday February 04, 2013 @07:59AM (#5163826)
Since when have gaping flaws in a concept been a deterrent against people trying to implement it?

Your typical Internet White Knight is most likely not explicitly aiming to get laid, but simply following the classical role model they've absorbed via Hollywood: women are weak and need to be defended, good men defend them (and get the girl in the end).

It can get a bit comical but the real problem is that it takes the form of personal defense in specific cases, and is focused on women. So males getting treated like shit are unlikely to get any help or even sympathy from a White Knight, and they're unlikely to spend any effort on actual solutions to a toxic atmosphere.

Re:Speaking up by pekk on Monday February 04, 2013 @11:47AM (#5165128)
There ARE men who jump on others in a showy way for strictly imagined offenses against women. Sometimes (as in perhaps most cases of men fighting in public) the motivation IS at least partly sexual, e.g. to seem attractive, or at least part of an anachronistic image of the chivalrous savior. But the sexual part isn't defining.

This doesn't mean that it is wrong to argue against misogyny.

It just points to a real phenomenon among men, where they are trying to look like they are calling out an asshole when what is really going on is logically much more similar to acting holy in a bar fight over a woman.

If you think observing actual idiotic behavior which occurs sometimes among men is misandrist then I am happy to be a "misandrist" in your perception. I think the condition of men in our society can withstand a small amount of anthropological observation.

Re:Speaking up by knowtheory on Monday February 04, 2013 @02:23PM (#5166396)
Really? Are there? Show me some examples.

What indications do you have that defending a woman is a sexually motivated act?

Re:Speaking up by mnicole on Monday February 04, 2013 @04:26PM (#5167253)
I have only seen it happen once or twice in-person, but I've run across it multiple times online. Had one guy, known for being awkwardly friendly (as in, had a motive) with the women in the group, even try to invite himself to stay with me multiple times while he would "be in town" and even when others would say "Dude, please stop," he would retort with "Once she meets me, she can decide!" Wouldn't let up on it, even after personally shooting him down.

Found out later he was doing this same thing with other girls, too, and was kicked out of the group.

Can I get a clarification on the downvote, given that the parent asked for examples and I provided one? I've elaborated on the specific situation.

Re:Speaking up by nollidge on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @10:03AM (#5170930)
I think they were asking for examples of white-knighting, which is not what your story was about. Not that it wasn't worth sharing, it just didn't answer knowtheory's question.
Re:Speaking up by ordinary on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @05:29AM (#5170016)
I think you provided a counter-example, instead.
Re:Speaking up by jjcm on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @04:46AM (#5169921)
I think the point he's trying to make with regards to the white knighting going on, is that when a nude of Gabe Newell or Sergey Brin is made it doesn't hit the front page of HN. We respond differently when it's done to a woman.
Re:Speaking up by mattdeboard on Monday February 04, 2013 @08:03AM (#5163844)
Your original thought matches my definition.
Re:Speaking up by roguecoder on Monday February 04, 2013 @10:50AM (#5164687)
I think the difference between white-knighting and not is whether it's about the woman or the person who's behaving badly.

"You shouldn't hit a girl!" <-- white knighting "You are being violent; if you do not stop we will ban you from this space." <-- insisting on basic, reasonable standards of behavior.

It's not about women needing special protection, it is about the community not welcoming people who act like assholes. Of course women can defend themselves, but no one should have to defend themselves against that kind of behavior. And the only reason I believe it is important to talk about gender in this context is because women are being targeted because of their gender and using cultural weapons specific to their gender. Again, it is about the people behaving badly, not their targets.

Re:Speaking up by pekk on Monday February 04, 2013 @11:33AM (#5165004)
To clarify, it is white-knighting when the woman doesn't care, when there was no actual offense, and it is really just an opportunity for someone to show off about how chivalrous or sensitive they are.

You don't have to be sensitive or show yourself off to shut down misogynists and you definitely don't have to go looking for unclear offenses which the purported victims have no complaint about.

Re:Speaking up by roguecoder on Monday February 04, 2013 @12:10PM (#5165345)
If the behavior makes me uncomfortable, it doesn't matter what the target thinks of it: I have a right to speak up. Even if the target is bothered by it I don't have a right to speak for her, though I can support her if she does speak up. All I can ever say is, "that behavior bothers me; I don't believe it is acceptable. Please stop." It doesn't matter if the offense is unclear to someone else, because it is about my boundaries, not theirs. You can disagree with my perception, but that doesn't make the behavior any more acceptable to me nor does it change how I feel about it.
Re:Speaking up by raganwald on Monday February 04, 2013 @02:27PM (#5166421)
This, a thousand times this. Misogyny, homophobia, racism, even slurs against programmers on the basis of their tool chocies: These are all offensive to me, and I wish to change that for my own reasons.

If a man hits his wife, I call the police. If she says, "No, it's ok, I provoked him, I deserve it," do I shrug and say, "Well that's all right then?"

Attempting to intimidate me out of speaking up by labelling me a "white knight" and questioning whether my motivation is to seduce women is pretty low and vile, but what I expect from the kind of apologist scum that perpetuate these kinds of social bullying behaviours.

"Reg, shut up, you're just trying to sleep with dykes" is not going to work in this or any century.

Re:Speaking up by pekk on Monday February 04, 2013 @10:15PM (#5168809)
Whoa, hold up. Is it really necessary to label me as "apologist scum"? This seems in itself a bit of bullying.

To be very clear: I haven't labeled you a "white knight," accused you of "trying to sleep with dykes" (!?), said that you shouldn't report men hitting their wife, approved of racial slurs or anything like that.

I have simply made an observation about an certain, occasional obnoxious behavior by certain males... I have never said that arguing against misogyny, or speaking out against bullying (etc.) are wrong. I certainly don't think those things. I certainly don't "apologize" for people behaving in a discriminatory way. I simply say that sometimes people aren't doing what they say they're doing. I refuse to give men carte blanche provided only that they claim or pretend to be defending someone weaker than themselves, but this doesn't in any way imply that I reject people trying to defend those weaker than themselves. Why does this seem to be so controversial?

Re:Speaking up by raganwald on Monday February 04, 2013 @02:16PM (#5166324)
I roll my eyes at some of the white-knighting that goes when a woman is slighted on the Internet

I don't give a rat's ass what the definition of "white knighting is. I'm calling you out now to be much more specific about what kind of slighting is involved and what you're rolling your eyes at. Give examples. Justify yourself.

Re:Speaking up by mattdeboard on Monday February 04, 2013 @07:11PM (#5168169)
The tone/aggressiveness of your response makes it read like you're projecting a bunch of subtext you're bringing into the conversation onto me. I respect you but/so/and I'm not going to play that game.
Re:Speaking up by Aaronontheweb on Monday February 04, 2013 @08:01AM (#5163831)
If you think the developer community is bad, try advertising / media / sales.
Re:Speaking up by malachismith on Monday February 04, 2013 @12:38PM (#5165620)
Having worked in both, I actually do not think the developer community is better (or less awful) than the advertising / media / sales community. The former is simply more nuanced and subtle. The sexism in the Ad / Media / Sales world is simply more obvious, unhidden and honest. Both are horrible and grotesque - but to be frank, I think that while there is less respect for women in the Ad / Media / Sales world, there is more women-hating in the Developer community.
Re:Speaking up by Aaronontheweb on Monday February 04, 2013 @06:35PM (#5168010)
If we're going to trade ancedotes: I worked at Microsoft, with lots of female co-workers in technical and non-technical roles.

I never once hear a DE, SDE, SDET, or any other technical person say anything remotely along the lines of "women suck at programming because they're women." Not once, amongst the hundreds of people I worked with there. That's an anecdote - take it for what it's worth.

Re:Speaking up by pjscott on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @01:00AM (#5169403)
That's what you would expect to observe if either (a) there were negligible sexism, or (b) the sexism was present, but "more nuanced and subtle" in its form. Therefore your observation does not count as strong evidence for distinguishing between these hypotheses. It counts as stronger evidence against widespread overt sexism.
Re:Speaking up by mnicole on Monday February 04, 2013 @03:48PM (#5167009)
Ditto for me as well. At least in advertising there are other female project managers, assistants and designers you can go to. I've only worked one other job in dev where I've had another female co-worker, and even still that doesn't mean we're close and can confide in each other if we're concerned about something.
Re:Speaking up by tudorw on Monday February 04, 2013 @06:06AM (#5163491)
I agree, all the stuff I read it's like going back a century, we are supposed to be on the vanguard of a brave new world, not re-hashing the same dumb ass attitude that has contaminated the past decades. Grow up, get on and be nice.
Re:Speaking up by nollidge on Monday February 04, 2013 @11:30AM (#5164970)
See, but the fact that you're reading about it at all, that people are arguing about it at all, means we're doing better. The fact that outrage about sexism even exists is progress. It's the (slight) progress of shining a harsh light on the previously unnoticed realities that were always there.
Re:Speaking up by lizzard on Monday February 04, 2013 @08:02PM (#5168370)
Maybe, but I'm in my 40s and have been reading and arguing about it as well as experiencing it for my whole life.
Re:Speaking up by hopeless_case on Monday February 04, 2013 @04:27PM (#5167261)
> What a nasty bunch of people we are.

Why is wondering aloud how sexist/creepy the bulk of male programmers are more acceptable than wondering aloud how untalented the bulk of female programmers are?

I think both behaviors are rather low shaming behaviors.

Re:Speaking up by andrewcooke on Monday February 04, 2013 @07:52PM (#5168338)
because discrimination is about power. if two groups have equal amounts of power it really doesn't matter that much (except for social courtesy sake) what they say about each other. discrimination is a problem when it's associated with inequality. it's a big deal when a majority bash a minority. the other way round, not so much. even less so when the criticism is internal to the majority.
Re:Speaking up by hopeless_case on Monday February 04, 2013 @08:30PM (#5168468)
I think you are conflating these two statements (the apex fallacy):

1. Most of the those who have power are men.

2. Most of those who are men have power.

They are very different statements and one does not imply the other.

The average man has no more power than the average woman.

Re:Speaking up by h2s on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @02:38AM (#5169639)

    > The average man has no more power than the average woman.
Can the average woman apply for any given technical position with an equal chance of being interviewed by a person of her gender? When the average woman's colleagues organise a social event outside of work, does she feel as powerful as the average man when she's the only female in a room full of inebriated men? When the average woman's colleague accidentally says something sexist and nobody else notices because she has no female colleagues, is she as powerful as the average man?
Re:Speaking up by hopeless_case on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @07:46AM (#5170347)
Can the average man expect to marry a woman with a higher educational attainment than him, who will bear more of the load of providing for the family so he can spend more time with the children? Does a man have an equal chance of getting a college degree (college enrollment and graduation now favors women by 60 to 40 percent)? When a man's wife beats him up and the police not only refuse to take him seriously, but arrest him instead (the primary aggressor doctrine) how does that make him more powerful than the average woman?
Re:Speaking up by andrewcooke on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @06:17AM (#5170112)
first, the apex fallacy is about, say, most ceos (most people at the top) being men - it's about assuming things given the extremes. but in the case of the tech industry, most programmers (most people at all levels) are male. we simply dominate - we are a clear majority. so it's not about bias from extremes. we dominate even in the middle.

second, arguments based on the apex fallacy assumes that power can be treated in some "average" way, so even if the top has power, if the bottom doesn't it somehow "averages out". and that's pretty clearly not a good model for how society works (which is why these kinds of arguments are popular only in fringe anti-feminist groups).

Re:Speaking up by hopeless_case on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @07:58AM (#5170389)
> but in the case of the tech industry, most programmers (most people at all levels) are male. we simply dominate - we are a clear majority. so it's not about bias from extremes. we dominate even in the middle.

I don't get how dominating the tech sector translates into a general dominance of the society, whereby a woman's sexist remark against a man can be thought less damaging than a man's sexist remark against a woman.

>which is why these kinds of arguments are popular only in fringe anti-feminist groups)

I think feminists have a long and proud tradition of employing the apex fallacy, whereby they argue that men have all the power worth talking about because of their representation at the top (CEOs, high government posts, ...) and ignore their over-representation at the bottom (prison, homeless, suicides (3x), high school and college drop outs, lower educational attainment (college enrollement and graduation is skewed 60/40 in favor of women now)).

Which anti-feminist apex fallacy arguments have you run into?

Re:Speaking up by kapowaz on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @04:45AM (#5169918)
Sexism is alive and well in the 21st Century.

Look at how women are treated in the Middle East. Listen to stories of the rape culture in Delhi. Pay inequality the world over. A media industry which sees young women as commodities to sell their product. What we're seeing here is the thin end of the wedge; the individual who committed this disgusting act would probably have felt entitled to behave this way even were they working in another industry.

It's ugly, but this is a very large societal problem that we're still really struggling to address. As pleased as I was to see President Obama address gay rights in his inauguration, it was equally significant that he addressed gender equality. We've a long way to go before this is fixed, but rather than indulging in self-pity or recrimination, how about we work to be the change we want to see in the world?

Re:Speaking up by Tichy on Monday February 04, 2013 @06:30PM (#5167987)
I don't like being compared to some random person (of unknown gender) who attacked a woman in an online forum just because I am a developer, thank you very much!
[deleted]
Re:Speaking up by CodeMage on Monday February 04, 2013 @08:48AM (#5164024)
Your comment is the most surprising thing I've read the whole week. The surprise is due to the fact that you led with a statement I wholeheartedly agreed with (no, it's not okay to generalize that we're all sexist) and that set up an expectation that I would agree with the rest. Instead, you came up with a bunch of archetypal examples of why sexism is still very much a problem.

But it seems if girls are bad at anything in the computer industry, they aren't actually bad at it, it's just because they are girls and developers are sexist and will not accept them.

I don't usually like to be rude, but this particular quote deserves pointing out that you've pulled that stuff out of your ass. Go look on previous HN discussions about sexist treatment and you'll see that most of the time the women's complaints are backed by specific examples of undeniably sexist behavior, such as one of the examples from Sarah's post: "no offence, I just don’t relate to girls speaking about the industry at all, I learn better from guys."

I'm in the domain for some years and never ever saw that happening.

"Works on my machine" logic. If you haven't seen it, then it must be an exaggeration, perpetrated by all those silly lying women who can't measure up to men and conspire to be treated as equals without merit.

You think I'm laying it on too thick? Read the next quote:

Girls should just stop complaining about it for their own good.

Why, because they're crying wolf? Nobody's going to believe them if they keep doing that, right?

I'm being serious here: either you're claiming that they're lying or you're claiming they aren't but they should shut up anyway. From what I've seen in your comment, it seems to be the former, but your mistake is that you're basing it on your anecdotal experience.

Doesn't it strike you at least a little bit arrogant to claim that a whole bunch of people are lying just because you haven't personally seen any evidence of something like that happening in your own environment? I'm not talking about expressing skepticism here, you're actually implying that they're lying. Think about it.

Re:Speaking up by mtrimpe on Monday February 04, 2013 @08:29AM (#5163953)
Just because you've never seen it doesn't mean it never happens. Sexism at work requires certain group dynamics to flourish and I'm pretty sure your female boss can identify those and make sure they never come to pass.

Also... why do you refer to men as men and woman as girls?

Re:Speaking up by bonaldi on Monday February 04, 2013 @08:36AM (#5163982)
"NO, WE ARE NOT" followed by a screed that goes to prove you are _exactly_ that. Couldn't have been more beautifully demonstrated.