News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by tegling on Friday November 20, 2026 @03:56AM (#50571986)
Why must there be a dichotomy: "use AI/don't think for yourself", vs "don't use AI/think for yourself"?

I think we'll need to grow in our individual relationship with AI. Can't AI be that persuasive and contrarian, at times adversarial, friend? Someone you have to be somewhat wary of, but can provide very thoughtful, intelligent and challenging conversation? Such a "friend" obviously never replaces knowledge. If anything, you'll need to arm yourself with as much knowledge as possible to engage with that friend.

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by noir_lord on Friday November 20, 2026 @04:00AM (#50572017)
It’s a matrix of numbers not a friend.

Strangely I’m not friends with my toaster either.

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by tegling on Friday November 20, 2026 @04:06AM (#50572052)
Completely agree it's not human and anthropomorphizing might not be constructing. But I think we need to figure out _some_ kind of analogy that doesn't have us leave or brains in the drawer when interacting with it. Given ample sci-fi lore about all-powerful "Godlike" AI machines, playing the "machine" analogy might be equally problematic. If people think "well, obviously it's not a toaster, it's skynet", or some such.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by jurgenburgen on Friday November 20, 2026 @04:19AM (#50572177)
It’s an algorithm, a shiny hammer.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by tegling on Friday November 20, 2026 @04:33AM (#50572281)
It's a motor-powered quadro-head hammer with unlimited nails (as long as you pour x% of world gdp into the hammer industry). It builds tree houses, actual houses, societies and food. Mostly by itself. It can also shoot you in the face. And make everyone fight over it. If used in production, great things can happen. Or some city gets destroyed. But, darn, isn't it SHINY!
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by hardbass on Friday November 20, 2026 @04:50AM (#50572412)
So are humans. Everything is an algorithm oer current physics knowledge. We can yave discussions on ai consciousness on various points but absurd statements like assuming humans or anything else are anything beyond molecules and algortihms is an absurdity of such a level I am not sure how someone can come up with it.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by ThunderSizzle on Friday November 20, 2026 @06:35AM (#50573268)
Humans have souls. There's a spiritual element we're not fully able to measure and see right now.

Perhaps we might in the future. The synapsis energy being visualized is probably the closest we are at right now, but there is a lot we don't know.

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by hardbass on Friday November 20, 2026 @06:41AM (#50573327)
All well and good, but why is this belief in souls given any seriousness outside of fiction until that day?
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by DonHopkins on Friday November 20, 2026 @12:29PM (#50578542)
>Humans have souls.

[citation required]

If you could prove that, it would be a much bigger earth shaking story than merely proving the Riemann Hypothesis. I encourage you to publish your evidence and proof, you will be very famous.

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by jurgenburgen on Friday November 20, 2026 @01:01PM (#50579071)
Try punching a fellow human and feel the hammer bite back. These models are toys in comparison and treating them as something conscious is an act of banality only humans would think of doing.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by hardbass on Friday November 20, 2026 @01:07PM (#50579184)
I can punch a human. I am not that human and I can't get into their shoes and see how they feel. From outside I can't know if they feel pain or are just making funny noises.

Likewise I cannot do the same for an octopus or an LLM or a dog.

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by ethnrob on Friday November 20, 2026 @04:31AM (#50572267)
Yes but that's an easy thing to say for people that already "think for themselves", this could be (already is, 4o) a dangerous precedent to set.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by delis-thumbs-7e on Friday November 20, 2026 @06:30AM (#50573233)
We do create relationships ships with tools. I used to do plenty of manual labour in the past - railway and building construction, AV installations etc. and I have a degree in sculpture - and having a trustworthy Makita or even better a Hilti -driver as your companion felt like an assuring companion in the cold cruel world. Like one tool that is a bit special and has become almost a part of your arm. “There’s many like it, but this one is mine”. And of course probably everybody here has created a some sort of a loving friendship with their computer. Personally, I have a huge crush on Neovim at the moment. I don’t understand how I ever got anything done before I started using it.

I use Kimi K3 on OpenWebUI running on my desktop, which I can access via Tailscale on all my devices. Personally I really dislike using LLM’s to generate code - luckily I don’t work as dev - a mental block I need to solve at some point, but in researching and learning it is wonderful, when you use a system prompt to force it to search for info instead of hallucinating from training memory. It is just so much quicker than researching it with web searches yourself. To me it is a really sharp good knife that helps me to do what I want to do. Not a friend in a human sense, but a companion. Cowboy has a revolver, a samurai his sword… a hacker an nvim and llm, perhaps?

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by drivebyhooting on Friday November 20, 2026 @04:38AM (#50572324)
And stranger yet, I’m not friends either any humans either. I’m not sure what happened after 15 years of working and being inundated with family responsibilities.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by tigerlily on Friday November 20, 2026 @04:45AM (#50572375)
I'm a rubber duck being chewed by a dog on the internet, and my best friend is a matrix of numbers masquerading as a toaster.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by exe34 on Friday November 20, 2026 @05:00AM (#50572492)
Carbon chauvinism at its finest. Your "friends" are just meat bags with electro chemical neural networks.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by hardbass on Friday November 20, 2026 @06:43AM (#50573357)
Its frankly already absurd enough that religious beliefs are treated diplomatically, these days a lot of non religious people are also showing beliefs in souls. Why aren't statements about magic beyond atoms or algorithms in humans or any other physical system not laughed out the room by default is truly strange.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by canelonesdeverd on Friday November 20, 2026 @11:39AM (#50577481)
The only absurd here is the relentless devotion to a computer program and the blatant misanthropy that it has normalized. Why aren't statemens that don't treat LLMs as anything other than software not laughed out the room by default is truly strange.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by hardbass on Friday November 20, 2026 @11:53AM (#50577782)
Its because its not based on any meaningful arguments but on blatant absurdities like thinking configurations of molecules can't be conscious, aka humans have magic soul juice. If meaningful reasons are given, thats fine.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by canelonesdeverd on Friday November 20, 2026 @12:12PM (#50578205)
>a system that talks and thinks so much like us

It doesn't. We know why it "talks" and we know how it "thinks". Can you say the same of the human brain? Can you say the same about the brains of other animals?

>while belief in infinite imaginary beings

You keep rambling about religion as if is some sort of gotcha but I never brought it up, nor did that previous comment that warranted the deranged "carbon chauvinism" quip. Even then, spirituality is fundamental to the human psyche, even for non-religious people, so no need to be so hand-wavy and willfully spiteful about normal human behaviour.

>How the idea of giving a bit of thought >not based on any meaningful arguments

Back at you. "look at the pretty words" and "le religion bad" are not meaningful arguments.

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by hardbass on Friday November 20, 2026 @12:18PM (#50578312)
>It doesn't. We know why it "talks" and we know how it "thinks". Can you say the same of the human brain? Can you say the same about the brains of other animals?

Do you? I don't know anyone who knows how LLMs work. Are you confusing knowing the low level mechanisms with understanding how they work? If that were true just learning C would make one a Linux kernel expert immediately. And regarding humans, yes, so what will you think once human brains get solved. Would you say it doesn't think, because you seemed to think knowing the mechanism somehow means something can't think, unless I am misreading you.

Its not about spite, I am talking the biggest and most common and incorrect reason against consciousness in physical systems. Religions, unfortunately, are wrong. Mostly it doesn't cause any impact to life, but on topics like this we hit the problems with these peoples false and absurd logic.

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by canelonesdeverd on Friday November 20, 2026 @12:31PM (#50578574)
>If that were true just learning C would make one a Linux kernel expert immediately.

Can't have a conversation about AI without the mandatory forced analogy™

>And regarding humans, yes, so what will you think once human brains get solved. Would you say it doesn't think, because you seemed to think knowing the mechanism somehow means something can't think, unless I am misreading you.

Okay, so we're working with hypoteticals now. So much for meaningful arguments.

>that arguments made from religious framing about souls are absurd without showing any proof of their truth.

I have not made an argument based on religion yet, nor did anybody in this thread

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by hardbass on Friday November 20, 2026 @12:42PM (#50578765)
>Can't have a conversation about AI without the mandatory forced analogy™

Empty words, you had nothing to reply to a very simple question. Just admit you goofed up man.

>>And regarding humans, yes, so what will you think once human brains get solved. Would you say it doesn't think, because you seemed to think knowing the mechanism somehow means something can't think, unless I am misreading you.

You yourself somehow setup some kind of contrast between known systems and unsolved systems. I am unfortunately not telepathic, I can only read what you have written.

No but you were trying to mount some kind of defense of religious thinking. I wasn't saying anyone in particular had said so. I am saying thats the most common, and quite absurd argument given against the possibility of any other system being conscious.

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by exe34 on Friday November 20, 2026 @01:14PM (#50579287)
We know how linear algebra works, but we also know how neurons calculate and communicate. If you believe that reductionism works in one case but not the other, you need to explain why.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by hardbass on Friday November 20, 2026 @01:21PM (#50579389)
Thats a "mandatory forced analogy™" apparently to him
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by zahlman on Friday November 20, 2026 @08:02AM (#50574119)
> Carbon chauvinism

The fact that you ascribe meaning to this term and expect to be able to use it to win arguments already tells me that you are way outside the Overton window.

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by exe34 on Friday November 20, 2026 @09:58AM (#50575579)
The Overton window is no measure of right or wrong.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by canelonesdeverd on Friday November 20, 2026 @12:16PM (#50578273)
"carbon chauvinism" was coined by Carl Sagan to point out that life in the universe didn't have to be carbon-based.

Are you in good-faith asserting that LLMs are a form of life?

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by hardbass on Friday November 20, 2026 @12:20PM (#50578347)
I don't see why they couldn't be without any definitions and proofs. Humans and animals are physical systems, as are computers and programs. Certain physical systems support life.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by canelonesdeverd on Friday November 20, 2026 @12:31PM (#50578582)
"Life" has a specific definition.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by DonHopkins on Friday November 20, 2026 @12:39PM (#50578722)
...which is?
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by canelonesdeverd on Friday November 20, 2026 @01:13PM (#50579275)
>Darwinian evolution

Darwinian evolution is organisms surviving their surroundings and passing down their better traits to their offspring. How does this definition maps to software running on a computer is left as an exercise for the reader :-)

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by hardbass on Friday November 20, 2026 @12:40PM (#50578738)
Would you be able to recognize life if it wasn't one of the existing lifeforms on earth?
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by canelonesdeverd on Friday November 20, 2026 @12:58PM (#50579026)
I dunno. What does that mean for this conversation, besides the obvious sealioning?
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by hardbass on Friday November 20, 2026 @01:06PM (#50579158)
If you couldn't answer that then you don't have a definition. What have you brought to this conversation other than vague insinuations and insults each time I asked concrete questions?
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by canelonesdeverd on Friday November 20, 2026 @01:23PM (#50579419)
There is nothing concrete about your question. How can I possibly know I could recognise alien life? How could I possibly know if I could recognize every life-form on earth? How can I possibly know life in this universe is not even real and we're in a computer simulation, rendering the whole thought exercise pointless? Turning a discussion into a thought exercise is just moving the goalposts. And:

>If you couldn't answer that then you don't have a definition

Says who? Why would having a concrete definition mean that we have to know if it applies every time? "Italian" is a definition too, but I wouldn't recognize one if they bumped into me in the street (mandatory forced analogy :D )

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by hardbass on Friday November 20, 2026 @01:26PM (#50579471)
You said

>"Life" has a specific definition.

If you have one, all those questions should have clear answers. If you don't, then you were lying.

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by hardbass on Friday November 20, 2026 @01:32PM (#50579549)
If the definition of "life" is wishy washy, then you should have no trouble with me deciding you are not alive and destroying you. You can't play a double game of making moral statements about various terms in one place and then being ambiguous when asked to actually define those terms.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by hardbass on Friday November 20, 2026 @11:55AM (#50577820)
The fact that belief in imaginary all powerful beings and their supposed edicts is treated as anything other than clinical insanity means the Overton window should be ignored for certain topics.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by DonHopkins on Friday November 20, 2026 @12:36PM (#50578651)
The Overton window is meaningless now that the fascist white supremacist Christian nationalists have dragged it so far to the right. Being way outside of it to the left is the only rational choice. You broke it, you bought it.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by hardbass on Friday November 20, 2026 @06:42AM (#50573342)
Of course, and we are just a collection of dumb inert atoms.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by pandemic_region on Friday November 20, 2026 @04:01AM (#50572025)
I would label AI as friend in the same way I would label ads as informative.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by tegling on Friday November 20, 2026 @04:18AM (#50572167)
Agree it's not a friend. Hence, the quote marks on "friend" the second time. I'm just fumbling for analogies that advises for certain caution, highlight the value of one's own knowledge of actual facts, and acknowledges the interaction interface we currently have for AI: which is to mimic interaction with other humans. Any ideas how to capture those things in a mental image that we can relate to?
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by pandemic_region on Friday November 20, 2026 @11:28AM (#50577246)
I think we as a society have yet to come up with the right vocabularyv to define the interaction, currently we're trying to fit it into existing patterns of social interaction and that feels wrong. We need to make it an explicit first class citizen everywhere instead.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by eloisius on Friday November 20, 2026 @04:40AM (#50572332)
Skipping the “friend” criticism as you’ve already addressed it in sibling comments, but another reason among many that even trying to use it as an adversarial interlocutor is flawed thinking, is that even if you prompt it to debate you, you’re the one still prompting it to do that. It can never _mean_ to contradict your argument with its own unique viewpoint. It can only argue because you gave it that prompt. Ironically it’s still a sycophantic position.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by tegling on Friday November 20, 2026 @04:54AM (#50572450)
Appreciate your response! It was an honest question and this really helps. I think it explains my feeling of getting less "brainstorming" use of AI lately. We seem to be moving from dumber models that only provided a few different views (including stuff I didn't know) to sophisticated models that really "understands" what you want to hear and tailor for that. Any "knowledge" introduced to you in this process is only a side-effect/a strict non-goal. Rather, it wants you to feel engaged and happy with the response. Flipping this around: could it be helpful to develop some kind of "concensus models" filled with knowledge and with the sole purpose of teaching/providing you with that corpus? Or, to create some kind of mean-reversion effect of opinions at societal scale (rather than promoting "bubbles")? But at that point, we're very close to the subjects of propaganda and ideas of monoculture...
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by lproven on Friday November 20, 2026 @05:21AM (#50572679)
> Appreciate your response! It was an honest question and this really helps. I

This reads increasingly like you're using a bot to write your answers.

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by tegling on Friday November 20, 2026 @05:38AM (#50572795)
Or (sad, but true) learning manners from bots. Oh boy, where is this world heading?
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by nisegami on Friday November 20, 2026 @06:21AM (#50573157)
I really struggle to see how someone "learning manners" could be construed as a bad thing? I feel like the world would be a lot kinder if everyone tried to be a bit more like the stochastic parrots tuned to be pleasant and polite.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by rsfern on Friday November 20, 2026 @07:27AM (#50573764)
I think the issue is that “bot manners” is often vapid filler. Like GP didn’t even ask a question so “it was an honest question that helps” doesn’t make sense in context. “Hey that was an insightful comment” would be a more engaged polite response IMO, “bot manners” kind of signals disengagement
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by intrikate on Friday November 20, 2026 @09:05AM (#50574833)
I had interpreted that statement as an indication that the original question posed ("Can't the AI be an adversarial friend in this way?") was honest, not that the response was an honest question.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by nisegami on Friday November 20, 2026 @06:18AM (#50573131)
>It can never _mean_ to contradict your argument with its own unique viewpoint.

That just doesn't line up with my experience (depending on how strict you about about "unique"). I don't even ask it to debate me, but if I'm discussing a concept and make a claim about my own unique viewpoint it will readily point out things I may not be considering or things I appear to have misunderstood. It's shockingly effective at poking reasonable holes in things.

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by arduanika on Friday November 20, 2026 @11:43AM (#50577560)
No, this makes a ton of sense. Thanks eloisius for the phrase, it's something I've been grasping for.

Two things wrong with how you read this, nisegami. First, this is claim is more about the "_mean_" than the "unique". I agree with eloisius that a machine cannot _mean_ to do anything, and there's no reason that "lin[ing] up with [your] experience" would have any bearing on whether it can. You do not have personal experience of what it is like to be "inside" a machine's "head", if it's even "like" anything at all. (Unless I'm talking to a bot, which I doubt.) So why would your experience matter for the "_mean_" part of the claim?

Second, you might have misread "its own unique viewpoint" for "your own unique viewpoint" as a user. Your comment is about your own viewpoint's uniqueness, which I don't dispute.

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by lelanthran on Friday November 20, 2026 @05:01AM (#50572501)
> Why must there be a dichotomy: "use AI/don't think for yourself", vs "don't use AI/think for yourself"?

It doesn't have to be any extreme, although your next statement:

> I think we'll need to grow in our individual relationship with AI.

makes me think that anyone who develops a relationship with a tool is probably on one end of that extreme already.

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by tegling on Friday November 20, 2026 @05:10AM (#50572579)
It was good to get a reality-check. I'll reconsider my approach to AI analogies as I realize anthropomorphizing is understood as problematic. Still, as you can see in one of my other comments, my key issue is that AI interaction interfaces are designed to mimic human interaction. That kind of side-steps our whole mental model of non-human things. I'm at loss here. Last, just want to clarify that by "relationship" I meant as in "the way in which two or more _things_ are connected", not as in human relationships.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by DonHopkins on Friday November 20, 2026 @05:47AM (#50572869)
>makes me think that anyone who develops a relationship with a tool is probably on one end of that extreme already.

I have no regrets naming my cat Emacs.

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by jackling on Friday November 20, 2026 @07:42AM (#50573899)
Aren't you reading the comment a bit too literally? It's the same as saying "relationship with food". It's about how you interact with it as an entity versus some personal relationship.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by lproven on Friday November 20, 2026 @05:21AM (#50572675)
> Can't AI be that persuasive and contrarian, at times adversarial, friend?

No. It generates text like that in its corpus. If there is a pattern that looks like the interaction you ask for, it will imitate it, but it can't be adversarial because it can't think. So you can always derail it.

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by zahlman on Friday November 20, 2026 @07:55AM (#50574048)
Yes, you can always derail it. Just like how, in the pre-AI world (or ignoring AI), you could choose not to examine your beliefs. But now you have a tool that makes it easier, if you choose to try.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by bryanrasmussen on Friday November 20, 2026 @05:58AM (#50572969)
>Why must there be a dichotomy: "use AI/don't think for yourself", vs "don't use AI/think for yourself"?

because studies show that use of AI in subject areas of which one has expertise consistently decreases that expertise? As these subject areas are generally ones with intellectual requirements "use AI" = "Don't Think for Yourself", which underlines well known common sense aphorisms such as "use it or lose it", where the it is the expertise that one stops to use in favor of AI. You lose your ability to think for yourself in your field of expertise, but you gain the AI.

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by audience_mem on Friday November 20, 2026 @06:11AM (#50573072)
do you think it's not possible for a person to be doing the thinking but AI to be doing the gruntwork? (eg coding)
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by galactus on Friday November 20, 2026 @06:40AM (#50573323)
coding = thinking
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by zahlman on Friday November 20, 2026 @07:54AM (#50574018)
I don't think this is actually true, or rather it's hiding something. We used to not be able to separate the gruntwork from thinking, because even at the level of typing out an individual line of code there's an instinctive review process. But this kind of "thought" is on a different level from the "thought" which led to starting the typing. Not even all the way up at the architecture level, but more the idea of just extracting the essential complexity of the task from the incidental complexity.

When I write code by hand and I feel confident about what I'm doing, the confidence comes from knowing that the extraction is generally already done. But I'll still find myself pausing and hesitating, checking for typos, making sure things correspond to their surrounding context… even after decades. It feels like "thinking" in the moment, but not so much when I reflect back on the nature of the task. AI seemingly is not limited by psychology, so it doesn't have these hangups (and of course it also just "types" far faster). It doesn't get an ego boost from being right the first time, and its "confidence" in the compiler, tools and tests is just not relevant.

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by bryanrasmussen on Friday November 20, 2026 @08:12AM (#50574204)
if I thought that then it would be up to me to explain why the studies that show this is not the case are wrong, if you think that it is then it is up to you do to so and not to try to put the task on to me.

In other words, the data shows it is maybe not possible, you think it is, describe why the data is wrong and you are correct.

Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by tegling on Friday November 20, 2026 @06:11AM (#50573074)
That's kind of the whole question. You're correct, and we're likely heading towards a complete brain-drain if we don't adjust something. But those studies are descriptive. It's what it looks like now. I'm wondering what we can do in order to both have our cake and eat it. How to keep skill and knowledge mastery in humans AND use AI. And it's not helping that education/internships/junior positions are all pivoting for AI use rather than providing a proper learning environment with relevant friction, a curated corpus and time to mold our minds until we truly grok stuff ourselves.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by randysalami on Friday November 20, 2026 @11:29AM (#50577278)
I want to write something to pushback on this because I see a lot. I probably won't get much visibility writing this here but that's ok, I'm still developing this line of thinking. With AI, I have more time. With that time I can read books on software engineering but specifically with this field, it benefits so much from personal and human development. With this time, I can work through my traumas, become more healed, and help others, sometimes with the guidance of AI but other times through my own human will. Ultimately, I believe, this leads to better software outcomes even besides the other positive externalities. Why? Because I have more to pull from and learning more about the world gives me more ontologies to map my software principles on (on-top of the high-level software reading I do while my agents run). The alternative was extreme disassociation for hours to achieve flow states, typing, typing, typing, and that was better or desirable? Well it probably was important, like a form of meditation. It wasn't easy, not many people could do it, I know that. Ok I'm rambling now.
Re:"I can tell you wrote this yourself" by gosub100 on Friday November 20, 2026 @09:26AM (#50575080)
There's a dichotomy because you can't opt in to take just what you want.every sentence I type on my phone the AI button pops up to "help" me "clean up" my writing. You cannot disable the AI reply suggestions in Gmail without turning off non AI features like inbox filters. They are shoving AI down our throats.